rate The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page

[Kavish]

Quote

(Previous Placement: #48)

What caused this JUMP? The Eras Tour I assume? 

[1989]

Aww I love YBWM, and if my personal top 10 can't happen then I'm glad this classic made it because she's still a 10/10 

[wastedpotential]

 

TAKE NOTES YOU HAGS

[4Real]

Fair placement for YBWM but i personally prefer Love Story and Fearless over it 

[terrorblade]

1 minute ago, gagacasanova said:

And that's on KARMA 

that's #118 sis

[Klein]

Just now, jacklovesyou1 said:

1989 stans are kind of annoying ... i'm gonna sabotage them next time 100%

You and me both sister. 

 

Spoiler

Notice how that this is second time in this thread that Puta and evermore stans are aligned. Truly nothing is impossible (even if it's only the pressed-ness binding us together).

 

[Miles.]

I know I keep saying this but WOW.  What an iconic, brilliant, perfect masterpiece.

 

Crazy how fire her pen game was even as a teenager.  The country Lorde  

[naval23]

amazing top 10. Cruel Summer is a sneak though - the recency bias is real. 

 

Clean, You Belong With Me and Cruel Summer are the only sneaks.

 

I would've replaced with "Dear John", "Getaway Car" and "tolerate it"

[G.U.Y_Del_Rey]

9 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

 

10. You Belong with Me

8.809

(Previous Placement: #48)

 

Saviours (11s): wehavetostan, FolkLover1989, holyground13, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, Feanor, Enrique523, sanzo, terrorblade

Stans (10s): NewStanner, 4Real, Holy Ground, paulyyyozd, Forever Winter, idkwiam, gagacasanova, wastedpotential, My Tears Ricochet, Kyle-x, Arrows, Solaria, MusicLoverDude, SLUTTVFTV, AbeHicks, Live To Tell, NEX, Namigo, Theluckyone, Hurem, Life Savers, folkloreking, chosensparkles, reputation1989, Gorjesspazze9, halcyonday, iamanearthling, frankvert, idkwiam, Mezik, Miles., NextBish90, modern thing, Nein, fridayteenage, brokee, Hooker Barbie, BOAZ, twoheadlightshine, yourfaviesaflop, greeneyedsoul, pavi, Bartender, Blood Magic, Rev8, K$Ellie, SoSickOfThatSOL, Teen Spirit, heckinglovato

Admirers (9s): TaylenaStan, PoisonedIvy, Cruel Summer, Lorenzo22, LastKiss, freakum., SylMacPer, PaloSanto, Soobin, Tusk, Bindi, Avrileon, Støned, The Music Industry, DevilsRollTheDice, CamiloPg_, llikeh, itsjem, D-@-N, badidearight, 305, KillingYourCareer, burninredhot, ellis-bell, Kyungsoowift, AdrianNicki, Top Dash, AshleyLovescats887, Axolotl, PerfectSacrifice, Yog, Fitzswiftie, vinicius, Prismee, djcalpal, Ger.vaz, makeawish, Catch22, creativity., TheArgonaut, Klein, Swirl900, fab, byzantium, SleepingTigers, jacklovesyou1, sparrowblue, enchanted0, chiliam, Sanguine, Don, Bosque, StonedSoulPicnic, Achilles.

Haters (1s): Taylor fanboy

Saboteurs (0s): Losing my ground, Bussea

 

Comments

holyground13

11 - "This has to be one of the most fun songs of all time, right? definitely a highlight of the Eras Tour for me. it pops off so much in any setting."

wastedpotential

10 - "I have no words. There is nothing I can say to reflect my current thoughts and musings on one of the greatest artistic creations of the anthropocene. Well, I guess I can say that this song has more straight stans than almost every other ATRL-fave combined, because the way this is reacted to at high school and college basketball games in the US is cultish. Other than that, you know it all. S-tier melody, s-tier lyrics, s-tier instrumentation, s-tier video, s-tier song, a career-defining and decade-defining classic."

1989

10 - "This classic."

Miles.

10 - "THEE other enduring classic!"

AbeHicks

10 - "The Demogorgon to Will Byers probably."

Lorenzo22

9.7 - "They don't make hits like this anymore."

sparrowblue

9 - "Gives '08 '09 flashbacks we really don't want or need."

