rate The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page

[Achilles.]

Just now, Forever Winter said:

This is the new base thread

 

This coup against me will not stand. 
 

[wastedpotential]

1 minute ago, Forever Winter said:

This is the new base thread

 

Sure

 

[Life Savers]

Style (Scooter's Version) is pop perfection so it's OK but some of you are not seeing heaving for what you've done to countrylor 

[wastedpotential]

Just now, NewStanner said:

The besties card was shipped, but it got immediately shipped back, I can't be friends with someone as tasteless as cardigod haters

Oh end them. If only we could hear @Bussea's response over all the ***** in their mouth, but alas 

[Dear Reader]

Page 400

 

 

Chloe and friends, I Hate it Here and link should've been higher, you stinkies 

 

[folkloreking]

I'm just glad the nightmare is over. 

[Great Username]

On 9/7/2024 at 9:48 PM, Forever Winter said:

 

  Hide contents

 

30. Treacherous

8.568

 

Saviours (11s): twoheadlightshine, Forever Winter, Soobin, Great Username, roso, beagle, iamanearthling, Vespertine, a_d_22, pinkbowvintage, greento

Stans (10s): The Music Industry, gagacasanova, Klein Ampersand13, wastedpotential, holyground13, Dear Reader, Cruel Summer, By the Water, Bindi, Strawberry Bubble, FolkLover1989, 1989, Taylor fanboy, Kyle-x, byzantium, My Tears Ricochet, Flames2Embers, Clauss, Quicksand, enchanted0, Bartender, Blood Magic, Sanguine, K$Ellie, Top Dash, Lazuli, sparrowblue, ellis-bell, paulyyyozd, fridayteenage, burninredhot, GuyNextDoor, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, Prismee, Fitzswiftie, Venice B, frankvert, badidearight, reputation1989, folkloreking, itsjem, Riverbank, Tusk, Arrows, llikeh, Namigo, 4Real, Avrileon, NEX

Admirers (9s): Velvet Night, MidnightsAtPeace, LastKiss, Uncatena, PerfectSacrifice, liam13, Sad Beautiful Tragic, RihannaLoverrr, AdrianNicki, TMRA, Lorenzo22, tb6591, Tedwards, PoisonedIvy, Solaria, DevilsRollTheDice, sanzo, Theluckyone, Life Savers, chosensparkles, Mr. Duff, AshleyLovescats887, Supernatural, TaylenaStan, Holy Ground, Catch22, Bussea, Kyungsoowift, Bosque, Achilles.

Haters (1s): creativity.

Saboteurs (0s): None

 

Comments

Vespertine

11 - "Lives were forever changed."

greento

11 - "My favourite song by her switches between this and Last Kiss, I just can't decide. Everything about this is perfect. The lyrics are simple yet paint such detailed imagery. The bridge is immaculate."

Forever Winter

11 - "The best bridge she's ever done. And she does it TWICE. She rightfully knows this is one of her best songs because whenever she performs it live she always prefaces it by saying 'This is one of my favourites.' and 'This is one of the best songs I've done.' Another song that was massively upgraded with the TV. The first three-track run on Red needs to be studied. Also, if there's any Taylor song you should play on blast in the car, it's Treacherous."

sparrowblue

10 - "The slow build from the start all the way til the bridge hits remains undefeated. maybe she can work with Dan Wilson again."

1989

10 - "THE best song of the Red era."

Ampersand13

10 - "My god, what could I possible say about this song? I actually listened to Treacherous for the first time on account of a thread on ATRL I perused before becoming a member. Someone had mentioned the double chorus and the song's overall euphoric quality. Well, they didn't lie. This will forever be a defining song with regard to my love for Taylor and her songwriting. There's a timeless quality not only to the production and melodies, but also the sentiment of throwing caution to the wind when presented the chance to jump in deep with someone you could potentially love."

The Music Industry

10 - "How can anyone possibly give Treacherous anything below 10? It's one of the most mature songs off of Red and her early career. It still stands out to me for its nuanced portrayal of the risks/rewards of falling in love. The double bridge is just so captivating as it keeps building in intensity until I feel myself ascending into heaven. Oh Treacherous, you will always be famous."

By the Water

10 - "Her best bridge still to this day."

