Popular Post EnigmaticAndroid Posted September 3 Popular Post Posted September 3 Poor @logarithsucks, delusional, miserable Swiftwat 35
burninredhot Posted September 3 Posted September 3 Probably.. for a song pulling such huge numbers there should be legit viral trends on tiktok or reels which I don't see on my timeline atleast
Johnny Jacobs Posted September 3 Posted September 3 5 hours ago, Lagerfeld said: I just saw a research analysis carried out by a Swiftie Hmm
yonsé Posted September 3 Posted September 3 Very interesting to base an entire theory on anecdotal evidence lol 1
yonsé Posted September 3 Posted September 3 (edited) 1 hour ago, burninredhot said: Probably.. for a song pulling such huge numbers there should be legit viral trends on tiktok or reels which I don't see on my timeline atleast If you don't like the song it's not going to show up on your TL. Echo chambers are a real thing. TikTok gives you things it knows you'll like. I have seen many people doing the slow motion spinning like Gaga in the video and Gaga commenting on said videos on MY timeline. So they are out there. Edited September 3 by yonsé 9 1
Phoenixstar Posted September 3 Posted September 3 where's TL;DR? ain't nobody gonna read the damn paragraph, touch some grass
Popular Post Infernal Paradise Posted September 3 Popular Post Posted September 3 #1 iTunes US #1 iTunes Global #1 Amazon Music US #1 Amazon Music Global #1 Youtube US #1 Youtube Global #1 Apple Music US #1 Apple Music Global #1 Spotify US #1 Spotify Global All "autoplayed" peaks. Fraudulent activity. Reverse Troy Carter expedition. 1 14
kwek_kwek Posted September 3 Posted September 3 46 minutes ago, yonsé said: If you don't like the song it's not going to show up on your TL. Echo chambers are a real thing. TikTok gives you things it knows you'll like. I have seen many people doing the slow motion spinning like Gaga in the video and Gaga commenting on said videos on MY timeline. So they are out there. There are also other sounds from DWAS that are going viral. https://vt.tiktok.com/ZS2DBeX4B/ This sound has been used more than 450k and the tiktok edits getting million likes.
Sugar-Rush Posted September 3 Posted September 3 2 hours ago, ShadeIena said: I'm serious and this is no shade at all. But I haven't heard the song nor know people who are listening to it to be this 'big' This is a silly argument. I don't know anyone who listens to Taylor or Sabrina outside of this site for instance, yet I don't deny that their singles are big hits. Why the goalposts get moved around whenever it's something regarding Gaga is... interesting 4 1
Infernal Paradise Posted September 3 Posted September 3 Also writing an ENTIRE essay about a song topping the charts is crazy 13
BrokenMachine Posted September 3 Posted September 3 6 hours ago, Lagerfeld said: research analysis carried out by a Swiftie on why it's an auto-played hit and inorganic. I'm sure Swifties know a thing or two about inorganic success 1
PrettyHurts Posted September 3 Posted September 3 Of course there is some payola/autoplay involved. But all our faves, or rather their labels, do it. Nothing we see is real. It's all an illusion.
BrokenMachine Posted September 3 Posted September 3 2 hours ago, EnigmaticAndroid said: Poor @logarithsucks, delusional, miserable Swiftwat 1
FrederickGa Posted September 3 Posted September 3 Not people using " it's only 20% from the US " argument to discredit DWAS Like, HELLO? Shallow did like 6M Spotify Global Streams and only 1.1M came from the US after the Oscar Win She's that GLOBAL.. she's not Taylor Swift with 50%-70% should come from the US or it's not a real hit 7 2
FrederickGa Posted September 3 Posted September 3 When a song is doing great in all Platforms, there's no really room for questioning of its legitimacy as a SMASH Now when the song is only doing great in one Platform like say.. Katy Perry's Bon Appetit, This Is How We Do and Swish Swish? Now the YT Payola allegations were very VALID 1
Lagerfeld Posted September 3 Author Posted September 3 3 hours ago, EnigmaticAndroid said: Poor @logarithsucks, delusional, miserable Swiftwat We kind of need an additional statement from the user. @logarithmsucks Please tweet your statements and I will tag the ATRLers for you. 3
MonsterNavy Posted September 3 Posted September 3 Sabrina Carpenter can use autoplay from Nonsense, Feather, Espresso, Please Please Please & Taste but Gaga can't? I sense ageism
YourFavoriteWeapon Posted September 3 Posted September 3 It's a real hit, yet people always question Gaga's organic success.
Outlaws Posted September 3 Posted September 3 Some people have way too much free time I don't think that's the song some of you should put all this hate into, like, there are several songs in the top 10 from labels that are playing the cheapest tricks without any of you saying a word. Look it up. Talent is winning 1
?????? Posted September 3 Posted September 3 The locals in my country are EATING this up and they all boycott Bruno Mars btw. It's a cute Shallow-esque ballad for me!
burninredhot Posted September 3 Posted September 3 5 hours ago, yonsé said: If you don't like the song it's not going to show up on your TL. Echo chambers are a real thing. TikTok gives you things it knows you'll like. I have seen many people doing the slow motion spinning like Gaga in the video and Gaga commenting on said videos on MY timeline. So they are out there. Considering it's pulling around 10m streams a day shouldn't the trend be universal like it was with Espresso and Birds Of A Feather?
Bojana Posted September 3 Posted September 3 18 minutes ago, burninredhot said: Considering it's pulling around 10m streams a day shouldn't the trend be universal like it was with Espresso and Birds Of A Feather? And what trend did those songs have? I have no idea because I don't engage in any content with those singers, but that doesn't mean they weren't massive hits I get videos after videos of anime/disney edits to the song, even if I don't watch any anime, they probably appear on my fyp because I engage with any Gaga content. Just because you didn't see any videos doesn't mean they don't exist (and they're out there pulling 500k likes and some even 1m likes) and same goes for me too, just because I didn't see any trend with BOAF doesn't mean it wasn't a hit Heres some videos and you can search through the sound Spoiler Spoiler Spoiler Spoiler 2 2
Recommended Posts