Popular Post Brooklyn Baby Posted September 9 Author Popular Post Posted September 9 Hey guys. Thank you to everyone who participated, commented, joined in on the mess in any way. This rate took A LOT of f***ing time to organise, but it was absolutely worth it and I would do it again. This was so much fun. LOVE Y'ALL!!! Spoiler Even though some of you have horrible taste. 33 2
wastedpotential Posted September 9 Posted September 9 2 minutes ago, aotearoa said: are you ready Mr Styles? 1
Edge Of Glory Posted September 9 Posted September 9 thank you @Forever Winter!! this was a hoot to go thru 1
Strawberry Bubble Posted September 9 Posted September 9 10 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Hide contents 2. All Too Well 9.328 Saviours (11s): Peroxide, Feanor, Velvet Night, byzantium, Flower, DevilsRollTheDice, MidnightsAtPeace, Avrileonterrorblade, SylMacPer, Live To Tell, sanzo, itsjem, Hurem, Mr. Duff, halcyonday, Schami66, LVP, Sad Beautiful Tragic, americanlife, modern thing, fridayteenage, Holy Ground, ellis-bell, BOAZ, TheArgonaut, beagle, pavi, Lazuli, LoveInStereo, heckinglovato Stans (10s): Gorjesspazze9, Kyle-x, PoisonedIvy, AbeHicks, Axolotl, Bosque, Cruel Summer, Michael196, Bindi, StonedSoulPicnic, Achilles., Lorenzo22, wehavetostan, Forever Winter, chosensparkles, reputation1989, pinkbowvintage, NEX, 4Real, a_d_22, Solaria, PaloSanto, greento, NordicGuy, Namigo, llikeh, 305, Arrows, Soobin, Riverbank, Theluckyone, Life Savers, folkloreking, freakum., D-@-N, badidearight, iamanearthling, jacobhalkohit, frankvert, vinicius, Prismee, djcalpal, Mezik, Miles., liam13, SLUTTVFTV, TaylenaStan, Ger.vaz, LovaticSwiftie, RihannaLoverrr, Dear Reader, roso, holyground13, Strawberry Bubble, Klein, Clauss, Hooker Barbie, Bussea, Quicksand, Kyungsoowift, fab, My Tears Ricochet, Where are you now?, sparrowblue, enchanted0, chiliam, greeneyedsoul, Bartender, Blood Magic, Sanguine, Don, SoSickOfThatSOL Admirers (9s): The Music Industry, PerfectSacrifice, wastedpotential, burninredhot, KillingYourCareer, Vespertine, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, Tedwards, NewStanner, Edge of Glory, Safe&Sound, idkwiam, 1989, LastKiss, gagacasanova, Enrique523, AshleyLovescats887, Ampersand13, Supernatural, Nein, ONOPKA, makeawish, paulyyyozd, twoheadlightshine, Swirl900, yourfaveisaflop Haters (1s): creativity. Saboteurs (0s): Losing my ground, Mocha, Rev8 Comments RihannaLoverrr 11 - "The most Taylor Swift song to ever Taylor Swift. Oh what a moment!!!!!" pavi 11 - "Basic choice for my 11, but this is just her peak, in every way." sparrowblue 10 - "The 5 minute version is best. Miss Liz Rose did what she had to do by cutting it down." Forever Winter 10 - "OG 5-minute version >>>" Peroxide 11 - "It's considered a masterpiece for a reason. What a perfect song." Holy Ground 11 - "The most Taylor Swift song to ever Taylor Swift. Oh what a moment!!!!!" LoveInStereo 11 - "For the record, I'm scoring the 10 min/magnum opus version." reputation1989 10 - "Yeah it deserves an 11 but I'm stuck between six songs and this gets enough love anyway. 10+ minute version>>>>" Bussea 10 - "The OG >>>> The Bloated version" Where are you now? 10 - "Dancing round the kitchen in the refrigerator light. Queen of wasting electricity." greento 10 - "Unpopular opinion, but I definitely think the 5 minute version is best. It feels more impactful thanks to the production and the more succinct lyrics." Achilles. 