Starchild Posted September 2 Posted September 2 (edited) I don't think Both of us, even only hearing it once in my lifetime, is as bad as other songs Edit: oh it's made by Luke, trash! Though it was when he was huge and it was only because of BOB Edited September 2 by Starchild
TaylenaStan Posted September 2 Posted September 2 1 minute ago, Forever Winter said: 246. Both of Us (B.o.B feat. Taylor Swift) 4.978 Comments BOAZ 10 - "Lol guilty pleasure." MusicLoverDude 6 - "B.o.B. was starting to lose his charm here. Taylor kind of saved him here." blown away 4.9 - "Taylor is definitely the highlight on this, she shouldn't have wasted this beautiful chorus on this song." wastedpotential 4.8 - "Let's pretend we don't see the production credits, and lets pretend B.o.B isn't a flat earther, and lets pretend this wasn't a ginormous flop (the fact that the Holy Williams collab this was clearly trying to replicate outsold this by a factor of 6 and she's now a TayOpener... that's embarrassing, but I guess that goes to show that Swifties save our money for music with Lord's name in the top billing), and then we'll probably be in better shape. We'd also be better off if Taylor's portion didn't consist of two lines repeated a few times, and then a bit of howling in the bridge." 1989 3.1 - "This great value Airplanes." Where are you now? 2.3 - "Neither of us." Achilles. 2 - "I still remember the words to the chorus but that's it. Flop effort." NewStanner 2 - "Why do almost all these side songs and collabs suck, help." Bosque 0 - "This seems like a fever dream in hindsight." Results Hide contents Starchild 5 AbeHicks 10 Miles. 10 Losing my ground 10 BOAZ 10 FolkLover1989 10 Enrique523 9 Don 9 wehavetostan 9 MidnightsAtPeace 8.7 LastKiss 8.5 folkloreking 8.5 SleepingTigers 8.5 @freakum. 8 Gorjesspazze9 8 burninredhot 8 Supernatural 8 fridayteenage 8 Strawberry Bubble 8 Swirl900 8 Blood Magic 8 Sanguine 8 heckinglovato 8 Top Dash 7.9 Bindi 7.8 terrorblade 7.7 enchanted0 7.5 Safe&Sound 7.3 tb6591 7.2 Michael196 7.2 Solaria 7 llikeh 7 badidearight 7 halcyonday 7 Axolotl 7 PerfectSacrifice 7 frankvert 7 vinicius 7 Yog 7 djcalpal 7 makeawish 7 kyungsoowift 7 Flower 7 Heldenzeit 7 chiliam 7 greeneyedsoul 7 The Music Industry 6.7 greento 6.5 Forever Winter 6.5 305 6.5 skizzo 6.5 liam13 6.5 SoSickOfThatSOL 6.5 Cruel Summer 6.4 Velvet Night 6.1 DevilsRollTheDice 6 sanzo 6 Vespertine 6 chosensparkles 6 Nein 6 brokee 6 ellis-bell 6 MusicLoverDude 6 Hooker Barbie 6 twoheadlightshine 6 sparrowblue 6 Bartender 6 Rev8 6 Edge of Glory 6 roso 5.7 G.U.Y_Del_Rey 5.5 Catch22 5.5 creativity. 5.5 tjspy 5.3 jacklovesyou1 5.2 Lazuli 5.1 NordicGuy 5 Live To Tell 5 Avrileon 5 CamiloPg_ 5 Theluckyone 5 Iamanearthling 5 Venice B 5 Great Username 5 Tedwards 5 Sad Beautiful Tragic 5 Terylee 5 paulyyyozd 5 Kyle-x 5 Ms. Togekiss 5 blown away 4.9 Mr. Duff 4.8 wastedpotential 4.8 Peroxide 4.7 SylMacPer 4.6 ChapelHooker 4.5 jacobhalkohit 4.5 SLUTTVFTV 4.5 TaylenaStan 4.4 pinkbowvintage 4 a_d_22 4 Soobin 4 Riverbank 4 Hurem 4 gagacasanova 4 Fitzswiftie 4 Feanor 4 Holy Ground 4 LovaticSwiftie 4 