gagacasanova Posted September 9 Posted September 9 2 minutes ago, Taylor fanboy said: My zero is still in That sounds like an issue between you and your ears 1
jacklovesyou1 Posted September 9 Posted September 9 4 minutes ago, 4Real said: Everyone who gave their 11's to any of the remaining songs is a basic ***** Success stans really came out the woodworks didn't they lmao 1 1
Taylor fanboy Posted September 9 Posted September 9 1 minute ago, jacklovesyou1 said: 11's all round to blank space lmfaooo 1 minute ago, 4Real said: Everyone who gave their 11's to any of the remaining songs is a basic ***** Just now, Michael196 said: exactly... where's I wish you would get your ass over here and you are in lena Exactly besties! In conclusion, 1989 will be sabotaged on next year's rate… already next year since we're getting TS12 on Q1 2025. 2
Michael196 Posted September 9 Posted September 9 "This is Taylor's greatest song ever." "This song is a solid 6 at best, but I'm gonna give it a zero because of how overrated it is within the fanbase." 2
1989 Posted September 9 Posted September 9 If anyone still has a 0 or an 11 left, why? nnnnn these songs were not going to be affected that much either way bffr 1
Taylor fanboy Posted September 9 Posted September 9 1 minute ago, gagacasanova said: That sounds like an issue between you and your ears I ain't a Loser apologist except for It's Nice To Have A 10/10 and False God when I'm ovulating.
Støned Posted September 9 Posted September 9 3 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: "Her magnum opus." oh no. not cardigan.
gagacasanova Posted September 9 Posted September 9 Anyone that scored the rest of the top even below a 7 deserves prison.
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 9 Author Posted September 9 8. State of Grace 8.900 (Previous Placement: #8) Saviours (11s): Feanor, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, Hurem, holyground13, tb6591, terrorblade, SylMacPer, sanzo. TaylenaStan Stans (10s): SLUTTVFTV, byzantium, liam13, modern thing, fridayteenage, Holy Ground, Dear Reader, Strawberry Bubble, Starchild, wehavetostan, My Tears Ricochet, Diarrhoea, Kyle-x, yourfaveisaflop, chiliam, BOAZ, TheArgonaut, FolkLover1989, Forever Winter, gagacasanova, Klein, Hooker Barbie, twoheadlightshine, Bussea, Kyungsoowift, freakum., Solaria, Peroxide, DevilsRollTheDice, NEX, Live To Tell, 4Real, Namigo, 305, Arrows, Riverbank, Theluckyone, folkloreking, LastKiss, MusicLoverDude, Enrique523, Uncatena, Gorjesspazze9, halcyonday, iamanearthling, AbeHicks, PerfectSacrifice, frankvert, Fitzswiftie, Yog, wastedpotential, Prismee, idkwiam, djcalpal, Miles., NextBish90, blown away, AdrianNicki, Lazuli, Bartender, Blood Magic, Don, K$Ellie, Bosque, heckinglovato, Teen Spirit, Ms. Togekiss, paulyyyozd Admirers (9s): Cruel Summer, PoisonedIvy, Rev8, NewStanner, greento, burninredhot, Ger.vaz, MidnightsAtPeace, Lorenzo22, NordicGuy, LoveInStereo, PaloSanto, pinkbowvintage, Avrileon, badidearight, Catch22, Flower, Top Dash, beagle, The Music Industry, Mr. Duff, Sad Beautiful Tragic, Soobin, reputation1989, Safe&Sound, Bindi, CamiloPg_, llikeh, skizzo, Life Savers, chosensparkles, AshleyLovescats887, Axolotl, jacobhalkohit, Ampersand13, tjspy, Supernatural, ONOPKA, brokee, ellis-bell, fab, enchanted0 Haters (1s): None Saboteurs (0s): KillingYourCareer, LovaticSwiftie Comments The Music Industry 11 - "This is Taylor's greatest song ever. State of Grace is anthemic to me. Right from the start, the driving drums and guitars give it this huge, soaring energy that's perfect for the emotions she's singing about. It's the perfect opening track for an album as thematically messy and diverse as Red. It speaks of love as both a battle and a sanctuary, something so powerful yet so fragile. When I hear this song, I'm reminded of Taylor at her very best artistically: passionate, introspective, deeply relatable yet uniquely in her element. If this song isn't in the top 5, we need the host to doxx everyone who gave it anything below 9.5. Thanks! :ryan3:" frankvert 11 - "This is her magnum opus as far as I'm concerned." Bussea 11 - "THIS is how you open an album." holyground13 10 - "One of my favourite Taylor songs and a sound I think would be great for her to expand on. it sounds timeless and evergreen." greento 10 - "She REALLY needs to do more stuff like this. Incredible lyrically, vocally and instrumentally. Really wish I could give this an 