KillingYourCareer Posted September 2 Posted September 2 First of all; I really appreciate our dear host's decision to match each era with a color in the results, it's really lovely. Shame on all of you for doing Sounds of the Season: The Taylor Swift Holiday Collection so dirty. It's a sweet EP full of love and emotions. Other than this, I can't complain about these results!
ONOPKA Posted September 2 Posted September 2 28 minutes ago, Starchild said: YALL JUST CANT LET TAYLOR HAVE FUN? I WILL STATE MY COMMENT AGAIN: GORGEOUS IS A BOP that is from a drunks persons perspective, I'm not hearing rep for I hate it here type lyricism let's be realistic 2023: #180 2024: #222 maybe the gutter is where it belongs
Life Savers Posted September 2 Posted September 2 No Peak Now song should have been touched this early.
G.U.Y_Del_Rey Posted September 3 Posted September 3 Is there a summary of the results so far, 'cuz I'm not reading all those pages.
Kyungsoowift Posted September 3 Posted September 3 5 hours ago, Forever Winter said: 235. Superstar 5.309 Comments The Music Industry 10 - "Expecting this to be ranked low, but Superstar is extremely underrated and deserves better. The way she sings it is so soft and yearning. There's a sweetness to the song, but also a hint of sadness, because deep down, you kind of know that this love might only ever be a fantasy. It brings back lots of memories of 10 year-old me having a crush on Chad Michael Murray." AshleyLovescats887 10 - "extremely underrated, why tf is this the lowest streamed one?" greento 8.2 - "I don't care how bad people think this is, it doesn't deserve to be one of her least popular songs ever." wastedpotential 7.9 - "Oh now this is a little musical number I hate to love and love to hate. I'm too lazy to unpack the lyrical implications here but I know the irony is delicious. Anyway, sometimes a skip and sometimes a lovely ditty to put on while cleaning the house. The chord progression into the bridge sends shivers down my spine because of how clean and perfect and excellent it is. Still, Nathan Chapman will be in HELL for the male vocals and Chris Rowe and his dirty beard will join him there for not explaining to Lord that they're horrible and a bad idea. We do NOT want any more hidden male producer harmonies! Repeat it with me, We do NOT want any more hidden male producer harmonies! We do NOT want any more hidden male producer harmonies! Maybe if I burn some stage around Electric Lady, we can get the evil spirit of Nathan Chapman out. Anyway, I wonder if Lord knows she probably sings millions of people to sleep every night on the radio, or if she's forgotten about this song just as much as the rest of us." Lorenzo22 7.8 - "The chorus is so freaking good, her melody game is unmatched." Where are you now? 7.4 - "The re-record made me see the light." Forever Winter 6.8 - "A cute song. I love the key change in the bridge. Overhated." pavi 3 - "Getting this as a surprise song was just cruel." KillingYourCareer 1.5 - "The Platinum Edition bonus tracks are some of the weakest of her discography (to the point they were among the very few songs I had to relisten to for this rate), and this one is the worst for me. The .5 is purely because the title is spelt as 'SuperStar' and I find this small detail super funny." 1989 1 - "The worst song of the Fearless era by a mile." blown away 1 - "This is not it." yall are tasteless wtf there's quite literally other worse songs especially the Vault 2
Lorenzo22 Posted September 3 Posted September 3 not me in my beauty sleep (i might have covid) while the rihveals happened, now i have 33 pages, with these slow servers, to go through
4Real Posted September 3 Posted September 3 Seeing the results now and SANTA BABY DID NOT DESERVE THAT
Peak Now Posted September 3 Posted September 3 5 hours ago, Forever Winter said: Today's Results Hide contents 221. Long Live Superman - 5.650 222. Gorgeous - 5.640 223. A Place in This World - 5.623 224. You All Over Me (feat. Maren Morris) - 5.617 225. The Man - 5.613 226. Suburban Legends - 5.590 227. Vigilante **** - 5.532 228. You Need to Calm Down - 5.459 229. We Were Happy - 5.455 230. London Boy - 5.407 231. us. (Gracie Abrams feat. Taylor Swift) - 5.386 232. Invisible - 5.371 233. This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things - 5.358 234. Girl at Home - 5.352 235. Superstar - 5.309 236. Tied Together with a Smile - 5.2859 237. Robin - 5.2853 238. I Heart ? - 5.282 239. Beautiful Eyes - 5.277 240. Birch (Big Red Machine feat. Taylor Swift) - 5.275 241. Beautiful Ghosts - 5.269 242. thanK you aIMee - 5.124 243. Last Christmas - 5.038 244. Two Is Better Than One (feat. Taylor Swift) - 5.025 245. Christmases When You Were Mine - 5.012 246. Both of Us (feat. Taylor Swift) - 4.978 247. Stay Beautiful - 4.921 248. Stay Stay Stay - 4.845 249. Run (feat. Ed Sheeran) - 4.765 