Jump to content

The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page


Recommended Posts

Posted
1 minute ago, Forever Winter said:

Which TTPD songs would you have placed in the top 25?

 

1073500797750476860.webp?size=240&qualit

one day people will see the light and realize the HOLINESS of But Satan I Love Jesus

 

  • Replies 10k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Brooklyn Baby

    1241

  • wastedpotential

    837

  • Dear Reader

    463

  • Klein

    375

Posted
2 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

Which TTPD songs would you have placed in the top 25?

 

1073500797750476860.webp?size=240&qualit

Spoiler

none :suburban: but IHIH, The Prophecy, GAS? and maybe ILIPW would be in the 26-50 range i think

1073500797750476860.webp?size=240&qualit

  • Haha 1
Posted
4 minutes ago, Klein said:

The fact both Getaway Car and Cruel Summer are basically 1989 songs... 1989 truly came here and said "this is MY rate". :deadbanana4:

The GRIP that album has on the fanbase's psyche is astounding 

Posted

Screen_Shot_2015-08-30_at_9.06.15_PM.0.0

 

12. Wildest Dreams

8.773

 

Saviours (11s): Quicksand, blown away, twoheadlightshine, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, Fitzswiftie, DevilsRollTheDice

Stans (10s): byzantium, By the Water, idkwiam, wastedpotential, Tusk, AbeHicks, Forever Winter, burninredhot, Bosque, My Tears Ricochet, Kyle-x, ONOPKA, Holy Ground, Miles., CamiloPg_, Dear Reader, a_d_22, Namigo, llikeh, MidnightsAtPeace, terrorblade, freakum., brokee, FolkLover1989, Klein, Hooker Barbie, reputation1989, badidearight, Enrique523, Solaria, TaylenaStan, Nein, fridayteenage, liam13, PaloSanto, sanzo, Theluckyone, Hurem, folkloreking, Gorjesspazze9, PerfectSacrifice, vinicius, Yog, Støned, djcalpal, tjspy, jacklovesyou1, Where are you now?, greeneyedsoul, pavi, Bartender, Don, K$Ellie, SoSickOfThatSOL, Lorenzo22, Teen Spirit

Admirers (9s): Avrileon, RihannaLoverrr, Velvet Night, Bindi, Safe&Sound, The Music Industry, LastKiss, roso, 305, jacobhalkohit, SLUTTVFTV, Sad Beautiful Tragic, Ger.vaz, holyground13, TheArgonaut, AdrianNicki, LoveInStereo, Soobin beagle, Ms. Togekiss, PoisonedIvy, 1989, Live To Tell, Arrows, chosensparkles, D-@-N, halcyonday, GuyNextDoor, modern thing, creativity., frankvert, Venice B, Ampersand13, Bussea, Strawberry Bubble, Swirl900, enchanted0, Lazuli, Blood Magic, Rev8, NewStanner, heckinglovatoFeanor, Mezik, NextBish90

Haters (1s): Losing my ground

Saboteurs (0s): Starchild

 

Comments

blown away

11 - "Top 5 in her discography. It's so good that not even the Taylor's Version could ruin it for me."

By the Water

10 - "What would 19K89 be without this song?"

Klein

10 - "This used to be one of my favorite favorite Taylor songs ever (like in the top 10, or at least 15). Since then it lost a bit of its superb in my eyes, but it is still a 10/10 any day of the week."

Forever Winter

10 - "I actually prefer the original version. Her younger vocals, the vocal mixing, the production. Top tier. Perfection. I still cannot fathom why she refuses to sing this one fully. It's always chopped up or mashed up with something. Ridiculous!!!"

