dumbsparce Posted August 28 Posted August 28 1 minute ago, Aden said: It's preposterous because an ancient solo Gaga song went mega viral enough LAST YEAR to go top 10 on radio and because ARUTW is dog-walking numerous 2020s hits in recurrent streams. A solo Gaga soundtrack song also almost went top 40 just two years ago when 99% of soundtracks don't even crack the Hot 100. The fact is that this forum loves to downplay Gaga's commercial success so while Gaga isn't solely responsible for this song smashing, it's just as preposterous to say Bruno is the sole reason this smashed. Both had relatively similar Billboard stats before this launch so it's moot to see which solo version would have theoretically smashed harder because we'll never know. Both of those songs had other factors going on for them that they massively benefited from. One being a viral moment and the other one a huge movie. I'm not downplaying her success. I'm just saying that it's harder for her nowadays to drop a song and have it smash """organically"" as in people having genuine interest for that mp3 file without other factors coming into play. Plus, I was referring to this song specifically which is Bruno's playground as he has had multiple other massive hits of the same vibe. Gaga not so much which is why I said what I said.
Blade Posted August 28 Posted August 28 2 minutes ago, SignificantOther said: Gaga hasn't had a top 3 solo hit in over a decade, so Bruno. And Bruno hasn't had a top 3 solo hit in 8 years??? Why are we acting like they both had extremely recent Top 3 solo hits. 3
Wewee Posted August 28 Posted August 28 (edited) Omgggggg @Kukai congrats for your gold certification Edited August 28 by Wewee 1
PYT Posted August 28 Posted August 28 Def 50/50. Tho if it were to be a solo song for each of them, I think Bruno would have a better chance to make it more successful than Gaga. The song is more of his repetitive throwback schtick. Apparently the sound that most have been using on tiktok is the one that uses his vocals only, uploaded by his fan. Surprised it even eclipsed the main sound. Spoiler Main sound: https://www.tiktok.com/music/Die-With-A-Smile-7403588534353528848 Bruno's vocals: https://www.tiktok.com/music/sonido-original-7403607973620157189
Mtjjproducer Posted August 28 Posted August 28 Bruno This song is basically a silk sonic song and Bruno took off Andersons vocals and replaced them with gaga 1 1
Kukai Posted August 28 Author Posted August 28 4 hours ago, FameIsForever said: With what vocal range? Sis has the range of a Fisher Price toy piano. It would not be a duet more like background vocals. Sabrina has a wider vocal range than GaGa sweetie Sabrina: 3 octaves and three half steps GaGa: 3 octaves and 1 half steps 10 minutes ago, PYT said: Def 50/50. Tho if it were to be a solo song for each of them, I think Bruno would have a better chance to make it more successful than Gaga. The song is more of his repetitive throwback schtick. Apparently the sound that most have been using on tiktok is the one that uses his vocals only, uploaded by his fan. Surprised it even eclipsed the main sound. Reveal hidden contents Main sound: https://www.tiktok.com/music/Die-With-A-Smile-7403588534353528848 Bruno's vocals: https://www.tiktok.com/music/sonido-original-7403607973620157189 Yes I also noticed most people only used Bruno's part of the song on Tik Tok… How peculiar 1 13
kudmips7890 Posted August 28 Posted August 28 6 hours ago, FameIsForever said: Fisher Price toy piano I actually do love her recent output but-
burninredhot Posted August 28 Posted August 28 (edited) I mean Bruno's charting like 5 other songs on global spotify while Gaga's coming off a mostly dull era (Chromatica and that Top Gun song) Edited August 28 by burninredhot
burninredhot Posted August 28 Posted August 28 6 hours ago, Doctor Dick said: She didn't NEED Ariana. As it became evident when Stupid Love dropped, her fanbase alone are able to give her a Top 5 debut. What's the point of going top 5 when the song's been stuck at 300M streams for like 4 years? It's clear Gaga hasn't scored a solo hit on her albums since 2011 2 1
Ethereaaal Posted August 28 Posted August 28 Another downvote farming thread by the one and only, the shakiest Ms. @Kukai. I hope you're getting paid. Bling not the music.
