gagacasanova Posted September 6 Posted September 6 42 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: 85. I Can See You 7.632 37 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: 84. False God 7.640 13 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: 81. So High School 7.686 You bum *******. 1
1989 Posted September 6 Posted September 6 As I said in my comment, The Black Dog is a career highlight I said the same about The Other Side Of The Door, and we all know what you rats did to that masterpiece None of you truly understand what an actual career highlight is 3
Don Posted September 6 Posted September 6 4 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: 79. The Black Dog 7.753 Saviours (11s): Tedwards, Nein Stans (10s): Bosque, Top Dash, SoSickOfThatSOL, TMRA, Blood Magic, Bartender, Kyle-x, Diarrhoea, byzantium, Flower, twoheadlightshine, Hooker Barbie, Strawberry Bubble, Dear Reader, Ger.vaz, SLUTTVFTV, Miles., Schami66, Prismee, wastedpotential, Venice B, AbeHicks, AshleyLovescats887, Enrique523, badiearight, reputation1989, folkloreking, itsjem, Theluckyone, Arrows, llikeh, MidnightsAtPeace, sanzo, DevilsRollTheDice, 1989, pinkbowvintage, PaloSanto, tb6591 Admirers (9s): heckinglovato, Achilles., pavi, greeneyedsoul, chiliam, enchanted0, Heldenzeit, Flames2Embers, Bussea, ellis-bell, RihannaLoverrr, fridayteenage, burninredhot, Great Username, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, jacobhalkohit, chosensparkles, gagacasanova, Namigo, The Music Industry, LoveInStereo, Cruel Summer, Poisonedivy, TaylenaStan, tjspy, Avrileon, Safe&Sound, Velvet Night, PerfectSacrifice, greento, iamanearthling, terrorblade, Lorenzo22, Taylor fanboy, LastKiss, Lazuli Haters (1s): GuyNextDoor, blown away Saboteurs (0s): NewStanner Comments Nein 11 - "This is by far one of her best songs ever. Seriously heart-wrenching anger that I relate a little too much to." wastedpotential 10 - "AND I HOPE IT'S SHITTY IN THE BLACK DOG WHEN SOMEONE PLAYS THE STARTING LINE AND YOU JUMP UP BUT SHES TOO YOUNG TO KNOW THIS SONG THAT WAS INTERTWINED IN THE TRAGIC FABRIC OF OUR DREAMING CAUSE TAIL BETWEEN YOUR LEGS YOU'RE LEAVING AND I STILL CAN'T BELIEVE IT CAUSE OLD HABITS DIE screaming." Miles. 10 - "I NEED ANOTHER 11! I could rave about this song for hours. The way the chorus changes, the bridge, the fact that I had to google a word (esoteric) because she's just too damn smart, but the number one thing I'm obsessed with is the fact that the song ends with her WHISPERING the word SCREAMING. BRILLIANT." pinkbowvintage 10 - "The bridge + final chorus alone clears most of her discography." 1989 10 - "A career highlight." SLUTTVFTV 10 - "She ate that! Reminds me so much of Red." kyungsoowift 8.5 - "I HOPE IT'S SHITTY IN THE BLACK DOG." Edge of Glory 8 - "Joe Alwyn, you're bones b*tch." blown away 1 - "Taylor, girl. You really said charts not arts huh?" NewStanner 0 - "Literally a jumpscare of a song." Reveal, Part 5 Results (So Far) Reveal hidden contents 90. Dress - 7.588 89. I Bet You Think About Me (feat. Chris Stapleton) - 7.595 88. Afterglow - 7.603 87. This Love - 7.623 86. Teardrops on My Guitar - 7.624 85. I Can See You - 7.632 84. False God 83. invisible string 82. Nothing New (feat. Phoebe Bridgers) 81. So High School 80. But Daddy I Love Him 79. The Black Dog ow woah this is pretty high.. I don't like this song that much, the vocals aren't very good
frankvert Posted September 6 Posted September 6 Just now, 1989 said: As I said in my comment, The Black Dog is a career highlight I said the same about The Other Side Of The Door, and we all know what you rats did to that masterpiece None of you truly understand what an actual career highlight is Imagine my horror when I saw 178. The Lucky One
Catch22 Posted September 6 Posted September 6 Good placement, but there are still songs in the rate that should've been out of top 200, so it is totally not right. I didn't care about The Black Dog at first, but it has changed after I've heard it live - I adore it now. That said, my 8th surprise song out
Catch22 Posted September 6 Posted September 6 Good placement, but there are still songs in the rate that should've been out of top 200, so it is totally not right. I didn't care about The Black Dog at first, but it has changed after I've heard it live - I adore it now. That said, my 8th surprise song out
Peroxide Posted September 6 Posted September 6 I Knew You Were a Mediocre Song has overstayed her welcome. 1 2
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 6 Author Posted September 6 Y'all are NASTY for this next one. I take this one personally.
