base talk Have Brat/HMHAS overshadowed TTPD?

[latingrl2005]

It doesn't matter. Taylor was smart to release new music while touring in Europe. It gave the tour new life and she selling like hotcakes. Midnights was already dying out and it gives her break from radio till TS12.  

[Guilherme Make Love]

I don´t think so in total numbers, no one can beat Taylor in this category

 

But in public conversation and overall cultural impact? It definitely feels like it, both are just constantly being discussed pretty much everywhere now while TTPD weirdly feels very contained in Taylor big fanbase.

 

The Eras tour is the only current project from Taylor that people overall seems very into it.

Edited August 1 by Guilherme Make Love

[Breathe On Moi]

all things point to a resounding YES 

 

[Twixxted]

Without a f'ing doubt.

[Maroonx]

with 12 weeks at #1... hmmm I think not.  x But good for Brat/HMHAS

 

[K$Ellie]

aren't both billie singles AND an album track outstreaming anything on the 31 track album right now?

[WildHeart]

3 hours ago, bad guy said:

In the real world where HMHAS has reigned at #1 longer than any Taylor album on Spotify, where both singles have outperformed Taylor's, and where it's doing better on AM as well, I'd go with yes for Billie. 

 

 

1 hour ago, K$Ellie said:

aren't both billie singles AND an album track outstreaming anything on the 31 track album right now?

Can we expect HMHAS to outstream TTPD then?

Looking at their track record ( DSAM failing against Reputation, WWAFAS failing against Lover, HTE failing against Folklore)... things are not in favor of Billie so let's hope it ends up different this time. 

 

Streaming era artist with 5 years career failing to outstream an artist with 18 years career from digital era is not a good look for the listen before i go chanteuse

Edited August 2 by WildHeart

[HASHTAGPOW]

My grandmother's last words was brat summer so YES

 

[lovecatt]

Yup!

[Gorjesspazze9]

Didn't Taylor sell like 5 million albums in the last 3 months alone?

 

[Bosque]

Mom said it's my turn to create the "did brat have more cultural impact than TTPD" thread tomorrow 

[Guilherme Make Love]

3 minutes ago, WildHeart said:

 

Can we expect HMHAS to outstream TTPD then?

Looking at their track record ( DSAM failing against Reputation, WWAFAS failing against Lover, HTE failing against Folklore)... things are not in favor of Billie so let's hope it ends up different this time. 

 

Streaming era artist with 5 years career failing to outstream an artist with 18 years career from digital era is not a good for the listen before i go chanteuse

I mean ... did you expect her to have more total streams with 10 tracks than an album with 31? 

 

Billie has been pulling stronger average per track streams than Taylor consistently since HMHAS dropped. Having the triple of songs is literally the only reason why Taylor have more streams lol

 

 

[Digitalism]

Hmhas of course

Brat is not there yet

They are both culturallly more relevant tho

Ttpd just feels as a part of the eras era. It doesn't hold itself on its own

Edited August 1 by Digitalism

[WildHeart]

7 minutes ago, Guilherme Make Love said:

Having the triple of songs is literally the only reason why Taylor have more streams lol

Is this why... 

13 minutes ago, WildHeart said:

DSAM failing against Reputation, WWAFAS failing against Lover, HTE failing against Folklore

 

Top 10 tracks 

TTPD - 2.6B

HMHAS - 2.3B 

 

And that's despite 21 other songs stealing streams from these 10 songs 

Edited August 1 by WildHeart

[feelslikeadream]

No.

 

I don't understand people saying yes to HMHAS. I haven't seen the album discussed anywhere outside of ATRL  I think it's a great album, but the idea of it overshadowing Taylor when shes at her popularity peak is... a little suspect.

[The Music Industry]

The biggest artist of the year with the biggest album of the year and the biggest tour of the year is being overshadowed? Y'all are so unserious it's actually hilarious

Edited August 1 by The Music Industry

[Kiss It Better]

for two albums i haven't listened since release week, i'm hearing more about brat than ttpd and that should say something 

[Samuel665]

In the long run, it will be !

[Popboi.]

12 minutes ago, Samuel665 said:

In the long run, it will be !

This is the first Charli album to chart for more than 2 weeks and Billie has a terrible track record of the albums falling off as soon as the singles do, good luck booking that long run you speak of  meanwhile only 1 of the 3 is returning (not everybody got there in the first place) to #1 for a 13th week 

 

 

Edited August 2 by Popboi.

[Guilherme Make Love]

2 hours ago, WildHeart said:

Is this why... 

 

Top 10 tracks 

TTPD - 2.6B

HMHAS - 2.3B 

 

And that's despite 21 other songs stealing streams from these 10 songs 

So with the same amount of tracks Taylor only have 300M more streams despite releasing her album 5 weeks before Billie ... which means Billie is going faster in the average per track

 

Thanks for reaffirming my point i guess

[WildHeart]

1 minute ago, Guilherme Make Love said:

So with the same amount of tracks Taylor only have 300M more streams despite releasing her album 5 weeks before Billie ...

Except that they don't have same amount of tracks... 

 

OT :

 

[Storm653]

Musically, not at all. 

 

In terms of sparking social media trends, maybe. 

 

But, overall, TTPD is bigger than both. Even globally, it's been very successful in a short period of time. 

 

And Taylor just went viral and got compared to MJ for having 40,000 people crowding themselves in a hill to watch her show in Germany.

 

But, it's ATRL, so of course people are going to act like TTPD is irrelevant and has nobody listening to it because it has no summer bops on it. Whatever makes people feel better is the right answer. 

Edited August 2 by Storm653

[Trash]

Most of the time I read about TTPD is people hating on it either here or on twitter, while Brat has positive clout and HMHAS has the critics, so kinda.