wastedpotential Posted August 31 Posted August 31 20 minutes ago, Klein said: I'll defend you. Scalp these songs. I want some mess. Hide contents Unless you're coming for my faves. Then I'll drag you too Spoiler What are your thoughts on the 19Katy9 vault? Spoiler Or the songs that some people think are filler and some people don't?
Klein Posted August 31 Posted August 31 2 minutes ago, wastedpotential said: Hide contents What are your thoughts on the 19Katy9 vault? Hide contents Or the songs that some people think are filler and some people don't? Spoiler You know, there's a total of 5 songs that I would be mad if you dragged them on 1989, vault included. And there's at least 4 of them I know you won't touch. The fifth one though... I'm not too sure but you've got taste overall so I'm inclined to think you'll do the right thing.
wastedpotential Posted August 31 Posted August 31 3 minutes ago, Klein said: Hide contents You know, there's a total of 5 songs that I would be mad if you dragged them on 1989, vault included. And there's at least 4 of them I know you won't touch. The fifth one though... I'm not too sure but you've got taste overall so I'm inclined to think you'll do the right thing. Spoiler I'm not touching any of the singles, not even the fourth one with the explosive video, or the... most recent one I'm also not touching the last few standard tracks or the objectively better of the non-single deluxe tracks. It's over for most of the vault, a smattering of standard tracks, and the most... dated of the deluxe tracks
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 31 Author Posted August 31 If not for @wastedpotential's commentary, some of these songs would be left with 0 comments Doing the Lord's work 1
wastedpotential Posted August 31 Posted August 31 Just now, Forever Winter said: If not for @wastedpotential's commentary, some of these songs would be left with 0 comments Doing the Lord's work I'm gonna deliver a few words for every single song As a fervent worshipper of the Lord, I really do believe it's my duty Every song is either so good I can't help but praise it, so mediocre that I must admonish Lord for not trying a bit harder, or so bad that I must lay the blame at the feet of Lord's demonic alter ego, Alison. 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 31 Author Posted August 31 Ballots Received (133): Spoiler 1. terrorblade 2. tb6591 3. SlyMacPer 4. PaloSanto 5. greento 6. NordicGuy 7. Forever Winter 8. The Music Industry 9. Solaria 10. pinkbowvintage 11. 1989 12. Peroxide 13. DevilsRollTheDice 14. NEX 15. Live To Tell 16. Teen Spirit 17. sanzo 18. MidnightsAtPeace 19. Avrileon 20. CamiloPg_ 21. 4Real 22. KillingYourCareer 23. a_d_22 24. Namigo 25. llikeh 26. 305 27. Arrows 28. skizzo 29. Soobin 30. Tusk 31. Riverbank 32. theluckyone 33. LastKiss 34. itsjem 35. Hurem 36. Life Savers 37. folkloreking 38. gagacasanova 39. Vespertine 40. freakum. 41. chosensparkles 42. reputation1989 43. D-@-N 44. badidearight 45. Velvet Night 46. Enrique523 47. Mr. Duff 48. AshleyLovescats887 49. ChapelHooker 50. Gorjesspazze9 51. halcyonday 52. iamanearthling 53. AbeHicks 54. Axolotl 55. jacobhalkohit 56. PerfectSacrifice 57. Frankvert 58. Venice B 59. vinicius 60. Fitzswiftie 61. Yog 62. Ampersand13 63. Feanor 64. wastedpotential 65. Prismee 66. idkwiam 67. Schami66 68. Støned 69. G.U.Y_Del_Rey 70. djcalpal 71. Great Username 72. Tedwards 73. tjspy 74. Mezik 75. LVP 76. Miles. 77. NextBish90 78. liam13 79. SLUTTVFTV 80. Sad Beautiful Tragic 81. Losing my ground 82. GuyNextDoor 83. ?????? 84. burninredhot 85. americanlife 86. Supernatural 87. Terylee 88. Mocha 89. Modern thing 90. TaylenaStan 91. Nein 92. Ger.vaz 93. fridayteenage 94. ONOPKA 95. makeawish 96. Holy Ground 97. LovaticSwiftie 98. RihannaLoverrr 99. Dear Reader 100. roso 101. Catch22 102. holyground13 103. creativity. 104. Strawberry Bubble 105. brokee 106. paulyyozd 107. ellis-bell 108. BOAZ 109. TheArgonaut 110. FolkLover1989 111. Klein 112. MusicLoverDude 113. Clauss 114. Hooker Barbie 115. twoheadlightshine 116. Bussea 117. Quicksand 118. kyungsoowift 119. Flames2Embers 120. Swirl900 121. beagle 122. Flower 123. byzantium 124. fab 125. Hendelzeit 126. Safe&Sound 127. SleepingTigers 128. Diarrhoea 129. My Tears Ricochet 130. Kyle-x 131. jacklovesyou1 132. PoisonedIvy 133. yourfaveisaflop Well fu*king finally 3