250. Only the Young - 4.731 251. Christmas Must Be Something More - 4.401 252. Half of My Heart (with Taylor Swift) - 4.320 253.A Perfectly Good Heart - 4.307 254. I Forgot That You Existed - 4.180 255. White Christmas - 4.115 256. Santa Baby - 4.110 257. Silent Night - 3.987 258. ME! (feat. Brendon Urie of Panic! at the Disco) - 3.984 259. The Joker and The Queen (Ed Sheeran feat. Taylor Swift) - 3.953 260. Macavity - 3.550 LOSER (and the era, SCAT you will never be forgiven) getting lashed left and right Her flop features serving OUT-OUT just like on the charts Thank You 2016 being EVICTED, which serves it right for the trenches we went through defending her petty ass Ed Sheeran? I made that ginger famous Red losing Runt, Stay×3 In The Vault and Girl At Club before Peak Now took any hits (John Mayer you will pay) On the other hand there is an alarming disrespect for early country Taylor... Justice for TTWAS! Justice for We Were Happy! Not A Perfectly Mid Shart though that can rot 1 1
Lorenzo22 Posted September 3 Posted September 3 some cute girls like vigilante caca and superstar gone but nothing that hurts
MusicLoverDude Posted September 3 Posted September 3 5 hours ago, StonedSoulPicnic said: A supermarket staple. As someone that actually WORKS in a grocery store, it actually isn't. Vons (Safeway) has played Love Story, Ours, You Belong With Me, Our Song, Teardrops On My Guitar, Shake It Off, Blank Space, 22, Getaway Car, ME!, The Man, willow, Message In a Bottle, Anti-Hero, This Love (Taylor's Version), Welcome To New York and Sparks Fly. 1
4Real Posted September 3 Posted September 3 1 hour ago, MusicLoverDude said: Glitch and I Can Fix Him still in Glitch is a solid 9 2
4Real Posted September 3 Posted September 3 Hope i'll be here in the next round cuz reading 50 pages was torture 5
Peak Now Posted September 3 Posted September 3 1 hour ago, MusicLoverDude said: Glitch and I Can Fix Him still in Two decent songs so yes? Broken Shart however...
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 3 Author Posted September 3 24 minutes ago, Where are you now? said: Girl if you hate it with every fiber of your being why is it rated a 5/10? That was a mistake on my part. They gave it a 0 1
Life Savers Posted September 3 Posted September 3 2 hours ago, MusicLoverDude said: Glitch and I Can Fix Him still in One of these is not like the other
Achilles. Posted September 3 Posted September 3 24 minutes ago, Life Savers said: One of these is not like the other In the sense that one is a ten and the other is a nine? 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 3 Author Posted September 3 In case you're reading this just now, here's the beginning of the reveal: Results (in spoilers): Spoiler 221. Superman - 5.650 222. Gorgeous - 5.640 223. A Place in This World - 5.623 224. You All Over Me (feat. Maren Morris) - 5.617 225. The Man - 5.613 226. Suburban Legends - 5.590 227. Vigilante **** - 5.532 228. You Need to Calm Down - 5.459 229. We Were Happy - 5.455 230. London Boy - 5.407 231. us. (Gracie Abrams feat. Taylor Swift) - 5.386 232. Invisible - 5.371 233. This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things - 5.358 234. Girl at Home - 5.352 235. Superstar - 5.309 236. Tied Together with a Smile - 5.2859 237. Robin - 5.2853 238. I Heart ? - 5.282 239. Beautiful Eyes - 5.277 240. Birch (Big Red Machine feat. Taylor Swift) - 5.275 241. Beautiful Ghosts - 5.269 242. thanK you aIMee - 5.124 243. Last Christmas - 5.038 244. Two Is Better Than One (feat. Taylor Swift) - 5.025 245. Christmases When You Were Mine - 5.012 246.Both of Us (feat. Taylor Swift) - 4.978 247. Stay Beautiful - 4.921 248. Stay Stay Stay - 4.845 249. Run (feat. Ed Sheeran) - 4.765 250. Only the Young - 4.731 251. Christmas Must Be Something More - 4.401 252. Half of My Heart (John Mayer with Taylor Swift) - 4.320 253. A Perfectly Good Heart - 4.307 254. I Forgot That You Existed - 4.180 255. White Christmas - 4.115 256. Santa Baby - 4.110 257. Silent Night - 3.987 258. ME! (feat. Brendon Urie of Panic! at the Disco) - 3.984 259. The Joker and The Queen (Ed Sheeran feat. Taylor Swift) - 3.953 260. Macavity - 3.550
Starchild Posted September 3 Posted September 3 2 hours ago, 4Real said: Glitch is a solid 9 51 minutes ago, Achilles. said: In the sense that one is a ten and the other is a nine? Thank god theres some taste here are some of y'all deaf? Cause these 2 songs aren't bad by any means also y'all doing that to thank you Aimee? When it's not even close to some of the songs that y'all haven't gotten rid of Get over yourselves "waa Taylor never got over it???1!" did you go through it? Tf 1
pinkbowvintage Posted September 3 Posted September 3 10 hours ago, Tusk said: I'm shocked! I love love love this song. This is the first gut punch. SHUT IT DOWN. OPEN THE STREAMING FARMS. No agreed this is one of my faves from 1989.