wastedpotential

10 - "I vividly remember sitting in my dad's car in our driveway listening to my 1989 CD for the first time after school on that Friday, and just ascending to this song. This remains, to this very day, my favorite Taylor music video, for a million reasons, of which I shall list a few: It's visually stunning and cinematic (I'm a sucker for 50s aesthetica and old Hollywood), the story is giving (and considering the tea about this song, it's probably the video that most closely resembles the song in question), Scott Eastwood is one of the hottest men on the planet (I know the girls fawn over Sean O'Pry, but Scott Eastwood is more attractive, I'm sorry), and it plays the extended radio edit, which is self explanatory. Her having a one-night stand with Alexander Skarsgard while filming The Giver (which... I loved the book but the producers butchered the entire concept for the movie, the romance should've been burned) in South Africa... that was fandom history. The night the paparazzi pictures from them in that restaurant in Cape Town were published was a similar experience for me to the night the Taylor And Tom Kick Rocks photos came out. Now, the song itself is also God-tier, I don't make the rules. Call it the Lana influence or the Taylor Discovers What Sex Is phenomenon, but the sensuality, delicateness, and earnestness of this song will go down in history. The only songs she's made that match that energy are Dress and False God, but there was NOTHING like it before. Listening to this hymn makes me feel like I also went off to Africa to shoot a movie and had a fling with a co-star I knew wouldn't ever last, but by God did we have fun while it was happening. The bridge is career defining and builds perfectly, and is something I considered getting tattooed at one point. I could go line by line through the entire song, but that's too much, even for me and my rambling essays. This song is so good y'all *bursts into tears*."

Where are you now?

10 - "A completely perfect pop song. The best 5th single of all time? Stunning music video visuals. Radio single remix with the added drums/echo effects is radiant. GORGEOUS chorus ad libs."

Lorenzo22

10 - "The Eras Tour performance is so underrated, the added percussions on the repeated bridge make me wanna nut ngl."

NewStanner

9 - "Would've been 10, but the similarities with Lana's Without You are too blatant to ignore."

greento

8.6 - "Seeing this live at the Eras Tour changed my life. Really enhanced my enjoyment of the song, the way she repeats the bridge as the drums build up..."

MusicLoverDude

8 - "The mix used in the music video should have been the main mix."

Achilles.

8 - "I love when Taylor Swift mimics other people's styles because she always does it so well that she renders the artists she's ripping off obsolete."

Posted
1 minute ago, Clauss said:

ATW gone before the TOP10 This is CRIMINAL

It's not out yet, that was a troll post.

Posted
Just now, Taylor fanboy said:

GETAWAY CAR SWEETIIEEEE!!! 

I mean, not even you, thee ultimate Puta stan, can deny that Getaway Car is an OOTW rip off. :suburban:

  • Haha 3
Posted

Oh it's Wildest Dreams which I definitely don't hate anymore yay, so happy to see you thriving sister! 
 

Anyway

  • Haha 1
Posted
Just now, Forever Winter said:

Screen_Shot_2015-08-30_at_9.06.15_PM.0.0

 

12. Wildest Dreams

8.773

 

Saviours (11s): Quicksand, blown away, twoheadlightshine, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, Fitzswiftie, DevilsRollTheDice

Stans (10s): byzantium, By the Water, idkwiam, wastedpotential, Tusk, AbeHicks, Forever Winter, burninredhot, Bosque, My Tears Ricochet, Kyle-x, ONOPKA, Holy Ground, Miles., CamiloPg_, Dear Reader, a_d_22, Namigo, llikeh, MidnightsAtPeace, terrorblade, freakum., brokee, FolkLover1989, Klein, Hooker Barbie, reputation1989, badidearight, Enrique523, Solaria, TaylenaStan, Nein, fridayteenage, liam13, PaloSanto, sanzo, Theluckyone, Hurem, folkloreking, Gorjesspazze9, PerfectSacrifice, vinicius, Yog, Støned, djcalpal, tjspy, jacklovesyou1, Where are you now?, greeneyedsoul, pavi, Bartender, Don, K$Ellie, SoSickOfThatSOL, Lorenzo22, Teen Spirit

Admirers (9s): Avrileon, RihannaLoverrr, Velvet Night, Bindi, Safe&Sound, The Music Industry, LastKiss, roso, 305, jacobhalkohit, SLUTTVFTV, Sad Beautiful Tragic, Ger.vaz, holyground13, TheArgonaut, AdrianNicki, LoveInStereo, Soobin beagle, Ms. Togekiss, PoisonedIvy, 1989, Live To Tell, Arrows, chosensparkles, D-@-N, halcyonday, GuyNextDoor, modern thing, creativity., frankvert, Venice B, Ampersand13, Bussea, Strawberry Bubble, Swirl900, enchanted0, Lazuli, Blood Magic, Rev8, NewStanner, heckinglovatoFeanor, Mezik, NextBish90

Haters (1s): Losing my ground

Saboteurs (0s): Starchild

 

Comments

blown away

11 - "Top 5 in her discography. It's so good that not even the Taylor's Version could ruin it for me."

