selena_lavigne Posted August 30 Posted August 30 I've listened to debut so many times for rates but i still can't remember half the songs.
selena_lavigne Posted August 30 Posted August 30 Tim McGraw just clicked after years of not getting it.
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 30 Author Posted August 30 Ballots Received (117): Spoiler 1. terrorblade 2. tb6591 3. SlyMacPer 4. PaloSanto 5. greento 6. NordicGuy 7. Forever Winter 8. The Music Industry 9. Solaria 10. pinkbowvintage 11. 1989 12. Peroxide 13. DevilsRollTheDice 14. NEX 15. Live To Tell 16. Teen Spirit 17. sanzo 18. MidnightsAtPeace 19. Avrileon 20. CamiloPg_ 21. 4Real 22. KillingYourCareer 23. a_d_22 24. Namigo 25. llikeh 26. 305 27. Arrows 28. skizzo 29. Soobin 30. Tusk 31. Riverbank 32. theluckyone 33. LastKiss 34. itsjem 35. Hurem 36. Life Savers 37. folkloreking 38. gagacasanova 39. Vespertine 40. freakum. 41. chosensparkles 42. reputation1989 43. D-@-N 44. badidearight 45. Velvet Night 46. Enrique523 47. Mr. Duff 48. AshleyLovescats887 49. ChapelHooker 50. Gorjesspazze9 51. halcyonday 52. iamanearthling 53. AbeHicks 54. Axolotl 55. jacobhalkohit 56. PerfectSacrifice 57. Frankvert 58. Venice B 59. vinicius 60. Fitzswiftie 61. Yog 62. Ampersand13 63. Feanor 64. wastedpotential 65. Prismee 66. idkwiam 67. Schami66 68. Støned 69. G.U.Y_Del_Rey 70. djcalpal 71. Great Username 72. Tedwards 73. tjspy 74. Mezik 75. LVP 76. Miles. 77. NextBish90 78. liam13 79. SLUTTVFTV 80. Sad Beautiful Tragic 81. Losing my ground 82. GuyNextDoor 83. ?????? 84. burninredhot 85. americanlife 86. Supernatural 87. Terylee 88. Mocha 89. Modern thing 90. TaylenaStan 91. Nein 92. Ger.vaz 93. fridayteenage 94. ONOPKA 95. makeawish 96. Holy Ground 97. LovaticSwiftie 98. RihannaLoverrr 99. Dear Reader 100. roso 101. Catch22 102. holyground13 103. creativity. 104. Strawberry Bubble 105. brokee 106. paulyyozd 107. ellis-bell 108. BOAZ 109. TheArgonaut 110. FolkLover1989 111. Klein 112. MusicLoverDude 113. Clauss 114. Hooker Barbie 115. twoheadlightshine 116. Bussea 117. Quicksand
selena_lavigne Posted August 30 Posted August 30 The production on this album is absolutely tragic. Oh my god.
gagacasanova Posted August 30 Posted August 30 12 hours ago, Bussea said: but i'll swing on you @gagacasanova I'm ready for combat. 4
selena_lavigne Posted August 30 Posted August 30 Yeah. You have to be on some sort of substance in order to appreciate debut.
Dear Reader Posted August 30 Posted August 30 1 minute ago, selena_lavigne said: Yeah. You have to be on some sort of substance in order to appreciate debut. the name of the substance: taste 4 3
Klein Posted August 30 Posted August 30 34 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Been so preoccupied with other rate-related things that I keep forgetting to edit my own ballot. Let me add some messy comments Btw do you need us to tell you everytime we edit the ballot? I did some changes today (scores and added some comments), and I will probably keep doing it until the deadline. 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 30 Author Posted August 30 Just now, Klein said: Btw do you need us to tell you everytime we edit the ballot? I did some changes today (scores and added some comments), and I will probably keep doing it until the deadline. Not after every change, but do let me know when you make some major ones, like huge additions so I can see if they updated. @wastedpotential tried adding his but he broke his form by reaching a character limit 3
LastKiss Posted August 30 Posted August 30 On 8/25/2024 at 10:39 AM, Forever Winter said: @LastKiss Hi friend. You gave 6 songs scores of 11. Please edit and bring it down to 5 only! Also you've only used 2 0s, you have 3 more! Hiiii I already edited them 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 30 Author Posted August 30 1 minute ago, LastKiss said: Hiiii I already edited them Got them. Thanks
wastedpotential Posted August 30 Posted August 30 I ******* hate this website sometimes because I'm desperately trying to dig up the old rankings from the TTPD thread where I had all of my nicknames and I CANT GET IT TO WORK AND I'M GOING TO LOSE IT 3
Achilles. Posted August 30 Posted August 30 On initial scoring I have 81 10s. And that is with me already marking down some 10s to avoid having too many. I don't really like that the songs with multiple versions are combined. Like "Karma" is a 10 and "Karma (feat. Ice Spice)" is easily a 0. But am I supposed to rate it 10 for the good version, 0 for the bad version, or 5 for the average of the two? reputation, 1989, and Loser are my least played Lord albums of 2024 (with reputation just entering my top 50 this morning), and my scores do reflect this. 2
