rate The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page

[PoisonedIvy]

1 minute ago, Forever Winter said:

The way I could let you know whether or not they're controversial if you just submitted

 

Saving the best for last, anticipation & suspense building, main character of ATRL yadda yadda blah blah blah

 

 

[greento]

2 hours ago, Forever Winter said:

  Hide contents

Now that I think about it, not even top 200 

 

Taste was displayed here

[Klein]

I finally sent my ballot @Forever Winter, I think I'm finally happy with the scores, jumping between the saves and sabotages and everything in between. 

 

My averages (and ranking)

#1. evermore - 8.9

#2. folklore - 8.5

#3. Speak Now - 8.2 (8.4 without the vault)

 

#4. Red - 7.2 (6.9 without the vault, we love a vault helping the album, best vault so far )

#4. TTPD - 7.2 (7.6 for the standard, 6.7 for The Anthology)

 

#6. Midnights - 6.6

 

#7. Fearless - 6.4 (7.4 without the vault, a whole ass point, it would fly in the top 5 )

#7. 1989 - 6.4 (6.6 without the vault)

 

#9. Debut - 6.2

#10. Lover - 5.7 

#11. Reputation - 5.0 

 

Spoiler

#12. Christmas EP - 1 (1.1 with Christmas Tree Farm added) 

Pretty much the ranking I expected to see. Even with all the shenanigans, the ranking is still great which means I didn't go too far in any direction. Only thing I didn't expect is Midnights above Fearless but poor Fearless is getting lashed because of the atrocious vault. 

Edited August 29 by Klein

[Bussea]

All my VOTES are DONE  just adding my comments and giving my 0s out accordingly 

 

an evermore song made it above 5 today too

[wastedpotential]

1 hour ago, Klein said:

I can assure you it'll get at least one score below 7.5. 

Oh it got a score far below a 7.5 from me too 

[wastedpotential]

50 minutes ago, Klein said:

I finally sent my ballot @Forever Winter, I think I'm finally happy with the scores, jumping between the saves and sabotages and everything in between. 

 

My averages (and ranking)

#1. evermore - 8.9

#2. folklore - 8.5

#3. Speak Now - 8.2 (8.4 without the vault)

 

#4. Red - 7.2 (6.9 without the vault, we love a vault helping the album, best vault so far )

#4. TTPD - 7.2 (7.6 for the standard, 6.7 for The Anthology)

 

#6. Midnights - 6.6

 

#7. Fearless - 6.4 (7.4 without the vault, a whole ass point, it would fly in the top 5 )

#7. 1989 - 6.4 (6.6 without the vault)

 

#9. Debut - 6.2

#10. Lover - 5.7 

#11. Reputation - 5.0 

 

  Reveal hidden contents

#12. Christmas EP - 1 (1.1 with Christmas Tree Farm added) 

Pretty much the ranking I expected to see. Even with all the shenanigans, the ranking is still great which means I didn't go too far in any direction. Only thing I didn't expect is Midnights above Fearless but poor Fearless is getting lashed because of the atrocious vault. 

Dddd I'm kinda shocked I gave several albums a higher score than you gave evermore 

[Klein]

7 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

Dddd I'm kinda shocked I gave several albums a higher score than you gave evermore 

I wouldn't be focusing on the scores too much tbh. I amplified a lot of opinions to have greater differences between my favorites and least favorites. Like I gave three 7s to evermore. I would never do that if I scored in perfect alignment with my opinions (if I did, it would have something like a 9.8 or above obviously ). 

Edited August 29 by Klein

[Brooklyn Baby]

1 hour ago, Klein said:

I finally sent my ballot @Forever Winter, I think I'm finally happy with the scores, jumping between the saves and sabotages and everything in between. 