RihannaLoverrr 4 Dear Reader 4 Klein 4 Clauss 4 Flames2Embers 4 fab 4 yourfaveisaflop 4 AdrianNicki 4 StonedSoulPicnic 4 reputation1989 3.8 Ger.vaz 3.6 Ampersand13 3.5 modern thing 3.5 1989 3.1 PoisonedIvy 3.1 PaloSanto 3 D-@-N 3 Prismee 3 Schami66 3 LVP 3 ONOPKA 3 Bussea 3 Byzantium 3 My Tears Ricochet 3 idkwiam 2.8 KillingYourCareer 2.5 beagle 2.5 Where are you now? 2.3 Namigo 2 Tusk 2 Life Savers 2 Mezik 2 GuyNextDoor 2 americanlife 2 pavi 2 Taylor fanboy 2 K$Ellie 2 NewStanner 2 Achilles. 2 Lorenzo22 2 TheArgonaut 1.5 Diarrhoea 1.5 LoveInStereo 1.2 NEX 1 Teen Spirit 1 4Real 1 Arrows 1 itsjem 1 AshleyLovescats887 1 StØned 1 NextBish90 1 Mocha 1 holyground13 1 Quicksand 1 By the Water 1 TMRA 0 Bosque 0 Truly the most random song in her discography
Taylor fanboy Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Oh. A Dr. L*ke song. We demand a Kesha collab to pay for this crime. 2 1
jacklovesyou1 Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Both of us is a mid song imo ... i remember it being big on uk 4music channel for like a good week tho
wastedpotential Posted September 2 Posted September 2 1 minute ago, Taylor fanboy said: Oh. A Dr. L*ke song. We demand a Kesha collab to pay for this crime. SPEAK ON IT
AshleyLovescats887 Posted September 2 Posted September 2 48 minutes ago, Taylor fanboy said: Is @AshleyLovescats887 Taylor Swift's ATRL handle?
Achilles. Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Just now, TaylenaStan said: Truly the most random song in her discography 8
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 2 Author Posted September 2 245. Christmases When You Were Mine 4.978 Comments SLUTTVFTV 9 - "Underrated as hell! She needs to re-record it." wastedpotential 8.8 - "An epiphany hit me the other day, that She basically ripped herself off when She made Message In A Bottle, because why does that have the EXACT same melody as this little classic? Y'all hear that too (assuming you listened to this ddd), right? I know I'm insane, but not for this one. Anyway, this is just a gorgeous and sweet and somber Christmas breakup anthem, it sits with me deeply, and I'll be adding it to my next Christmas party playlist to depress everyone and to send them to the open bar! I do believe this could be classified as her single worst vocal performance on a studio track, but that's fine because literally nobody has heard it. I love the imagery She uses in this song, because it's so patently phony and She doesn't even try to disguise it. Sister, you moved to Nashville when you were 14, and as far as I know never had a serious relationship before that (at least I'd hope so). Why on EARTH are you writing about the freezing Christmas weather and the snow-covered little town when Nashville gets snow on Christmas once a decade and drops below freezing a few nights a year? Sister, be serious, please." reputation1989 8.5 - "Absolutely horrible but I stan." Achilles. 