rate The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page

[wastedpotential]

12 minutes ago, Achilles. said:

How many songs do I still not have comments for?

 

 

 

I think only 12-15 of them NEED comments though…

To this end, I'm kinda feeling like not giving especially thorough comments for TTPD because the songs are so new and also there are so many of them and I cba and I'm already over 40,000 words written in less than three days 

 

@Forever Winter has anyone provided lovely comments for the TTPD songs so I can be relieved of that ******* duty and can just stick to one sentence kii's?

 

And yes I am entirely aware that this is completely self imposed and I can also just do whatever I want but I'm planning to make this entire reveal about ME!, so if there aren't any comments then I'll power through but I'd really rather not 

Edited September 2 by wastedpotential

[Achilles.]

For some reason I am struggling to come up with things to say about the Fearless songs

[wastedpotential]

Just now, NewStanner said:

I tried to write comments for multiple songs, but ended up scrapping so many of them Maybe I will be able to form more coherent thoughts on the next rate in 2034

Oh girl at the rate things are going we'll probably have another one in Q4 2026 or Q1 2027 because Taylor can't stop making music 

[Achilles.]

What if I show up to the party without any comments for Love Story, Wildest Dreams, Don't Blame Me, illicit affairs, or High Infidelity? 

[Miles.]

22 minutes ago, Achilles. said:

Call It What You Want and So It Goes… SNUBBED!

 

  Hide contents

Gorgeous too I fear

Oh come on TASTE!  The only 3 Puta songs I gave less than an 8 to  

 

Spoiler

And one of them was a 0

 

[Achilles.]

I think that as the founder of the Taylor Swift base thread I should be entitled to a sixth 11. 
 

Spoiler

This is just me trying to get out of having to choose.
 

 

Spoiler

I would certainly accept more than 6, too.

 

[Miles.]

2 minutes ago, NewStanner said:

CIWYW is her best song, it better not be a 0

Call It What It Is: Mediocre gets a solid 7! 
 

So It Snores gets a 6!

 

Ergo…

[Where are you now?]

Sorry in advance if my many comments come across as basic state the obvious! 
 

Also some of you are gonna hate what I did to Speak Now. 

Edited September 2 by Where are you now?

[wastedpotential]

9 minutes ago, Achilles. said:

I think that as the founder of the Taylor Swift base thread I should be entitled to a sixth 11. 
 

  Hide contents

This is just me trying to get out of having to choose.
 

 

  Hide contents

I would certainly accept more than 6, too.

 

What are you deciding between beloved, we can do a communal vote? 

 

[Cruel Summer]

57 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

Excuse you! There are SIX good songs on reputation 

 

(I'm joking, I gave Call God What You Worship her flowers, don't come for me!)

[wastedpotential]

1 minute ago, Cruel Summer said:

 

(I'm joking, I gave Call God What You Worship her flowers, don't come for me!)

The way the best (and only good imo at this point) version of Christ Is Who You Want is the acoustic version she performed for Hobo we got like 45 seconds of in Miss Americana 

 

 

I want to burn Jack Antonoff's drum machine

 

[Brooklyn Baby]

46 minutes ago, NewStanner said:

@Forever Winter done finally

 

Also:

 

#1 I Can See God

#2 Charts Crumbling

#3 When Emma Gets A Grammy

 

#4 Electric Touch

#5 Timeless

 

#6 The Overrated One

 

 

1 hour ago, By the Water said:

Sent! I really hope ATRL user @Forever Winter rigs Forever Winter into the top 5 or we'll have some problems 

 

1 hour ago, Bindi said:

Done 

Received all of your ballots. Thanks 

[Brooklyn Baby]

31 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

To this end, I'm kinda feeling like not giving especially thorough comments for TTPD because the songs are so new and also there are so many of them and I cba and I'm already over 40,000 words written in less than three days 

 

@Forever Winter has anyone provided lovely comments for the TTPD songs so I can be relieved of that ******* duty and can just stick to one sentence kii's?

