Miles. Posted September 9 Posted September 9 All Too Well is by far the most deserving winner, if it's out before the top 5, before Style and Cruel Summer............
wastedpotential Posted September 9 Posted September 9 Just now, Dear Reader said: Oh sis you know you're already on my shortlist. You can have my guest bedroom after everyone else leaves 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 9 Author Posted September 9 6. cardigan 9.000 (Previous Placement: #1) Saviours (11s): By the Water, paulyyyozd, NewStanner, Vespertine, FolkLover1989, Soobin, chiliam, StonedSoulPicnic, MidnightsAtPeace, Swirl900, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, PerfectSacrifice, iamanearthling, Mr. Duff, reputation1989, folkloreking, 305, llikeh, PaloSanto, roso, itsjem, BOAZ, Clauss Stans (10s): 1989, wastedpotential, Michael196, Forever Winter, Bindi, Achilles., Dear Reader, The Music Industry, Bosque, Starchild, Holy Ground, holyground13, DevilsRollTheDice, NEX, Live To Tell, sanzo, 4Real, AbeHicks, Axolotl, frankvert, Venice B, vinicius, a_d_22, Riverbank, skizzo, Solaria, MusicLoverDude, Theluckyone, Hurem, LIfe Savers, freakum., chosensparkles, badidearight, Enrique523, Gorjesspazze9, Tedwards, Mezik, Ger.vaz, LovaticSwiftie, fridayteenage, creativity., ellis-bell, TheArgonaut, Hooker Barbie, Kyungsoowift, Flames2Embers, beagle, fab, yourfaveisaflop, enchanted0, greeneyedsoul, blown away, Bartender, Blood Magic, Blood Magic, K$Ellie, TMRA, SoSickOfThatSOL, heckinglovato, NextBish90 Admirers (9s): Cruel Summer, Klein, LVP, Top Dash, LoveInStereo, PoisonedIvy, Lorenzo22, terrorblade, LastKiss, gagacasanova, Velvet Night, Flower, AdrianNicki, Ms. Togekiss, yog, Avrileon, idkwiam, D-@-N, Uncatena, Ampersand13, Feanor, djcalpal, americanlife, Nein, makeawish, AshleyLovescats887, twoheadlightshine, byzantium, Lazuli, Rev8, Don, Edge of Glory Haters (1s): None Saboteurs (0s): Peroxide, KillingYourCareer, Tusk, Mocha, Bussea, Taylor fanboy Comments Vespertine 11 - "Taylor Swift deserves the death penalty for cutting this from the Eras Tour when I paid good money to see it in IMAX." By the Water 11 - "A perfect song. Lyrics, melody, production all top notch." reputation1989 11 - "Her best song on her best album, a timeless masterpiece and those final two minutes whew." Forever Winter 10 - "My most-played Taylor Swift song (I still play it almost daily) and my #1 overall in her discography. I remember hearing this for the first time and being so gagged. When she revealed that she wrote to track on most of the songs on folklore, that just further solidified her genius for me. This song and album literally got me through 2020 and 2021. This song will probably place high already so I'm giving my 11s to other songs." The Music Industry 10 - "Considered giving this an 11. It's a hauntingly beautiful masterpiece that weaves nostalgia and heartbreak perfectly. It captures the bittersweet essence of lost love and longing like pretty much no other song. I still think it's an absolute crime that she cut off some of the lyrics of the last verse from the demo version. We need an HQ version with "I knew you'd miss me once the moment died, I knew to love would be to lose my mind." :chick3:" wastedpotential 10 - "If there's one song I know I can skip writing some lengthy comment for because y'all will all have something to say in its absolute praise, it's this one. Its win in the last rate was merited and I do love it dearly, but I'm ready for new blood. In the meantime, have you consumed the delightful Cabin in Candlelight version recently? I'm not sure how She managed to folklore-ify a song already on folklore, but She did here." 1989 10 - "I mean…those lyrics speak for themselves. Timeless." Life Savers 10 - "Oh, cardigan the song that you are." frankvert 10 - "Would've been an 11 if I had more to give." Where are you now? 10 - "Career highlight and wonderful lead single choice to showcase the album. Lyrics can be tricky in parts to decipher/relate to. "You drew stars around my scars, but now I'm bleeding", other discographies seethe." blown away 10 - "One of her finest songs." Achilles. 10 - "Simultaneously a magnum opus and her most annoying merchandising gimmick." Starchild 10 - "cardigan fun fact: I've only bought 2 Taylor cardigans." LoveInStereo 9.9 - "Unbelievably good lyrics." SLUTTVFTV 8.2 - "Good but it's def bottom 5 on the album. Maybe I don't enjoy it bc it's the lead, still a good song tho." KillingYourCareer 0 - "I'm sure she wanted to prove how powerful her fanbase is by releasing this song as the lead single, because it has absolutely no melody or chart potential. Of ALL songs on the album, she went for this non-event. " Bussea 0 - "NOPE! Not again!!! PLEASE NOT AGAIN." Peroxide 0 - "I know. Throw the stones. I'm ready. She's completely average… (despite belonging to her best album)… Cardiflop is NAWT winning for a second time on my watch."