Cruel Summer Posted September 6 Posted September 6 Just now, Forever Winter said: Y'all are NASTY for this next one. I take this one personally. oh now I'm worried
Klein Posted September 6 Posted September 6 1 minute ago, Forever Winter said: Y'all are NASTY for this next one. I take this one personally. Forever Winter is gone I fear.
TaylenaStan Posted September 6 Posted September 6 1 minute ago, Forever Winter said: Y'all are NASTY for this next one. I take this one personally. Forever Winter??
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 6 Author Posted September 6 78. Forever Winter 7.790 Saviours (11s): Forever Winter, By the Watera_d_22, llikeh, vinicius, Sad Beautiful Tragic, GuyNextDoor, burninredhot, RihannaLoverrr, Flames2Embers, Kyle-x, Top Dash Stans (10s): Michael196, Achilles., Lazuli, SleepingTigers, Swirl900, Quicksand, Bussea, Hooker Barbie, Klein, FolkLover1989, TaylenaStan, Strawberry Bubble, americanlife, Miles., Great Username, wastedpotential, AbeHicks, iamanearthling, Vespertine, Tusk, Arrows, sanzo Admirers (9s): The Music Industry, Velvet Night, Støned, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, Ger.vaz, NordicGuy, Soobin, 1989, Cruel Summer, Live To Tell, Riverbank, folkloreking, Enrique523, Holy Ground, Dear Reader, roso, Flower, enchanted0, chiliam, Blood Magic, Don, heckinglovato Haters (1s): KillingYourCareer, Taylor fanboy Saboteurs (0s): None Comments Forever Winter 11 - "It would be crazy if I didn't give this an 11 given my username. This song means so much to me and it's a crime that it's the lowest-streamed Red vault. SICK and TWISTED! Also, the Demo version is the one I use and it eats up Jack's horn-y version." Flames2Embers 11 - "THIS SONG BREAKS MY HEART." RihannaLoverrr 11 - "The best vault track. Just incredible." By the Water 11 - "Underrated masterpiece. Not everyone gets this, but I do!" Klein 10 - "While in the group of songs I find hard to rate, I just find it too magnificent to not give it a 10. That bridge wrecks me everytime I listen to it. I completely understand why it wasn't on the original Red, but it's in moments like this that I actually thank Scotter and Scott for being garbage because without them we wouldn't have this masterpiece." Miles. 10 - "So gutwrenchingly beautiful." Achilles. 10 - "She has so many songs that are so sweetly reassuring and they are all so good and important and special." wastedpotential 10 - "It's obviously never been confirmed if this was written about Jeff Lang (and I don't think it should be, that's such a deeply personal thing and Lord doesn't owe anyone an explanation there), but if it is, this is such a beautiful and tragic documentation and memorialization of Her dear friend. I've definitely had really scary situations like this with a close friend of mine in the past (thankfully, they're in a better places now, but it was rocky for quite a while), and I really appreciate that Lord released this, because I can only know it's provided a lot of comfort to people in times of need. In terms of Lord songs I relate to the absolute hardest and that rocked my world the most intensely when they first came out, this is absolutely on top of that list, and I definitely choke up when listening. To bring a bit of levity to this comment, I vividly remember being floored by the rumors that Lord had worked with Mark Foster (and then being gutted when whatever they'd made didn't end up on the album), and unlike other rumored songwriting collaborations with legends (cough cough Diane Warren), this one FAR exceeded my expectations in production and obviously in lyrics. A beautiful hymn that's very underrated, but I do take comfort in that. If more people needed this song in the way I do, the world would be worse off." 1989 9.2 - "The only song in the Red Vault that deserved to be on the actual album in 2012." Where are you now? 7.6 - "The horns in this song (especially the intro) are otherworldly." SLUTTVFTV 7.5 - "Cute." Reveal, Part 5 Results (So Far) Spoiler 90. Dress - 7.588 89. I Bet You Think About Me (feat. Chris Stapleton) - 7.595 88. Afterglow - 7.603 87. This Love - 7.623 86. Teardrops on My Guitar - 7.624 85. I Can See You - 7.632 84. False God 83. invisible string 82. Nothing New (feat. Phoebe Bridgers) 81. So High School 80. But Daddy I Love Him 79. The Black Dog 78. Forever Winter 1
wastedpotential Posted September 6 Posted September 6 2 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Y'all are NASTY for this next one. I take this one personally. 1
