Brooklyn Baby Posted September 7 Author Posted September 7 36. Dear John 8.317 Saviours (11s): SLUTTVFTV, freakum., Axolotl, twoheadlightshine, blown away Stans (10s): Fitzswiftie, Feanor, byzantium, burninredhot, TaylenaStan, Dear Reader, Strawberry Bubble, wehavetostan, Achilles., Cruel Summer, Forever Winter, 1989, TMRA, Blood Magic, Bartender, Taylor fanboy, PoisonedIvy, jacklovesyou1, Kyle-x, Diarrhoea, SleepingTigers, Heldenzeit, Clauss, Klein, Starchild, MusicLoverDude, ellis-bell, paulyyyozd, Holy Ground, fridayteenage, americanlife, Prismee, GuyNextDoor, LVP, Great Username, Gorjesspazze9, badidearight, Vespertine, folkloreking, itsjem, Arrows, Namigo, a_d_22, 4Real, MidnightsAtPeace, DevilsRollTheDice, SylMacPer, PaloSanto Admirers (9s): TheArgonaut, LastKiss, idkwiam, Safe&Sound, Theluckyone, holyground13, SoSickOfThatSOL, wastedpotential, Soobin, tb6591, Life Savers, chosensparkles, D-@-N, Velvet Night, Enrique523, iamanearthling, Ampersand13, Tedwards, Supernatural, Nein, RihannaLoverrr, My Tears Ricochet, enchanted0 pavi, sparrowblue, K$Ellie, LoveInStereo, Lorenzo22 Haters (1s): KillingYourCareer, Quicksand, NextBish90 Saboteurs (0s): None Comments blown away 11 - "The emotion, the scathing lyrics, the drama. Everything about this song is great." Achilles. 10 - "You can pinpoint the exact timestamp in this song where Taylor Swift stopped being a teen prodigy and became a definitive generational talent with the potential (now realized!) of building a career of truly historic proportions." greento 10 - "Incredibly well written song, especially for her age. One of the first songs that made me understand her hype." 1989 10 - "A lyrical masterpiece. One of the best takedowns ever recorded." Forever Winter 10 - "This is how you write a six-minute song. TTPD Taylor, take notes." wastedpotential 9.4 - "I really think this is one of Lord's most technically perfect hymns. The only reason I'm not giving this a 10 is because I know y'all have this one covered. I feel like this song is the Alexander the Great of Lord's discography, it came, it saw, and it ******* conquered. It's nearly seven minutes with multiple guitar solos and some insane vocal runs, and never once does it let its heel up from John Mayo's neck. I hope Her stiletto shattered his trachea and left his worthless loser ass gasping for breath. Technically, I can talk about the layering or the building or the instrumentation or the fact that this was Nathan Chapman's only non-consensual duet that I think works as intended, or the perfection of the multiple stacked lyrical metaphors, plus the meta moment at the end, but y'all already know how substantively perfect this hymn is, and I'm not going to worry about proselytizing this one. Y'all get it." sparrowblue 9 - "The draggings on the bridge just keep going and going." Nein 9 - "SCALP HA AGAIN!" Edge of Glory 8.5 - "I hate that she has to be the bigger person cause imo she should've been allowed to put john mayer in one of those medieval torture machines where ur limbs get tied to the four corners of a platform and slowly stretched apart for what he did on national television I fear." Bussea 8 - "Another magnificent bridge." Bosque 7 - "Good song but points deducted for putting "John" in the title of a song about John Mayer." Where are you now? 4.8 - "Respect her songwriting and lyricism here but idk, have never been into the bluesy style, not crazy about the melodies, and can't not think about John Mayer." Reveal, Part 6 Results (So Far) Spoiler 50. Don't Blame Me - 8.127 49. Maroon - 8.129 48. willow - 8.138 47. Anti-Hero - 8.179 46. Cornelia Street - 8.181 45. Safe & Sound (feat. The Civil Wars) - 8.189 44. ...Ready for It? - 8.203 43. the 1 - 8.205 42. ivy - 8.206 41. cowboy like me - 8.210 40. seven - 8.220 39. Holy Ground - 8.268 38. Mine - 8.294 37. illicit affairs - 8.303 36. Dear John - 8.317 1
Bosque Posted September 7 Posted September 7 (edited) Oh I didn't realize this one would be... so highly rated As long as mirrorball is still in Edited September 7 by Bosque
ONOPKA Posted September 7 Posted September 7 Just now, Forever Winter said: blown away 11 - "The emotion, the scathing lyrics, the drama. Everything about this song is great." i'm shook miss blown away gave any song an 11 5
gagacasanova Posted September 7 Posted September 7 Honestly thought that would have made the top twenty.