Cruel Summer Posted September 9 Posted September 9 Oh I thought - oh Granny Jacket got that -5 PUNCH 1
wastedpotential Posted September 9 Posted September 9 If it really is All Too Well... I fear it's a victory for those of us tired of bullshit and overhype everywhere
gagacasanova Posted September 9 Posted September 9 Just now, Forever Winter said: 6. cardigan 9.000 (Previous Placement: #1) Saboteurs (0s): Peroxide, KillingYourCareer, Tusk, Mocha, Bussea, Taylor fanboy
swifthino Posted September 9 Posted September 9 1 minute ago, Forever Winter said: 6. cardigan 9.000 (Previous Placement: #1) Saviours (11s): By the Water, paulyyyozd, NewStanner, Vespertine, FolkLover1989, Soobin, chiliam, StonedSoulPicnic, MidnightsAtPeace, Swirl900, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, PerfectSacrifice, iamanearthling, Mr. Duff, reputation1989, folkloreking, 305, llikeh, PaloSanto, roso, itsjem, BOAZ, Clauss Stans (10s): 1989, wastedpotential, Michael196, Forever Winter, Bindi, Achilles., Dear Reader, The Music Industry, Bosque, Starchild, Holy Ground, holyground13, DevilsRollTheDice, NEX, Live To Tell, sanzo, 4Real, AbeHicks, Axolotl, frankvert, Venice B, vinicius, a_d_22, Riverbank, skizzo, Solaria, MusicLoverDude, Theluckyone, Hurem, LIfe Savers, freakum., chosensparkles, badidearight, Enrique523, Gorjesspazze9, Tedwards, Mezik, Ger.vaz, LovaticSwiftie, fridayteenage, creativity., ellis-bell, TheArgonaut, Hooker Barbie, Kyungsoowift, Flames2Embers, beagle, fab, yourfaveisaflop, enchanted0, greeneyedsoul, blown away, Bartender, Blood Magic, Blood Magic, K$Ellie, TMRA, SoSickOfThatSOL, heckinglovato, NextBish90 Admirers (9s): Cruel Summer, Klein, LVP, Top Dash, LoveInStereo, PoisonedIvy, Lorenzo22, terrorblade, LastKiss, gagacasanova, Velvet Night, Flower, AdrianNicki, Ms. Togekiss, yog, Avrileon, idkwiam, D-@-N, Uncatena, Ampersand13, Feanor, djcalpal, americanlife, Nein, makeawish, AshleyLovescats887, twoheadlightshine, byzantium, Lazuli, Rev8, Don, Edge of Glory Haters (1s): None Saboteurs (0s): Peroxide, KillingYourCareer, Tusk, Mocha, Bussea, Taylor fanboy Comments Vespertine 11 - "Taylor Swift deserves the death penalty for cutting this from the Eras Tour when I paid good money to see it in IMAX." By the Water 11 - "A perfect song. Lyrics, melody, production all top notch." reputation1989 11 - "Her best song on her best album, a timeless masterpiece and those final two minutes whew." Forever Winter 10 - "My most-played Taylor Swift song (I still play it almost daily) and my #1 overall in her discography. I remember hearing this for the first time and being so gagged. When she revealed that she wrote to track on most of the songs on folklore, that just further solidified her genius for me. This song and album literally got me through 2020 and 2021. This song will probably place high already so I'm giving my 11s to other songs." The Music Industry 10 - "Considered giving this an 11. It's a hauntingly beautiful masterpiece that weaves nostalgia and heartbreak perfectly. It captures the bittersweet essence of lost love and longing like pretty much no other song. I still think it's an absolute crime that she cut off some of the lyrics of the last verse from the demo version. We need an HQ version with "I knew you'd miss me once the moment died, I knew to love would be to lose my mind." :chick3:" wastedpotential 10 - "If there's one song I know I can skip writing some lengthy comment for because y'all will all have something to say in its absolute praise, it's this one. Its win in the last rate was merited and I do love it dearly, but I'm ready for new blood. In the meantime, have you consumed the delightful Cabin in Candlelight version recently? I'm not sure how She managed to folklore-ify a song already on folklore, but She did here." 1989 10 - "I mean…those lyrics speak for themselves. Timeless." Life Savers 10 - "Oh, cardigan the song that you are." frankvert 10 - "Would've been an 11 if I had more to give." Where are you now? 10 - "Career highlight and wonderful lead single choice to showcase the album. Lyrics can be tricky in parts to decipher/relate to. "You drew stars around my scars, but now I'm bleeding", other discographies seethe." blown away 10 - "One of her finest songs." Achilles. 