11 but some of my other 11s needed the help more." Forever Winter 10 - "Too many amazing things about this song to list out. Her BEST opener and it's not close. I think even she herself knows that she won't top this as a Track 1. I slightly prefer the original because of her baby vocals and the raw emotion. I've been a Swiftie since Fearless, but I became a *stan* stan during Red. When I heard this song up until All Too Well, I knew I was going to stan her for life." pinkbowvintage 10 - "A literal perfect album opener." reputation1989 10 - "Kicking off the best start to an album of all time." Ampersand13 10 - "Perhaps my favorite Taylor opening sitting right nex to RFI (and perhaps Fortnight but more on that later.) State of Grace does a masterful job setting the scene for its parent album. Big drums, anthemic chorus, and dictating conflicting feelings of what one needs and what one wants really helps to establish this theme of dichotomy present throughout Red. It's also one of my favorite Taylor vocal performances demonstrating her ability to make pop/rock sound fresh, captivating, and powerful. On another note, I think it inadvertantly works really nicely as a bridge from Speak Now to Red. It's not quite as poppy as the Max tracks, but not quite as country or youthful as songs like Sparks Fly or Mine. An absolute battle cry for those craving connection in a world that all too often prioritizes ephemeral and transactional experiences." Achilles. 10 - "Both versions are TENS." wastedpotential 10 - "No see, I start this song and I'm IMMEDIATELY walking down Madison Avenue in a perfectly tailored suit from Milan heading into my office at a big name advertising company, where I get to knock heads together and be an absolute menace of a boss. Granted, right now I work in a shitty office in the suburbs modeling wheat yields but I'm on the verge of quitting and finding a new job (again ddd). Basically... I have mental Devil Wears Prada montages every time I hear this that pull me out of my rather mundane life now. The Whitnification of the New Testament vocals here, it literally blows my hair back and sweeps me off my feet, She'd clearly recently re-upped Her illuminati contract or something, because they just never let up. If y'all have ever seen that meme of Squidward getting thrown through the spiked steamroller wheels, that's how I feel whilst and immediately after listening to this song. It's been what, 12 years, and I still couldn't really tell you what it's about because I am literally incapable of listening to the lyrics because I'm too ******* busy having a ******* hot rich NYC girl moment. This is Carrie Bradshaw's favorite Lord Hmyn, you absolutely cannot tell me otherwise." Where are you now? 9.1 - "Timeless masterpiece. Seven singles from RED OG and this wasn't one of them???" Nein 9 - "Dare I say her best opener..." Holy Ground 9 - "Just rating the normal song. The acoustic version is such a snoozefest. I boycott the song when driving to protect everyone else's lives, because I would defnitely fall asleep at the wheel." blown away 8.6 - "A great, rousing song. It takes a few listens to appreciate though." Rev8 2 - "Kings of Leon vibes. :eli:" sparrowblue 1 - "I like how mosaic was used." My Tears Ricochet 0 - "This song is a solid 6 at best, but I'm gonna give it a zero because of how overrated it is within the fanbase. It's a long, drawn-out song with a basic melody, and her use of clichés and metaphors comes off as tryhard. So it deserves nothing more than a zero. Seethe swifties!!" 1
wastedpotential Posted September 9 Posted September 9 1 minute ago, Forever Winter said: 8. State of Grace 8.900 (Previous Placement: #8) Saviours (11s): Feanor, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, Hurem, holyground13, tb6591, terrorblade, SylMacPer, sanzo Stans (10s): SLUTTVFTV, byzantium, liam13, modern thing, TaylenaStan, fridayteenage, Holy Ground, Dear Reader, Strawberry Bubble, Starchild, wehavetostan, My Tears Ricochet, Diarrhoea, Kyle-x, yourfaveisaflop, chiliam, BOAZ, TheArgonaut, FolkLover1989, Forever Winter, gagacasanova, Klein, Hooker Barbie, twoheadlightshine, Bussea, Kyungsoowift, freakum., Solaria, Peroxide, DevilsRollTheDice, NEX, Live To Tell, 4Real, Namigo, 305, Arrows, Riverbank, Theluckyone, folkloreking, LastKiss, MusicLoverDude, Enrique523, Uncatena, Gorjesspazze9, halcyonday, iamanearthling, AbeHicks, PerfectSacrifice, frankvert, Fitzswiftie, Yog, wastedpotential, Prismee, idkwiam, djcalpal, Miles., NextBish90, blown