rate The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page

[Miles.]

2 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

5. Cruel Summer

9.078

AshleyLovescats887

3 - "yeah ikik"

Oh I know she's TIRED of performing it over and over again  

[4Real]

Cardigan should be in the top 5 instead of Enchanted, imagine how tired we are of that song 

[ONOPKA]

cmon august girlie we need you to WIN

[Achilles.]

I'm surprised Style didn't get dropped after the universal pannings of the TV. 
 

If it was swapped for cowboy like me or tis the damn season or tolerate it or marjorie or right where you left me or coney island or champagne problems or ivy or willow or happiness, then all 4 of lord's best albums could have been in the final four.

[Edge Of Glory]

2 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

 

5. Cruel Summer

9.078

(Previous Placement: #31)

 

Saviours (11s): DevilsRollTheDice, LastKiss, Mr. Duff, iamanearthling, Yog, Feanor, Schami66, Støned, djcalpal, LVP, Sad Beautiful Tragic, FolkLover1989, Quicksand, Kyungsoowift, Swirl900, Lazuli, Edge of Glory

Stans (10s): chosensparkles, byzantium, ONOPKA, Holy Ground, Ampersand13, NewStanner, wehavetostan, reputation1989, terrorblade, PaloSanto, NordicGuy, Solaria, pinkbowvintage, 1989, Peroxide, NEX, Live To Tell, MusicLoverDude, sanzo, Avrileon, MidnightsAtPeace, CamiloPg_, 4Real, a_d_22, Namigo, llikeh, 305, Arrows, Theluckyone, itsjem, Hurem, Life Savers, folkloreking, freakum., badidearight, Enrique523, halcyonday, AbeHicks, PerfectSacrifice, Fitzswiftie, Mezik, Great Username, Miles., NextBish90, liam13, SLUTTVFTV, burninredhot, Supernatural, Terylee, Ger.vaz, fridayteenage, LovaticSwiftie, Dear Reader, holyground13, creativity., Strawberry Bubble, BOAZ, TheArgonaut, Klein, Clauss, Hooker Barbie, twoheadlightshine, Flower, fab, SleepingTigers, Diarrhoea, Kyle-x, yourfaveisaflop, Where are you now?, blown away, AdrianNicki, Bartender, Blood Magic, Don, K$Ellie, StonedSoulPicnic, heckinglovato, Teen Spirit

Admirers (9s): The Music Industry, tedwards, TaylenaStan, PoisonedIvy, jacobhalkohit, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, modern thing, ellis-bell, SoSickOfThatSOL, Ms. Togekiss, Velvet Night, Cruel SUmmer, Bindi, tb6591, wastedpotential, Michael196, Soobin, Safe&Sound, greento, Tusk, Riverbank, Gorjesspazze9, Axolotl, frankvert, vinicius, americanlife, beagle, My Tears Ricochet, enchanted0, chiliam, greeneyedsoul, pavi, Top Dash

Haters (1s): KillingYourCareer

Saboteurs (0s): Forever Winter, Taylor fanboy, Bussea, Starchild, Mocha

 

Comments

Yog

11 - "TOP TIER POP PERFECTION."

kyungsoowift

11 - "This is THE poplor song."

Edge of Glory

11 - "My most played song every year since it's released...it's pop taylor at her absolute ******* best. a glittery anthemic heartwrenching adrenaline rush...i could listen to it 50 times in a row and not get sick :jonny:)"

1989

10 - "This will go down in history as one of the top three Taylor Swift songs of all time, and for good reason. There's really no way to get sick of this song due to the quality. Pop perfection in every way."

Peroxide

10 - "Pop justice was served when this became a mega hit."

Life Savers

10 - "THEE 2023-2024 hit."

reputation1989

10 - "Still timeless."

AbeHicks

10 - "Cruel Summer is about confessing your love to someone. it's about admiring someone from afar, it's about waiting for them. its a song about hoping and praying that they'll say yes to you. it's about the cloud of unknown that fogs your vision and plagues your thoughts the weeks spent working up the courage to ask. wondering if they're as afraid as you, and hoping that they'll understand you, that their fears will fade away. it's a song about yearning for them to accept you, because you'll give them heaven, you'll treat them right and never break their heart."

