rate The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page

[1989]

Red taking another hit, deserved 

[jacklovesyou1]

Nothing new out next????

[1989]

Red taking another hit, deserved 

3 minutes ago, PoisonedIvy said:

Red is so polarizing fr, it has some of her absolute best and some of her absolute worst  

It's mostly her worst 

[SoSickOfThatSOL]

Wow. The worst song from Red already out but Vigilante **** still in 

[AshleyLovescats887]

Just now, Miles. said:

Obsessed with the new conspiracy theory that @AshleyLovescats887 is Taylor's burner account.  Either way, LOVE that she is giving 10s to basically every song in the rate  

I am surprised my ratings even got accepted. I thought they were gonna get ignored cuz i rated pretty much every song 7+ 

[FolkLover1989]

I hope you all don't attack me when my 0 start appearing 

 

It's gonna be insane 

[Brooklyn Baby]

 

233. This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things

5.358

 

Comments

AbeHicks

10 - "This unapologetic female rage is everything."

pavi

9 - "People who don't like this don't know how to have FUN."

Where are you now?

7.1 - "Annie/It's a hard knock life's ugly red-headed stepchild."

blown away

2.1 - "Childish, cringe and unnecessary, although I cackled during the bridge."

Achilles.

2 - "Becomes hilarious when you realize "not the only friend you've lost lately" means Beyoncé and Jay Z."

1989

1 - "Oof."

Klein

0 - "One word: garbage. I debated a lot whether or not to give this one of my 0. What saved it against its closest competitor is the laugh in the middle of the song that is kinda camp. The rest is terrible."

wastedpotential

 0 - "I repudiate this so strongly. This isn't a Lord song, it was made by her deranged alter-ego Alison, who has bad taste and makes bad music. Alison is an alcoholic loser who doesn't understand ironic humor, and as such makes bad songs like this and tries to play them off genuinely. I hate Alison, almost as much as I hate this song. This is truly the only song ever released with Lord's name on it that embarrasses me. I'm embarrassed to listen to this song, I'm embarrassed to think about it, I'm embarrassed that other people think of this song when they think of Lord. Alison, I hate you so much. This is a trainwreck from start to finish, and the thought of listening to it actually makes me sick. THIS is why I make disliking Resurreputation a part of my personality, and why I will never understand or engage with Resurreputationators in good faith. Even if She botches every other track on Resurreputation New Testament Version, that album will be an improvement over this one if the track list just... doesn't have this cacophonous, jarring, nails-on-a-chalkboard shitstain of a song on it. #JustSayNoToTIWWCHNTTV!"

 

Results

Spoiler

terrorblade	6
tb6591	7.2
SylMacPer	7
PaloSanto	7.5
greento	5.3
NordicGuy	7
The Music Industry	2
Solaria	0
Forever Winter	2
pinkbowvintage	5
1989	1
Peroxide	5.8
DevilsRollTheDice	6
NEX	1
Live To Tell	7
Teen Spirit	4
sanzo	6
MidnightsAtPeace	7
Avrileon	6.5
CamiloPg_	7
4Real	0
a_d_22	0
Namigo	0
llikeh	6
305	7
KillingYourCareer	9
Arrows	6
skizzo	7
Soobin	1
Tusk	3
Riverbank	4
Theluckyone	0.8
LastKiss	8.5
itsjem	2.3
Hurem	3.5
Life Savers	1
folkloreking	8
gagacasanova	8
Vespertine	7
@freakum.	5
chosensparkles	7
reputation1989	8.5
D-@-N	7
badidearight	4
Velvet Night	3
Enrique523	8
Mr. Duff	1
AshleyLovescats887	10
ChapelHooker	7.5
Gorjesspazze9	7.5
halcyonday	6
Iamanearthling	7.5
AbeHicks	10
Axolotl	5
jacobhalkohit	6.5
PerfectSacrifice	8.5
frankvert	1
Venice B	8
vinicius	6
Fitzswiftie	4
Yog	6.5
Ampersand13	4
Feanor	1
wastedpotential	0
Prismee	10
idkwiam	4.7
Schami66	8.5
StØned	2.1
G.U.Y_Del_Rey	5.5
djcalpal	7
Great Username	4
Tedwards	3
tjspy	6.2
Mezik	3
LVP	4
Miles.	9
NextBish90	10
liam13	6.5
SLUTTVFTV	7
Sad Beautiful Tragic	6.5
Losing my ground	5
GuyNextDoor	4
burninredhot	7
americanlife	6
Supernatural	7.5
Terylee	3.5
Mocha	6.5
modern thing	5.5
TaylenaStan	6
Nein	5
Ger.vaz	1
fridayteenage	9
ONOPKA	6
makeawish	7
Holy Ground	7
LovaticSwiftie	1
RihannaLoverrr	3
Dear Reader	4
roso	1
Catch22	8
holyground13	4.5
creativity.	4.5
Strawberry Bubble	10
brokee	6.7
paulyyyozd	9.5
ellis-bell	5.5
BOAZ	2
TheArgonaut	8.1
FolkLover1989	5
Klein	0
MusicLoverDude	6
Clauss	3.5
Hooker Barbie	6
twoheadlightshine	5
Bussea	7
Quicksand	7.5
kyungsoowift	6
Flames2Embers	5
Swirl900	3
beagle	4
Flower	2
Byzantium	1
fab	8
Heldenzeit	1
Safe&Sound	5.4
SleepingTigers	10
Diarrhoea	2
My Tears Ricochet	7
Kyle-x	8
jacklovesyou1	5.5
PoisonedIvy	5.5
yourfaveisaflop	3
Where are you now?	7.1
sparrowblue	3
enchanted0	8
chiliam	7
greeneyedsoul	7
blown away	2.1
AdrianNicki	10
pavi	9
Lazuli	2
Taylor fanboy	10
Bartender	7
Blood Magic	7.5
Rev8	9.4
Sanguine	1
Don	7
K$Ellie	7.5
TMRA	0
SoSickOfThatSOL	9
Bosque	7
Top Dash	6.5
Cruel Summer	6.5
Michael196	7.6
By the Water	1
Bindi	6.1
NewStanner	6
StonedSoulPicnic	4
Achilles.	2
Edge of Glory	7
LoveInStereo	7
heckinglovato	9
Lorenzo22	4.7
wehavetostan	6.4
Starchild	6
Ms. Togekiss	0