away, AdrianNicki, Lazuli, Bartender, Blood Magic, Don, K$Ellie, Bosque, heckinglovato, Teen Spirit, Ms. Togekiss Admirers (9s): Cruel Summer, PoisonedIvy, Rev8, NewStanner, greento, burninredhot, Ger.vaz, MidnightsAtPeace, Lorenzo22, NordicGuy, LoveInStereo, PaloSanto, pinkbowvintage, Avrileon, badidearight, Catch22, Flower, Top Dash, beagle, The Music Industry, Mr. Duff, Sad Beautiful Tragic, Soobin, reputation1989, Safe&Sound, Bindi, CamiloPg_, llikeh, skizzo, Life Savers, chosensparkles, AshleyLovescats887, Axolotl, jacobhalkohit, Ampersand13, tjspy, Supernatural, ONOPKA, brokee, ellis-bell, fab, enchanted0 Haters (1s): None Saboteurs (0s): KillingYourCareer, paulyyyozd Comments The Music Industry 11 - "This is Taylor's greatest song ever. State of Grace is anthemic to me. Right from the start, the driving drums and guitars give it this huge, soaring energy that's perfect for the emotions she's singing about. It's the perfect opening track for an album as thematically messy and diverse as Red. It speaks of love as both a battle and a sanctuary, something so powerful yet so fragile. When I hear this song, I'm reminded of Taylor at her very best artistically: passionate, introspective, deeply relatable yet uniquely in her element. If this song isn't in the top 5, we need the host to doxx everyone who gave it anything below 9.5. Thanks! :ryan3:" frankvert 11 - "This is her magnum opus as far as I'm concerned." Bussea 11 - "THIS is how you open an album." holyground13 10 - "One of my favourite Taylor songs and a sound I think would be great for her to expand on. it sounds timeless and evergreen." greento 10 - "She REALLY needs to do more stuff like this. Incredible lyrically, vocally and instrumentally. Really wish I could give this an 11 but some of my other 11s needed the help more." Forever Winter 10 - "Too many amazing things about this song to list out. Her BEST opener and it's not close. I think even she herself knows that she won't top this as a Track 1. I slightly prefer the original because of her baby vocals and the raw emotion. I've been a Swiftie since Fearless, but I became a *stan* stan during Red. When I heard this song up until All Too Well, I knew I was going to stan her for life." pinkbowvintage 10 - "A literal perfect album opener." reputation1989 10 - "Kicking off the best start to an album of all time." Ampersand13 10 - "Perhaps my favorite Taylor opening sitting right nex to RFI (and perhaps Fortnight but more on that later.) State of Grace does a masterful job setting the scene for its parent album. Big drums, anthemic chorus, and dictating conflicting feelings of what one needs and what one wants really helps to establish this theme of dichotomy present throughout Red. It's also one of my favorite Taylor vocal performances demonstrating her ability to make pop/rock sound fresh, captivating, and powerful. On another note, I think it inadvertantly works really nicely as a bridge from Speak Now to Red. It's not quite as poppy as the Max tracks, but not quite as country or youthful as songs like Sparks Fly or Mine. An absolute battle cry for those craving connection in a world that all too often prioritizes ephemeral and transactional experiences." Achilles. 10 - "Both versions are TENS." wastedpotential 10 - "No see, I start this song and I'm IMMEDIATELY walking down Madison Avenue in a perfectly tailored suit from Milan heading into my office at a big name advertising company, where I get to knock heads together and be an absolute menace of a boss. Granted, right now I work in a shitty office in the suburbs modeling wheat yields but I'm on the verge of quitting and finding a new job (again ddd). Basically... I have mental Devil Wears Prada montages every time I hear this that pull me out of my rather mundane life now. The Whitnification of the New Testament vocals here, it literally blows my hair back and sweeps me off my feet, She'd clearly recently re-upped Her illuminati contract or something, because they just never let up. If y'all have ever seen that meme of Squidward getting thrown through the spiked steamroller wheels, that's how I feel whilst and immediately after listening to this song. It's been what, 12 years, and I still couldn't really tell you what it's about because I am literally incapable of listening to the lyrics because I'm too ******* busy having a ******* hot