Edge Of Glory Posted September 3 Posted September 3 11 hours ago, Forever Winter said: 222. Hide contents Gorgeous Comments Hide contents AbeHicks 10 - "This album not having a grammy is criminal." NewStanner 10 - "gsdkfdgkfdkgfd" greento 9.5 - "Why on earth is this the least streamed song on reputation??" Achilles. 8 - "The outro contains some of the holiest ad libs of her career and they do a lot to elevate this song." Where are you now? 7.6 - "By the time this song gets voted out, we will all have heard Gorgeous by Katheryn Hudson." Edge of Glory 7.5 - "This song is so silly idc...ive loved it since day 1." Nein 7 - "Cute crush song." Starchild 7 - "No regrets, it's a drunk person's perspective and I'm dying on that hill." wastedpotential 6.9 - "Oh now this is one everyone loves to hate. I'm with you, and I'm not, in the sense that I hate this song so much I've gone full circle and now love it again, if that makes sense? My appreciation for this song is ironic (and probably stems from my love for mess and "300 people know." ddd). I consume this song driven by the fuel of your hatred. I wouldn't listen like I do if there wasn't an irony to it, and there wouldn't be irony to it if y'all weren't fun haters. I fear I'm gonna need y'all to get with this program before this too gets cannibalized by the anti-Blake Lively propaganda floating around. The production is like genuinely terrible and the lyrics are corny as **** but I just swing my head and shoulders side to side and bop around like a child when I hear this one. It makes me so happy, I turn back to sad!" blown away 6.9 - "Not the best song, but it's fun to listen to once in a while." Bosque 2 - "A very unfortunate accident." Peroxide 1.5 - "What an unfitting song title. She ugly as f*ck." sparrowblue 1 - "We still ain't heard the lyrics that cut glass." The Music Industry 0 - "She tried to ship the glass-cutting lyrics but they got shipped back :dancehall2:" 1989 0 - "Tied as the worst song of her career. I honestly can't believe she thought those lyrics were fine enough to be recorded and then released on an album. Legitimately embarrassing." frankvert 0 - "SKID MARK of a song." Yog 0 - "These lyrics will forever leave the glass intact." Miles. 0 - "The WTNY of reputation. Hate everything about this, especially I can't look at your face... cuz look at your face. I genuinely struggle to wrap my brain around the fact that the same woman who wrote Speak Now (solo), Folklore, and TTPD also wrote this atrocity, ME!th, and Karma." WAKE UP BONNIE BONNIE WAKE UP I NEED YOU AND THEN WATCH SOME UNDESERVING SNOOZE **** LIKE CHAPPINESS OR DELETEHER OR THE MOMENT I MUTE MAKE THE TOP 50 3
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 3 Author Posted September 3 Reveal Results, Part 1 Spoiler 260. Macavity - 3.550 259. The Joker and The Queen (Ed Sheeran feat. Taylor Swift) - 3.953 258. ME! (feat. Brendon Urie of Panic! at the Disco) - 3.984 257. Silent Night - 3.987 256. Santa Baby - 4.110 255. White Christmas - 4.115 254. I Forgot That You Existed - 4.180 253. A Perfectly Good Heart - 4.307 252. Half of My Heart (with Taylor Swift) - 4.320 251. Christmases When You Were Mine - 5.012 250. Only the Young - 4.731 249. Run (feat. Ed Sheeran) - 4.765 248. Stay Stay Stay - 4.845 247. Stay Beautiful - 4.921 246. Both of Us (feat. Taylor Swift) - 4.978 245. Christmases When You Were Mine - 5.012 244. Two Is Better Than One (Boys Like Girls feat. Taylor Swift) - 5.025 243. Last Christmas - 5.038 242. thanK you aIMee - 5.124 241. Beautiful Ghosts - 5.269 240. Birch (Big Red Machine feat. Taylor Swift) - 5.275 239. Beautiful Eyes - 5.277 238. I Heart ? - 5.282 237. Robin - 5.2853 236. Tied Together with a Smile - 5.2859 235. Superstar - 5.309 234. Girl at Home - 5.352 233. This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things - 5.358 232. Invisible - 5.371 231. us (Gracie Abrams feat. Taylor Swift) - 5.386 230. London Boy - 5.407 229. We Were Happy - 5.455 228. You Need to Calm Down - 5.459 227. Vigilante Sh*t - 5.532 226. Suburban Legends - 5.590 225. The Man - 5.613 224. You All Over Me (feat. Maren Morris) - 5.617 223. A Place in This World - 5.623 222. Gorgeous - 5.640 221. Superman - 5.650 1 1
Mr. Duff Posted September 3 Posted September 3 Super late to the party... but ME! deserves so much higher, the hate is insane 1
Recommended Posts