Europe Posted September 2 Posted September 2 13 minutes ago, Achilles. said: It's so funny to see the universal pannings for ME! because the horror and trauma yall feel about it is how I felt the first time I heard WANEGOD. Some of yall weren't country music stans reeling in despair at the words "worked with my hero Max Martin." I survived that and no **** Taylor ever throws at us will ever hurt me again. We are never ever getting back together is a really good song though. Were you really upset at that pop perfection? + the lyrics are so Taylor 1
Klein Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Just now, 1989 said: Okay IFTYE is bad, but London Boy is even worse (lowkey worse than Me! too), so the fact that it isn't the lowest Lover track I- No it's definitely not
Starchild Posted September 2 Posted September 2 I'm glad to see everyone thought the same, a mid score for a mid song, a forgettable dud 1
wastedpotential Posted September 2 Posted September 2 1 minute ago, Tusk said: The Lover Holiday Day Collection is getting steamrolled. But Crucifix Wood Tree Farm is still in and will be for a while?
Tusk Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Just now, Mezik said: IFTYE is so bad. How does 'Lover' have such high highs like Cruel Summer, Daylight, Afterglow, False God, and then this garbage.... on the album? She tried to muse Joe and this is what happened.
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 2 Author Posted September 2 253. A Perfectly Good Heart 4.307 Comments AshleyLovescats887 10 - "extremely underrated" wastedpotential 7.1 - "Genesis really had strong closers, because this song sounds exactly like something that would play over the end credits of an indie coming of age film playing at a snobby indie theater that sells like 300 tickets. Overall, not my favorite song, especially not the way she sings "that I would be the one to fa-a-all" in the second verse, because she was really falling off key in real time there. Still, I did have a good melodramatic moment or two staring out the window of the car at night while listening to this in high school, and some of y'all do way too much to trash it." The Music Industry 6.8 - "This was one of my surprise songs in Zurich. When Taylor went "whyyyyyyyyy would you wanna break-'', literally everyone went quiet. :redface:" Starchild 6 - "Last track, relistening I really enjoy it, way more than I remember, but would I go back to this album on my own free will? Absolutely not, I love Taylors artistry in any genre but I do not like country like that (old outlaw country? Now that's where it's at)." pinkbowvintage 5 - "It has nice moments but it's so repetitive." Achilles. 3 - "Whyyyyy would you wanna repeat a chorus five times in a song with one verse?" Where are you now? 1.3 - "Fell out of my chair when she did this as a surprise song." 1989 1 - "This song is such ass. You can definitely tell this was the song on Debut that they made her outsource and use different cowriters on. Terrible." kyungsoowift 1 - "A not-so-perfect attempt." Forever Winter 1 - "Whoever got this as a surprise song... I'm so sorry." Klein 1 - "Someone once called it A Perfectly Good Fart and it's never going away. The most perfect description of the song. Imagine closing your album with this? Like Debut TV couldn't come any sooner to save us and give us a proper closer." blown away 1 - "I've seen this song get a lot of hate. It definitely deserves it." Results Spoiler MusicLoverDude 8 SLUTTVFTV 4 AshleyLovescats887 10 paulyyyozd 10 StØned 8.4 LastKiss 8.2 idkwiam 8.1 AbeHicks 8 fridayteenage 8 Hooker Barbie 8 Cruel Summer 8 tjspy 7.8 KillingYourCareer 7.5 PerfectSacrifice 7.5 makeawish 7.5 Michael196 7.3 wastedpotential 7.2 greento 7.1 chosensparkles 7 vinicius 7 Miles. 