rich NYC girl moment. This is Carrie Bradshaw's favorite Lord Hmyn, you absolutely cannot tell me otherwise." Where are you now? 9.1 - "Timeless masterpiece. Seven singles from RED OG and this wasn't one of them???" Nein 9 - "Dare I say her best opener..." Holy Ground 9 - "Just rating the normal song. The acoustic version is such a snoozefest. I boycott the song when driving to protect everyone else's lives, because I would defnitely fall asleep at the wheel." blown away 8.6 - "A great, rousing song. It takes a few listens to appreciate though." Rev8 2 - "Kings of Leon vibes. :eli:" sparrowblue 1 - "I like how mosaic was used." My Tears Ricochet 0 - "This song is a solid 6 at best, but I'm gonna give it a zero because of how overrated it is within the fanbase. It's a long, drawn-out song with a basic melody, and her use of clichés and metaphors comes off as tryhard. So it deserves nothing more than a zero. Seethe swifties!!" I'm walking fast through the traffic lights Busy streets and busy lives And all we know is touch and go
gagacasanova Posted September 9 Posted September 9 1 minute ago, Taylor fanboy said: I ain't a Loser apologist except for It's Nice To Have A 10/10 and False God when I'm ovulating. Oop clock me bc I am a Lo*er apologist 1
paulyyyozd Posted September 9 Posted September 9 1 minute ago, Forever Winter said: Saboteurs (0s): KillingYourCareer, paulyyyozd FAKE NEWS!! This is an actual GREAT song I believe I gave it a 10
terrorblade Posted September 9 Posted September 9 a bit too high but ok i only use the intro n the buildup to the "you're my Achilles heel" part
TaylenaStan Posted September 9 Posted September 9 2 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: 8. State of Grace 8.900 (Previous Placement: #8) Saviours (11s): Feanor, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, Hurem, holyground13, tb6591, terrorblade, SylMacPer, sanzo Stans (10s): SLUTTVFTV, byzantium, liam13, modern thing, TaylenaStan, fridayteenage, Holy Ground, Dear Reader, Strawberry Bubble, Starchild, wehavetostan, My Tears Ricochet, Diarrhoea, Kyle-x, yourfaveisaflop, chiliam, BOAZ, TheArgonaut, FolkLover1989, Forever Winter, gagacasanova, Klein, Hooker Barbie, twoheadlightshine, Bussea, Kyungsoowift, freakum., Solaria, Peroxide, DevilsRollTheDice, NEX, Live To Tell, 4Real, Namigo, 305, Arrows, Riverbank, Theluckyone, folkloreking, LastKiss, MusicLoverDude, Enrique523, Uncatena, Gorjesspazze9, halcyonday, iamanearthling, AbeHicks, PerfectSacrifice, frankvert, Fitzswiftie, Yog, wastedpotential, Prismee, idkwiam, djcalpal, Miles., NextBish90, blown away, AdrianNicki, Lazuli, Bartender, Blood Magic, Don, K$Ellie, Bosque, heckinglovato, Teen Spirit, Ms. Togekiss Admirers (9s): Cruel Summer, PoisonedIvy, Rev8, NewStanner, greento, burninredhot, Ger.vaz, MidnightsAtPeace, Lorenzo22, NordicGuy, LoveInStereo, PaloSanto, pinkbowvintage, Avrileon, badidearight, Catch22, Flower, Top Dash, beagle, The Music Industry, Mr. Duff, Sad Beautiful Tragic, Soobin, reputation1989, Safe&Sound, Bindi, CamiloPg_, llikeh, skizzo, Life Savers, chosensparkles, AshleyLovescats887, Axolotl, jacobhalkohit, Ampersand13, tjspy, Supernatural, ONOPKA, brokee, ellis-bell, fab, enchanted0 Haters (1s): None Saboteurs (0s): KillingYourCareer, paulyyyozd Comments The Music Industry 11 - "This is Taylor's greatest song ever. State of Grace is anthemic to me. Right from the start, the driving drums and guitars give it this huge, soaring energy that's perfect for the emotions she's singing about. It's the perfect opening track for an album as thematically messy and diverse as Red. It speaks of love as both a battle and a sanctuary, something so powerful yet so fragile. When I hear this song, I'm reminded of Taylor at her very best artistically: passionate, introspective, deeply relatable yet uniquely in her element. If this song isn't in the top 5, we need the host to doxx everyone who gave it anything below 9.5. Thanks! :ryan3:" frankvert 11 - "This is her magnum opus as far as I'm concerned." Bussea 11 - "THIS is how you open an album." holyground13 10 - "One of my favourite Taylor songs and a sound I think would be great for her to expand on. it sounds timeless and evergreen." greento 10 - "She REALLY needs to do more stuff like this. Incredible lyrically, vocally and instrumentally. Really wish I could give this an 11 but some of my other 11s needed the help more." Forever Winter 10 - "Too many amazing