Where are you now?

10 - "Serendipitous that this smashed when it did. Don't think it would've been nearly as successful if released at any point during the actual Lover era. Outstanding & phenomenal, and I refuse to ever turn my back on it."

Miles.

10 - "Of course this masterpiece is a ten.  It doesn't fit in on Loser, which is why it had to be rereleased during the Midnights era!"

SLUTTVFTV

10 - "Polar opposite of the preceding song. Amazing, pop perfection."

blown away

10 - "I hated it when it first came out, but it's so infectious and eventually won me over."

NewStanner

10 - "Has been one of her best songs since the release and still is to this day, no amount of success or overplay will ever change that."

wastedpotential

9.2 - "Y'all are going to be so annoying with this one, I already know. Yay for a career defining smash hit, 18 years in, 4 years after release! Still top 20 on Spotify WW! 2023! Ooh ooh woah! Great hook! Bridge fun! Deja Vu! St. Vincent! No Video! Iconic Tour Moment! Have I covered every talking point, now? Can I move on?"

greento

9 - "So glad this ended up becoming so massive, the lead single that got away."

Achilles.

6 - "This is not in Taylor Swift's top 100 songs."

By the Water

4 - "I was gonna sabotage this but the Eras Tour made it grow on me. Still overrated though."

AshleyLovescats887

3 - "yeah ikik"

Bussea

0 - "I guess… I used to hate this song but it grew on me just a tad I GUESS but I refuse to let it win."

Forever Winter

0 - "I love this song but I have to sabotage. Real score (9.1). "

i was really ready to be hurting when this got punched out, ive had a bit of tension for every result in the top 40 bc of this  but gaining 26 spots, from outside the top 30 to TOP 5???? yeah, i'll take it!!

 

 

Spoiler

the sabotage next rate is gonna be SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO brutal tho omg

 

[folkloreking]

I remember getting my hands on a Lover chicken and just listening to Cruel Summer bc I'd seen the hype. By the third replay I knew it would be a Swiftian classic, time the ultimate truth teller. 

 

With that being said top 5 is insane but we move. 

[Støned]

3 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

5. Cruel Summer

9.078

(Previous Placement: #31)

 

 Lover. You fought a good fight. 

[Brooklyn Baby]

Anyway, the REAL #5 

 

 

 

5. seven

9.999

 

Saviours (11s): 1989, Holy Ground, Don, StonedSoulPicnic, NEX, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, itsjem, ellis-bell, fab, Hooker Barbie, sparrowblue, enchanted0, chiliam, Don, StonedSoulPicnic

Stans (10s): Kyle-x, Forever Winter, pinkbowvintage, TaylenaStan, FolkLover1989, Nein, Ampersand13, NewStanner, Achilles., Taylor fanboy, Klein, wastedpotential, Bosque, Cruel Summer, Tusk, Vespertine, Gorjesspazze9, Arrows, DevilsRollTheDice, Fitzswiftie, sanzo, Namigo, 305, skizzo, Riverbank, folkloreking, badidearight, Ger.vaz, fridayteenage, creativity., TheArgonaut,  iamanearthling, PerfectSacrifice, vinicius, djcalpal, MusicLoverDude, twoheadlightshine, Flower, SleepingTigers, Great Username, LVP, liam13, Supernatural, Bartender, SoSickOfThatSOL

Admirers (9s): MidnightsAtPeace, reputation1989, Top Dash, LoveInStereo, greento, The Music Industry, Soobin, Theluckyone, Uncatena, idkwiam, Kyungsoowift, Diarrhoea, greeneyedsoul, Lazuli, LastKiss, Bindi, Lorenzo22, terrorblade, Live To Tell, 4Real, chosensparkles, D-@-N, Enrique523, Mr. Duff, AshleyLovescats887, halcyonday, AbeHicks, Axolotl, Prismee, Mezik, Losing my ground, GuyNextDoor, makeawish, Dear Reader, Strawberry Bubble, My Tears Ricochet, yourfaveisaflop, Blood Magic