AshleyLovescats887

9 - "the live eras version is so good"

Where are you now?

7.9 - "Forever classic, but don't love the re-record."

pinkbowvintage

6.5 - "This was overplayed to death too much for me to love it and I can't not think of Girl Next Door by Saving Jane."

blown away

6.5 - "I like it once in a while, but it's far from my favorite Taylor songs."

Starchild

6 - "A classic but I personally never liked it."

Bussea

0 - "Played out, annoying, mid, White Horse deserved!"

My third 11 out, but great to see it ended up in the top 10, did not expect to see it above Love Story 

 

 

Edited September 9 by G.U.Y_Del_Rey

[Brooklyn Baby]

1 minute ago, Kavish said:

What caused this JUMP? The Eras Tour I assume? 

There are double the participants from last rate. That might be the reason why. Just a whole bunch of different taste affecting the rate

 

[Cruel Summer]

Just now, jacklovesyou1 said:

1989 stans are kind of annoying ... i'm gonna sabotage them next time 100%

Are there any such stans, though? Like I said yesterday, I don't think this was because it has a dedicated cohort like Reputation or Evermore do. It's just that we all happen to like it, more or less. I'd almost argue that the fact that nobody really thought to sabotage it, paired with its general well-likedness, kind of means it deserves its impressive performance.

[Nein]

What this rate has taught me is that I need to actively start sabotaging songs

 

Why is the top 10 looking like a local's list wtf

[terrorblade]

atp i'll take anything for #1 as long as it's not atw

edit: or cardigan

Edited September 9 by terrorblade

[jacklovesyou1]

3 minutes ago, Klein said:

You and me both sister. 

 

  Reveal hidden contents

Notice how that this is second time in this thread that Puta and evermore stans are aligned. Truly nothing is impossible (even if it's only the pressed-ness binding us together).

 

F it .. next time i'm just gonna go over the top with rep and evermore scores 10's and 11's all around poor other era stans lmao 

[Edge Of Glory]

1 minute ago, naval23 said:

amazing top 10. Cruel Summer is a sneak though - the recency bias is real. 

 

Clean, You Belong With Me and Cruel Summer are the only sneaks.

 

I would've replaced with "Dear John", "Getaway Car" and "tolerate it"

if the recency bias was real, TTPD wouldn't have gotten slaughtered like it did

[gagacasanova]

2 minutes ago, terrorblade said:

that's #118 sis

Don't remind me.

[Brooklyn Baby]

For our next reveal:

 

Quote

 "Respect and enjoy it, probably don't love the same way everyone else seems to."

Quote

"For me, this song is pure magic."

Quote

"Immaculate song."

 

[Taylor fanboy]

3 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

 

10. You Belong with Me

8.809

(Previous Placement: #48)

Haters (1): Taylor fanboy

Bussea

0 - "Played out, annoying, mid, White Horse deserved!"

@Bussea my DMs were open!!!

 

Getaway Car was almost TOP 10! ugh

 

Missed opportunity for a joint slay!

 

[holyground13]

3 minutes ago, Kavish said:

What caused this JUMP? The Eras Tour I assume? 

My 11 

 

Sorta sad it's out but top 10 is basically the same as #1 so I'm glad it just made it (over the just good Getaway Car). A win

Spoiler

[Dear Reader]

Enchanted might be next

[wastedpotential]

2 minutes ago, Cruel Summer said:

Are there any such stans, though? Like I said yesterday, I don't think this was because it has a dedicated cohort like Reputation or Evermore do. It's just that we all happen to like it, more or less. I'd almost argue that the fact that nobody really thought to sabotage it, paired with its general well-likedness, kind of means it deserves its impressive performance.

Lesson ******* learned 

 

 

[Cruel Summer]

Just now, Forever Winter said:

For our next reveal:

 

 

Oh it's giving one of the fan classics - Style? August? Enchanted?

[Blood Magic]

Probably Clean

[gagacasanova]

STAY WITH ME ENCHANTED

[Klein]

2 minutes ago, Nein said:

What this rate has taught me is that I need to actively start sabotaging songs

 

Why is the top 10 looking like a local's list wtf

Because these are the songs everyone likes. Sadly, the love for the deep cuts is a lot more fractured. Everyone loves the deep cuts, but not everyone loves the same deep cuts (mainly because the fandom is so large now and with so many different preferences).