things about this song to list out. Her BEST opener and it's not close. I think even she herself knows that she won't top this as a Track 1. I slightly prefer the original because of her baby vocals and the raw emotion. I've been a Swiftie since Fearless, but I became a *stan* stan during Red. When I heard this song up until All Too Well, I knew I was going to stan her for life." pinkbowvintage 10 - "A literal perfect album opener." reputation1989 10 - "Kicking off the best start to an album of all time." Ampersand13 10 - "Perhaps my favorite Taylor opening sitting right nex to RFI (and perhaps Fortnight but more on that later.) State of Grace does a masterful job setting the scene for its parent album. Big drums, anthemic chorus, and dictating conflicting feelings of what one needs and what one wants really helps to establish this theme of dichotomy present throughout Red. It's also one of my favorite Taylor vocal performances demonstrating her ability to make pop/rock sound fresh, captivating, and powerful. On another note, I think it inadvertantly works really nicely as a bridge from Speak Now to Red. It's not quite as poppy as the Max tracks, but not quite as country or youthful as songs like Sparks Fly or Mine. An absolute battle cry for those craving connection in a world that all too often prioritizes ephemeral and transactional experiences." Achilles. 10 - "Both versions are TENS." wastedpotential 10 - "No see, I start this song and I'm IMMEDIATELY walking down Madison Avenue in a perfectly tailored suit from Milan heading into my office at a big name advertising company, where I get to knock heads together and be an absolute menace of a boss. Granted, right now I work in a shitty office in the suburbs modeling wheat yields but I'm on the verge of quitting and finding a new job (again ddd). Basically... I have mental Devil Wears Prada montages every time I hear this that pull me out of my rather mundane life now. The Whitnification of the New Testament vocals here, it literally blows my hair back and sweeps me off my feet, She'd clearly recently re-upped Her illuminati contract or something, because they just never let up. If y'all have ever seen that meme of Squidward getting thrown through the spiked steamroller wheels, that's how I feel whilst and immediately after listening to this song. It's been what, 12 years, and I still couldn't really tell you what it's about because I am literally incapable of listening to the lyrics because I'm too ******* busy having a ******* hot rich NYC girl moment. This is Carrie Bradshaw's favorite Lord Hmyn, you absolutely cannot tell me otherwise." Where are you now? 9.1 - "Timeless masterpiece. Seven singles from RED OG and this wasn't one of them???" Nein 9 - "Dare I say her best opener..." Holy Ground 9 - "Just rating the normal song. The acoustic version is such a snoozefest. I boycott the song when driving to protect everyone else's lives, because I would defnitely fall asleep at the wheel." blown away 8.6 - "A great, rousing song. It takes a few listens to appreciate though." Rev8 2 - "Kings of Leon vibes. :eli:" sparrowblue 1 - "I like how mosaic was used." My Tears Ricochet 0 - "This song is a solid 6 at best, but I'm gonna give it a zero because of how overrated it is within the fanbase. It's a long, drawn-out song with a basic melody, and her use of clichés and metaphors comes off as tryhard. So it deserves nothing more than a zero. Seethe swifties!!" I gave this a 11 and.. 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 9 Author Posted September 9 Just now, paulyyyozd said: FAKE NEWS!! This is an actual GREAT song I believe I gave it a 10 You're correct. I'll edit the post!! 1
Peroxide Posted September 9 Posted September 9 Oh Clean. You performed so well. Honestly, I've spent so much time sitting with that song - means a lot to me (and to a lot of fans) She'll get her top 5 placement eventually…
Cruel Summer Posted September 9 Posted September 9 State of Grace will never not be in my Taylor Top Ten. Literally never. 1
Taylor fanboy Posted September 9 Posted September 9 4 minutes ago, wastedpotential said: Anyway if y'all need a moment of levity someone deadass posted nudes in the megathread on page 28 14
TaylenaStan Posted September 9 Posted September 9 NATHAN CHAPMAN YOU WILL ALWAYS BE FAMOUS CAN WE FINALLY GET OUR STATE OF GRACE-like ARENA ROCK ALBUM... ENOUGH WITH THE SYNTHS PLEASE I BEG U 4
Recommended Posts