10 - "This song (in either form) more than earns its status as a defining part of her legacy; lyrically utilizes so many of her songwriting trademarks, thematically summarizes the entire mission statement of her whole career, its second wind in extended form (topping the Hot 100 and winning a Grammy) exemplifies the significance of the bond between artist and audience." Lorenzo22 10 - "(10MV) 5MV, they could never make me like you, you better thank Forever Winter for the merging or you'd be one of my 0s" wastedpotential 9.7 - "Can y'all ******* get over this one? It's good, it's great, it's fantastic, but we need some new blood on the top of these discography rates. This is geriatric and I've heard it too many times to feel the way I used to. Maybe if there was such a thing as viagra for musical taste then I might get reinvigorated here, but I'm just tired. Ain't y'all tired of this one too? Also, I am rating the New Testament version here because her vocals and the guitar tone are stronger and I like the crescendo better, but the vocal glitch at 1:17, oh Chris Rowe your date with the guillotine is next week for that one!" 1989 9 - "A bit overrated and I don't return to it as much anymore, but I get it. When I do listen to it, it's hard not to argue it as being one of the Crown Jewels of her career." blown away 8.5 - "I do not use that phoned in 10 Minute Version, the original is rather good. The pen game is immaculate." Fitzswiftie 8 - "10 minute version drags it down so much." Flames2Embers 8 - "Somehow this song has lost a bit of its mystique for me over the last couple of years." Yog 7.8 - "OVERRATED AF SONG." TMRA 5 - "Had to sabotage the 10-minute version sorry not sorry." Hide contents 1. Style 9.466 Saviours (11s): Ampersand13, TaylenaStan, holyground13, Yog, Feanor, idkwiam, Riverbank, pinkbowvintage, CamiloPg_, LastKiss, Hurem, D-@-N, tjspy, Mezik, LVP, liam13, SLUTTVFTV, modern thing, creativity., brokee, MusicLoverDude, Clauss, Hooker Barbie, Swirl900, chiliam, K$Ellie, Edge of Glory, Ms. Togekiss, tb6591 Stans (10s): wastedpotential, wehavetostan, The Music Industry, Klein, Tusk, Forever Winter, Dear Reader, FolkLover1989, PoisonedIvy, Bosque, Michael196, Bindi, enchanted0, greeneyedsoul, Bussea, Quicksand, Kyungsoowift, Flower, byzantium, Heldenzeit, My Tears Ricochet, Kyle-x, Strawberry Bubble, twoheadlightshine, BOAZ, TheArgonaut, Solaria, Peroxide, DevilsRollTheDice, Live To Tell, sanzo, Avrileon, a_d_22, 4Real, Soobin, Theluckyone, terrorblade, SylMacPer, greento, PaloSanto, Namigo, 305, skizzo, Arrows, skizzo, itsjem, Life Savers, folkoreking, gagacasanova, freakum., chosensparkles, badidearight, Enrique523, Mr. Duff, Gorjesspazze9, halcyonday, iamanearthling, AbeHicks, Axolotl, PerfectSacrifice, frankvert, vinicius, GuyNextDoor, burninredhot, americanlife, Supernatural, Mocha, Nein, Ger.vaz, fridayteenage, ONOPKA, Holy Ground, LovaticSwiftie, RihannaLoverrr, Schami66, Fitzswiftie, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, djcalpal, Great Username, NextBish90, blown away, pavi, Lazuli, Bartender, Blood Magic, Rev8, Don, TMRA, StonedSoulPicnic, LoveInStereo, heckinglovato, Teen Spirit Admirers (9s): Vespertine, 1989, NewStanner, MidnightsAtPeace, Tedwards, Lorenzo22, Uncatena, jacobhalkohit, Safe&Sound, roso, reputation1989, Venice B, Catch22, yourfaveisaflop, AshleyLovescats887 Haters (1s): NEX Saboteurs (0s): By the Water, Losing my ground Comments Ampersand13 11 - "If you were to ask me what my absolute favorite song by Taylor Swift was, if I truly had only one option, I would have told you this one right up until 2017. It's certainly tied with a few others as my absolute favorite, which says something considering how much of her discography I've come to adore and how many times I've listened to this song. The guitar riff, the synths, the drama, the pleading bridge, and the physical imagery intertwined throughout the verses is just a master class of pop songwriting. Beautifully atmospheric and hauntingly moving doesn't even begin to touch the reasons why I consider this a true chef d'oeuvre. This song exemplifies Taylor's idiosyncrasies I find most captivating. Easy to interpret in one way, but more fulfilling when you take the time to discover all the workings lurking underneath. Is it just a pop song about an ex-boyfriend or is it an exercise in infatuation not only with lovers but aesthetics? That's what's so powerful about Style, it works either way." pinkbowvintage 11 - "Her pop masterpiece." Yog 11 - "A GENERATIONAL BOP." MusicLoverDude 11 - "My favorite single of hers that isn't