By the Water

10 - "What would 19K89 be without this song?"

Klein

10 - "This used to be one of my favorite favorite Taylor songs ever (like in the top 10, or at least 15). Since then it lost a bit of its superb in my eyes, but it is still a 10/10 any day of the week."

Forever Winter

10 - "I actually prefer the original version. Her younger vocals, the vocal mixing, the production. Top tier. Perfection. I still cannot fathom why she refuses to sing this one fully. It's always chopped up or mashed up with something. Ridiculous!!!"

wastedpotential

10 - "I vividly remember sitting in my dad's car in our driveway listening to my 1989 CD for the first time after school on that Friday, and just ascending to this song. This remains, to this very day, my favorite Taylor music video, for a million reasons, of which I shall list a few: It's visually stunning and cinematic (I'm a sucker for 50s aesthetica and old Hollywood), the story is giving (and considering the tea about this song, it's probably the video that most closely resembles the song in question), Scott Eastwood is one of the hottest men on the planet (I know the girls fawn over Sean O'Pry, but Scott Eastwood is more attractive, I'm sorry), and it plays the extended radio edit, which is self explanatory. Her having a one-night stand with Alexander Skarsgard while filming The Giver (which... I loved the book but the producers butchered the entire concept for the movie, the romance should've been burned) in South Africa... that was fandom history. The night the paparazzi pictures from them in that restaurant in Cape Town were published was a similar experience for me to the night the Taylor And Tom Kick Rocks photos came out. Now, the song itself is also God-tier, I don't make the rules. Call it the Lana influence or the Taylor Discovers What Sex Is phenomenon, but the sensuality, delicateness, and earnestness of this song will go down in history. The only songs she's made that match that energy are Dress and False God, but there was NOTHING like it before. Listening to this hymn makes me feel like I also went off to Africa to shoot a movie and had a fling with a co-star I knew wouldn't ever last, but by God did we have fun while it was happening. The bridge is career defining and builds perfectly, and is something I considered getting tattooed at one point. I could go line by line through the entire song, but that's too much, even for me and my rambling essays. This song is so good y'all *bursts into tears*."

Where are you now?

10 - "A completely perfect pop song. The best 5th single of all time? Stunning music video visuals. Radio single remix with the added drums/echo effects is radiant. GORGEOUS chorus ad libs."

Lorenzo22

10 - "The Eras Tour performance is so underrated, the added percussions on the repeated bridge make me wanna nut ngl."

NewStanner

9 - "Would've been 10, but the similarities with Lana's Without You are too blatant to ignore."

greento

8.6 - "Seeing this live at the Eras Tour changed my life. Really enhanced my enjoyment of the song, the way she repeats the bridge as the drums build up..."

MusicLoverDude

8 - "The mix used in the music video should have been the main mix."

Achilles.

8 - "I love when Taylor Swift mimics other people's styles because she always does it so well that she renders the artists she's ripping off obsolete."

f85db52a6207df5d0066c404535bdf01.jpg

 

#iykyk

  • Like 1
  • Haha 3
Posted

Yeah, I actually like WD, however, it didn't deserve this high placement.

Posted

Cruel Summer...

spacer.png

  • Like 1
  • Haha 2
Posted

Me coming back to this thread and seeing that my two favorite songs are out….

 

tis the damn season there will never be a more detailed story in a song than u

Posted

Oh Wisest Deities, you were once my stan song, but my tastes have evolved and you're merely another of my 10s now. I'm glad to see you shine and thrive, though I wish you'd cleared Mr. Clean's ass for a slot in the top 10. Go with grace. 