6.5 - "This one is actually quite good!" Where are you now? 6.5 - "Heartwarming original - she's gotta re-record it!" LoveInStereo 5.9 - "These vocals... this could be redeemed with a TV, till then, pass!" Bosque 5 - "The most tolerable vocals on this album." Lorenzo22 1.8 - "The vocal delivery is atrocious. :deadbanana:" Klein 1 - "You can't spell Christmases When You Were Mine without ME!" blown away 1 - "Compared to these vocals miss Selena Gomez sounds like peak Mariah Carey." Results Spoiler MusicLoverDude 6 Starchild 5 KillingYourCareer 10 AshleyLovescats887 10 AbeHicks 10 fridayteenage 10 Kyle-x 10 Taylor fanboy 10 SLUTTVFTV 9 Losing my ground 9 chiliam 9 wastedpotential 8.8 StØned 8.6 makeawish 8.5 llikeh 8 folkloreking 8 Iamanearthling 8 PerfectSacrifice 8 burninredhot 8 brokee 8 enchanted0 8 sparrowblue 7.5 Sanguine 7.5 tjspy 7.3 Michael196 7.2 Soobin 7.1 greento 7 Live To Tell 7 a_d_22 7 Hurem 7 reputation1989 7 Enrique523 7 Axolotl 7 liam13 7 Supernatural 7 Mocha 7 Holy Ground 7 Dear Reader 7 ellis-bell 7 TheArgonaut 7 Bussea 7 kyungsoowift 7 SleepingTigers 7 greeneyedsoul 7 Lazuli 7 Rev8 7 Don 7 SoSickOfThatSOL 7 StonedSoulPicnic 7 Safe&Sound 6.9 Mr. Duff 6.8 MidnightsAtPeace 6.6 Quicksand 6.5 Where are you now? 6.5 Achilles. 6.5 Edge of Glory 6.5 roso 6.3 djcalpal 6.2 tb6591 6 NordicGuy 6 Forever Winter 6 pinkbowvintage 6 Namigo 6 Riverbank 6 LastKiss 6 itsjem 6 gagacasanova 6 chosensparkles 6 Gorjesspazze9 6 Feanor 6 Tedwards 6 Nein 6 Ger.vaz 6 BOAZ 6 Flower 6 Bartender 6 LoveInStereo 5.9 Velvet Night 5.7 Avrileon 5.6 SylMacPer 5.5 G.U.Y_Del_Rey 5.5 Bindi 5.4 idkwiam 5.1 PaloSanto 5 sanzo 5 4Real 5 Theluckyone 5 Life Savers 5 badidearight 5 halcyonday 5 Venice B 5 Yog 5 Miles. 5 RihannaLoverrr 5 Hooker Barbie 5 My Tears Ricochet 5 K$Ellie 5 Bosque 5 Ms. Togekiss 5 FolkLover1989 4.8 305 4.5 ChapelHooker 4.5 terrorblade 4 Solaria 4 CamiloPg_ 4 skizzo 4 jacobhalkohit 4 vinicius 4 Ampersand13 4 Schami66 4 TaylenaStan 4 Catch22 4 paulyyyozd 4 twoheadlightshine 4 Blood Magic 4 heckinglovato 4 wehavetostan 4 Cruel Summer 3.5 The Music Industry 3 Arrows 3 Fitzswiftie 3 Prismee 3 Great Username 3 GuyNextDoor 3 americanlife 3 ONOPKA 3 Strawberry Bubble 3 Flames2Embers 3 fab 3 yourfaveisaflop 3 pavi 3 Top Dash 3 PoisonedIvy 2.5 1989 2.2 beagle 2.1 Peroxide 2 DevilsRollTheDice 2 Vespertine 2 D-@-N 2 LVP 2 Terylee 2 LovaticSwiftie 2 creativity. 2 Clauss 2 Byzantium 2 Heldenzeit 2 jacklovesyou1 2 Lorenzo22 1.8 AdrianNicki 1.5 NewStanner 1.5 Tusk 1.2 NEX 1 Teen Spirit 1 @freakum. 1 frankvert 1 Mezik 1 NextBish90 1 modern thing 1 holyground13 1 Klein 1 Swirl900 1 Diarrhoea 1 blown away 1 TMRA 1 By the Water 1 Sad Beautiful Tragic 0 1
chiliam Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Meth deserved better, you guys doing too much on a carefree fun bop. I wish it was an album track to be appreciate rather than a dragfest lead single. 1
wastedpotential Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Just now, NewStanner said: Highway Nightmare is NEXT I fear Yeah let's book Highway Sleepovers next 1
Taylor fanboy Posted September 2 Posted September 2 These are sisters Chrismases When You Were Mine The Moment I Knew Champagne Problems Tis The Damn Season The second child are always the ugliest!