PoisonedIvy Posted August 31 Posted August 31 1 minute ago, Forever Winter said: Ballots Received (132): Reveal hidden contents 1. terrorblade 2. tb6591 3. SlyMacPer 4. PaloSanto 5. greento 6. NordicGuy 7. Forever Winter 8. The Music Industry 9. Solaria 10. pinkbowvintage 11. 1989 12. Peroxide 13. DevilsRollTheDice 14. NEX 15. Live To Tell 16. Teen Spirit 17. sanzo 18. MidnightsAtPeace 19. Avrileon 20. CamiloPg_ 21. 4Real 22. KillingYourCareer 23. a_d_22 24. Namigo 25. llikeh 26. 305 27. Arrows 28. skizzo 29. Soobin 30. Tusk 31. Riverbank 32. theluckyone 33. LastKiss 34. itsjem 35. Hurem 36. Life Savers 37. folkloreking 38. gagacasanova 39. Vespertine 40. freakum. 41. chosensparkles 42. reputation1989 43. D-@-N 44. badidearight 45. Velvet Night 46. Enrique523 47. Mr. Duff 48. AshleyLovescats887 49. ChapelHooker 50. Gorjesspazze9 51. halcyonday 52. iamanearthling 53. AbeHicks 54. Axolotl 55. jacobhalkohit 56. PerfectSacrifice 57. Frankvert 58. Venice B 59. vinicius 60. Fitzswiftie 61. Yog 62. Ampersand13 63. Feanor 64. wastedpotential 65. Prismee 66. idkwiam 67. Schami66 68. Støned 69. G.U.Y_Del_Rey 70. djcalpal 71. Great Username 72. Tedwards 73. tjspy 74. Mezik 75. LVP 76. Miles. 77. NextBish90 78. liam13 79. SLUTTVFTV 80. Sad Beautiful Tragic 81. Losing my ground 82. GuyNextDoor 83. ?????? 84. burninredhot 85. americanlife 86. Supernatural 87. Terylee 88. Mocha 89. Modern thing 90. TaylenaStan 91. Nein 92. Ger.vaz 93. fridayteenage 94. ONOPKA 95. makeawish 96. Holy Ground 97. LovaticSwiftie 98. RihannaLoverrr 99. Dear Reader 100. roso 101. Catch22 102. holyground13 103. creativity. 104. Strawberry Bubble 105. brokee 106. paulyyozd 107. ellis-bell 108. BOAZ 109. TheArgonaut 110. FolkLover1989 111. Klein 112. MusicLoverDude 113. Clauss 114. Hooker Barbie 115. twoheadlightshine 116. Bussea 117. Quicksand 118. kyungsoowift 119. Flames2Embers 120. Swirl900 121. beagle 122. Flower 123. byzantium 124. fab 125. Hendelzeit 126. Safe&Sound 127. SleepingTigers 128. Diarrhoea 129. My Tears Ricochet 130. Kyle-x 131. jacklovesyou1 132. PoisonedIvy Well fu*king finally me pressing submit on that rate 4
PoisonedIvy Posted August 31 Posted August 31 I will try to add thoughts or something between now and the deadline but I'm about to go to work so what will likely happen is I will share my thoughts when the reveals happen 2
wastedpotential Posted August 31 Posted August 31 17 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Ballots Received (132): Hide contents 1. terrorblade 2. tb6591 3. SlyMacPer 4. PaloSanto 5. greento 6. NordicGuy 7. Forever Winter 8. The Music Industry 9. Solaria 10. pinkbowvintage 11. 1989 12. Peroxide 13. DevilsRollTheDice 14. NEX 15. Live To Tell 16. Teen Spirit 17. sanzo 18. MidnightsAtPeace 19. Avrileon 20. CamiloPg_ 21. 4Real 22. KillingYourCareer 23. a_d_22 24. Namigo 25. llikeh 26. 305 27. Arrows 28. skizzo 29. Soobin 30. Tusk 31. Riverbank 32. theluckyone 33. LastKiss 34. itsjem 35. Hurem 36. Life Savers 37. folkloreking 38. gagacasanova 39. Vespertine 40. freakum. 41. chosensparkles 42. reputation1989 43. D-@-N 44. badidearight 45. Velvet Night 46. Enrique523 47. Mr. Duff 48. AshleyLovescats887 49. ChapelHooker 50. Gorjesspazze9 51. halcyonday 52. iamanearthling 53. AbeHicks 54. Axolotl 55. jacobhalkohit 56. PerfectSacrifice 57. Frankvert 58. Venice B 59. vinicius 60. Fitzswiftie 61. Yog 62. Ampersand13 63. Feanor 64. wastedpotential 65. Prismee 66. idkwiam 67. Schami66 68. Støned 69. G.U.Y_Del_Rey 70. djcalpal 71. Great Username 72. Tedwards 73. tjspy 74. Mezik 75. LVP 76. Miles. 77. NextBish90 78. liam13 79. SLUTTVFTV 80. Sad Beautiful Tragic 81. Losing my ground 82. GuyNextDoor 83. ?????? 84. burninredhot 85. americanlife 86. Supernatural 87. Terylee 88. Mocha 89. Modern thing 90. TaylenaStan 91. Nein 92. Ger.vaz 93. fridayteenage 94. ONOPKA 95. makeawish 96. Holy Ground 97. LovaticSwiftie 98. RihannaLoverrr 99. Dear Reader 100. roso 101. Catch22 102. holyground13 103. creativity. 104. Strawberry Bubble 105. brokee 106. paulyyozd 107. ellis-bell 108. BOAZ 109. TheArgonaut 110. FolkLover1989 111. Klein 112. MusicLoverDude 113. Clauss 114. Hooker Barbie 115. twoheadlightshine 116. Bussea 117. Quicksand 118. kyungsoowift 119. Flames2Embers 120. Swirl900 121. beagle 122. Flower 123. byzantium 124. fab 125. Hendelzeit 126. Safe&Sound 127. SleepingTigers 128. Diarrhoea 129. My Tears Ricochet 130. Kyle-x 131. jacklovesyou1 132. PoisonedIvy Well fu*king finally Oh she gave in? Oh. Aw. Alright! 2
wastedpotential Posted August 31 Posted August 31 ddd wait @Forever Winter, has anyone written things for the Christmas songs? More than like a sentence for each?
