Jump to content

The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page


Recommended Posts

Posted

Tragic placement. 

  • Thanks 1

  • Replies 10k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Brooklyn Baby

    1241

  • wastedpotential

    837

  • Dear Reader

    463

  • Klein

    375

Posted

This one is definitely not among the worst ones from TTPD

  • Thanks 1
Posted

Yeah I like this, but it's still in the bottom of TTPD for me, so not a huge loss. 
 

I need my last 0 to GO though 

Posted
6 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

the-tortured-poets-department-photoshoot

 

220. I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

5.698

 

Guardian Angels (11s): None

Lovers (9s-10s): AbeHicks, vinicius, Great UserName, GuyNextDoor, Nein, Taylor fanboy, heckinglovato, PoisonedIvy, PerfectSacrifice, Vespertine, Enrique523, AshleyLovescats887, Miles., Terylee, fridayteenage, Bartender, Achilles.

Haters (1s): Feanor, Teen Spirit, LovaticSwiftie, paulyyyozd, FolkLover1989, fab, Sanguine

Murderers (0): Edge of Glory, SoSickofThatSOL, MusicLoverDude, creativity., Prismee

 

Comments

Nein

10 - "Y'all don't get this one like I do."

Achilles.

9 - "Bumped its score because it is unfairly maligned."

Miles.

9 - "This has grown on me so much. Love the eerie western vibes, and the way it comes full circle by the end. Maybe IIIII can't."

SLUTTVFTV

8.1 - "She has to stop making these great songs and making them 2 minutes long. It's evil!"

wastedpotential

6.7 - "I'm so glad Lord provided the obvious worst song on the book for everyone to righteously dump their hate on!"

Forever Winter

6.6 - "Wish this was longer and the album expanded more on this sound. Love the western vibes."

Where are you now?

6.4 - "I think she succeeded in the direction she sought out. Will probably always be overlooked. Parts of the verse sound a little like Fortnight's verse to me."

greento

5.5 - "I can see this being a huge grower for me and I think in a year or so, I'll absolutely love it."

blown away

1.6 - "There's no soul in this song."

MusicLoverDude

0 - "Another waste of space."

Edge of Glory

0 - "BORING........ YAWNING.......... SLOPPY.......... LAZY."

The Tortured Ears Department, Should've Stayed in the Slammer and The Albatross were RIGHT THERE

  • Thumbs Down 3
Posted

Cute song. Y'all can't handle anything that isn't Fad Martin generic pop

  • Like 3
Posted

yesss :jonny: the only skip from TTPD is gone. The only good part of this son is the "woah maybe I can'ttttt" at the end 

Posted
1 minute ago, gagacasanova said:

The Tortured Ears Department, Should've Stayed in the Slammer and The Albatross were RIGHT THERE

All in the top half of TTPD. No words.

Posted

been trying to access atrl for 2 hours and this is the first time the page actually loads, if they get to rihveal the results then I'll try to catch up later. Last song reveal I could see was ******* Me! so I have a lot to catch up with :deadbanana4:

Posted
Just now, gagacasanova said:

The Tortured Ears Department, Should've Stayed in the Slammer and The Albatross were RIGHT THERE

it's one of her best this decade :deadbanana4:

  • Confused 1
Posted

THIS before Bye Bye Baby?

 

I DEMAND A RECOUNT…

  • Like 1
Posted

ATRL User @NewStanner on the next song:

Quote

"This song doesn't deserve a comment."

 

Posted

Its giving cute lil interlude, some worse songs still in but idc that this is out :clack:

Posted

 

230817104322-02-tim-mcgraw-taylor-swift-

 

219. Highway Don't Care (Tim McGraw feat. Taylor Swift & Keith Urban)

5.748

 

Guardian Angels (11s): None

Lovers (9s-10s): Namigo, AbeHicks, Støned, Losing my ground, Dear Reader, Kyle-x, sparrowblue, Miles., idkwiam, PerfectSacrifice, blown away, llikeh, Enrique523, Mezik, Bosque

Haters (1s): Teen Spirit, 4Real, AshleyLovescats887, NextBish90, GuyNextDoor, Mocha, Holy Ground, Quicksand, By the Water

Murderers (0s): Where are you now?, NewStanner

 

Comments

sparrowblue

10 - "Tim McGraw is king and this collab is excellence. Shoutout to Keith Urban."

blown away

9.2 - "An unusual pairing, but it works really well."

wastedpotential

6.6 - "One last country radio huzzah for Lord, and a cute little moment with Tim McGraw, I guess. I hope Faith brought them baked goods in the studio to make this worth it. I'm glad we got to experience far greater Taylor x Keith Urban moment on the New Testament of Flawless. I don't consume this one very much, and I don't think anyone should, really. If Tim McGraw wanted me to stream this, he should've given Lord more of the song than just the meta song-on-the-radio with "I can't live without you, I can't live without you baby" (where her vocals are snatched, btw), and then a matched harmony in the second verse. I guess I should be glad I'm not a Keith Urban stan, because you quite literally cannot hear him on this song."