wastedpotential Posted September 2 Posted September 2 1 minute ago, Forever Winter said: 245. Christmases When You Were Mine 4.978 Comments SLUTTVFTV 9 - "Underrated as hell! She needs to re-record it." wastedpotential 8.8 - "An epiphany hit me the other day, that She basically ripped herself off when She made Message In A Bottle, because why does that have the EXACT same melody as this little classic? Y'all hear that too (assuming you listened to this ddd), right? I know I'm insane, but not for this one. Anyway, this is just a gorgeous and sweet and somber Christmas breakup anthem, it sits with me deeply, and I'll be adding it to my next Christmas party playlist to depress everyone and to send them to the open bar! I do believe this could be classified as her single worst vocal performance on a studio track, but that's fine because literally nobody has heard it. I love the imagery She uses in this song, because it's so patently phony and She doesn't even try to disguise it. Sister, you moved to Nashville when you were 14, and as far as I know never had a serious relationship before that (at least I'd hope so). Why on EARTH are you writing about the freezing Christmas weather and the snow-covered little town when Nashville gets snow on Christmas once a decade and drops below freezing a few nights a year? Sister, be serious, please." reputation1989 8.5 - "Absolutely horrible but I stan." Achilles. 6.5 - "This one is actually quite good!" Where are you now? 6.5 - "Heartwarming original - she's gotta re-record it!" LoveInStereo 5.9 - "These vocals... this could be redeemed with a TV, till then, pass!" Bosque 5 - "The most tolerable vocals on this album." Lorenzo22 1.8 - "The vocal delivery is atrocious. :deadbanana:" Klein 1 - "You can't spell Christmases When You Were Mine without ME!" blown away 1 - "Compared to these vocals miss Selena Gomez sounds like peak Mariah Carey." Results Reveal hidden contents MusicLoverDude 6 Starchild 5 KillingYourCareer 10 AshleyLovescats887 10 AbeHicks 10 fridayteenage 10 Kyle-x 10 Taylor fanboy 10 SLUTTVFTV 9 Losing my ground 9 chiliam 9 wastedpotential 8.8 StØned 8.6 makeawish 8.5 llikeh 8 folkloreking 8 Iamanearthling 8 PerfectSacrifice 8 burninredhot 8 brokee 8 enchanted0 8 sparrowblue 7.5 Sanguine 7.5 tjspy 7.3 Michael196 7.2 Soobin 7.1 greento 7 Live To Tell 7 a_d_22 7 Hurem 7 reputation1989 7 Enrique523 7 Axolotl 7 liam13 7 Supernatural 7 Mocha 7 Holy Ground 7 Dear Reader 7 ellis-bell 7 TheArgonaut 7 Bussea 7 kyungsoowift 7 SleepingTigers 7 greeneyedsoul 7 Lazuli 7 Rev8 7 Don 7 SoSickOfThatSOL 7 StonedSoulPicnic 7 Safe&Sound 6.9 Mr. Duff 6.8 MidnightsAtPeace 6.6 Quicksand 6.5 Where are you now? 6.5 Achilles. 6.5 Edge of Glory 6.5 roso 6.3 djcalpal 6.2 tb6591 6 NordicGuy 6 Forever Winter 6 pinkbowvintage 6 Namigo 6 Riverbank 6 LastKiss 6 itsjem 6 gagacasanova 6 chosensparkles 6 Gorjesspazze9 6 Feanor 6 Tedwards 6 Nein 6 Ger.vaz 6 BOAZ 6 Flower 6 Bartender 6 LoveInStereo 5.9 Velvet Night 5.7 Avrileon 5.6 SylMacPer 5.5 G.U.Y_Del_Rey 5.5 Bindi 5.4 idkwiam 5.1 PaloSanto 5 sanzo 5 4Real 5 Theluckyone 5 Life Savers 5 badidearight 5 halcyonday 5 Venice B 5 Yog 5 Miles. 