 

htgwm-vila-davis.gif

  • Haha 1
Posted

So, which songs are in the top 12?

 

You Belong With Me

Enchanted

State Of Grace

All Too Well

Blank Space

Style

Wildest Dreams

Clean

Getaway Car

Cruel Summer

Cardigan

August

 

Is that correct? I didn't follow all the reveals

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 2
Posted

Not my favourite 1989 that was left being eliminated

 

 :clack:

Posted

EVERQUEEF OUT OF THE TOP 10 YUUUUUPPPP

 

spacer.png

  • Haha 2
  • Confused 2
  • Thumbs Down 1
Posted
2 minutes ago, Klein said:

I mean, not even you, thee ultimate Puta stan, can deny that Getaway Car is an OOTW rip off. :suburban:

Which makes Cruel Summer a double extra ripoff :khalyan:

  • Like 1
  • Haha 3
Posted
1 minute ago, Forever Winter said:

Screen_Shot_2015-08-30_at_9.06.15_PM.0.0

 

12. Wildest Dreams

8.773

 

Saviours (11s): Quicksand, blown away, twoheadlightshine, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, Fitzswiftie, DevilsRollTheDice

Stans (10s): byzantium, By the Water, idkwiam, wastedpotential, Tusk, AbeHicks, Forever Winter, burninredhot, Bosque, My Tears Ricochet, Kyle-x, ONOPKA, Holy Ground, Miles., CamiloPg_, Dear Reader, a_d_22, Namigo, llikeh, MidnightsAtPeace, terrorblade, freakum., brokee, FolkLover1989, Klein, Hooker Barbie, reputation1989, badidearight, Enrique523, Solaria, TaylenaStan, Nein, fridayteenage, liam13, PaloSanto, sanzo, Theluckyone, Hurem, folkloreking, Gorjesspazze9, PerfectSacrifice, vinicius, Yog, Støned, djcalpal, tjspy, jacklovesyou1, Where are you now?, greeneyedsoul, pavi, Bartender, Don, K$Ellie, SoSickOfThatSOL, Lorenzo22, Teen Spirit

Admirers (9s): Avrileon, RihannaLoverrr, Velvet Night, Bindi, Safe&Sound, The Music Industry, LastKiss, roso, 305, jacobhalkohit, SLUTTVFTV, Sad Beautiful Tragic, Ger.vaz, holyground13, TheArgonaut, AdrianNicki, LoveInStereo, Soobin beagle, Ms. Togekiss, PoisonedIvy, 1989, Live To Tell, Arrows, chosensparkles, D-@-N, halcyonday, GuyNextDoor, modern thing, creativity., frankvert, Venice B, Ampersand13, Bussea, Strawberry Bubble, Swirl900, enchanted0, Lazuli, Blood Magic, Rev8, NewStanner, heckinglovatoFeanor, Mezik, NextBish90

Haters (1s): Losing my ground

Saboteurs (0s): Starchild

 

Comments

blown away

11 - "Top 5 in her discography. It's so good that not even the Taylor's Version could ruin it for me."

By the Water

10 - "What would 19K89 be without this song?"

Klein

10 - "This used to be one of my favorite favorite Taylor songs ever (like in the top 10, or at least 15). Since then it lost a bit of its superb in my eyes, but it is still a 10/10 any day of the week."

Forever Winter

10 - "I actually prefer the original version. Her younger vocals, the vocal mixing, the production. Top tier. Perfection. I still cannot fathom why she refuses to sing this one fully. It's always chopped up or mashed up with something. Ridiculous!!!"