swifthino Posted September 7 Posted September 7 4 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Choose your fighter: Dear John mirrorball Guilty as Sin? NO NOT MIRRORBALL
folkloreking Posted September 7 Posted September 7 1 minute ago, Forever Winter said: 36. Dear John 8.317 Saviours (11s): SLUTTVFTV, freakum., Axolotl, twoheadlightshine, blown away Stans (10s): Fitzswiftie, Feanor, byzantium, burninredhot, TaylenaStan, Dear Reader, Strawberry Bubble, wehavetostan, Achilles., Cruel Summer, Forever Winter, 1989, TMRA, Blood Magic, Bartender, Taylor fanboy, PoisonedIvy, jacklovesyou1, Kyle-x, Diarrhoea, SleepingTigers, Heldenzeit, Clauss, Klein, Starchild, MusicLoverDude, ellis-bell, paulyyyozd, Holy Ground, fridayteenage, americanlife, Prismee, GuyNextDoor, LVP, Great Username, Gorjesspazze9, badidearight, Vespertine, folkloreking, itsjem, Arrows, Namigo, a_d_22, 4Real, MidnightsAtPeace, DevilsRollTheDice, SylMacPer, PaloSanto Admirers (9s): TheArgonaut, LastKiss, idkwiam, Safe&Sound, Theluckyone, holyground13, SoSickOfThatSOL, wastedpotential, Soobin, tb6591, Life Savers, chosensparkles, D-@-N, Velvet Night, Enrique523, iamanearthling, Ampersand13, Tedwards, Supernatural, Nein, RihannaLoverrr, My Tears Ricochet, enchanted0 pavi, sparrowblue, K$Ellie, LoveInStereo, Lorenzo22 Haters (1s): KillingYourCareer, Quicksand, NextBish90 Saboteurs (0s): None Comments blown away 11 - "The emotion, the scathing lyrics, the drama. Everything about this song is great." Achilles. 10 - "You can pinpoint the exact timestamp in this song where Taylor Swift stopped being a teen prodigy and became a definitive generational talent with the potential (now realized!) of building a career of truly historic proportions." greento 10 - "Incredibly well written song, especially for her age. One of the first songs that made me understand her hype." 1989 10 - "A lyrical masterpiece. One of the best takedowns ever recorded." Forever Winter 10 - "This is how you write a six-minute song. TTPD Taylor, take notes." wastedpotential 9.4 - "I really think this is one of Lord's most technically perfect hymns. The only reason I'm not giving this a 10 is because I know y'all have this one covered. I feel like this song is the Alexander the Great of Lord's discography, it came, it saw, and it ******* conquered. It's nearly seven minutes with multiple guitar solos and some insane vocal runs, and never once does it let its heel up from John Mayo's neck. I hope Her stiletto shattered his trachea and left his worthless loser ass gasping for breath. Technically, I can talk about the layering or the building or the instrumentation or the fact that this was Nathan Chapman's only non-consensual duet that I think works as intended, or the perfection of the multiple stacked lyrical metaphors, plus the meta moment at the end, but y'all already know how substantively perfect this hymn is, and I'm not going to worry about proselytizing this one. Y'all get it." sparrowblue 9 - "The draggings on the bridge just keep going and going." Nein 9 - "SCALP HA AGAIN!" Edge of Glory 8.5 - "I hate that she has to be the bigger person cause imo she should've been allowed to put john mayer in one of those medieval torture machines where ur limbs get tied to the four corners of a platform and slowly stretched apart for what he did on national television I fear." Bussea 8 - "Another magnificent bridge." Bosque 7 - "Good song but points deducted for putting "John" in the title of a song about John Mayer." Where are you now? 4.8 - "Respect her songwriting and lyricism here but idk, have never been into the bluesy style, not crazy about the melodies, and can't not think about John Mayer." Reveal, Part 6 Results (So Far) Hide contents 50. Don't Blame Me - 8.127 49. Maroon - 8.129 48. willow - 8.138 47. Anti-Hero - 8.179 46. Cornelia Street - 8.181 45. Safe & Sound (feat. The Civil Wars) - 8.189 44. ...Ready for It? - 8.203 43. the 1 - 8.205 42. ivy - 8.206 41. cowboy like me - 8.210 40. seven - 8.220 39. Holy Ground - 8.268 38. Mine - 8.294 37. illicit affairs - 8.303 36. Dear John - 8.317 Guilty As Overrated I really do love you but GIRL. There would be no Allah Too Well without Dear Lord.
