Jump to content

Who's more responsible for Die With A Smile's success: Bruno or GaGa?


Who’s more responsible for the song’s success?  

362 members have voted

  1. 1. Who’s more responsible for the song’s success?



Recommended Posts

Posted
Spoiler

Thread making abilities should be stripped with that amount of negative reputation.

OT: Both. Generational talented artists that make incredible music that resonated with the GeePee and irks Kukai to no end.

MIc7wn0.thumb.gif.09b51e3f687ed1c1a148db

  • Like 4

  • Replies 171
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Blade

    11

  • Kukai

    9

  • Sex with Rih

    5

  • Yes, AND

    5

Posted

Your obsession Kukai

Posted

The Gargoyles are NOT gonna be happy with this thread

 

MIc7wn0.thumb.gif.09b51e3f687ed1c1a148db

  • Haha 1
  • Thumbs Down 2
Posted

:eli:

  • Like 7
Posted

Love Gaga with all my heart but she's not made for this kind of songs. Yes I know Shallow and the other songs from ASIB were huge but in this one specifically she gets massively outshined by Bruno. This is his bread and butter and I would enjoy the song more if it was solely sung by him. I'm sure gp agrees too.

  • Like 1
  • Haha 2
  • Confused 5
  • Thumbs Down 18
Posted (edited)
12 minutes ago, Pop Art said:

More downvotes?

 

OT: I actually think this is a pretty equal billing in terms of who is to be #Thanked. I believe this is Bruno's highest debut (#ThankYouGaga), it's had greater longevity so far than some of Gaga's recent material (#ThankYouBruno), they both have about the same amount of Top 10s (#ThankYouGagaANDBruno), etcetera. Gaga is bringing the more intense punch of acute attention, while Bruno is bringing the slower burn of extended consumption. The best of both worlds that BOTH are responsible for. :cm:

So what you're saying is Gaga's next SOLO single will reach the top 3 as well since, according to you, she played a huge role in DWAS' success?

 

Brave prediction.

 

spacer.png

Edited by Kukai
  • Confused 1
  • Thumbs Down 23
Posted
1 minute ago, dumbsparce said:

Love Gaga with all my heart but she's not made for this kind of songs. Yes I know Shallow and the other songs from ASIB were huge but in this one specifically she gets massively outshined by Bruno. This is his bread and butter and I would enjoy the song more if it was solely sung by him. I'm sure gp agrees too.

Not you saying this when the song's first viral moment was Gaga's dance during the bridge :rip: 

  • Like 7
Posted

Good question, who can I blame for the LG7 delay due to this shaky smash hit? 

Kukai

Posted

Obviously Bruno since the sing is 100% his type of music, it caters mostly to his fanbase imo. It would have the same success without gaGa.

  • Thanks 2
  • Thumbs Down 8
Posted
8 minutes ago, Nicholai said:

Is the song tanking yet miss @bjorn?

spacer.png

  • Thumbs Down 5
Posted

90% Auto play 10% Bruno 

 

MIc7wn0.thumb.gif.09b51e3f687ed1c1a148db

  • Thumbs Down 10
Posted

I'm just here for Kukai to smash the ATRL Downvote Hot 100 once again

 

Pxv2n0j.gif

  • Like 3
  • Haha 7
Posted

Miss @Kukai becoming an ATRL legend with just 1400 posts. Some of yall WISH.

 

MIc7wn0.thumb.gif.09b51e3f687ed1c1a148db

  • Haha 3
Posted

Both are responsible for the one version of the song :clap3:

b34c40635cdae715f112f86d9ab7aa25.gif

  • Like 1
Posted
18 minutes ago, Kukai said:

So what you're saying is Gaga's next SOLO single will reach the top 3 as well because she played a huge role in DWAS' success?

 

Brave prediction.

 

spacer.png

No, I'm saying it wasn't until Bruno collabed with Gaga that he was able to debut higher than #4 on the Hot 100, whereas Gaga has done that three times already before this (and twice SOLO since that's your favorite word it seems).

 

My only prediction is that you'll reach a -2000 reputation before your fave's album comes out next month (or even by the end of this month if you keep this foolishness up). 

 

giphy.gif

  • Like 5
  • Haha 4
Posted

We will never know, legend, since it's a DUO, now and forever. 

 

MIc7wn0.thumb.gif.09b51e3f687ed1c1a148db

Posted
19 minutes ago, ClashAndBurn said:

The song could have charted the same even if it were a Bruno Mars solo. Gaga has needed collaborations for every top 3 single she's had since after The Edge Of Glory in 2011, so... :michael: 

he's never had a #1 on Global Spotify nor a Top 3 debut on the Hot 100 while Gaga has achieved both of those things before, sometimes even several times.

 

Considering it's only had 1 full week on the charts, there is ZERO evidence to assume it would have done better than #3 on the Hot 100 without Gaga. Not even his biggest hits have debuted that high.

  • Like 7
Posted
19 minutes ago, Walk_Away21 said:

The Gargoyles are NOT gonna be happy with this thread

 

MIc7wn0.thumb.gif.09b51e3f687ed1c1a148db

Whatever "unhappiness" this thread brings us (as if we care about the opinion of tasteless twinks) will be undone the second we open the Global Spotify chart and look at #1

 

MIc7wn0.thumb.gif.09b51e3f687ed1c1a148db

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 3
Posted (edited)

The hypotheticals in this thread to cope :skull:

 

-----------

Both. 

 

GV7HO7IWAAAcjfP?format=jpg&name=large

 

 

Edited by Infernal Paradise
  • Like 4
  • Thanks 3
Posted

If Shallow was a mega hit, what makes you think it's only Bruno? So Bruno and Bradley Cooper are on the same level?

  • Thanks 1
Posted
Just now, duybeeGAshantiGA said:

If Shallow was a mega hit, what makes you think it's only Bruno? So Bruno and Bradley Cooper are on the same level?

The only prior "collab" evidence they have is Rain On Me, where Ariana was clearly at her peak streaming wise.

 

Shallow being a data point for Gaga "needing collabs" to smash is laughable to anyone with half a brain.

  • Like 4
Posted (edited)
8 minutes ago, Infernal Paradise said:

GV7HO7IWAAAcjfP?format=jpg&name=large

Bruno then?

 

spacer.png

 

14 minutes ago, Pop Art said:

No, I'm saying it wasn't until Bruno collabed with Gaga that he was able to debut higher than #4 on the Hot 100, whereas Gaga has done that three times already before this (and twice SOLO since that's your favorite word it seems).

 

My only prediction is that you'll reach a -2000 reputation before your fave's album comes out next month (or even by the end of this month if you keep this foolishness up). 

 

giphy.gif

So LG7's solo single will replicate DWAS' success?

 

Noted.

 

spacer.png

 

21 minutes ago, Jacobdaniel said:

Would Bruno feat. Katy have been as successful?

 

MIc7wn0.thumb.gif.09b51e3f687ed1c1a148db

 

 

Bruno feat. Sabrina Carpenter (my fave) would easily be more successful, yes.
 

But Sabrina is already going no. 1 with SOLO singles so that's not necessary 

 

spacer.png

Edited by Kukai
  • Thumbs Down 24
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.