a collab." SLUTTVFTV 11 - "One of her best." brokee 11 - "Another great song from miss taylorrrrrrr. this song take you to magical places." Edge of Glory 11 - "This and cruel summer take turns at my #1 spot...both just pure pop perfection. how many songs get news outlets making video essays on how good they are?? like!!" RihannaLoverrr 10 - "Pop perfection." Klein 10 - "One of the very best pop song she ever wrote. Like damn! Truly a shame that it didn't get a proper video... And btw, yes, the TV is atrocious (comparatively, because in itself it's ok, but it just isn't even close to the greatness of the original)." greento 10 - "Perfect pop song, nothing beats it. Just couldn't give it an 11 as other songs needed help more." kyungsoowift 10 - "OG stans where y'all at." Forever Winter 10 - "Original version is absolute perfection." Life Savers 10 - Pop perfection. She cooked with this one. The Music Industry 10 - "Pop perfection. This is a song that even in decades from now, it'll still sound just as good. It has a uniquely sleek and polished sound that makes it feel both like a very modern hit and a classic at the same time. It achieves something that isn't necessarily easy with Taylor music: it feels effortlessly *cool*. It's one of those songs that is universally loved by almost every demo, and for a good reason. It still remains the quintessential 1989 song in my book. :heart:" Nein 10 - "My favourite song of hers, ever." wastedpotential 10 - "It's funny how Lord released the New Testament versions of every track in this book except for this one! This literally gets even the most fervent of THOTS onto their feet in joyous praise of its perfection, so I shall not bother telling you what you already know. If only this got a better video and a Grammy performance, but I understand why that didn't happen." blown away 10 - "Love this one a lot. It has a classic feel to it." Rev8 10 - "Thank you Harry Styles." 1989 9.8 - "The TV sounds fine, y'all are just overdramatic." Achilles. 8 - "When they find the gene that makes people gay it will look suspiciously similar to the opening riff of Style. That **** is embedded in our DNA." Where are you now? 7.8 - "Classic + iconic. Classiconic. New words invented to describe this once in a lifetime work of art." Miles. 6 - "I like it, but it's so overrated." I'm pretty sure I used my 11 on all too well
wastedpotential Posted September 9 Posted September 9 Just now, Forever Winter said: Hey guys. Thank you to everyone who participated, commented, joined in on the mess in any way. This rate took A LOT of f***ing time to organise, but it was absolutely worth it and I would do it again. LOVE Y'ALL!!! Reveal hidden contents Even though some of you have horrible taste. Just know I'm gonna make you do it again next time but I'm also gonna demand access to the spreadsheet so I can tweak the numbers to fit my superior taste 6
Ms. Togekiss Posted September 9 Posted September 9 all I know is that im sabotaging getaway fart and delishit next rate. no puta should be in the top 50 except for call it what it is: legendary 2
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 9 Author Posted September 9 @NewStanner not you falling for terrorblade's fake ass post 1
Strawberry Bubble Posted September 9 Posted September 9 3 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Hey guys. Thank you to everyone who participated, commented, joined in on the mess in any way. This rate took A LOT of f***ing time to organise, but it was absolutely worth it and I would do it again. This was so much fun. LOVE Y'ALL!!! Reveal hidden contents Even though some of you have horrible taste. thank youuu, you are the best swiftie (i love forever winter, btw) 1
swifthino Posted September 9 Posted September 9 wait let me start my campaign to get begin again back to top 5
Strawberry Bubble Posted September 9 Posted September 9 14 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Hide contents 1. Style Okay, Style, I love you... but I already know who I'm sabotaging next year