Bosque Posted September 7 Posted September 7 The delayed posts way after the reveal has already happened are killing me 1
holyground13 Posted September 7 Posted September 7 5 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Choose your fighter: Dear John mirrorball Guilty as Sin? Can we lose none of them please? If I had to I'd ask Dear John even though it's an ANTHEM
Cruel Summer Posted September 7 Posted September 7 Dear John barely top forty I mean I guess it's not too much worse than last year but it's definitely one of those songs I expect the fanbase to send top ten 1
wastedpotential Posted September 7 Posted September 7 Tried to find a gif of John Mayer getting... bloodied, but alas, such does not exist 1 1
TaylenaStan Posted September 7 Posted September 7 (edited) Haters (1s): KillingYourCareer, Quicksand, NextBish90 HOW DO YOU GIVE THIS A 1 Edited September 7 by TaylenaStan 3 5
holyground13 Posted September 7 Posted September 7 @Forever Winter taking a shameless swing at TTPD in that comment 2
Michael196 Posted September 7 Posted September 7 Two of my 11s getting punched back to back outside the top 30 is appalling, I can't ******* imagine what would've happened if she didn't put it on the setlist and everyone finally latched to the train after disliking since day one. illicit is a masterpiece and easily top 5 in her discography, I have no words... 2
frankvert Posted September 7 Posted September 7 GAS LEAK, WELCOME TO YOUR TAPE. YOUVE OVERSTAYED BY 100+ SPOTS 2 1
Cruel Summer Posted September 7 Posted September 7 Lmao wait this means one of my elevens went at least +23 or something this year, maybe more - maybe we do stan this messy rate 1
ATRL Moderator wehavetostan Posted September 7 ATRL Moderator Posted September 7 5 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: 36. Dear John 8.317 Saviours (11s): SLUTTVFTV, freakum., Axolotl, twoheadlightshine, blown away Stans (10s): Fitzswiftie, Feanor, byzantium, burninredhot, TaylenaStan, Dear Reader, Strawberry Bubble, wehavetostan, Achilles., Cruel Summer, Forever Winter, 1989, TMRA, Blood Magic, Bartender, Taylor fanboy, PoisonedIvy, jacklovesyou1, Kyle-x, Diarrhoea, SleepingTigers, Heldenzeit, Clauss, Klein, Starchild, MusicLoverDude, ellis-bell, paulyyyozd, Holy Ground, fridayteenage, americanlife, Prismee, GuyNextDoor, LVP, Great Username, Gorjesspazze9, badidearight, Vespertine, folkloreking, itsjem, Arrows, Namigo, a_d_22, 4Real, MidnightsAtPeace, DevilsRollTheDice, SylMacPer, PaloSanto Admirers (9s): TheArgonaut, LastKiss, idkwiam, Safe&Sound, Theluckyone, holyground13, SoSickOfThatSOL, wastedpotential, Soobin, tb6591, Life Savers, chosensparkles, D-@-N, Velvet Night, Enrique523, iamanearthling, Ampersand13, Tedwards, Supernatural, Nein, RihannaLoverrr, My Tears Ricochet, enchanted0 pavi, sparrowblue, K$Ellie, LoveInStereo, Lorenzo22 Haters (1s): KillingYourCareer, Quicksand, NextBish90 Saboteurs (0s): None Comments blown away 11 - "The emotion, the scathing lyrics, the drama. Everything about this song is great." Achilles. 