base talk Rebel Heart vs Brat

[UrMom]

Hey little huffers

 

So Brat summer is over and Christian girl autumn has begun. I think it's time to reevaluate  Choli's album now that some time has passed. Let's compare it to some pop excellence by her mother.

 

Rebel Heart is a criminally underrated album. It's an eclectic and vulnerable body of work with a range of genres, including some light hyperpop influences (RIP Sophie). Please enjoy.

 

Brat needs no introduction here... it's a cute lil hyperpop that benefited from some very charitable reviews.

 

For me:

 

Living for Love vs 360
Devil Pray vs Club classics
Ghosttown vs Sympathy is a knife
Unapologetic B!tch vs I might say something stupid
Illuminati vs Talk talk
***** I'm Madonna vs Von dutch
Hold Tight vs Everything is romantic
Joan of Arc vs Rewind
Iconic vs So I
HeartBreakCity vs Girl, so confusing
Body Shop vs Apple
Holy Water vs B2b
Inside Out vs Mean girls
Wash All Over Me vs I think about all the time
Best Night vs 365
Veni Vidi Vici vs Hello goodbye
S.E.X. vs Guess
Messiah vs Spring breakers

 

Madame Xbox: 14

Choli Xbox: 4

 

Thanks LUVs Please share ur thots and prayers

 

Edited September 9 by UrMom

[Raver]

Rebel Heart for all 

[jezebelvictoria]

Rebel Heart is Madonna's best overall album. Brat isn't good, period. 

[Contessa]

These lies above. Brat easily.

[MP3]

Finally some praise for RH

I enjoy some Brat songs but it's nothing compared to RH, that album is full of nuances and it's her best work post-Confessions. For me, it's a highlight in Madonna's career, it was full of visuals, full of promos/perfos and a complete round era 

 

[Venice B]

21 minutes ago, jezebelvictoria said:

Rebel Heart is Madonna's best overall album.

[flower moon]

repelled fart isnt touching brat excellence

[Scandalous]

i like RH and it's def an underrated madge album but brat >>

[Gladiator]

I think Brat is better.

Having said that, I don't really get the dislike for Rebel Heart. I think its a great album.

[Princess Aurora]

Living for Love vs 360
Devil Pray vs Club classics
Ghosttown vs Sympathy is a knife
Unapologetic B!tch vs I might say something stupid
Illuminati vs Talk talk
***** I'm Madonna vs Von dutch
Hold Tight vs Everything is romantic
Joan of Arc vs Rewind
Iconic vs So I
HeartBreakCity vs Girl, so confusing
Body Shop vs Apple
Holy Water vs B2b
Inside Out vs Mean girls
Wash All Over Me vs I think about all the time
Best Night vs 365
Veni Vidi Vici vs Hello goodbye
S.E.X. vs Guess
Messiah vs Spring breakers

[JoeAg]

Living for Love vs 360
Devil Pray vs Club classics
Ghosttown vs Sympathy is a knife
Unapologetic B!tch vs I might say something stupid
Illuminati vs Talk talk
***** I'm Madonna vs Von dutch
Hold Tight vs Everything is romantic
Joan of Arc vs Rewind
Iconic vs So I
HeartBreakCity vs Girl, so confusing
Body Shop vs Apple
Holy Water vs B2b
Inside Out vs Mean girls
Wash All Over Me vs I think about all the time
Best Night vs 365
Veni Vidi Vici vs Hello goodbye
S.E.X. vs Guess
Messiah vs Spring breakers

 

3 vs 15

 

oh wowww Madonna winning for 3! i'm surprised lol

I obviously love 360 too but Living for Love is just IMMACULATE 

 

also if you replaced any of those three bonus tracks with either Rebel Heart or Beautiful Scars, that'd win against its opponent 

 

but yeah anyway! Brat is obviously better and more iconic, but Rebel Heart is totally underappreciated 

[HardBambi]

Brat is the album of the year, why would you compare it with Rebel Heart

 

Rebel Heart could have been much better btw

Living for love as lead was so boring 

[Popboi.]

RH was rushed as hell as everything leaked, multiple times, before she even announced the album or finish it (that leakpalooza was iconic), so of course BRAT wins in quality.

[Daddy]

Rebel Heart is a collection of 3 good songs and abysmal trash. Brat is album of the year and will forever be remembered for its excellence. 

 

Only MDNA is worse than RH.

[CherryBay]

RH album cover is more relevant and iconic than Brat era 

[Kern]

Rebel Heart is the worst Madonna album. Definition of boring, faceless, generic. I remember it made me unstan but then I staned again with Madame X...

[Chris]

What a random thread.