Flames2Embers

10 - "Just. Say. It. With. Your. Hands."

wastedpotential

10 - "Y'all know the video of the Lord lookalike jumping off that cliff in heels while Love Story (Old Testament) plays? That's how I feel when I listen to this song. I'm tapping out and going base jumping! I'll see y'all at the bottom or I won't! I fear I'll be screaming this the entire time I hurtle down the side of the cliff-face. "TWO HEADLIGHTS *spits out bug* SHINE THROUGH *gulp of air* MY SLEEPLESS NIGHTS AND-"

Lorenzo22

9.3 - "Aged a bit but they could never make me not give you less than a 9."

Achilles.

9 - "The way this song builds is incredible."

AshleyLovescats887

9 - "surprised that it's so liked tbh but i get it"

Where are you now?

8.9 - "Breathtaking and captivating. The re-record finally sucked me in."

blown away

6.2 - "The lyrics are good and the bridge is heaven, but the song as a whole could've used some kick."

Peroxide

6.1 - "I've never clicked with this one… bit overhyped me thinks -  *prepares to be stoned*"

pavi

4.5 - "I've always found this melody to be annoying, whoops."

 

  Reveal, Part 6 Results (So Far)

  Reveal hidden contents

50. Don't Blame Me - 8.127

49. Maroon - 8.129

48. willow - 8.138

47. Anti-Hero - 8.179

46. Cornelia Street - 8.181

45. Safe & Sound (feat. The Civil Wars) - 8.189

44. ...Ready for It? - 8.203

43. the 1 - 8.205

42. ivy - 8.206

41. cowboy like me - 8.210

40. seven - 8.220

39. Holy Ground - 8.268

38. Mine - 8.294

37. illicit affairs - 8.303

36. Dear John - 8.303

35. Long Live - 8.328

34. Call It What You Want - 8.467

33. You're on Your Own, Kid - 8.540

32. right where you left me - 8.550

31. Fearless - 8.562

30. Treacherous - 8.568

 

The real #1

[Solaria]

The COMPLETE assasination of the Fadtology  how delicious

 

[Brooklyn Baby]

Kinda glad Style won cause I got to use this picture of the new outfit

 

 

 

[Strawberry Bubble]

5 minutes ago, Dear Reader said:

Page 400

 

 

Chloe and friends, I Hate it Here and link should've been higher, you stinkies 

 

TOLERATE IT SHOULD'VE BEEN TOP 10 

[wastedpotential]

3 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

Kinda glad Style won cause I got to use this picture of the new outfit

 

 

 

 

That's so hot omg

[sparrowblue]

and Enchanted is just the song. an album track with a permanent residence in the top 3 (#1 several times not every song has that to their credit)

 

 

 

[Lorenzo22]

thank you @Forever Winter  a legend

[Lorenzo22]

next rate Dear Reader and How Did It End? will be top 10 #TRUST 

[pinkbowvintage]

STYLE-IZERS WE WON!!!! 

 

who else remembers when we FIRST heard this utter bop and a half during the 1989 Target commercial and went WOA OKAY, this album is gonna be IT??

 

for those still uninitiated on why this is her pop masterpiece, this video breakdown might help:

 

Edited September 9 by pinkbowvintage

[Brooklyn Baby]

19 minutes ago, blown away said:

Thank you so much for doing this @Forever Winter. I loved the messy comments, the meltdowns, ... everything. Also, if it weren't for you I wouldn't have discovered how great Folklore is.

 

Ngl all your comments took me out, but I know you actually listened to the entire discography cause you commented on every single song 

 

Which is more than I can say for some people who participated

 

[KillingYourCareer]

1 minute ago, Lorenzo22 said:

next rate Dear Reader and How Did It End? will be top 10 #TRUST 

Ahh another Dear Adobe Reader stan, maybe our tastes are more similar than I thought

[Don]

27 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

Hey guys.

 

Thank you to everyone who participated, commented, joined in on the mess in any way.

This rate took A LOT of f***ing time to organise, but it was absolutely worth it and I would do it again. This was so much fun.

 

 

 

LOVE Y'ALL!!!

 

  Reveal hidden contents

Even though some of you have horrible taste.

 

Thank YOU!!!

[Lorenzo22]

I would love to do the next rate once all the TVs are released and maybe a new studio album  but i guess we'll see

[pinkbowvintage]

This was truly a blast and the comments had me cracking up at work! Thank you THANK YOU @Forever Winter for such a fantastic rate with so many hilarious accompanying images and an intricate knowledge and appreciation of the TayLORE.