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 30 Author Posted August 30 2 minutes ago, Achilles. said: On initial scoring I have 81 10s. And that is with me already marking down some 10s to avoid having too many. I don't really like that the songs with multiple versions are combined. Like "Karma" is a 10 and "Karma (feat. Ice Spice)" is easily a 0. But am I supposed to rate it 10 for the good version, 0 for the bad version, or 5 for the average of the two? reputation, 1989, and Loser are my least played Lord albums of 2024 (with reputation just entering my top 50 this morning), and my scores do reflect this. Just rate for the best version of each song, so if you prefer Karma (solo), just give it a 10 and don't average it out with the Ice Spice ver
wastedpotential Posted August 30 Posted August 30 7 minutes ago, Achilles. said: On initial scoring I have 81 10s. And that is with me already marking down some 10s to avoid having too many. ddd and I thought I was way out of line for having seventy four 10s and 11s 3
Blood Magic Posted August 30 Posted August 30 I hope I have enough time to listen to everything before the deadline. 1
Achilles. Posted August 30 Posted August 30 17 minutes ago, wastedpotential said: ddd and I thought I was way out of line for having seventy four 10s and 11s I believe that for people who actually like Taylor Swift—as in the country-pop / indie-rock songwriter who writes clunky and overlong lyrics with too many big words—it is very easy to have 70+ 10s. If a person has less than that, the odds are good that they are a tasteless and braindead pop music stan who just likes basic Max Martin beats and catchy choruses. 1 2
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 30 Author Posted August 30 26 minutes ago, wastedpotential said: ddd and I thought I was way out of line for having seventy four 10s and 11s 5 minutes ago, Achilles. said: I believe that for people who actually like Taylor Swift—as in the country-pop / indie-rock songwriter who writes clunky and overlong lyrics with too many big words—it is very easy to have 70+ 10s. If a person has less than that, the odds are good that they are a tasteless and braindead pop music stan who just likes basic Max Martin beats and catchy choruses. I limited myself to 30-50ish 10s because I needed to use them as a benchmark as the absolute best songs. 100 10s for me would mean all 100 of those are contenders for her best songs and I have some puta and Loser songs in my top 51-100 which I KNOW realistically are not contenders for the top spot. 1
wastedpotential Posted August 30 Posted August 30 (edited) 10 minutes ago, Achilles. said: I believe that for people who actually like Taylor Swift—as in the country-pop / indie-rock songwriter who writes clunky and overlong lyrics with too many big words—it is very easy to have 70+ 10s. If a person has less than that, the odds are good that they are a tasteless and braindead pop music stan who just likes basic Max Martin beats and catchy choruses. Oh drag them My spread of 10s per album is actually pretty even Spoiler *TS - 2 Fearless - 7 SN - 8 Red - 10 1989 - 5 Rep - 2 Lover - 3 folklore - 8 evermore - 9 Midnights - 6 TTPD - 8 Others - 6 *I've got a few more I'd make 10s after Whitney-cization Edited August 30 by wastedpotential 1
Dear Reader Posted August 30 Posted August 30 Spoiler Let's be honest, she has at least 150 10s, but I think I gave around 40-50. 2
wastedpotential Posted August 30 Posted August 30 3 minutes ago, Dear Reader said: Reveal hidden contents Let's be honest, she has at least 150 10s, but I think I gave around 40-50. 10 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: I limited myself to 30-50ish 10s because I needed to use them as a benchmark as the absolute best songs. 100 10s for me would mean all 100 of those are contenders for her best songs and I have some puta and Loser songs in my top 51-100 which I KNOW realistically are not contenders for the top spot. Spoiler I'm so amazed y'all limited yourselves to that degree, I just do not have the willpower. I hope none of those 10s were wasted on songs like Enchanted or Cardigan, and were instead distributed to the deep cuts that the OTH participants won't score fairly 1
Dear Reader Posted August 30 Posted August 30 1 minute ago, wastedpotential said: Reveal hidden contents I'm so amazed y'all limited yourselves to that degree, I just do not have the willpower. I hope none of those 10s were wasted on songs like Enchanted or Cardigan, and were instead distributed to the deep cuts that the OTH participants won't score fairly Spoiler I mean I had to give Cardigod a 10, but avoided giving it an obvious 11 1 2
Recommended Posts