10 - "You can pinpoint the exact timestamp in this song where Taylor Swift stopped being a teen prodigy and became a definitive generational talent with the potential (now realized!) of building a career of truly historic proportions." greento 10 - "Incredibly well written song, especially for her age. One of the first songs that made me understand her hype." 1989 10 - "A lyrical masterpiece. One of the best takedowns ever recorded." Forever Winter 10 - "This is how you write a six-minute song. TTPD Taylor, take notes." wastedpotential 9.4 - "I really think this is one of Lord's most technically perfect hymns. The only reason I'm not giving this a 10 is because I know y'all have this one covered. I feel like this song is the Alexander the Great of Lord's discography, it came, it saw, and it ******* conquered. It's nearly seven minutes with multiple guitar solos and some insane vocal runs, and never once does it let its heel up from John Mayo's neck. I hope Her stiletto shattered his trachea and left his worthless loser ass gasping for breath. Technically, I can talk about the layering or the building or the instrumentation or the fact that this was Nathan Chapman's only non-consensual duet that I think works as intended, or the perfection of the multiple stacked lyrical metaphors, plus the meta moment at the end, but y'all already know how substantively perfect this hymn is, and I'm not going to worry about proselytizing this one. Y'all get it." sparrowblue 9 - "The draggings on the bridge just keep going and going." Nein 9 - "SCALP HA AGAIN!" Edge of Glory 8.5 - "I hate that she has to be the bigger person cause imo she should've been allowed to put john mayer in one of those medieval torture machines where ur limbs get tied to the four corners of a platform and slowly stretched apart for what he did on national television I fear." Bussea 8 - "Another magnificent bridge." Bosque 7 - "Good song but points deducted for putting "John" in the title of a song about John Mayer." Where are you now? 4.8 - "Respect her songwriting and lyricism here but idk, have never been into the bluesy style, not crazy about the melodies, and can't not think about John Mayer." Reveal, Part 6 Results (So Far) Reveal hidden contents 50. Don't Blame Me - 8.127 49. Maroon - 8.129 48. willow - 8.138 47. Anti-Hero - 8.179 46. Cornelia Street - 8.181 45. Safe & Sound (feat. The Civil Wars) - 8.189 44. ...Ready for It? - 8.203 43. the 1 - 8.205 42. ivy - 8.206 41. cowboy like me - 8.210 40. seven - 8.220 39. Holy Ground - 8.268 38. Mine - 8.294 37. illicit affairs - 8.303 36. Dear John - 8.317 This is top 10… what are y’all doing 2 1
4Real Posted September 7 Posted September 7 Stinky as Fart being somehow decent compared to the rest of ttpd really made yall think it's some masterpiece
gagacasanova Posted September 7 Posted September 7 Just now, 4Real said: Stinky as Fart being somehow decent compared to the rest of ttpd really made yall think it's some masterpiece Bc it is 2 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 7 Author Posted September 7 35. Long Live 8.317 Saviours (11s): 1989, Heldenzeit, beagle, jacobhalkohit, SylMacPer Stans (10s): Gorjesspazze9, Holy Ground, Dear Reader, holyground13, wehavetostan, Lorenzo22, Achilles., Forever Winter, Top Dash, K$Ellie, Don, Sanguine, Blood Magic, Bartender, Taylor fanboy, pavi, greeneyedsoul, chiliam, Kyle-x, Safe&Sound, Hooker Barbie, Klein, FolkLover1989, paulyyyozd, Ger.vaz, americanlife, Miles., idkwiam, Prismee, PerfectSacrifice, iamanearthling, Enrique523, D-@-N, chosensparkles, Arrows, a_d_22, MidnightsAtPeace, sanzo, NEX, DevilsRollTheDice, NordicGuy, PaloSanto, MusicLoverDude Admirers (9s): reputation1989, PoisonedIvy, SLUTTVFTV, LastKiss, Peroxide, 4Real, Soobin, folkloreking, freakum., badidearight, TaylenaStan, Kyungsoowift, Diarrhoea, My Tears Ricochet, enchanted0, Avrileon, Lazuli, roso, tb6591, The Music Industry, itsjem, Life