base talk More RAW Talent: Beyoncé or Lady Gaga?

[king_queen]

9 minutes ago, sunbathinganimal said:

both have far more raw talent than most of atrl's favs

 

 

That gif 

[Breathe On Moi]

you ATRL bottoms sure would know a thing or two about raw 

[ChooseyLover]

Just now, NoOneDiesFromLove said:

To me it's lady Gaga 

 

Now let's stop telling jokes.. 

I'm not kidding, I was just being a lil' messy stating a personal preference. But anyway, all three are very different kind of artists with different strengths and ways to express their art.

[Big Bad Wolf]

4 minutes ago, ChooseyLover said:

I'm not kidding, I was just being a lil' messy stating a personal preference. But anyway, all three are very different kind of artists with different strengths and ways to express their art.

Nobody asked. Take you and your AI ass posts out of my thread. Thank you!

Edited September 30 by Big Bad Wolf

[Cheers]

Beyonce

- Can sing

- Can dance

 

Gaga

- Can write music (solo or with 1 other collaborator)

- Can sing

 

Neither is creating exciting visuals or assembling exciting looks all on her own.

[Big Bad Wolf]

Just now, Cheers said:

Beyonce

- Can sing

- Can dance

 

Gaga

- Can write music (solo or with 1 other collaborator)

- Can sing

 

Neither is creating exciting visuals or assembling exciting looks all on her own.

Gaga assembled iconic looks of her own with The Fame era. A lot of those looks were created by herself and 1-2 other people. That's raw talent. 

[ChooseyLover]

Just now, Big Bad Wolf said:

Nobody asked. Take you and your AI ass posts out of my thread. Thank you!

Eh, I wouldn't be attacking anyone's posts with the kind of things you say and contribute here in general.

[Big Bad Wolf]

6 minutes ago, Breathe On Moi said:

you ATRL bottoms sure would know a thing or two about raw 

Says a Britney Stan in 2024. Back to defending your ***** facing the world ass fave while she jacks a hammer between another tooth.

[AxelFox]

Whatever songwriting affinities y'all believe lady gaga possesses cannot make up for the vast difference in singing, dancing and creative vision where she is leagues beneath Beyoncé's caliber. 
 

This is nonsense. 

[Big Bad Wolf]

1 minute ago, ChooseyLover said:

Eh, I wouldn't be attacking anyone's posts with the kind of things you say and contribute here in general.

Aaliyah avi but defends a minstrel show. I would not take anything you say seriously whatsoever. You are a weirdo. Please seek help <3 

[Big Bad Wolf]

Just now, AxelFox said:

Whatever songwriting affinities y'all believe lady gaga possesses cannot make up for the vast difference in singing, dancing and creative vision where she is leagues beneath Beyoncé's caliber. 
 

This is nonsense. 

Beyonce has an entire camp crafting her music. Gaga does not. 

[Cheers]

3 minutes ago, Big Bad Wolf said:

Gaga assembled iconic looks of her own with The Fame era. A lot of those looks were created by herself and 1-2 other people. That's raw talent. 

Which ones did she assemble completely on her own

[Big Bad Wolf]

Just now, Cheers said:

Which ones did she assemble completely on her own

Do your research, mama. I'm not here to spoon feed you the answers. Go back and study some Gaga TF era facts. 

[ONOPKA]

singing - equal match

writing - gaga

dancing - beyonce

visuals - equal match

acting - gaga

 

gaga edges it i fear. 

[Pheromosa]

So you made this thread just to argue with people who disagree with your opinion? Ok got it 

[Jay07]

Superfluous question when they are THE two most talented popular artists of the past twenty five years. They have their strong and weaker points (Beyonce is a better dancer, Gaga a better songwriter) but they put 99.9% of other popstars to shame.

 

I will say this. Even if I think Gaga is a better raw songwriter (put her in a room with a piano and she will walk out with a potential classic) Beyonce has the discipline and vision to curate better overall projects. 

Edited September 30 by Jay07

[ScorpiosGroove]

- Can sing : Beyoncé

- Can dance : Beyoncé

- Can write music : Gaga

- Can create exciting visuals : Beyoncé

- Can assemble exciting looks and costumes : Beyoncé bc they don't look like halloween costumes 

 

Beyoncé wins 

[LadyFlopga]

Don't need to compare to highly talented and successful women

they both are winning in life

[GraceRandolph]

Retro Physical

Animal

Wonderland

 

The answer is obvious

[Big Bad Wolf]

5 minutes ago, Pheromosa said:

So you made this thread just to argue with people who disagree with your opinion? Ok got it 

Eat a dick. 

[Anvarie]

22 minutes ago, Infatuation_Junkie said:

If all the power went out in the arena, gaga could still wow with just a piano and vocals. Beyonce, not so much. No shade, love them both, but let's be real. 

 

you're telling me the clip below wouldn't wow you? I don't think Gaga has the range or vocal capability to pull this off (not even mentioning stage presence)
 

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZCA0FPjeCfM&t=4m29s

[AxelFox]

3 minutes ago, Big Bad Wolf said:

Beyonce has an entire camp crafting her music. Gaga does not. 

Both Beyoncé and lady gaga work with around 3-4 other people on a given song on average, so this isn't really the flex you think it is, unless gaga was solo writing most of her work. 
 

I do agree that she most likely contributes more to the composing of a song than Beyoncé does, but that was literally the point of my post. That whatever edge lady gaga may have in songwriting it is not enough to make up for the fact that she does not compete in everything else. 

[Big Bad Wolf]

2 minutes ago, LadyFlopga said:

Don't need to compare to highly talented and successful women

they both are winning in life

Wow thanks, LadyFlopga, for being so ******* useless and unimportant 

[Big Bad Wolf]

Just now, AxelFox said:

Both Beyoncé and lady gaga work with around 3-4 other people on a given song on average, so this isn't really the flex you think it is, unless gaga was solo writing most of her work. 
 

I do agree that she most likely contributes more to the composing of a song than Beyoncé does, but that was literally the point of my post. That whatever edge lady gaga may have in songwriting it is not enough to make up for the fact that she does not compete in everything else. 

How are you saying this when Beyonce songs have at least a dozen creditors. This is not the case on Joanne or Chromatica but it's the case for every Beyonce album. Your post has been disregarded 

[Pinkbutterflies]

Singing - Gaga. Gaga is way more emotive and dynamic. Bey has good runs but plays it too safe and also tone is really bad.

 

Acting - Gaga. Just listen to lion king to see how bad beys acting foundation is.

 

Dance - bey. Bey wins this one although beys dancing is highly overrated. Watch someone like tinashe or Ciara and you will see what real dancing it.

 

Create music - Gaga. Bey does not possess the capacity to write songs; it is a highly demanding skil to have.

 

Create exciting visuals - Gaga. Every music video from Gaga is unique and full of surprised. With bey, if you have seen one you have seen them all. Her videos are like the saw franchise