7 Sad Beautiful Tragic 7 holyground13 7 brokee 7 FolkLover1989 7 enchanted0 7 greeneyedsoul 7 Top Dash 7 StonedSoulPicnic 7 The Music Industry 6.8 Velvet Night 6.8 reputation1989 6.7 Bindi 6.7 Kyle-x 6.6 NordicGuy 6.5 My Tears Ricochet 6.5 jacklovesyou1 6.1 terrorblade 6 Live To Tell 6 MidnightsAtPeace 6 Namigo 6 Life Savers 6 folkloreking 6 Gorjesspazze9 6 G.U.Y_Del_Rey 6 Losing my ground 6 ONOPKA 6 Byzantium 6 Blood Magic 6 Rev8 6 Don 6 SoSickOfThatSOL 6 Edge of Glory 6 heckinglovato 6 Starchild 6 burninredhot 5.1 SylMacPer 5 PaloSanto 5 pinkbowvintage 5 DevilsRollTheDice 5 sanzo 5 Arrows 5 Riverbank 5 Theluckyone 5 @freakum. 5 Enrique523 5 jacobhalkohit 5 Venice B 5 Fitzswiftie 5 Yog 5 Ampersand13 5 djcalpal 5 Mezik 5 liam13 5 americanlife 5 Clauss 5 Swirl900 5 fab 5 pavi 5 Taylor fanboy 5 Bartender 5 K$Ellie 5 tb6591 4.5 Catch22 4.5 Peroxide 4.2 llikeh 4 skizzo 4 Hurem 4 gagacasanova 4 badidearight 4 Mr. Duff 4 Iamanearthling 4 Axolotl 4 LVP 4 Supernatural 4 TaylenaStan 4 Nein 4 BOAZ 4 Bussea 4 Heldenzeit 4 chiliam 4 Lazuli 4 ChapelHooker 3.5 Dear Reader 3.5 creativity. 3.5 Sanguine 3.5 NewStanner 3.5 TheArgonaut 3.2 NEX 3 CamiloPg_ 3 Soobin 3 Tedwards 3 modern thing 3 RihannaLoverrr 3 Flames2Embers 3 Flower 3 yourfaveisaflop 3 AdrianNicki 3 Bosque 3 Achilles. 3 Lorenzo22 3 NextBish90 2.7 Quicksand 2.5 Safe&Sound 2.5 wehavetostan 2.5 Tusk 2.2 beagle 2.1 Solaria 2 4Real 2 D-@-N 2 halcyonday 2 frankvert 2 Great Username 2 Terylee 2 Mocha 2 Ger.vaz 2 LovaticSwiftie 2 Strawberry Bubble 2 ellis-bell 2 SleepingTigers 2 Diarrhoea 2 TMRA 2 Ms. Togekiss 2 roso 1.4 Where are you now? 1.3 Forever Winter 1 1989 1 Teen Spirit 1 a_d_22 1 Vespertine 1 Feanor 1 Prismee 1 Schami66 1 GuyNextDoor 1 Klein 1 twoheadlightshine 1 kyungsoowift 1 sparrowblue 1 blown away 1 By the Water 1 Avrileon 0 305 0 itsjem 0 Holy Ground 0 PoisonedIvy 0 LoveInStereo 0 1
Miles. Posted September 2 Posted September 2 ME!th out already, the first song from ANY of her albums OUT, oh this rate is off to such a great start. I was worried the tasteless LOSER defenders in here would somehow get it into the top 250 but I should've known common sense would prevail. CONGRATS to all Swifties for this accomplishment
TaylenaStan Posted September 2 Posted September 2 I Forgot That This Spotify Playlist Fodder Shite Existed getting rightfully lashed
Axolotl Posted September 2 Posted September 2 (edited) The vocals for this song are atrocius Edited September 2 by Axolotl
Mezik Posted September 2 Posted September 2 IFTYE is so bad. How does 'Lover' have such high highs like Cruel Summer, Daylight, Afterglow, False God, and then this garbage.... on the album?
wastedpotential Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Oh **** let me get out my APGH is actually a good song and you just don't get it hat and put it on for a while END OF AN INDIE MOVIE SOUND TRACK LOOKING OUT THE WINDOW LEAVING TOWN RAIN SADNESS MELANCHOLY??? NO??? 1 1
Achilles. Posted September 2 Posted September 2 I always use ATRL on mobile and don't see signatures so I had NO IDEA that I have been rocking this "you can't spell Achilles. without 'chill'" signature for five ******* years. 9
Dear Reader Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Quote Where are you now? 1.3 - "Fell out of my chair when she did this as a surprise song." I'm so sorry @Where are you now? 1 2
Mezik Posted September 2 Posted September 2 IFTYE is so bad. How does 'Lover' have such high highs like Cruel Summer, Daylight, Afterglow, False God, and then this garbage.... on the album?
