Dear Reader Posted August 27 Posted August 27 6 minutes ago, wastedpotential said: We'd bully @Forever Winter into making the ballots public and then make some problems disappear Reveal hidden contents Still mad at you for the SBT thing but if you start hiding bodies with me for evermore then it's all forgiven Spoiler noooo no body, no crime 3
wastedpotential Posted August 27 Posted August 27 2 minutes ago, PoisonedIvy said: Did anyone else give "That's When" a 0? It is literally one of the worst songs in her catalogue to me It's nice having a definitive ranking/scoresheet of her songs & albums (even though it would literally change next month if I were to re-do this) Not you randomly lashing one of the two okay songs in the Flawless vault when there are so many better, easier targets in there 1
PoisonedIvy Posted August 27 Posted August 27 Just now, wastedpotential said: Not you randomly lashing one of the two okay songs in the Flawless vault when there are so many better, easier targets in there Don't You & BBB get behind me! 1 1
Dear Reader Posted August 27 Posted August 27 Fearless vault is not as bad as y'all make it to be 2 1
wastedpotential Posted August 27 Posted August 27 4 minutes ago, PoisonedIvy said: Don't You & BBB get behind me! Well yes, Bible Baby is the other above average song to be found I was a rider for Don't You for a while but now it's kinda the prime evidence for the OJAH comments. I'd go down on my knees for Jack in a heartbeat, but he kinda ruined the production All that's to say, the real enemy is fuckass You All Over Me
wastedpotential Posted August 27 Posted August 27 4 minutes ago, Dear Reader said: Fearless vault is not as bad as y'all make it to be It's the same thing I have to say about Reputation or Lover, it's not that they're bad albums, it's that Taylor has made 9 better ones The Fearless vault is perfectly listenable (mostly), but why would I listen to any of those songs when I could be enjoying the majority of the Red vault, blasting most of the 1989 vault, and worshipping the back half of the Speak Now vault 1
Dear Reader Posted August 27 Posted August 27 3 minutes ago, wastedpotential said: It's the same thing I have to say about Reputation or Lover, it's not that they're bad albums, it's that Taylor has made 9 better ones The Fearless vault is perfectly listenable (mostly), but why would I listen to any of those songs when I could be enjoying the majority of the Red vault, blasting most of the 1989 vault, and worshipping the back half of the Speak Now vault Speak Now vault is the weakest 1
greento Posted August 27 Posted August 27 5 minutes ago, wastedpotential said: All that's to say, the real enemy is fuckass You All Over Me Not when it's the best Fearless vault 1
1989 Posted August 27 Posted August 27 4 hours ago, Klein said: On another note, some of my 11s are clearly out there trying to save some of these songs from the limbo of her discography because I know y'all are tasteless. Oh I already know that one of my 11s is in vain, but I can't not do it. I mean, the song isn't hated by any means, but it's Top 10 in her discography for me (more realistically like Top 7), but the way ATRL's taste skews I just hope it'll make like Top 50. 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 2 minutes ago, Dear Reader said: Speak Now vault is the weakest You just made that up!
Dear Reader Posted August 27 Posted August 27 Just now, Forever Winter said: You just made that up! I mean, Goddish One and Prayness are great girls, the others… 1
Dear Reader Posted August 27 Posted August 27 Just now, Forever Winter said: Vault Ranking: Speak Now Red 1989 Fearless You just made that up! 2
wastedpotential Posted August 27 Posted August 27 2 minutes ago, Dear Reader said: Speak Now vault is the weakest You're getting put on ignore Sure Electric Toothbrush is meh melodically and When Emma Covers Drops of Jupiter is like 15 years too late, but Christ Is Coming, Fortunate One, and Timeless are like THE three best vault tracks*, and I Can See You has a PHD in cunty string-based bottom-line melodies from the YNTCD university *alongside other highlights like Better Man, Forever Winter, The Very First Night, and Is It Over Now? 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 1 minute ago, Dear Reader said: I mean, Goddish One and Prayness are great girls, the others… I Can See God, Godstles Crumbling, When God Falls in Love, and Electric God are all great songs 2
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 The vault yall should be dragging is 1989, with those horrible songs (Ntwdt and SL) 1 1
Dear Reader Posted August 27 Posted August 27 (edited) 6 minutes ago, wastedpotential said: You're getting put on ignore I'd like to see you try, who's making you laugh after that? Maybe the lame attempts from THOTS Edited August 27 by Dear Reader 1
wastedpotential Posted August 27 Posted August 27 3 minutes ago, Dear Reader said: I'd like to see you try, who's making you laugh after that? Maybe the lane attempts from THOTS I'll have you know I make myself laugh (I've spent an unhealthy amount of time looking back at my funniest comments here nnnnn), and for the moments when I'm too serious and need some assistance, I can run to Kleinstie for help, or just go watch y'all (not you though obviously) go lash the THOTS gifs intended to accompany this message: 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 1 minute ago, Catch22 said: Sent! Received. Thanks! Remember you have up until the deadline to edit your scores or add comments.
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 1 hour ago, 1989 said: Vault Ranking: 1989 = Speak Now Fearless Red Fearless above Red vault?
1989 Posted August 27 Posted August 27 (edited) 12 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Fearless above Red vault? We Were Happy and That's When are boring af, but there's nothing as bad on the Fearless vault as Message In A Butthole or Run Also I genuinely stan Mr. Perfectly Fine and Don't You Edited August 27 by 1989
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 10 minutes ago, 1989 said: We Were Happy and That's When are boring af, but there's nothing as bad on the Fearless vault as Message In A Butthole or Run Also I genuinely stan Mr. Perfectly Fine and Don't You Better Man, Nothing New, and Forever Winter clear everything on Fearless vault tho
Klein Posted August 27 Posted August 27 I leave for a couple hours and I come back to people trashing the Red and Speak Now vault, and being Fearless vault apologists? Just go ahead and delete your ballots for this rate, for god's sake, we can't trust anyone. 1 4
Recommended Posts