10 - "Simultaneously a magnum opus and her most annoying merchandising gimmick." Starchild 10 - "cardigan fun fact: I've only bought 2 Taylor cardigans." LoveInStereo 9.9 - "Unbelievably good lyrics." SLUTTVFTV 8.2 - "Good but it's def bottom 5 on the album. Maybe I don't enjoy it bc it's the lead, still a good song tho." KillingYourCareer 0 - "I'm sure she wanted to prove how powerful her fanbase is by releasing this song as the lead single, because it has absolutely no melody or chart potential. Of ALL songs on the album, she went for this non-event. " Bussea 0 - "NOPE! Not again!!! PLEASE NOT AGAIN." Peroxide 0 - "I know. Throw the stones. I'm ready. She's completely average… (despite belonging to her best album)… Cardiflop is NAWT winning for a second time on my watch." NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
Achilles. Posted September 9 Posted September 9 1 minute ago, wastedpotential said: You know, upon further reflection, I think I might organize an orgy with all of Taylor's hottest music video stars (and also Alexander Skarsgard), lmk if you want to come! Are ICDIWABH stars Jan and Sam invited? 1
KillingYourCareer Posted September 9 Posted September 9 It wouldn't be an ATRL rate without KillingYourCareer giving a 0 to an overrated fan favorite 1 1
Cruel Summer Posted September 9 Posted September 9 1 minute ago, wastedpotential said: Oh sis you know you're already on my shortlist. You can have my guest bedroom after everyone else leaves I presume that's because I'm in the master bedroom? 1
terrorblade Posted September 9 Posted September 9 Just now, Forever Winter said: 6. cardigan 9.000 (Previous Placement: #1) Saviours (11s): By the Water, paulyyyozd, NewStanner, Vespertine, FolkLover1989, Soobin, chiliam, StonedSoulPicnic, MidnightsAtPeace, Swirl900, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, PerfectSacrifice, iamanearthling, Mr. Duff, reputation1989, folkloreking, 305, llikeh, PaloSanto, roso, itsjem, BOAZ, Clauss Stans (10s): 1989, wastedpotential, Michael196, Forever Winter, Bindi, Achilles., Dear Reader, The Music Industry, Bosque, Starchild, Holy Ground, holyground13, DevilsRollTheDice, NEX, Live To Tell, sanzo, 4Real, AbeHicks, Axolotl, frankvert, Venice B, vinicius, a_d_22, Riverbank, skizzo, Solaria, MusicLoverDude, Theluckyone, Hurem, LIfe Savers, freakum., chosensparkles, badidearight, Enrique523, Gorjesspazze9, Tedwards, Mezik, Ger.vaz, LovaticSwiftie, fridayteenage, creativity., ellis-bell, TheArgonaut, Hooker Barbie, Kyungsoowift, Flames2Embers, beagle, fab, yourfaveisaflop, enchanted0, greeneyedsoul, blown away, Bartender, Blood Magic, Blood Magic, K$Ellie, TMRA, SoSickOfThatSOL, heckinglovato, NextBish90 Admirers (9s): Cruel Summer, Klein, LVP, Top Dash, LoveInStereo, PoisonedIvy, Lorenzo22, terrorblade, LastKiss, gagacasanova, Velvet Night, Flower, AdrianNicki, Ms. Togekiss, yog, Avrileon, idkwiam, D-@-N, Uncatena, Ampersand13, Feanor, djcalpal, americanlife, Nein, makeawish, AshleyLovescats887, twoheadlightshine, byzantium, Lazuli, Rev8, Don, Edge of Glory Haters (1s): None Saboteurs (0s): Peroxide, KillingYourCareer, Tusk, Mocha, Bussea, Taylor fanboy Comments Vespertine 11 - "Taylor Swift deserves the death penalty for cutting this from the Eras Tour when I paid good money to see it in IMAX." By