Starchild Posted September 2 Posted September 2 1 minute ago, Cruel Summer said: Wait how is London Boy not out lmao Tea Oh I scored that song the way 1t deserved to be scored
Taylor fanboy Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Is @AshleyLovescats887 Taylor Swift's ATRL handle? 1
wastedpotential Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Just now, Achilles. said: I always use ATRL on mobile and don't see signatures so I had NO IDEA that I have been rocking this "you can't spell Achilles. without 'chill'" signature for five ******* years. NO PLEASE
gagacasanova Posted September 2 Posted September 2 3 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: 253. A Perfectly Good Heart 4.307 Comments blown away 1 - "I've seen this song get a lot of hate. It definitely deserves it." Results Reveal hidden contents MusicLoverDude 8 SLUTTVFTV 4 AshleyLovescats887 10 paulyyyozd 10 StØned 8.4 LastKiss 8.2 idkwiam 8.1 AbeHicks 8 fridayteenage 8 Hooker Barbie 8 Cruel Summer 8 tjspy 7.8 KillingYourCareer 7.5 PerfectSacrifice 7.5 makeawish 7.5 Michael196 7.3 wastedpotential 7.2 greento 7.1 chosensparkles 7 vinicius 7 Miles. 7 Sad Beautiful Tragic 7 holyground13 7 brokee 7 FolkLover1989 7 enchanted0 7 greeneyedsoul 7 Top Dash 7 StonedSoulPicnic 7 The Music Industry 6.8 Velvet Night 6.8 reputation1989 6.7 Bindi 6.7 Kyle-x 6.6 NordicGuy 6.5 My Tears Ricochet 6.5 jacklovesyou1 6.1 terrorblade 6 Live To Tell 6 MidnightsAtPeace 6 Namigo 6 Life Savers 6 folkloreking 6 Gorjesspazze9 6 G.U.Y_Del_Rey 6 Losing my ground 6 ONOPKA 6 Byzantium 6 Blood Magic 6 Rev8 6 Don 6 SoSickOfThatSOL 6 Edge of Glory 6 heckinglovato 6 Starchild 6 burninredhot 5.1 SylMacPer 5 PaloSanto 5 pinkbowvintage 5 DevilsRollTheDice 5 sanzo 5 Arrows 5 Riverbank 5 Theluckyone 5 @freakum. 5 Enrique523 5 jacobhalkohit 5 Venice B 5 Fitzswiftie 5 Yog 5 Ampersand13 5 djcalpal 5 Mezik 5 liam13 5 americanlife 5 Clauss 5 Swirl900 5 fab 5 pavi 5 Taylor fanboy 5 Bartender 5 K$Ellie 5 tb6591 4.5 Catch22 4.5 Peroxide 4.2 llikeh 4 skizzo 4 Hurem 4 gagacasanova 4 badidearight 4 Mr. Duff 4 Iamanearthling 4 Axolotl 4 LVP 4 Supernatural 4 TaylenaStan 4 Nein 4 BOAZ 4 Bussea 4 Heldenzeit 4 chiliam 4 Lazuli 4 ChapelHooker 3.5 Dear Reader 3.5 creativity. 3.5 Sanguine 3.5 NewStanner 3.5 TheArgonaut 3.2 NEX 3 CamiloPg_ 3 Soobin 3 Tedwards 3 modern thing 3 RihannaLoverrr 3 Flames2Embers 3 Flower 3 yourfaveisaflop 3 AdrianNicki 3 Bosque 3 Achilles. 3 Lorenzo22 3 NextBish90 2.7 Quicksand 2.5 Safe&Sound 2.5 wehavetostan 2.5 Tusk 2.2 beagle 2.1 Solaria 2 4Real 2 D-@-N 2 halcyonday 2 frankvert 2 Great Username 2 Terylee 2 Mocha 2 Ger.vaz 2 LovaticSwiftie 2 Strawberry Bubble 2 ellis-bell 2 SleepingTigers 2 Diarrhoea 2 TMRA 2 Ms. Togekiss 2 roso 1.4 Where are you now? 1.3 Forever Winter 1 1989 1 Teen Spirit 1 a_d_22 1 Vespertine 1 Feanor 1 Prismee 1 Schami66 1 GuyNextDoor 1 Klein 1 twoheadlightshine 1 kyungsoowift 1 sparrowblue 1 blown away 1 By the Water 1 Avrileon 0 305 0 itsjem 0 Holy Ground 0 PoisonedIvy 0 LoveInStereo 0 3