 

My averages (and ranking)

#1. evermore - 8.9

#2. folklore - 8.5

#3. Speak Now - 8.2 (8.4 without the vault)

 

#4. Red - 7.2 (6.9 without the vault, we love a vault helping the album, best vault so far )

#4. TTPD - 7.2 (7.6 for the standard, 6.7 for The Anthology)

 

#6. Midnights - 6.6

 

#7. Fearless - 6.4 (7.4 without the vault, a whole ass point, it would fly in the top 5 )

#7. 1989 - 6.4 (6.6 without the vault)

 

#9. Debut - 6.2

#10. Lover - 5.7 

#11. Reputation - 5.0 

 

  Reveal hidden contents

#12. Christmas EP - 1 (1.1 with Christmas Tree Farm added) 

Pretty much the ranking I expected to see. Even with all the shenanigans, the ranking is still great which means I didn't go too far in any direction. Only thing I didn't expect is Midnights above Fearless but poor Fearless is getting lashed because of the atrocious vault. 

Received. Thanks!

 

Spoiler

Very interesting 11s 

 

[Brooklyn Baby]

 Ballots Received (111):

Spoiler

1. terrorblade

2. tb6591

3. SlyMacPer

4. PaloSanto

5. greento

6. NordicGuy

7. Forever Winter

8. The Music Industry

9. Solaria

10. pinkbowvintage

11. 1989

12. Peroxide

13. DevilsRollTheDice

14. NEX

15. Live To Tell

16. Teen Spirit

17. sanzo

18. MidnightsAtPeace

19. Avrileon

20. CamiloPg_

21. 4Real

22. KillingYourCareer

23. a_d_22

24. Namigo

25. llikeh

26. 305

27. Arrows

28. skizzo

29. Soobin

30. Tusk

31. Riverbank

32. theluckyone

33. LastKiss

34. itsjem

35. Hurem

36. Life Savers

37. folkloreking

38. gagacasanova

39. Vespertine

40. freakum.

41. chosensparkles

42. reputation1989

43. D-@-N

44. badidearight

45. Velvet Night

46. Enrique523

47. Mr. Duff

48. AshleyLovescats887

49. ChapelHooker

50. Gorjesspazze9

51. halcyonday

52. iamanearthling

53. AbeHicks

54. Axolotl

55. jacobhalkohit

56. PerfectSacrifice

57. Frankvert

58. Venice B

59. vinicius

60. Fitzswiftie

61. Yog

62. Ampersand13

63. Feanor

64. wastedpotential

65. Prismee

66. idkwiam

67. Schami66

68. Støned

69. G.U.Y_Del_Rey

70. djcalpal

71. Great Username

72. Tedwards

73. tjspy

74. Mezik

75. LVP

76. Miles.

77. NextBish90

78. liam13

79. SLUTTVFTV

80. Sad Beautiful Tragic

81. Losing my ground

82. GuyNextDoor

83. ??????

84. burninredhot

85. americanlife

86. Supernatural

87. Terylee

88. Mocha

89. Modern thing

90. TaylenaStan

91. Nein

92. Ger.vaz

93. fridayteenage

94. ONOPKA

95. makeawish

96. Holy Ground

97. LovaticSwiftie

98. RihannaLoverrr

99. Dear Reader

100. roso

101. Catch22

102. holyground13

103. creativity.

104. Strawberry Bubble

105. brokee

106. paulyyozd

107. ellis-bell

108. BOAZ

109. TheArgonaut

110. FolkLover1989

111. Klein

 

[Klein]

1 minute ago, Forever Winter said:

Received. Thanks!

 

  Hide contents

Very interesting 11s 

 

Spoiler

Don't you dare! I need to support my girlies 

 

[Dear Reader]

I gave two 11s to TTPD because I knew people would sabotage it. Some of y'all hate talent 

[1989]

1 hour ago, PoisonedIvy said:

My 0's better not be controversial. They are songs I would literally nuke out of her catalogue's existence if it were up to me.

 

ME! actually got higher than a 0 believe it or not 

 

 

Now sis, I don't consider my 0's to be controversial either and I would also absolutely nuke them out of her catalog as well, but Me! is not a 0? 