[Great Username]

3 hours ago, Forever Winter said:

 

19. Guilty as Sin?

8.6628

 

Saviours (11s): Velvet Night, holyground13, burninredhot, SLUTTVFTV, Great Username, iamanearthling, Avrileon, a_d_22, pinkbowvintage, greento, Ger.vaz, Supernatural, Bartender, Don, LovaticSwiftie, Ms. Togekiss

Stans (10s): PoisonedIvy, Peroxide, gagacasanova, Cruel Summer, wehavetostan, Starchild, Bosque, 1989, RihannaLoverrr, Klein, The Music Industry, wastedpotential, K$Ellie, Dear Reader, terrorblade, PaloSanto, byzantium, NordicGuy, DevilsRollTheDice, NEX, sanzo, MidnightsAtPeace, 305, skizzo, Tusk, Theluckyone, itsjem, brokee, ellis-bell, Life Savers, folkloreking, Axolotl, Prismee, Støned, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, twoheadlightshine, beagle, Kyungsoowift, Flower, djcalpal, Mezik, Miles., SleepingTigers, Diarrhoea, Kyle-x, enchanted0, chiliam, Blood Magic, SoSickOfThatSOL, LoveInStereo, Lorenzo22, Starchild, Mocha, Nein, Holy Ground, Venice B, vinicius, chosensparkles, D-@-N, badidearight, AshleyLovescats887

Admirers (9s): Bindi, Where are you now?, Forever Winter, tb6591, PerfectSacrifice, TaylenaStan, Catch22, TMRA, idkwiam, Live To Tell, Arrows, Soobin, Riverbank, Enrique523, Uncatena, Ampersand13, liam13, modern thing, fridayteenage, Hooker Barbie, Flames2Embers, Lazuli, Achilles.

Haters (1s): None

Saboteurs (0s): sparrowblue

 

Comments

greento

11 - "Such an addictive song, I haven't been able to stop listening to it since April. So glad it's already cemented as a fan fav."

pinkbowvintage

11 - "Her Michelle Branch-coded magnum opus."

SLUTTVFTV

11 - "One of her best songs, def top 10 for me. Matty masturbation song did that!"

The Music Industry

10 - "Guilty as Sin? is a track that hits hard and lingers long after it ends. On my initial listen, I immediately knew that it'd be one of my favorites. The song presents a gripping tale of guilt and redemption that is addictive. Her delivery of the very last "Am I allowed to cry?" gets me everytime  She ate and left no crumbs, sisters."

blown away

10 - "By far the best song on TTPD. A career highlight that is the only saving grace on this album."

kyungsoowift

10 - "Yasss wet anthem."

1989

10 - "I mean, it's been getting so much hype and attention for a reason. Perfect song."

Life Savers

10 - "Holy as hymn."

Starchild

10 - "Oh another 11 I'm so sorry hymn."

Miles.

10 - "One of the greatest bridges she's ever written. For anyone with religious trauma, this is IT. It's like she took my heart in her hands and SQUEEZED. I choose you and me... religiously... :heart:"

wastedpotential

10 - "In my mind, this song is about what I do whilst thinking of my beau, 2015 Henry Cavill. 2015 Henry Cavill, if you're reading this, call me! I'm lonely and ready!"

Where are you now?

9.8  - "Truly a slow burner in the best possible way. Phenomenal penmanship, Taylor."

Forever Winter

9.2 - "THIS is what TTPD standard should've sounded like all throughout.  "

Achilles.

9 - "I'm afraid this could have been better produ—GUNSHOTS."

Changed lives 

[Bussea]

15 minutes ago, NewStanner said:

The besties card was shipped, but it got immediately shipped back, I can't be friends with someone as tasteless as cardigod haters

 

13 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

Oh end them. If only we could hear @Bussea's response over all the ***** in their mouth, but alas 

 

7 minutes ago, NewStanner said:

I can't take the betrayals and lack of taste anymore, Cruel Summer and Cardigod are BOTH in her top 10 songs @Taylor fanboy@Bussea @KillingYourCareer

 

 

Not you as well @Forever Winter @Starchild 

 

 

I have not seen the top 4 yet, but I hope y'all are happy with Overchanted winning, surely it's gonna get my 0 next rate, I was way too nice

[pinkbowvintage]

1 minute ago, Great Username said:

Changed lives 

when my DJ friend played this out of nowhere and I lost my mind:

 

 

[Strawberry Bubble]

1 hour ago, Cruel Summer said:

When my 1989 manifestations actually take Style to #1… what then? At what cost? 

Girl you are powerful... and dangerous

[fab]

should've sabotaged Style more tbh, it's a great song but Taylor's best? pls