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 2 Author Posted September 2 252. Half of My Heart 4.320 Comments blown away 7.8 - "Great song, John and Taylor blend well together. It's a shame he's such a piece of ****, they could've made a cute duet album." Forever Winter 6.5 - "Objectively speaking, this song is decent. Ranking it based on the song alone and not based on how I feel about John Mayer. He is trash though just to be clear :suburban:" Achilles. 6 - "One of John Mayer's best songs." MusicLoverDude 5 - "Go away John." wastedpotential 4.4 - "John Mayo, I've begun to live in your walls. The yogurt in your fridge is expired, and you need to re-up your car insurance coverage. Just know that we might come face to face at any time now. Okay, with that out of the way, let me admit that I really actually like this song. I think he's a talented guy and I think the melody is really good. If only She was credited for this (and honestly, since She's NOT credited, maybe we shouldn't be rating this). The fact that he submitted the solo version for the Grammys... oh that should be punishable by death. The fact that she got Snow On The Beach-ed here is disgusting to me. John Mayo, meet my firing squad!" kyungsoowift 2 - "Traumatizing, no really." Where are you now? 2.8 - "Peasant scullery maid of Adult Contemporary, not everyone has that!" NewStanner 1.5 - "Sounds like a Morgan Wallen's song and a very bad one at that." a_d_22 0 - "Lowkey actually like this song but the groomer makes it a 0." Dear Reader 0 - "F*ck John Mayer!" Results Spoiler Starchild 1 AbeHicks 10 Losing my ground 10 greeneyedsoul 10 FolkLover1989 9.2 Axolotl 9 Great Username 9 Supernatural 8.5 StØned 8.3 tb6591 8.2 folkloreking 8 Enrique523 8 Mr. Duff 8 djcalpal 8 blown away 7.8 makeawish 7.5 enchanted0 7.5 Cruel Summer 7.3 Solaria 7 Avrileon 7 Iamanearthling 7 vinicius 7 Tedwards 7 Sad Beautiful Tragic 7 RihannaLoverrr 7 BOAZ 7 Clauss 7 Rev8 7 Sanguine 7 Bosque 7 Bindi 7 heckinglovato 7 greento 6.8 Forever Winter 6.5 Vespertine 6.5 Flower 6.5 Heldenzeit 6.5 Michael196 6.3 tjspy 6.1 itsjem 6 @freakum. 6 chosensparkles 6 ChapelHooker 6 halcyonday 6 PerfectSacrifice 6 Yog 6 burninredhot 6 brokee 6 Hooker Barbie 6 sparrowblue 6 Blood Magic 6 Don 6 StonedSoulPicnic 6 Achilles. 6 Velvet Night 5.6 SylMacPer 5.5 SLUTTVFTV 5.5 NordicGuy 5 DevilsRollTheDice 5 Live To Tell 5 sanzo 5 CamiloPg_ 5 llikeh 5 Riverbank 5 Theluckyone 5 Life Savers 5 badidearight 5 Gorjesspazze9 5 jacobhalkohit 5 Venice B 5 Mezik 5 americanlife 5 Mocha 5 Strawberry Bubble 5 MusicLoverDude 5 Bussea 5 My Tears Ricochet 5 Kyle-x 5 pavi 5 SoSickOfThatSOL 5 Edge of Glory 5 Ms. Togekiss 5 roso 4.9 beagle 4.8 Safe&Sound 4.8 modern thing 4.5 wastedpotential 4.4 terrorblade 4 pinkbowvintage 4 4Real 4 Soobin 4 Hurem 4 Fitzswiftie 4 Schami66 4 Miles. 4 ONOPKA 4 Catch22 4 holyground13 4 Flames2Embers 4 Byzantium 4 yourfaveisaflop 4 Lorenzo22 4 idkwiam 3.7 Ger.vaz 3.3 The Music Industry 3 Namigo 3 skizzo 3 Ampersand13 3 Terylee 3 Nein 3 LovaticSwiftie 3 creativity. 3 paulyyyozd 3 Klein 3 chiliam 3 Lazuli 3 Bartender 3 K$Ellie 3 1989 2.8 TaylenaStan 2.8 Where are you now? 2.8 KillingYourCareer 2.5 SleepingTigers 2.5 LoveInStereo 2.5 PoisonedIvy 2.1 NEX 2 MidnightsAtPeace 2 Arrows 2 Feanor 2 LVP 2 GuyNextDoor 2 Quicksand 2 kyungsoowift 2 fab 2 wehavetostan 2 Peroxide 1.9 NewStanner 1.5 PaloSanto 1 Teen Spirit 1 305 1 Tusk 1 gagacasanova 1 reputation1989 1 D-@-N 1 frankvert 1 Prismee 1 NextBish90 1 Holy Ground 1 ellis-bell 1 Swirl900 1 Diarrhoea 1 jacklovesyou1 1 AdrianNicki 1 Taylor fanboy 1 TMRA 1 Top Dash 1 By the Water 1 a_d_22 0 LastKiss 0 AshleyLovescats887 0 G.U.Y_Del_Rey 0 liam13 0 fridayteenage 0 Dear Reader 0 TheArgonaut 0 twoheadlightshine 0
Recommended Posts