base talk More RAW Talent: Beyoncé or Lady Gaga?

[Big Bad Wolf]

Which artist has more RAW Talent?

 

RAW Talent:

- Can sing

- Can dance

- Can write music (solo or with 1 other collaborator)

- Can create exciting visuals

- Can assemble exciting looks and costumes

 

Based on the criteria, which one of the pop divas has more RAW Talent? Place your vote at the polls and discuss. 

Edited September 30 by Big Bad Wolf

[Brooklyn Baby]

[KatyPrismSpirit]

make polls public for the ultimate ki

[Big Bad Wolf]

3 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

But why can't Beyonce write a song without a minimum of 12 people present in the room with her? Based on credentials that is

Edited September 30 by Big Bad Wolf

[JO1s]

[perfect blue]

Beyonce in EVERY category - acting included.

[Big Bad Wolf]

2 minutes ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

make polls public for the ultimate ki

Kii 

[polygon]

6 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

 

[tost1]

Rain On Me

Alejandro

World on a String

 

The answer is obvious

[Flanders]

it's not really a great comparison, their talents are different but equally raw in different ways

 

I voted for Beyoncé because between the two she is the one where I can remember being literally stunned

[Brooklyn Baby]

3 minutes ago, Big Bad Wolf said:

But why can't Beyonce write a song without a minimum of 12 people present in the room with her? Based on credentials that is

Some of the greatest artists, singers and performers were not writers.

 

I don't understand the obsession with writing when Beyoncé excels in almost everything else and has a better overall discography. There really is no argument here.

 

[ImpressMeMuch]

why even compare 

 

they both pass the point of being untouchable levels of talent so just celebrate them both 

[Vixen Eyes]

Gaga

[sunbathinganimal]

both have far more raw talent than most of atrl's favs

 

 

[Infatuation_Junkie]

If all the power went out in the arena, gaga could still wow with just a piano and vocals. Beyonce, not so much. No shade, love them both, but let's be real. 

[Brooklyn Baby]

Glad we agree. The answer is still Beyoncé though

 

[JO1s]

1 minute ago, Infatuation_Junkie said:

If all the power went out in the arena, gaga could still wow with just a piano and vocals. Beyonce, not so much. No shade, love them both, but let's be real. 

Not the Nicki Minaj excuses 

[Curaga]

 

Beyoncé's RAW talent as a vocalist and overall performer is more impressive to me

[ChooseyLover]

Both of them > Lana del Rey

/endthread

[enchanted0]

Beyonce sweetie

[Big Bad Wolf]

Just now, ChooseyLover said:

Both of them > Lana del Rey

/endthread

You stan an artist who dedicated an album to a minstrel show.

 

Anyone else's opinion > Yours

[Big Bad Wolf]

4 minutes ago, Curaga said:

 

Beyoncé's RAW talent as a vocalist and overall performer is more impressive to me

?

 

Beyonce's vocals are often times overwhelming much like Christina's, she sings too loudly at times and it's unpleasant

 

Both Bey and Gaga have previous injuries that impact their dance abilities today. With this in mind I think Gaga gives more energy at her shows, has more welcoming vocals, and can play a mean piano.

Edited September 30 by Big Bad Wolf

[jezebelvictoria]

Bey is an incredible dancer and singer. GaGa is an okay dancer and singer. GaGa has more input in her music. Bey creates great music videos but then again that's due to her being a better dancer, in my opinion. I'll give it to Bey since she's a better dancer and singer but also has some input in creating her music.  While GaGa's most strong point is having more input in her music. 

[NoOneDiesFromLove]

To me it's lady Gaga 

 

3 minutes ago, ChooseyLover said:

Both of them > Lana del Rey

/endthread

Now let's stop telling jokes.. 

[Curaga]

1 minute ago, Big Bad Wolf said:

Beyonce's vocals are often times overwhelming much like Christina's, she sings too loudly at times and it's unpleasant

I would have said the same thing of Gaga nnn 

But you are right that she's great on the piano