Jump to content

Who's more responsible for Die With A Smile's success: Bruno or GaGa?


Who’s more responsible for the song’s success?  

362 members have voted

  1. 1. Who’s more responsible for the song’s success?



Recommended Posts

Posted
On 8/29/2024 at 12:59 PM, Sex with Rih said:

If she were to be singing the song alone, it would also give a stupid love/million reasons trajectory

not when million reasons is one of her most stable hits :rip:

  • Replies 171
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Blade

    11

  • Kukai

    9

  • Sex with Rih

    5

  • sunbathinganimal

    5

Posted
On 8/29/2024 at 8:10 PM, Kukai said:

Are we sure about that sis? Bruno currently has more votes in the poll despite the fact that this website is crawling with GaGa fans

 

MIc7wn0.thumb.gif.09b51e3f687ed1c1a148db

 

 

well

MIc7wn0.thumb.gif.09b51e3f687ed1c1a148db

Posted
1 hour ago, John Slayne said:

not when million reasons is one of her most stable hits :rip:

Stable? I remember yall were comparing it to LOTB back in 2024. Fast-forward LOTB has 1.5B streams and is gaining  nearly 1M streams per day. Million reasons is barely past 800M( fuelled by the superbowl) and is gaining 300K per day. Is the stability you speak of in the room with us?:bibliahh:

  • Haha 1
  • Thumbs Down 4
Posted
30 minutes ago, Sex with Rih said:

Stable? I remember yall were comparing it to LOTB back in 2024. Fast-forward LOTB has 1.5B streams and is gaining  nearly 1M streams per day. Million reasons is barely past 800M( fuelled by the superbowl) and is gaining 300K per day. Is the stability you speak of in the room with us?:bibliahh:

girl whatever 

Posted
28 minutes ago, Sex with Rih said:

Stable? I remember yall were comparing it to LOTB back in 2024. Fast-forward LOTB has 1.5B streams and is gaining  nearly 1M streams per day. Million reasons is barely past 800M( fuelled by the superbowl) and is gaining 300K per day. Is the stability you speak of in the room with us?:bibliahh:

That song did not spent a single day on TTH when that playlist had a huge impact on streaming. Also ARUTW has 1.3B streams with 1M daily streams, soon to overtake hits like No Tears Left to Cry and In My Feelings:rip: Not to mention You and I was also a solo ballad hit. I love Bruno but his last Global Spotify #1 was Uptown Funk, which is not even his song.

Posted
On 8/30/2024 at 10:31 AM, ThePopStop said:

It's weird because the song mostly sounds like a Bruno Mars single, but I think Lady Gaga had more of the hype upon release. 
 

As a Gaga fan I was disappointed because Bruno's voice is mixed way too loud in the harmonies. It mostly sounds like Bruno Mars feat. Lady Gaga, not a duet. 
 

I think he only gave her duet credit out of respect.

The song was released by Gaga's label, only on Gaga's Channel and Gaga is credited the first lead artist. You don't give all of that just out of respect lol. Gaga clearly contributed a lot to the song.

Posted
3 hours ago, shyboi said:

Success?

You dont think it's a success? :xtinass:

Posted
1 hour ago, jijie101 said:

That song did not spent a single day on TTH when that playlist had a huge impact on streaming. Also ARUTW has 1.3B streams with 1M daily streams, soon to overtake hits like No Tears Left to Cry and In My Feelings:rip: Not to mention You and I was also a solo ballad hit. I love Bruno but his last Global Spotify #1 was Uptown Funk, which is not even his song.

Lol I'm definitely not worried about spotify peaks but I know you don't want to argue spotify? Bruno has 5 songs that have 2B on spotify and 2 of them are gaining 2M streams per day and Gaga barely has 5 songs that surpassed 1B streams( she's literally gaining less streams than Rih despite having a song that does nearly 10M per day), so i wouldn't attribute the spotify success of this song to Gaga at all.

  • Like 1
  • Thumbs Down 3
Posted
1 hour ago, jijie101 said:

That song did not spent a single day on TTH when that playlist had a huge impact on streaming. Also ARUTW has 1.3B streams with 1M daily streams, soon to overtake hits like No Tears Left to Cry and In My Feelings:rip: Not to mention You and I was also a solo ballad hit. I love Bruno but his last Global Spotify #1 was Uptown Funk, which is not even his song.

Additionally,  Bruno is the 29th biggest Hot100 artist of all time, whereas Gaga is the 55th biggest.