Haters (1s): None

Saboteurs (0s): None

[Dear Reader]

I'd love for august to win, but that won't happen

[Dear Reader]

Just now, Forever Winter said:

Anyway, the REAL #5 

 

 

 

5. seven

9.999

 

Saviours (11s): 1989, Holy Ground, Don, StonedSoulPicnic, NEX, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, itsjem, ellis-bell, fab, Hooker Barbie, sparrowblue, enchanted0, chiliam, Don, StonedSoulPicnic

Stans (10s): Kyle-x, Forever Winter, pinkbowvintage, TaylenaStan, FolkLover1989, Nein, Ampersand13, NewStanner, Achilles., Taylor fanboy, Klein, wastedpotential, Bosque, Cruel Summer, Tusk, Vespertine, Gorjesspazze9, Arrows, DevilsRollTheDice, Fitzswiftie, sanzo, Namigo, 305, skizzo, Riverbank, folkloreking, badidearight, Ger.vaz, fridayteenage, creativity., TheArgonaut,  iamanearthling, PerfectSacrifice, vinicius, djcalpal, MusicLoverDude, twoheadlightshine, Flower, SleepingTigers, Great Username, LVP, liam13, Supernatural, Bartender, SoSickOfThatSOL

Admirers (9s): MidnightsAtPeace, reputation1989, Top Dash, LoveInStereo, greento, The Music Industry, Soobin, Theluckyone, Uncatena, idkwiam, Kyungsoowift, Diarrhoea, greeneyedsoul, Lazuli, LastKiss, Bindi, Lorenzo22, terrorblade, Live To Tell, 4Real, chosensparkles, D-@-N, Enrique523, Mr. Duff, AshleyLovescats887, halcyonday, AbeHicks, Axolotl, Prismee, Mezik, Losing my ground, GuyNextDoor, makeawish, Dear Reader, Strawberry Bubble, My Tears Ricochet, yourfaveisaflop, Blood Magic

Haters (1s): None

Saboteurs (0s): None

YOU SCARED ME

[jacklovesyou1]

Bye cruel summer 

[Edge Of Glory]

wait, which songs have won the past discog rates?? i wanna root for a new winner

[swifthino]

lets go enchanted! 

[TaylenaStan]

4. Disgust
3. Encrusted
2. Stale
1. All Too Overrated

[1989]

that Cruel Summer jump is kinda iconic tho ngl 

[naval23]

ngl though the top 4 is amazing

 

Enchanted and Style a bit too high but august and All Too Well being top 2 will salvage the rate

[Miles.]

Despite my constant Loser lashings, Cruel Summer has always and will always be a 10!

 

But I admit to being a BIT of a success stan because everytime I hear it on the radio (which was every five ******* minutes for the last year and half) I feel the need to immediately go listen to it on Spotify as well

[fab]

need august to win and end the All Too Well / Enchanted / Style stronghold on TS megarates  

[Brooklyn Baby]

For our #4 song...

 

 

Quote

"Would've been an 11 if I had more to give."

Quote

"Amazing song but Lord is it overplayed."

Quote

"So good. She invented xxxxxx."

Quote

"If there's one song I'd want to erase from my memory just so I could experience listening to it for the first time again, it would be this."

 

[Achilles.]

2 minutes ago, Dear Reader said:

I'd love for august to win, but that won't happen

I've kinda had the feeling it might. But I don't wanna jinx it. 

[ONOPKA]

4. All too Well

3. Enchanted

2. Style

1. august

 

[wastedpotential]

I'm taking this as a victory 

 

Spoiler

Spoiler

also sorry to the moddies for my accidental slurring I'll get back to lovingly calling y'all hags or losers instead

Spoiler

please don't give me points or a posting restriction until after the reveal 

 

 

 

 

[KillingYourCareer]

Sounds like Auggie is out next!

[wastedpotential]

None of these are ideal win scenarios, but yeah lets give this one to august

 

[paulyyyozd]

Enchanted FTW