AshleyLovescats887 Posted September 9 Posted September 9 Thank you @Forever Winter and everyone for making this so fun! This is the first time I've participated in a rate like this and it was such a joy to see everyone react over song x being lower than song y. It'll be very fun to compare this rate's ranking with the next rate's ranking, considering with what's coming soon 1 6
sparrowblue Posted September 9 Posted September 9 @Forever Winter thanks for the mess and the effort on the color schemes was a+ 1
wastedpotential Posted September 9 Posted September 9 I'm so tired now y'all, I can't even begin to imagine how @Forever Winter feels at this point
blown away Posted September 9 Posted September 9 Thank you so much for doing this @Forever Winter. I loved the messy comments, the meltdowns, ... everything. Also, if it weren't for you I wouldn't have discovered how great Folklore is. 2 1
G.U.Y_Del_Rey Posted September 9 Posted September 9 (edited) OH WOW did not expect Style to win, I thought the girls were going to sabotage it. Thank you @Forever Winter Edited September 9 by G.U.Y_Del_Rey 1
1989 Posted September 9 Posted September 9 Thank you @Forever Winter, this has been so much fun and it was so well done! 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 9 Author Posted September 9 I'm all out of reactions for today **** ATRL but I will upvote everything tomorrow 5
Dear Reader Posted September 9 Posted September 9 2 minutes ago, AshleyLovescats887 said: Thank you @Forever Winter and everyone for making this so fun! This is the first time I've participated in a rate like this and it was such a joy to see everyone react over song x being lower than song y. It'll be very fun to compare this rate's ranking with the next rate's ranking, considering with what's coming soon cmon ashley, spill 2
KillingYourCareer Posted September 9 Posted September 9 Time to participate in the Ashlee Simpson discography rate for all of you who consider yourselves tasteful music lovers and very discerning people!
wastedpotential Posted September 9 Posted September 9 And now I'm gonna RUN to the album thread and pretend there's nothing else going on on this website today regarding Taylor, nothing at all Y'all wanna join me? 2
Strawberry Bubble Posted September 9 Posted September 9 2 hours ago, Forever Winter said: 13. tolerate it 8.759 Okay, in reality number 13 is the real winner 1
Achilles. Posted September 9 Posted September 9 I think I hosted what might have been ATRL's very first Taylor discography rate (Essentially, Swift!) way back before 1989 dropped and I remember it being a huge undertaking at the time. Her catalog has basically quadrupled since then, so I can't imagine the amount of effort this took for you @Forever Winter You did such an amazing job with it! The fact that All Too Well, Enchanted, and State of Grace was the top 3 in 2014 and two of them are still in the top 3 in 2024. 3
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 9 Author Posted September 9 1 minute ago, wastedpotential said: And now I'm gonna RUN to the album thread and pretend there's nothing else going on on this website today regarding Taylor, nothing at all Y'all wanna join me? This is the new base thread 1
Mocha Posted September 9 Posted September 9 Thank you for hosting Forever Winter! Despite sabotaging a few , whew I can't deny what a cracked top 20 this was 1
wastedpotential Posted September 9 Posted September 9 1 minute ago, Achilles. said: I think I hosted what might have been ATRL's very first Taylor discography rate (Essentially, Swift!) way back before 1989 dropped and I remember it being a huge undertaking at the time. Her catalog has basically quadrupled since then, so I can't imagine the amount of effort this took for you @Forever Winter You did such an amazing job with it! The fact that All Too Well, Enchanted, and State of Grace was the top 3 in 2014 and two of them are still in the top 3 in 2024. dddd wait, swiffers never change 1
Recommended Posts