5 RihannaLoverrr 5 Hooker Barbie 5 My Tears Ricochet 5 K$Ellie 5 Bosque 5 Ms. Togekiss 5 FolkLover1989 4.8 305 4.5 ChapelHooker 4.5 terrorblade 4 Solaria 4 CamiloPg_ 4 skizzo 4 jacobhalkohit 4 vinicius 4 Ampersand13 4 Schami66 4 TaylenaStan 4 Catch22 4 paulyyyozd 4 twoheadlightshine 4 Blood Magic 4 heckinglovato 4 wehavetostan 4 Cruel Summer 3.5 The Music Industry 3 Arrows 3 Fitzswiftie 3 Prismee 3 Great Username 3 GuyNextDoor 3 americanlife 3 ONOPKA 3 Strawberry Bubble 3 Flames2Embers 3 fab 3 yourfaveisaflop 3 pavi 3 Top Dash 3 PoisonedIvy 2.5 1989 2.2 beagle 2.1 Peroxide 2 DevilsRollTheDice 2 Vespertine 2 D-@-N 2 LVP 2 Terylee 2 LovaticSwiftie 2 creativity. 2 Clauss 2 Byzantium 2 Heldenzeit 2 jacklovesyou1 2 Lorenzo22 1.8 AdrianNicki 1.5 NewStanner 1.5 Tusk 1.2 NEX 1 Teen Spirit 1 @freakum. 1 frankvert 1 Mezik 1 NextBish90 1 modern thing 1 holyground13 1 Klein 1 Swirl900 1 Diarrhoea 1 blown away 1 TMRA 1 By the Water 1 Sad Beautiful Tragic 0 Fly High, angel
Achilles. Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Something about the lyric "I bet you bought your mother another sweater" is just so good.
Cruel Summer Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Quote wastedpotential 8.8 - I know I'm insane, but not for this one. @wastedpotential 1
LoveInStereo Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Were some users not aware that we were allowed to give out scores other than 10? To me, 10 is perfection. There's no ******* way y'all are hearing perfection on this EP. Truly a Christmas miracle 1 3
a_d_22 Posted September 2 Posted September 2 2 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: 245. Christmases When You Were Mine 4.978 Comments SLUTTVFTV 9 - "Underrated as hell! She needs to re-record it." wastedpotential 8.8 - "An epiphany hit me the other day, that She basically ripped herself off when She made Message In A Bottle, because why does that have the EXACT same melody as this little classic? Y'all hear that too (assuming you listened to this ddd), right? I know I'm insane, but not for this one. Anyway, this is just a gorgeous and sweet and somber Christmas breakup anthem, it sits with me deeply, and I'll be adding it to my next Christmas party playlist to depress everyone and to send them to the open bar! I do believe this could be classified as her single worst vocal performance on a studio track, but that's fine because literally nobody has heard it. I love the imagery She uses in this song, because it's so patently phony and She doesn't even try to disguise it. Sister, you moved to Nashville when you were 14, and as far as I know never had a serious relationship before that (at least I'd hope so). Why on EARTH are you writing about the freezing Christmas weather and the snow-covered little town when Nashville gets snow on Christmas once a decade and drops below freezing a few nights a year? Sister, be serious, please." reputation1989 8.5 - "Absolutely horrible but I stan." Achilles. 