PoisonedIvy Posted August 31 Posted August 31 The way I had about 30 11s in my first draft Whittling it down to 5 felt like a firing squad. 1
wastedpotential Posted August 31 Posted August 31 2 minutes ago, PoisonedIvy said: The way I had about 30 11s in my first draft Whittling it down to 5 felt like a firing squad. I ended up with seventy six 10s, and every single one of them could've been an 11 if I felt differently right now 2
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 31 Author Posted August 31 15 minutes ago, wastedpotential said: ddd wait @Forever Winter, has anyone written things for the Christmas songs? More than like a sentence for each? I see no more than one sentence per song. Go for it 1
yourfaveisaflop Posted August 31 Posted August 31 (edited) submitted Edited August 31 by yourfaveisaflop 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 31 Author Posted August 31 3 minutes ago, yourfaveisaflop said: submitted Received. Thanks 1
Tusk Posted August 31 Posted August 31 1 hour ago, Forever Winter said: If not for @wastedpotential's commentary, some of these songs would be left with 0 comments Doing the Lord's work What's there to say about Stranger Than Fiction other than it's s-h-i-t? 1
wastedpotential Posted August 31 Posted August 31 6 minutes ago, Tusk said: What's there to say about Stranger Than Fiction other than it's s-h-i-t? Well I haven't submitted 1989 comments yet (I got distracted essaying the Christmas songs) but I wrote the following: Spoiler Stronger Through Faith - 5.1 - Please, someone stop me from associating this song with imagery of James Cordon slowly jogging down a street. I stopped watching movies for Lord's sake years ago after forcing myself through one of Hobo's many terrible flop indie projects, but this came out before that cutoff, and it has scarred me ever since. Otherwise, this hymn is pretty paint-by-the-numbers, serving more as an audition for Jack more than a merited piece of music. I'm glad they've come a long way in their work together, imagine if we were getting a dozen or more Jack songs a year for several years in a row and they all sounded like this ddd. 2
blown away Posted August 31 Posted August 31 I'll submit my scores tomorrow. Apparently I have to cut some of my comments short before I can submit them. 1
By the Water Posted September 1 Posted September 1 I'm almost done. Just have to listen to Mixtape again tomorrow so I just don't give everything a 1. Tried giving out more 10s but was still very harsh so I just don't give everything a 7 or 8. My 0s will probably upset a few people Spoiler Fearless - 4.68 Speak Now - 6.30 Red - 5.11 1989 - 3.5 reputation - 4.43 Lover - 4.58 folklore - 5.14 evermore - 6.12 Midnights - 5.14 TTPD - 4.92 Pretty accurate in terms of ranking. Red below folklore is a surprise and Midnights kinda gagged me ngl Peak Now vault is just pure excellence wow. 19K89 though... 1
Quicksand Posted September 1 Posted September 1 My averages Original album/deluxe: Spoiler Debut - 4.71 Fearless - 5.36 Speak Now - 5.32 Red - 6.13 1989 - 7.25 reputation - 7.83 Lover - 7.44 folklore - 5.47 evermore - 6.44 Midnights - 6.52 TTPD - 4.5 The Anthology - 5.83 Holiday Collection - 2.83 With Vault tracks: Spoiler Debut - 4.71 Fearless - 5.78 Speak Now - 4.96 Red - 6.29 1989 - 6.52 reputation - 7.83 Lover - 7.5 folklore - 5.47 evermore - 6.44 Midnights - 6.27 TTPD - 4.5 The Anthology - 5.83 Holiday Collection - 2.83 1
wastedpotential Posted September 1 Posted September 1 I already know y'all are going to be evil to this one Maybe next time we should limit the rate to people who can correctly tell me what lyric has the Whitney note at the end 1
Achilles. Posted September 1 Posted September 1 Shortlisted 13 songs for consideration to be my 11s. 1
Achilles. Posted September 1 Posted September 1 12 minutes ago, wastedpotential said: Maybe next time we should limit the rate to people who can correctly tell me what lyric has the Whitney note at the end You and you alone I fear. 1
Recommended Posts