Infernal Paradise Posted August 28 Posted August 28 1 hour ago, burninredhot said: What's the point of going top 5 when the song's been stuck at 300M streams for like 4 years? It's clear Gaga hasn't scored a solo hit on her albums since 2011 Imagine how TIRED we are...Weren't you clockedT over your stale attempts in the DWAS streams thread just recently On 8/23/2024 at 10:15 PM, Miichael said: You said before that she hasn't had a solo hit since 2011, she literally has a solo album track from 2018 outstreaming other artists #1 singles right now. It's giving I'm afraid but repeating this over and over again isn't going to make it magically true. Now let's look at the reality. SoLo GLOBAL HIT Applause (578M streams, pre-streaming boom, 5x Plat eligible in US) Region Certification Certified units/sales Australia (ARIA)[205] 3× Platinum 210,000‡ Brazil (Pro-Música Brasil)[206] Diamond 250,000‡ Canada (Music Canada)[207] 5× Platinum 400,000‡ France — 60,000[208] Germany (BVMI)[209] Gold 150,000‡ Italy (FIMI)[65] Platinum 30,000* Japan (RIAJ)[210] Gold 100,000* Mexico (AMPROFON)[211] Platinum 60,000* New Zealand (RMNZ)[66] Gold 7,500* Norway (IFPI Norway)[212] 2× Platinum 120,000‡ South Korea — 106,385[213] Spain (PROMUSICAE)[214] Since 2015 Gold 30,000‡ Sweden (GLF)[215] 2× Platinum 80,000‡ United Kingdom (BPI)[63] Platinum 530,000[64] United States (RIAA)[60] 4× Platinum 2,700,000[59] Streaming Denmark (IFPI Danmark)[216] Gold 900,000† SoLo GLOBAL HIT Million Reasons (843M streams, ZERO days spent on TTH, 4x Plat eligible in US) Region Certification Certified units/sales Australia (ARIA)[127] 4× Platinum 280,000‡ Brazil (Pro-Música Brasil)[128] Diamond 250,000‡ Canada (Music Canada)[129] Gold 40,000‡ Denmark (IFPI Danmark)[130] Gold 45,000‡ France (SNEP)[131] Platinum 200,000‡ Germany (BVMI)[132] Gold 200,000‡ Italy (FIMI)[133] 3× Platinum 150,000‡ Norway (IFPI Norway)[134] Platinum 60,000‡ Poland (ZPAV)[135] 2× Platinum 40,000‡ Spain (PROMUSICAE)[136] Platinum 60,000‡ United Kingdom (BPI)[137] Platinum 600,000‡ United States (RIAA)[43] 3× Platinum 1,100,000[44] Streaming Sweden (GLF)[138] Gold 4,000,000† SoLo GLOBAL MEGA-HIT Always Remember Us This Way (1.33B streams, non-single in most countries, 5x Plat eligible in US) Region Certification Certified units/sales Australia (ARIA)[31] 7× Platinum 490,000‡ Belgium (BEA)[98] Platinum 40,000‡ Brazil (Pro-Música Brasil)[99] 4× Diamond 640,000‡ Denmark (IFPI Danmark)[100] 2× Platinum 180,000‡ France (SNEP)[101] Diamond 333,333‡ Germany (BVMI)[102] Gold 200,000‡ Italy (FIMI)[103] 2× Platinum 200,000‡ New Zealand (RMNZ)[33] Platinum 30,000‡ Norway (IFPI Norway)[104] 4× Platinum 240,000‡ Poland (ZPAV)[105] 4× Platinum 200,000‡ Portugal (AFP)[106] 2× Platinum 20,000‡ Spain (PROMUSICAE)[107] 2× Platinum 120,000‡ Switzerland (IFPI Switzerland)[108] Gold 10,000‡ United Kingdom (BPI)[38] 2× Platinum 1,200,000‡ United States (RIAA)[109] Platinum 248,000[27] Streaming Sweden (GLF)[110] 3× Platinum 24,000,000† All three belonging to albums credited to the artist Lady Gaga. Very apt username, burnin' red hot with anger, but it is time to accept that Gaga is here to stick around with iconic hits beloved by the GP, both solo or otherwise. 5
Aston Martin Posted August 28 Posted August 28 8 hours ago, Yes, AND said: Neither. Massive playlist reach and no 1 on TTH. If Womans world had that it would also be in the top 10. If this were true then WW and DWAS would have similar performances on other platforms like YouTube and Apple Music. Yet DWAS has over double the views WW has and it topped AM US (and it's currently at #4) whereas WW never cracked the top 200 not to mention DWAS has been huge on TikTok, but WW's only mentions on that platform were to ridicule it. ot: seeing as both Gaga and Bruno have great talent, back catalogues, hits, and longevity, they both contributed to the song's success. 1
ChooseyLover Posted August 28 Posted August 28 (edited) 9 hours ago, Yes, AND said: Neither. Massive playlist reach and no 1 on TTH. If Womans world had that it would also be in the top 10. The level of delusion is through the roof Can't believe I discussed chart talk with you two days ago thinking you were a person with common sense Edited August 28 by ChooseyLover 1
Mr. Duff Posted August 28 Posted August 28 Both. Come on now, the song won't be as good as it is with just only one of them. They contributed equally to the greatness of the song.
burninredhot Posted August 28 Posted August 28 2 hours ago, Infernal Paradise said: Imagine how TIRED we are...Weren't you clockedT over your stale attempts in the DWAS streams thread just recently Just because I didn't reply to all the 20 liddos quoting me at the same time doesn't mean I was "clockedT" Tell me where I'm wrong with saying stupid love is a flop? Any other pop girl pulls those numbers and bored liddos themselves would enter those threads to call them "frontloaded" or "she's over"
Digitalism Posted August 28 Posted August 28 (edited) Tbh I agree with the poll They were in a similar stage of their careers and they both do well with ballads Edited August 28 by Digitalism
Yes, AND Posted August 28 Posted August 28 23 hours ago, Doctor Dick said: She didn't NEED Ariana. As it became evident when Stupid Love dropped, her fanbase alone are able to give her a Top 5 debut. With or without Ariana the song would've been a Top 10 single. She also didn't NEED Bradley, if Shallow had been solo it would've smashed the same way. This is super delusional. 2 1
Recommended Posts