the Water 11 - "A perfect song. Lyrics, melody, production all top notch." reputation1989 11 - "Her best song on her best album, a timeless masterpiece and those final two minutes whew." Forever Winter 10 - "My most-played Taylor Swift song (I still play it almost daily) and my #1 overall in her discography. I remember hearing this for the first time and being so gagged. When she revealed that she wrote to track on most of the songs on folklore, that just further solidified her genius for me. This song and album literally got me through 2020 and 2021. This song will probably place high already so I'm giving my 11s to other songs." The Music Industry 10 - "Considered giving this an 11. It's a hauntingly beautiful masterpiece that weaves nostalgia and heartbreak perfectly. It captures the bittersweet essence of lost love and longing like pretty much no other song. I still think it's an absolute crime that she cut off some of the lyrics of the last verse from the demo version. We need an HQ version with "I knew you'd miss me once the moment died, I knew to love would be to lose my mind." :chick3:" wastedpotential 10 - "If there's one song I know I can skip writing some lengthy comment for because y'all will all have something to say in its absolute praise, it's this one. Its win in the last rate was merited and I do love it dearly, but I'm ready for new blood. In the meantime, have you consumed the delightful Cabin in Candlelight version recently? I'm not sure how She managed to folklore-ify a song already on folklore, but She did here." 1989 10 - "I mean…those lyrics speak for themselves. Timeless." Life Savers 10 - "Oh, cardigan the song that you are." frankvert 10 - "Would've been an 11 if I had more to give." Where are you now? 10 - "Career highlight and wonderful lead single choice to showcase the album. Lyrics can be tricky in parts to decipher/relate to. "You drew stars around my scars, but now I'm bleeding", other discographies seethe." blown away 10 - "One of her finest songs." Achilles. 10 - "Simultaneously a magnum opus and her most annoying merchandising gimmick." Starchild 10 - "cardigan fun fact: I've only bought 2 Taylor cardigans." LoveInStereo 9.9 - "Unbelievably good lyrics." SLUTTVFTV 8.2 - "Good but it's def bottom 5 on the album. Maybe I don't enjoy it bc it's the lead, still a good song tho." KillingYourCareer 0 - "I'm sure she wanted to prove how powerful her fanbase is by releasing this song as the lead single, because it has absolutely no melody or chart potential. Of ALL songs on the album, she went for this non-event. " Bussea 0 - "NOPE! Not again!!! PLEASE NOT AGAIN." Peroxide 0 - "I know. Throw the stones. I'm ready. She's completely average… (despite belonging to her best album)… Cardiflop is NAWT winning for a second time on my watch." OH
Miles. Posted September 9 Posted September 9 Wait looooooooooooooooooooooooool. I guess sabotage finally came into play here!
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 9 Author Posted September 9 Yall wanted cardigod out so badly you let Cruel Summer into the Top 5 3
Dear Reader Posted September 9 Posted September 9 (edited) When Cruel Summer wins and Loser stans become even more unbearable cause you decided to sabotage CardiGOD Edited September 9 by Dear Reader 3
4Real Posted September 9 Posted September 9 Just now, Forever Winter said: Yall wanted cardigod out so badly you let Cruel Summer into the Top 5 AS IT SHOULD 1
Taylor fanboy Posted September 9 Posted September 9 (edited) Let me cleanse the thread from my own doing after posting Chr*s R*we's photo. Edited September 9 by Taylor fanboy 8 2
wastedpotential Posted September 9 Posted September 9 NO JFLKSDJFSLKDJFSKJDHFLKJ **** **** **** **** **** TAKE IT BACK **** NO I REFUSE 1
Recommended Posts