Starchild Posted September 1 Posted September 1 Thank you for the extra day omg I got covid and was sick these past 2 weeks, I already know her discography by heart so I just need to get to actually filling the form I'll be sure to finish by morning 4
Starchild Posted September 1 Posted September 1 I know I will be disappointed with the ranking though based on past rates I'll say that 2
PoisonedIvy Posted September 1 Posted September 1 6 minutes ago, Starchild said: I know I will be disappointed with the ranking though based on past rates I'll say that Don't worry, I'll be hosting the real rate in this thread simultaneously, while Forever Winter puts on a puppet show for the tasteless ATRLers Spoiler: evermore's entire tracklist occupies the top 17 6
Achilles. Posted September 1 Posted September 1 6 minutes ago, Starchild said: I know I will be disappointed with the ranking though based on past rates I'll say that I stopped following the last rate halfway through. If tastes around here haven't improved since then I might just preemptively ask our hostess not to tag me at all during updates. 4
wastedpotential Posted September 1 Posted September 1 10 minutes ago, PoisonedIvy said: Don't worry, I'll be hosting the real rate in this thread simultaneously, while Forever Winter puts on a puppet show for the tasteless ATRLers Not when I've already written over 29,000 words in commentary and I still have four albums to go, and I'm gonna force y'all to talk about them after every reveal because my taste is just objectively correct and y'all need to learn You may be the main character of this website, but I'm absolutely going to make this entire rate about ME!.mp3 7
Starchild Posted September 1 Posted September 1 9 minutes ago, PoisonedIvy said: Don't worry, I'll be hosting the real rate in this thread simultaneously, while Forever Winter puts on a puppet show for the tasteless ATRLers Spoiler: evermore's entire tracklist occupies the top 17 8 minutes ago, Achilles. said: I stopped following the last rate halfway through. If tastes around here haven't improved since then I might just preemptively ask our hostess not to tag me at all during updates. I always have a meltdown here when the countdown is going on Sadly our good taste will be drowned by the flop swifties (and you know who y'all are ) But TRUST I will read through this all tonight and make sure I sabotage to the best possible most accurate probability to help us out because if we fail ... I fear this will be the same list minus minor changes as usual 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 1 Author Posted September 1 Just now, chiliam said: Just submit. Hopefully still in time Received. Thanks
Achilles. Posted September 1 Posted September 1 13 minutes ago, wastedpotential said: Not when I've already written over 29,000 words in commentary and I still have four albums to go Am I supposed to be impressed by 29K words for 7 albums when Mary's Song alone merits double that? 1 minute ago, Almodusa said: A reminder that Safe & Sound should win. I love facts. 1
PoisonedIvy Posted September 1 Posted September 1 22 minutes ago, wastedpotential said: You may be the main character of this website Thank you, I didn't need your permission though. 3
Achilles. Posted September 1 Posted September 1 Why is it so much harder to come up with things to say about my 10s than about any of the other songs? Like. The greatness is just self evident so what could I possibly have to say?
wastedpotential Posted September 1 Posted September 1 9 minutes ago, Achilles. said: Am I supposed to be impressed by 29K words for 7 albums when Mary's Song alone merits double that? I love facts. Well I only really started yesterday so the answer is well yes Mary's Song got a healthy amount of praise and one of my 76 10s 1
wastedpotential Posted September 1 Posted September 1 3 minutes ago, PoisonedIvy said: Thank you, I didn't need your permission though. Babe go worry about the skyscraper of dishes you have piled up in the sink right now and stop hogging the spotlight 2
PoisonedIvy Posted September 1 Posted September 1 3 minutes ago, wastedpotential said: Babe go worry about the skyscraper of dishes you have piled up in the sink right now and stop hogging the spotlight SECURITY @ATRL Administration 1
PoisonedIvy Posted September 1 Posted September 1 6 minutes ago, Achilles. said: Why is it so much harder to come up with things to say about my 10s than about any of the other songs? Like. The greatness is just self evident so what could I possibly have to say? It's like trying to describe the majesty of a sunrise over a mountain range to a blind person.. 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 1 Author Posted September 1 @greeneyedsoul Hi bestie I received your ballot. Btw - you still have one more 11. You can still edit the ballot then submit again at the bottom.
greeneyedsoul Posted September 1 Posted September 1 1 minute ago, Forever Winter said: @greeneyedsoul Hi bestie I received your ballot. Btw - you still have one more 11. You can still edit the ballot then submit again at the bottom. I ctrl+f'ed 11 and it showed me 5 results. One must have been from the rules. Anyway, done. 1
Lazuli Posted September 1 Posted September 1 doing it now! gonna do the discography sorter and give my scores based on that. might take me hours straight to go thru it 1
Klein Posted September 1 Posted September 1 1 hour ago, Almodusa said: A reminder that Safe & Sound should win. This is the absolute best take I've read in this entire thread... after mine ofc. Because Sad Beautiful Tragic should win, and Safe & Sound be 2nd. 1 3
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 1 Author Posted September 1 22 hours remaining to submit/finalize your ballots!
Miles. Posted September 1 Posted September 1 All Of The Sluts You ****** Before praise, now I've seen it all This drivel sounds like the epitome of a Loser song (derogatory). It is better than ME!th and Soon You'll Get Sicker though, I'll give y'all that much! 3
blown away Posted September 1 Posted September 1 I've just sent in my rates @Forever Winter. Spoiler Average scores Debut - 3.07 Fearless (without vault tracks) - 4.08 Fearless (with vault tracks) - 4.31 Speak Now (without vault tracks) - 8.02 Speak Now (with vault tracks) - 7 Red (without vault tracks) - 6.55 Red (with vault tracks) - 5.87 1989 (without vault tracks) - 7.93 1989 (with vault tracks) - 7.02 Reputation - 7.81 Lover - 5.05 Folklore - 6.98 Evermore - 6.52 Midnights - 6.25 TTPD - 2.93 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 1 Author Posted September 1 8 minutes ago, blown away said: I've just sent in my rates @Forever Winter. Hide contents Average scores Debut - 3.07 Fearless (without vault tracks) - 4.08 Fearless (with vault tracks) - 4.31 Speak Now (without vault tracks) - 8.02 Speak Now (with vault tracks) - 7 Red (without vault tracks) - 6.55 Red (with vault tracks) - 5.87 1989 (without vault tracks) - 7.93 1989 (with vault tracks) - 7.02 Reputation - 7.81 Lover - 5.05 Folklore - 6.98 Evermore - 6.52 Midnights - 6.25 TTPD - 2.93 Received. Thanks! 1
Recommended Posts