[Klein]

1 minute ago, Dear Reader said:

I gave two 11s to TTPD because I knew people would sabotage it. Some of y'all hate talent 

I am 99.9999% sure there's two of my 11s that NOBODY shared (and the songs will probably be out the top 150 because of y'all tasteless *******).

[Dear Reader]

Just now, Klein said:

I am 99.9999% sure there's two of my 11s that NOBODY shared (and the songs will probably be out the top 150 because of y'all tasteless *******).

I know one of my 11s will be out of the Top 150 too. 

 

 

-

 

@Forever Winter will you reveal what each person gave to each song? I'm trying to see something 

[Blood Magic]

I'm listening to Debut and actually enjoying it quite a bit. Perhaps I treated you too harshly. 

[Brooklyn Baby]

2 minutes ago, Blood Magic said:

I'm listening to Debut and actually enjoying it quite a bit. Perhaps I treated you too harshly. 

[PoisonedIvy]

13 minutes ago, 1989 said:

Now sis, I don't consider my 0's to be controversial either and I would also absolutely nuke them out of her catalog as well, but Me! is not a 0? 

I gave it something more humiliating than a 0 don't worry 

[Miles.]

My album averages:

 

Reputation: 8.2

Speak Now: 7.8

TTPD: 7.8

1989: 7.5 - tanked by the vault.  Would be 8.5 otherwise.

Red: 7.5

Folklore: 7.1

Debut: 6.9

Midnights: 6.9

Fearless: 4.9 - tanked by the Vault.  Would be 5.8 otherwise.

Evermore: 4.6

Loser: 4.2

 

[Brooklyn Baby]

11 minutes ago, Blood Magic said:

I'm listening to Debut and actually enjoying it quite a bit. Perhaps I treated you too harshly. 

We love debut appreciators. Classic after classic I fear 

[Brooklyn Baby]

Just now, Miles. said:

My album averages:

 

Reputation: 8.2 (?????)

Fearless: 4.9 - tanked by the Vault.  Would be 5.8 otherwise.

Evermore: 4.6

 

Oh... 

[Dear Reader]

1 minute ago, Miles. said:

My album averages:

 

Reputation: 8.2

Speak Now: 7.8

TTPD: 7.8

1989: 7.5 - tanked by the vault.  Would be 8.5 otherwise.

Red: 7.5

Folklore: 7.1

Debut: 6.9

Midnights: 6.9

Fearless: 4.9 - tanked by the Vault.  Would be 5.8 otherwise.

Evermore: 4.6

Loser: 4.2

 

[1989]

3 minutes ago, Miles. said:

My album averages:

 

Reputation: 8.2

 

Fearless: 4.9 - tanked by the Vault.  Would be 5.8 otherwise.

Evermore: 4.6

 

[1989]

This rate needs more 1989 Vault appreciators, I fear. The lyricism, the replay-ability. 
 

The girls that get it, get it.

[Dear Reader]

Just now, 1989 said:

This rate needs more 1989 Vault appreciators, I fear. The lyricism, the replay-ability. 
 

The girls that get it, get it.

Finally someone 

[Brooklyn Baby]

26 minutes ago, Dear Reader said:

I know one of my 11s will be out of the Top 150 too. 

 

 

-

 

@Forever Winter will you reveal what each person gave to each song? I'm trying to see something 

Let me see if I can do that. That would be a lot of compiling, showing the individual results of 100+ users for 260 songs. A bit tedious.

 

But for anyone who left comments, I'll reveal what score each commenter gave alongside their comment.

For example, if I gave The Man a 2 and left a comment on it, I'll show:

 

The Man:

@Dear Reader 10 - Best song in her discography.

@Forever Winter: 2 -  Horrible song.

 

If compiling all individual scores proves to be tedious... instead, at the end of the rate, I can share the Google Sheet for everyone to see what each user gave each song 

Should I be messy like that?