Achilles.

4 - "Do you ever think about how she could have sent I Almost Do or Holy Ground to country radio if she didn't have to waste 6 months of the Red era on this?"

NewStanner

0 - "This song doesn't deserve a comment."

  • Like 2
Posted

the lack of taste is finally showing :rip:

i'm so mad i didn't give a 10 to my surprise song!!

Posted

I gotta admit i didn't revisit this to rate it :ryan3:

Posted

@wastedpotential I think you can't hear Keith on the song because he's only playing guitar, I could be wrong though 

 

 

  • Thanks 1
Posted

I actually forgot about this song until the rate so when I re-listened to it... 

spacer.png

Posted
4 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

ATRL User @NewStanner on the next song:

 

Oh god based on yesterday I'm expecting The Alcott or something, brb need to leave work so I can grab a drink

  • Haha 2
Posted
4 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

 

230817104322-02-tim-mcgraw-taylor-swift-

 

219. Highway Don't Care (Tim McGraw feat. Taylor Swift & Keith Urban)

5.748

 

Guardian Angels (11s): None

Lovers (9s-10s): Namigo, AbeHicks, Støned, Losing my ground, Dear Reader, Kyle-x, sparrowblue, Miles., idkwiam, PerfectSacrifice, blown away, llikeh, Enrique523, Mezik, Bosque

Haters (1s): Teen Spirit, 4Real, AshleyLovescats887, NextBish90, GuyNextDoor, Mocha, Holy Ground, Quicksand, By the Water

Murderers (0s): Where are you now?, NewStanner

 

Comments

sparrowblue

10 - "Tim McGraw is king and this collab is excellence. Shoutout to Keith Urban."

blown away

9.2 - "An unusual pairing, but it works really well."

wastedpotential

6.6 - "One last country radio huzzah for Lord, and a cute little moment with Tim McGraw, I guess. I hope Faith brought them baked goods in the studio to make this worth it. I'm glad we got to experience far greater Taylor x Keith Urban moment on the New Testament of Flawless. I don't consume this one very much, and I don't think anyone should, really. If Tim McGraw wanted me to stream this, he should've given Lord more of the song than just the meta song-on-the-radio with "I can't live without you, I can't live without you baby" (where her vocals are snatched, btw), and then a matched harmony in the second verse. I guess I should be glad I'm not a Keith Urban stan, because you quite literally cannot hear him on this song."

Achilles.

4 - "Do you ever think about how she could have sent I Almost Do or Holy Ground to country radio if she didn't have to waste 6 months of the Red era on this?"

NewStanner

0 - "This song doesn't deserve a comment."

I really love this song :dancehall3:

  • Like 1
Posted

@wastedpotential I think you can't hear Keith on the song because he's only playing guitar, I could be wrong though 

 

 

Posted
4 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

 

230817104322-02-tim-mcgraw-taylor-swift-

 

219. Highway Don't Care (Tim McGraw feat. Taylor Swift & Keith Urban)

5.748

 

              Comments

wastedpotential

6.6 - "One last country radio huzzah for Lord, and a cute little moment with Tim McGraw, I guess. I hope Faith brought them baked goods in the studio to make this worth it. I'm glad we got to experience far greater Taylor x Keith Urban moment on the New Testament of Flawless. I don't consume this one very much, and I don't think anyone should, really. If Tim McGraw wanted me to stream this, he should've given Lord more of the song than just the meta song-on-the-radio with "I can't live without you, I can't live without you baby" (where her vocals are snatched, btw), and then a matched harmony in the second verse. I guess I should be glad I'm not a Keith Urban stan, because you quite literally cannot hear him on this song."

He's the one playing the guitar bb

Posted

Well today is starting out horribly.

 

Y'all, we still have 13 Loser songs and the Fearless Vault to focus on!  Stop sabotaging TTPD and her country classics!

 

And not Taylor herself @AshleyLovescats887 giving this a 1!  What gives!?

  • Haha 1
Posted

I Can Fix Him is definitely the worst song on TTPD and I think people probably rated it low because of that. Is it worse than most of her early career droplets and Christmas jingles? Of course not, so dead last seems a bit undeserved 

  • Like 1
Posted

highway don't care and neither do I :suburban:

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.