rate The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page

[Velvet Night]

Ofc it's Maroon!

The taste level in this rate is on the floor! 

[TaylenaStan]

Moron OUT  (i blame Hack for this one tho, i like it lyrically but HATE the washed out production)

Edited September 7 by TaylenaStan

[4Real]

Maroon deserved almost scrapping top 100 placement at best let's bfr

[1989]

OH MY GOD 

[By the Water]

Maroon haters are so weird

[1989]

MY FIRST 11 OUT 

 

[wastedpotential]

Just now, By the Water said:

Maroon haters are so weird

I feel such a deep sense of hatred for them, actually

 

[Dear Reader]

Jack haters kind of need to be studied just as much as Taylor haters. Both deranged  you see his name in the credits and you automatically dislike the song. 

[wastedpotential]

Just now, 1989 said:

MY FIRST 11 OUT 

 

ddddd welcome to the ******* club

 

[Cruel Summer]

Quote

Saviours (11s): Vespertine

And I know exactly why, oh how unsurprising 

[1989]

7 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

BETTER be blank space? I'm shook

I love ha, but she and Red are the only two that are quite 10/10

[Catch22]

Just now, Dear Reader said:

Jack haters kind of need to be studied just as much as Taylor haters. Both deranged  you see his name in the credits and you automatically dislike the song. 

This was so obvious with Please Please Please premiere  

[Klein]

1 minute ago, 1989 said:

MY FIRST 11 OUT 

 

Be grateful it is the first one 

 

[gagacasanova]

2 minutes ago, 1989 said:

MY FIRST 11 OUT 

 

Stings, doesn't it?

[burninredhot]

5 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

 

49. Maroon

8.129

 

Saviours (11s): 1989, Theluckyone, Vespertine, jacobhalkohit, Swirl900, Don

Stans (10s): NewStanner, Bartender, Kyle-x, byzantium, Flower, Klein, TheArgonaut, Dear Reader, BOAZ, RihannaLoverrr, fridayteenage, Ger.vaz, LovaticSwiftie, wastedpotential, Ampersand13, djcalpal, Great Username, americanlife, Supernatural, Mr. Duff, halcyonday, AbeHicks, frankfurt, iamanearthling, folkloreking, Tusk, skizzo, KillingYourCareer, 305, CamiloPg_, MidnightsAtPeace, sanzo, DevilsRollTheDice, pinkbowvintage, Solaria, PaloSanto, tb6591, heckinglovato, Where are you now?, fab, Quicksand, 

Admirers (9s): twoheadlightshine, Lazuli, LoveInStereo, SoSickOfThatSOL, Yog, Avrileon, gagacasanova, badidearight, SLUTTVFTV, Kyungsoowift, Heldenzeit, PoisonedIvy, Sanguine, Lorenzo22, NordicGuy, Velvet Night, PerfectSacrifice, NEX, Live To Tell, Enrique523, AshleyLovescats887, burninredhot, Mocha, Holy Ground, Flames2Embers, chiliam, Ms. Togekiss

Haters (1s): sparrowblue

Saboteurs (0s): TaylenaStan, ONOPKA, idkwiam, terrorblade

 

Comments

1989

11 - "One of her best songs ever. The lyrics, the production—everything works so well here. I will always be a Maroon stan."

Vespertine

11 - "RIP Kaylor."

wastedpotential

10 - "Here lies a true contender for one of my 11 slots. As surprising as it may be for some of y'all to learn given just how much I have made adoring this hymn a part of my personality, it took me a while to get into this hymn. It was a real "you're not gonna get this song the first time you hear it. After the second and third time, you're gonna be like woah, what is this? It's nothing like anything that's out right now, um, you know, it- its, the lyrics are very, um-" experience for me. One day I was going for a hot girl walk around my neighborhood when I felt the compulsion to listen to nothing but Maroon over and over and over and over and over, and by the time I got back it was my favorite hymn on the album, a title it still holds. There's so much power and grace to the instrumental, so much sadness and loss in the lyrics, so much talent in the hymn. If I had to convince an alien that Lord was the greatest musical act of all time, I'd play this hymn for them, because I know they would understand. OJackAntonoffH, when you go in on that man for his work on like Don't You or whatever, you're also going in on him for his work here, which is shameful. You don't have to like everything he's made, but disparaging his work with a broad brush stroke just makes you look uninformed."

Ampersand13

10 - "10 - This is an 11 and I fully admit that the only reason I didn't give it one was because I ran out of them. However, this song rivals Style, Delicate, and Cowboy Like Me as personal favorites. There's not a single time in which those opening synths don't enrapture and envelop me. I'm suddenly in New York on a cloudy day observing the rise and fall of a love-drunk tryst. Remarkably evocative, doused in poetic physical imagery, haunting lyrics, and complete with a chorus vocal that perfectly reflects the spiral of a person whose mind struggles to comprehend how something effervescent turned ephemeral. I'll never recover from this song and I'll never stop loving it. Just a gorgeous and moody haze of love lost."

frankvert

10 - "Would've been an 11 if I had more to give."

Miles.

10 - "I LOVE this and I was about to give it an 11 when I remembered I had to save one for WAOLOM. Just know this is an honorary 11. The chorus with like 7 different shades of red mentioned is so brilliant. That's a real ******* legacy is a perfect, powerful, PUNCHING use of the F bomb. Masterpiece."

Where are you now?

10 - "All the burgundy, wine, blood, scarlet, rust, maroon color references are magical. Love on the second chorus when she sings "t-shirt" and the "collarbone" on a different note."

SLUTTVFTV

9.5 - "One of the few gems on Midnights, this is where the moody synth-pop really works."

Starchild

8 - "Her rap game is strong here, end fame who?"

blown away

5.5 - "It's okay."

Achilles.

4 - "Overrated and kinda bland, but great bridge."

 

Reveal Part 6 Results (So Far)

  Reveal hidden contents

50. Don't Blame Me - 8.127

49. Maroon - 8.129

 

I love this track but it has also aged a bit for me

 

[Brooklyn Baby]

For the next reveal, an opener makes its exit.

[holyground13]

I'm behind a few pages but just to say on yesterday's result: I had no idea that some songs were so popular in the fandom:

 

These are so mid to me:

The Way I Loved You

Death By A Thousand Cuts

Midnight Rain

 

Better Man is a cute girl but not stunning to me. I had no idea she was so loved. I also like Forever Winter but I didn't think she was a top 100 girlie (sorry rate host). Maybe I need to listen to the demo which I've never heard.

[1989]

1 minute ago, wastedpotential said:

ddddd welcome to the ******* club

 

I Hate It Here, truly 

 

also this was not one of my two 11s I have been worried about since yesterday nnnn, I am very confused and afraid now 

[Dear Reader]

Just now, Catch22 said:

This was so obvious with Please Please Please premiere  

I remember being on that thread the night the song dropped and 95% of the comments was saying how the song was trash cause of him and that she had fumbled the second single just for it to reach #1 the next week. Weirdos 

[4Real]

Bye bye RFI you did AMAZING

[burninredhot]

Ready for it LET'S GOOO

 

[gagacasanova]

[Cruel Summer]

1 minute ago, Forever Winter said:

For the next reveal, an opener makes its exit.

Oh god finally I'm so ready for it

[Klein]

Just now, Forever Winter said:

For the next reveal, an opener makes its exit.

Should be a very easy choice when they are

 

Fearless, Mine, State Of Grace, Ready For It, the 1 and willow 

[wastedpotential]

Ready for ****, you have outstayed your welcome. Don't let the door hit you on the way out!