wastedpotential Posted September 6 Posted September 6 Just now, Forever Winter said: 78. Forever Winter 7.790 Saviours (11s): Forever Winter, By the Watera_d_22, llikeh, vinicius, Sad Beautiful Tragic, GuyNextDoor, burninredhot, RihannaLoverrr, Flames2Embers, Kyle-x, Top Dash Stans (10s): Michael196, Achilles., Lazuli, SleepingTigers, Swirl900, Quicksand, Bussea, Hooker Barbie, Klein, FolkLover1989, TaylenaStan, Strawberry Bubble, americanlife, Miles., Great Username, wastedpotential, AbeHicks, iamanearthling, Vespertine, Tusk, Arrows, sanzo Admirers (9s): The Music Industry, Velvet Night, Støned, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, Ger.vaz, NordicGuy, Soobin, 1989, Cruel Summer, Live To Tell, Riverbank, folkloreking, Enrique523, Holy Ground, Dear Reader, roso, Flower, enchanted0, chiliam, Blood Magic, Don, heckinglovato Haters (1s): KillingYourCareer, Taylor fanboy Saboteurs (0s): None Comments Forever Winter 11 - "It would be crazy if I didn't give this an 11 given my username. This song means so much to me and it's a crime that it's the lowest-streamed Red vault. SICK and TWISTED! Also, the Demo version is the one I use and it eats up Jack's horn-y version." Flames2Embers 11 - "THIS SONG BREAKS MY HEART." RihannaLoverrr 11 - "The best vault track. Just incredible." By the Water 11 - "Underrated masterpiece. Not everyone gets this, but I do!" Klein 10 - "While in the group of songs I find hard to rate, I just find it too magnificent to not give it a 10. That bridge wrecks me everytime I listen to it. I completely understand why it wasn't on the original Red, but it's in moments like this that I actually thank Scotter and Scott for being garbage because without them we wouldn't have this masterpiece." Miles. 10 - "So gutwrenchingly beautiful." Achilles. 10 - "She has so many songs that are so sweetly reassuring and they are all so good and important and special." wastedpotential 10 - "It's obviously never been confirmed if this was written about Jeff Lang (and I don't think it should be, that's such a deeply personal thing and Lord doesn't owe anyone an explanation there), but if it is, this is such a beautiful and tragic documentation and memorialization of Her dear friend. I've definitely had really scary situations like this with a close friend of mine in the past (thankfully, they're in a better places now, but it was rocky for quite a while), and I really appreciate that Lord released this, because I can only know it's provided a lot of comfort to people in times of need. In terms of Lord songs I relate to the absolute hardest and that rocked my world the most intensely when they first came out, this is absolutely on top of that list, and I definitely choke up when listening. To bring a bit of levity to this comment, I vividly remember being floored by the rumors that Lord had worked with Mark Foster (and then being gutted when whatever they'd made didn't end up on the album), and unlike other rumored songwriting collaborations with legends (cough cough Diane Warren), this one FAR exceeded my expectations in production and obviously in lyrics. A beautiful hymn that's very underrated, but I do take comfort in that. If more people needed this song in the way I do, the world would be worse off." 1989 9.2 - "The only song in the Red Vault that deserved to be on the actual album in 2012." Where are you now? 7.6 - "The horns in this song (especially the intro) are otherworldly." SLUTTVFTV 7.5 - "Cute." Reveal, Part 5 Results (So Far) Reveal hidden contents 90. Dress - 7.588 89. I Bet You Think About Me (feat. Chris Stapleton) - 7.595 88. Afterglow - 7.603 87. This Love - 7.623 86. Teardrops on My Guitar - 7.624 85. I Can See You - 7.632 84. False God 83. invisible string 82. Nothing New (feat. Phoebe Bridgers) 81. So High School 80. But Daddy I Love Him 79. The Black Dog 78. Forever Winter
Cruel Summer Posted September 6 Posted September 6 I think everyone else said it well in the comments, but this song is a deeply meaningful song to have gotten at all. I also use the demo version about equally to the main one. 3
Where are you now? Posted September 6 Posted September 6 @Forever Winter I will be needing your name and address for rating BDILH a 2.5 2
Peroxide Posted September 6 Posted September 6 @Forever Winter it was her time sis. She put up a good fight tho. Good for ha. 1
Recommended Posts