bielneira Posted August 26 Posted August 26 Charli xcx — Brat: 8.6 KINDA Beyoncé — Cowboy Carter: 8.4 DEFINITELY NO Sabrina Carpenter — Short n' Sweet: 8.0 DEFINITELY NO Ariana Grande — eternal sunshine: 7.2 KINDA Chappell Roan — Midwest Princess: 7.2 YES Billie Eilish — Hit Me Hard and Soft: 6.8 DEFINITELY NO Dua Lipa — Radical Optimism: 6.6 YES Taylor Swift — Tortured Poets: The Anthology: 6.0 KINDA 1
Tm4074 Posted August 26 Posted August 26 Pitchfork seems to have it out for the established stars this year besides Beyoncé lol. They gave artists like Ice Spice a 7.6 , Tyla an 8.0, and Sabrina an 8.0. Ariana should be high 70s, Billie should definitely be high 70s, at least. Sabrina should be lower 70s. SnS was solid but not 8.0 material compared to how they rated other pop albums this year. Entitled to their own opinion though so whatever.
Ewan Chaos Posted August 26 Posted August 26 Beyonce is a little too high, Sabrina is too high, and Billie is too low, otherwise not bad looking at it outside. Personally my list is a tiny bit different: Charli > Billie > Beyonce > Sabrina > Ariana > Dua > Chappell > Taylor
wish Posted August 26 Posted August 26 Brat - 9.0 Hit Me Hard And Soft - 8.2 Midwest Princess - 8.0 Cowboy Carter - 8.0 Eternal Sunshine - 7.8 Short N Sweet - 7.6 Radical Optimism - 6.5 TTPD - 6.2 ^ These scores are closer to what I would have expected from Pitchfork years ago. 1
ONOPKA Posted August 26 Posted August 26 here's how it should look: brat - 9.2 HMHAS - 8.3 cowboy carter - 8.0 midwest princess - 7.1 eternal sunshine - 6.9 TTPD - 6.2 short n sweet - 6.0 radical optimism - 5.5 i do not agree w the scores for billie or sabrina at all 1
Price of Fame Posted August 26 Posted August 26 Swap Billie and Sabrina in that order and it's a perfectly respectable list
Arrows Posted August 26 Posted August 26 9 hours ago, Arrows said: Chappell, Billie and Taylor released the best albums, so they're wrong Why are hordes down-voting me for praising 3 albums? Is the anti-Taylor cult that obsessed?
StayFrosty Posted August 26 Posted August 26 Wait a minute, why doesn't Chappel's album have a metacritic page?
Noodles Posted August 26 Posted August 26 They're largely correct. I'd put Billie a bit higher (but no higher than 7.5) and Sabrina lower (but no lower than 7)
YourFavoriteWeapon Posted August 26 Posted August 26 Brat - 9.2 Hit Me Hard And Soft - 8.8 Midwest Princess - 8.4 Cowboy Carter - 8.4 Eternal Sunshine - 7.9 Short N Sweet - 7.8 Radical Optimism - 6.9 TTPD - 7.9
Contessa Posted August 27 Posted August 27 (edited) Charli xcx — Brat Billie Eilish — Hit Me Hard and Soft Ariana Grande — eternal sunshine Sabrina Carpenter — Short n' Sweet Dua Lipa — Radical Optimism Chappell Roan — Midwest Princess Beyoncé — Cowboy Carter Taylor Swift — Tortured Poets: The Anthology This would be my ranking of these albums, yours truly xoxo Edited August 27 by Contessa
modeblock Posted August 27 Posted August 27 (edited) I would switch Sabrina and Billie, but Taylor last feels right because of the poor material. Edited August 27 by modeblock
CottageHore Posted August 27 Posted August 27 I like Sabrina but PF rating her new album above Chappell and Billie's albums is insane
CottageHore Posted August 27 Posted August 27 46 minutes ago, Contessa said: Charli xcx — Brat: 8.6 Billie Eilish — Hit Me Hard and Soft: 6.8 Ariana Grande — eternal sunshine: 7.2 Sabrina Carpenter — Short n' Sweet: 8.0 Dua Lipa — Radical Optimism: 6.6 Chappell Roan — Midwest Princess: 7.2 Beyoncé — Cowboy Carter: 8.4 Taylor Swift — Tortured Poets: The Anthology: 6.0 This would be my ranking of these albums, yours truly xoxo Brat: 7.5 (I love Charli sm but y'all are doing way too much) HMHAS: 8.1 Eternal Sunshine: 7.0 Midwest Princess: 9.0 Short n Sweet: 7.5 Radical Optimism: 7.2 Cowboy Carter: 8.7 TTPD: 4.0
Letemtalk Posted August 30 Posted August 30 On 8/27/2024 at 6:55 AM, StayFrosty said: Wait a minute, why doesn't Chappel's album have a metacritic page? Metacritic only seems to accept reviews submitted in the first few weeks after release. She has 84 on albumoftheyear.org https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/712410-chappell-roan-the-rise-and-fall-of-a-midwest-princess.php
Recommended Posts