wastedpotential

10 - "I vividly remember sitting in my dad's car in our driveway listening to my 1989 CD for the first time after school on that Friday, and just ascending to this song. This remains, to this very day, my favorite Taylor music video, for a million reasons, of which I shall list a few: It's visually stunning and cinematic (I'm a sucker for 50s aesthetica and old Hollywood), the story is giving (and considering the tea about this song, it's probably the video that most closely resembles the song in question), Scott Eastwood is one of the hottest men on the planet (I know the girls fawn over Sean O'Pry, but Scott Eastwood is more attractive, I'm sorry), and it plays the extended radio edit, which is self explanatory. Her having a one-night stand with Alexander Skarsgard while filming The Giver (which... I loved the book but the producers butchered the entire concept for the movie, the romance should've been burned) in South Africa... that was fandom history. The night the paparazzi pictures from them in that restaurant in Cape Town were published was a similar experience for me to the night the Taylor And Tom Kick Rocks photos came out. Now, the song itself is also God-tier, I don't make the rules. Call it the Lana influence or the Taylor Discovers What Sex Is phenomenon, but the sensuality, delicateness, and earnestness of this song will go down in history. The only songs she's made that match that energy are Dress and False God, but there was NOTHING like it before. Listening to this hymn makes me feel like I also went off to Africa to shoot a movie and had a fling with a co-star I knew wouldn't ever last, but by God did we have fun while it was happening. The bridge is career defining and builds perfectly, and is something I considered getting tattooed at one point. I could go line by line through the entire song, but that's too much, even for me and my rambling essays. This song is so good y'all *bursts into tears*."

Where are you now?

10 - "A completely perfect pop song. The best 5th single of all time? Stunning music video visuals. Radio single remix with the added drums/echo effects is radiant. GORGEOUS chorus ad libs."

Lorenzo22

10 - "The Eras Tour performance is so underrated, the added percussions on the repeated bridge make me wanna nut ngl."

NewStanner

9 - "Would've been 10, but the similarities with Lana's Without You are too blatant to ignore."

greento

8.6 - "Seeing this live at the Eras Tour changed my life. Really enhanced my enjoyment of the song, the way she repeats the bridge as the drums build up..."

MusicLoverDude

8 - "The mix used in the music video should have been the main mix."

Achilles.

8 - "I love when Taylor Swift mimics other people's styles because she always does it so well that she renders the artists she's ripping off obsolete."

From 4Real's lips to God's ears yup yup

 

we-love.gif

Posted

Blank Space is so overrated... there.. i said it!

Posted
3 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

Which TTPD songs would you have placed in the top 25?

Personally:

Top 3: WAOLOM

Top 10: The Black Dog

Top 15: The Prophecy, How Did It End

Top 20: GAS

 

Which ones did I realistically think had a shot at being top 25:

GAS, BDILH, The Prophecy, The Black Dog, How Did It End, LOML, TSMWEL

 

I was so wrong :toofunny3:

  • Like 4
Posted

Wildest Dreams radio/video version *chef's kiss*

  • Like 3
Posted

wildest dreams radio edit never being on streaming.........a nightmare LITERALLY a f**king nightmare. i need it so bad too for my local files like 😭

  • Like 3
Posted

Poor Wildest Dreams but the competition is too stiff.

Posted
3 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

Haters (1s): Losing my ground

Saboteurs (0s): Starchild

azealia-banks-liviecult.gif

  • Haha 1
Posted (edited)
4 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

Screen_Shot_2015-08-30_at_9.06.15_PM.0.0

 

12. Wildest Dreams

8.773

 

Saviours (11s): Quicksand, blown away, twoheadlightshine, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, Fitzswiftie, DevilsRollTheDice

Stans (10s): byzantium, By the Water, idkwiam, wastedpotential, Tusk, AbeHicks, Forever Winter, burninredhot, Bosque, My Tears Ricochet, Kyle-x, ONOPKA, Holy Ground, Miles., CamiloPg_, Dear Reader, a_d_22, Namigo, llikeh, MidnightsAtPeace, terrorblade, freakum., brokee, FolkLover1989, Klein, Hooker Barbie, reputation1989, badidearight, Enrique523, Solaria, TaylenaStan, Nein, fridayteenage, liam13, PaloSanto, sanzo, Theluckyone, Hurem, folkloreking, Gorjesspazze9, PerfectSacrifice, vinicius, Yog, Støned, djcalpal, tjspy, jacklovesyou1, Where are you now?, greeneyedsoul, pavi, Bartender, Don, K$Ellie, SoSickOfThatSOL, Lorenzo22, Teen Spirit