Savers, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, Mezik, Supernatural, fridayteenage, RihannaLoverrr, ellis-bell, BOAZ, twoheadlightshine, byzantium, AdrianNicki, Ms. Togekiss Haters (1s): jacklovesyou1 Saboteurs (0s): Where are you now? Comments 1989 11 - "Top Ten in her discography. We need to bully her into putting it back on the setlist for the last leg of Eras." Forever Winter 10 - "I love this song so much. I went to two Eras Tour shows and I teared up both times during this song...the entire Speak Now set in fact. Enchanted also got me in my feels." Miles. 10 - "This is so beautiful. I had the time of my life fighting dragons with you is a top 3 line in her discography. Spine-tingling, tear-inducing, bone-chilling nostalgia. :heart:" pavi 10 - "Crying screaming throwing up, so mad she cut this from the setlist and I didn't get to experience it live." Achilles. 10 - "I still remember reading a Speak Now review in 2010 where this was described as a song written about graduating high school and that was when I realized that all critics are stupid and refuse to engage in anything deeper than the shallowest reading of an artist's work… but this also came out my senior year of high school and I wrote "long live" on the underside of my graduation cap so……" Lorenzo22 10 - "Swifties may be fat, ugly and unattractive but that's okay because we got the best song ever." wastedpotential 8.3 - "This one does choke me up, I cannot lie. I really am Her *****. I'm but a humble servant, and She was so benevolent and kind to bless me, to bless us, with a hymn about Her adoration for us. Swifties, times may be hard, times may get harder, but we are so loved. I feel so loved when I hear this song. Swifties, I was so saddened when this was cut from the Eras setlist. I was sad for the future attendees of the tour who would never get to hear it live (except for the blessed souls at Lisbon N2 and London N7), but moreso I was sad for me, because I'd lost the privelidge of hearing it on every livestream I watched. How sad was that, Swifties? I know the stans of the other girls fume in the knowledge that their fave doesn't love them as much as Lord loves us." sparrowblue 8 - "Funny this now feels like a ripped jeans era type of song." Edge of Glory 8 - "Her adding it to the eras setlist AND removing it before my date is nasty work." blown away 8 - "Great song, beautiful song. Sounds like an anthem." pinkbowvintage 7 - "Another Swiftie fave I enjoy but it never got me as excited." Bussea 7 - "The bridge and final chorus? *chefs kiss*" Where are you now? 0 - "Blah. I feel like I'm not a real Swiftie for not loving this song. The genre, melody, chord progression and subject do nothing for me. :(" Reveal, Part 6 Results (So Far) Spoiler 50. Don't Blame Me - 8.127 49. Maroon - 8.129 48. willow - 8.138 47. Anti-Hero - 8.179 46. Cornelia Street - 8.181 45. Safe & Sound (feat. The Civil Wars) - 8.189 44. ...Ready for It? - 8.203 43. the 1 - 8.205 42. ivy - 8.206 41. cowboy like me - 8.210 40. seven - 8.220 39. Holy Ground - 8.268 38. Mine - 8.294 37. illicit affairs - 8.303 36. Dear John - 8.303 35. Long Live - 8.317
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 7 Author Posted September 7 35 is fair for Long Live imo. This is where I have it too
holyground13 Posted September 7 Posted September 7 Just now, frankvert said: NOT LONG LIVE MTE. where on earth is the TASTE? I needed more 11s, clearly - poor Speak Now
Recommended Posts