6.5 - "This one is actually quite good!" Where are you now? 6.5 - "Heartwarming original - she's gotta re-record it!" LoveInStereo 5.9 - "These vocals... this could be redeemed with a TV, till then, pass!" Bosque 5 - "The most tolerable vocals on this album." Lorenzo22 1.8 - "The vocal delivery is atrocious. :deadbanana:" Klein 1 - "You can't spell Christmases When You Were Mine without ME!" blown away 1 - "Compared to these vocals miss Selena Gomez sounds like peak Mariah Carey." Results Hide contents MusicLoverDude 6 Starchild 5 KillingYourCareer 10 AshleyLovescats887 10 AbeHicks 10 fridayteenage 10 Kyle-x 10 Taylor fanboy 10 SLUTTVFTV 9 Losing my ground 9 chiliam 9 wastedpotential 8.8 StØned 8.6 makeawish 8.5 llikeh 8 folkloreking 8 Iamanearthling 8 PerfectSacrifice 8 burninredhot 8 brokee 8 enchanted0 8 sparrowblue 7.5 Sanguine 7.5 tjspy 7.3 Michael196 7.2 Soobin 7.1 greento 7 Live To Tell 7 a_d_22 7 Hurem 7 reputation1989 7 Enrique523 7 Axolotl 7 liam13 7 Supernatural 7 Mocha 7 Holy Ground 7 Dear Reader 7 ellis-bell 7 TheArgonaut 7 Bussea 7 kyungsoowift 7 SleepingTigers 7 greeneyedsoul 7 Lazuli 7 Rev8 7 Don 7 SoSickOfThatSOL 7 StonedSoulPicnic 7 Safe&Sound 6.9 Mr. Duff 6.8 MidnightsAtPeace 6.6 Quicksand 6.5 Where are you now? 6.5 Achilles. 6.5 Edge of Glory 6.5 roso 6.3 djcalpal 6.2 tb6591 6 NordicGuy 6 Forever Winter 6 pinkbowvintage 6 Namigo 6 Riverbank 6 LastKiss 6 itsjem 6 gagacasanova 6 chosensparkles 6 Gorjesspazze9 6 Feanor 6 Tedwards 6 Nein 6 Ger.vaz 6 BOAZ 6 Flower 6 Bartender 6 LoveInStereo 5.9 Velvet Night 5.7 Avrileon 5.6 SylMacPer 5.5 G.U.Y_Del_Rey 5.5 Bindi 5.4 idkwiam 5.1 PaloSanto 5 sanzo 5 4Real 5 Theluckyone 5 Life Savers 5 badidearight 5 halcyonday 5 Venice B 5 Yog 5 Miles. 5 RihannaLoverrr 5 Hooker Barbie 5 My Tears Ricochet 5 K$Ellie 5 Bosque 5 Ms. Togekiss 5 FolkLover1989 4.8 305 4.5 ChapelHooker 4.5 terrorblade 4 Solaria 4 CamiloPg_ 4 skizzo 4 jacobhalkohit 4 vinicius 4 Ampersand13 4 Schami66 4 TaylenaStan 4 Catch22 4 paulyyyozd 4 twoheadlightshine 4 Blood Magic 4 heckinglovato 4 wehavetostan 4 Cruel Summer 3.5 The Music Industry 3 Arrows 3 Fitzswiftie 3 Prismee 3 Great Username 3 GuyNextDoor 3 americanlife 3 ONOPKA 3 Strawberry Bubble 3 Flames2Embers 3 fab 3 yourfaveisaflop 3 pavi 3 Top Dash 3 PoisonedIvy 2.5 1989 2.2 beagle 2.1 Peroxide 2 DevilsRollTheDice 2 Vespertine 2 D-@-N 2 LVP 2 Terylee 2 LovaticSwiftie 2 creativity. 2 Clauss 2 Byzantium 2 Heldenzeit 2 jacklovesyou1 2 Lorenzo22 1.8 AdrianNicki 1.5 NewStanner 1.5 Tusk 1.2 NEX 1 Teen Spirit 1 @freakum. 1 frankvert 1 Mezik 1 NextBish90 1 modern thing 1 holyground13 1 Klein 1 Swirl900 1 Diarrhoea 1 blown away 1 TMRA 1 By the Water 1 Sad Beautiful Tragic 0 Her best Christmas song gone already?!?
Peroxide Posted September 2 Posted September 2 @Forever Winter good sis… what number are we aiming to get to tonight?
Recommended Posts