  • Like 1
  • Thumbs Down 1
Posted (edited)

It's potentially  Brunos BIGGEST Global and European SMASH since UF

 

And Gaga's potentially BIGGEST in WW/US/Asia since Shallow or BTW Era Charts-wise

 

I say, BOTH

Edited by FrederickGa
Posted
10 hours ago, Sex with Rih said:

Stable? I remember yall were comparing it to LOTB back in 2024. Fast-forward LOTB has 1.5B streams and is gaining  nearly 1M streams per day. Million reasons is barely past 800M( fuelled by the superbowl) and is gaining 300K per day. Is the stability you speak of in the room with us?:bibliahh:

LOTB was spammed on Radios plz plus she got better Spotify Playlist Support

 

MR received ZERO TTH/Big Playlists Support

 

MR was even outstreaming WORK on daily streams until Superbowl... Superbowl you say? :coffee:

  • Like 1
Posted

There should be a "both" option. The song wouldn't be the same song without both of them, and it's giving both a peak in certain métrics.

 

They should be very proud.

  • Thanks 1
Posted

You and your demonic ways.

Posted
On 8/30/2024 at 10:31 AM, ThePopStop said:

It's weird because the song mostly sounds like a Bruno Mars single, but I think Lady Gaga had more of the hype upon release. 
 

As a Gaga fan I was disappointed because Bruno's voice is mixed way too loud in the harmonies. It mostly sounds like Bruno Mars feat. Lady Gaga, not a duet. 
 

I think he only gave her duet credit out of respect.

The song is uploaded on gaga's channel. I dont think it is a Bruno song and "he only gave her duet credit out of respect". It doesnt work that way

Posted

Apart from the ASIB songs, Gaga rarely does well with slow songs while Bruno has a bunch of hit ballads under his belt, so realistically I think he could have carried this song alone.

Posted

The song feels more gaga. hold my hand/shallow etc so Gags

Posted

Capture.png

 

:deadbanana4:

  • Haha 1
Posted (edited)
On 9/1/2024 at 3:31 PM, Sex with Rih said:

Stable? I remember yall were comparing it to LOTB back in 2024. Fast-forward LOTB has 1.5B streams and is gaining  nearly 1M streams per day. Million reasons is barely past 800M( fuelled by the superbowl) and is gaining 300K per day. Is the stability you speak of in the room with us?:bibliahh:

As if that's a bad thing. Many artists perform their new music at the Super Bowl and yet the songs don't take off like Million Reasons - for example Beyoncé's Formation. 88k streams daily. Justin Timberlake's Filthy. 6k streams daily.

 

Million Reasons is a HIT whether you like it or not. SEETHE! :bibliahh:

Edited by lg6chromatica
  • Like 1
Posted
4 minutes ago, lg6chromatica said:

As if that's a bad thing. Many artists perform their new music at the Super Bowl and yet the songs don't take off like Million Reasons - for example Beyoncé's Formation. 88k streams daily. Justin Timberlake's Filthy. 6k streams daily.

 

Million Reasons is a HIT whether you like it or not. SEETHE! :bibliahh:

Gaining 300K would not be the reason why DWAS is smashing though...it could be the fact that Bruno is the bigger streaming and Hot100 act between the two. Gagas solo hits haven't made noise since 2013 tbh. The solo "hits"she's scored since then either chart poorly( see ARUTW) or have horrible streams( see stupid love).

Posted
1 minute ago, Sex with Rih said:

Gaining 300K would not be the reason why DWAS is smashing though...it could be the fact that Bruno is the bigger streaming and Hot100 act between the two. Gagas solo hits haven't made noise since 2013 tbh. The solo "hits"she's scored since then either chart poorly( see ARUTW) or have horrible streams( see stupid love).

Million Reasons has always been consistent with its streams - it pulling 200k-300k daily is not a recent thing. Nothing to do with DWaS :rip:

 

And as for you discounting ARUTW, maybe it's time for you to realize that Hot 100 chart positions aren't everything --

 

Always Remember Us This Way - 893k daily streams

 

--BARRIER--

 

Watermelon Sugar - 818k

good 4 u - 769k

drivers license - 763k

7 rings - 746k

Señorita - 738k

Lucid Dreams - 733k

God's Plan - 670k

The Box - 651k

Havana - 641k

rockstar - 634k

Bad Guy - 590k

Without Me - 552k

Dynamite - 545k

positions - 462k

Peaches - 462k

thank u, next - 433k

SAD! - 424k

Stuck with U - 421k

The Middle - 394k

Meant to Be - 272k

Nice For What - 266k

Say So - 261k

Girls Like You - 232k

Old Town Road - 187k

Truth Hurts - 186k

Toosie Slide - 183k

In My Feelings - 171k

This Is America - 92k

Boo'd Up - 85k

TROLLZ - 34k

 

Please join your fellow OGH in seething.

 

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1
  • 2 months later...
Posted

good morning

MIc7wn0.thumb.gif.09b51e3f687ed1c1a148db

  • Haha 1
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.