Admirers (9s): Avrileon, RihannaLoverrr, Velvet Night, Bindi, Safe&Sound, The Music Industry, LastKiss, roso, 305, jacobhalkohit, SLUTTVFTV, Sad Beautiful Tragic, Ger.vaz, holyground13, TheArgonaut, AdrianNicki, LoveInStereo, Soobin beagle, Ms. Togekiss, PoisonedIvy, 1989, Live To Tell, Arrows, chosensparkles, D-@-N, halcyonday, GuyNextDoor, modern thing, creativity., frankvert, Venice B, Ampersand13, Bussea, Strawberry Bubble, Swirl900, enchanted0, Lazuli, Blood Magic, Rev8, NewStanner, heckinglovatoFeanor, Mezik, NextBish90

Haters (1s): Losing my ground

Saboteurs (0s): Starchild

 

Comments

blown away

11 - "Top 5 in her discography. It's so good that not even the Taylor's Version could ruin it for me."

By the Water

10 - "What would 19K89 be without this song?"

Klein

10 - "This used to be one of my favorite favorite Taylor songs ever (like in the top 10, or at least 15). Since then it lost a bit of its superb in my eyes, but it is still a 10/10 any day of the week."

Forever Winter

10 - "I actually prefer the original version. Her younger vocals, the vocal mixing, the production. Top tier. Perfection. I still cannot fathom why she refuses to sing this one fully. It's always chopped up or mashed up with something. Ridiculous!!!"

wastedpotential

10 - "I vividly remember sitting in my dad's car in our driveway listening to my 1989 CD for the first time after school on that Friday, and just ascending to this song. This remains, to this very day, my favorite Taylor music video, for a million reasons, of which I shall list a few: It's visually stunning and cinematic (I'm a sucker for 50s aesthetica and old Hollywood), the story is giving (and considering the tea about this song, it's probably the video that most closely resembles the song in question), Scott Eastwood is one of the hottest men on the planet (I know the girls fawn over Sean O'Pry, but Scott Eastwood is more attractive, I'm sorry), and it plays the extended radio edit, which is self explanatory. Her having a one-night stand with Alexander Skarsgard while filming The Giver (which... I loved the book but the producers butchered the entire concept for the movie, the romance should've been burned) in South Africa... that was fandom history. The night the paparazzi pictures from them in that restaurant in Cape Town were published was a similar experience for me to the night the Taylor And Tom Kick Rocks photos came out. Now, the song itself is also God-tier, I don't make the rules. Call it the Lana influence or the Taylor Discovers What Sex Is phenomenon, but the sensuality, delicateness, and earnestness of this song will go down in history. The only songs she's made that match that energy are Dress and False God, but there was NOTHING like it before. Listening to this hymn makes me feel like I also went off to Africa to shoot a movie and had a fling with a co-star I knew wouldn't ever last, but by God did we have fun while it was happening. The bridge is career defining and builds perfectly, and is something I considered getting tattooed at one point. I could go line by line through the entire song, but that's too much, even for me and my rambling essays. This song is so good y'all *bursts into tears*."

Where are you now?

10 - "A completely perfect pop song. The best 5th single of all time? Stunning music video visuals. Radio single remix with the added drums/echo effects is radiant. GORGEOUS chorus ad libs."

Lorenzo22

10 - "The Eras Tour performance is so underrated, the added percussions on the repeated bridge make me wanna nut ngl."

NewStanner

9 - "Would've been 10, but the similarities with Lana's Without You are too blatant to ignore."

greento

8.6 - "Seeing this live at the Eras Tour changed my life. Really enhanced my enjoyment of the song, the way she repeats the bridge as the drums build up..."

MusicLoverDude

8 - "The mix used in the music video should have been the main mix."

Achilles.

8 - "I love when Taylor Swift mimics other people's styles because she always does it so well that she renders the artists she's ripping off obsolete."

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, I was so sure it'd end up in the top 10

 

spacer.png

 

How are Corona Summer and Getaway Shart above this

Edited by G.U.Y_Del_Rey
Posted (edited)
3 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

12. Wildest Dreams

8.773

Decent placement. Not bad for the 'Without You' rip off song. Still my favorite from the album tho.

Edited by Støned
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.