 

And yes I am entirely aware that this is completely self imposed and I can also just do whatever I want but I'm planning to make this entire reveal about ME!, so if there aren't any comments then I'll power through but I'd really rather not 

TTPD has a lower average of comments I'm afraid

 

[Achilles.]

Scores (Deluxe Editions, But Not Vaults):

folklore: 9.47

Fearless: 8.95

evermore: 8.88
Debut: 8.69

Speak Now: 8.53

The Anthology: 8.13

1989: 7.56

reputation: 7.43

Red: 7.32

Midnights: 7.1

Tortured Poets: 7.06

Loser: 5.79

Other: 5.19

Holiday EP: 3.42

 

 

Sacred has 3 bad songs and one song that I am sabotaging a bit so that drags the album down a lot.  
 

 

Scores With Vaults:

Speak Now: 8.3

Fearless: 8.24

Red: 7.08

Midnights: 6.86

1989: 6.86

 

I did Midnights without YLM above because it was unfair to have the album dragged down nearly .3 by one bad bonus track.

[wastedpotential]

7 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

TTPD has a lower average of comments I'm afraid

 

Well, I guess that's just too damn bad 

 

[Miles.]

4 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

Well, I guess that's just too damn bad 

At least write a short essay for Who's Afraid Of Heaven and The Black God

 

Assuming you gave them their rightful 10s  

[wastedpotential]

4 minutes ago, Miles. said:

At least write a short essay for Who's Afraid Of Heaven and The Black God

 

Assuming you gave them their rightful 10s  

Well no and well yes 

 

Spoiler

I can give you suggestions for what I'd write about if I had the brain wattage to successfully write things now (waiting for my red bull to kick in before I tackle evermore) but I fear neither of them will breach the 50 word mark

 

 

[Miles.]

1 minute ago, wastedpotential said:

Well no and well yes 

 

  Reveal hidden contents

I can give you suggestions for what I'd write about if I had the brain wattage to successfully write things now (waiting for my red bull to kick in before I tackle evermore) but I fear neither of them will breach the 50 word mark

 

 

Now what is there to say about Everbore besides zzzzzzzzzzzzzz  

[Achilles.]

33 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

What are you deciding between beloved, we can do a communal vote? 

I ended up with: First Testament, Preach Now, folklore, evermore, and Other. 
 

Sixth option was "I Hate It Here," which I just KNOW will have the haters pressed, but I couldn't justify giving an 11 to a song that's only 5 months old. 

[Tusk]

1 minute ago, Achilles. said:

Sixth option was "I Hate It Here," which I just KNOW will have the haters pressed, but I couldn't justify giving an 11 to a song that's only 5 months old. 

I gave it an 11 

[wastedpotential]

5 minutes ago, Miles. said:

Now what is there to say about Everbore besides zzzzzzzzzzzzzz  

[wastedpotential]

6 minutes ago, Achilles. said:

I ended up with: First Testament, Preach Now, folklore, evermore, and Other. 
 

Sixth option was "I Hate It Here," which I just KNOW will have the haters pressed, but I couldn't justify giving an 11 to a song that's only 5 months old. 

I had that as an 11 for a few weeks (until I transferred it to FOTS and then onto Speak Now), but I think it'll get its due love. 

[Achilles.]

It just told me my response is too large

 

@Forever Winter is it alright if I submit like an hour after midnight? I need to make it short enough to send but I'm going offline for a few hours.

[wastedpotential]

4 minutes ago, Achilles. said:

It just told me my response is too large

 

@Forever Winter is it alright if I submit like an hour after midnight? I need to make it short enough to send but I'm going offline for a few hours.

Oh this happened to me too, and @Forever Winter was incredibly gracious enough to let me submit them through PMs for which I'm still incredibly grateful 

[wehavetostan]

is the top 3 close? gathering my scores rn