 

[a_d_22]

Thank ******* god that piece of **** song should've been out first

[AshleyLovescats887]

Oh? 

[Tusk]

1 minute ago, Forever Winter said:

233. This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things

5.358

oop.

 

I gave this song a 3.  I should have doubled it to a 6.  Oh well.

 

rep is now tainted.

[Hunter_13]

This Is Why I Lost Grammy Respect is utter garbage. Possibly her worst song ever. 

[Dear Reader]

Quote

 

Achilles.

2 - "Becomes hilarious when you realize "not the only friend you've lost lately" means Beyoncé and Jay Z."

I didn't know this 

[Miles.]

Oh no.  This Is Why We Can't Have Iconic Songs out before Gorgyuck?  Karmass?  The entire Fearthis Vault and three quarters of Loser?

 

Oh this is taking a dark turn...

[Klein]

2 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

Klein

0 - "One word: garbage. I debated a lot whether or not to give this one of my 0. What saved it against its closest competitor is the laugh in the middle of the song that is kinda camp. The rest is terrible."

Forgot to edit my comment after giving it the 0 anyway. Oopsie. 

[Catch22]

Rated way too low. I guess I'm a sucker for revenge songs 

[jacklovesyou1]

Like i said sabotage luckily for us rep stans it's the weakest song on the album even i rated it low

[Life Savers]

This is Why We Skip a Song, good riddance 

[Axolotl]

This Is Why My Ears Bleed is finally gone

[Cruel Summer]

I legitimately didn't realize y'all were this serious about hating this song 

[Achilles.]

6 minutes ago, Cruel Summer said:

So I started listening to Fearless TV to mourn its first loss and kinda realized just this second that The Other Side of the Door is kinda just Mine but before Mine, like you know?

Love Story was actually Mine before Mine because the whole point of making Mine the lead single was "rewrite Love Story but ditch the fairytale imagery and mention bills and college to create the illusion of maturity." And before Love Story was Love Story, there was Mary's Song. But more on that in my book, someday. 
 

[gagacasanova]

*******

[Tusk]

poor rep.

 

Here we go with it's downfall

[Brooklyn Baby]

 

232. Invisible

5.371

 

Comments

1989

9.4 - "Incredibly underrated. Great lyrics; I just know that the TV will finally get people discovering this gem."

pinkbowvintage

7 - "I just know the TV will bump this one up because the Eras Tour live version is supreme."

wastedpotential

5.8 - "I do not think about this song. I do not listen to it. This is quite possibly the only song in Taylor's entire discography (and on this list) that I couldn't sing for you word for word. I remember her dedicating it to a random homo at a random Rep tour date, but that's literally all that comes to mind. I can't believe this song has over 35 million streams on Spotify when it's so unmemorable it probably warrants like… 12. I guess TaylorMania was so strong last year that y'all were streaming anything you could get your hands on. I can safely say I was too busy enjoying evermore to listen to this drivel."

By the Water

5.5 - "I hope this gets its due when the TV comes out. What a song."

reputation1989

5 - "Fitting song title."

Where are you now?

3.8 - "Really excited to hear the re-record. Lovely bridge."

blown away

2.1 - "I like the verses, but that chorus is horrible. The vocals in particular..."

 

Results

Spoiler

MusicLoverDude	7
Starchild	5
SLUTTVFTV	3
Tusk	10
AbeHicks	10
Kyle-x	10
Taylor fanboy	10
1989	9.4
PerfectSacrifice	9.4
StØned	9.3
folkloreking	9
Enrique523	9
Holy Ground	9
enchanted0	9
Mr. Duff	8.4
SylMacPer	8.3
greento	8.3
Tedwards	8.2
jacklovesyou1	8.1
llikeh	8
LastKiss	8
chosensparkles	8
AshleyLovescats887	8
Ger.vaz	8
fridayteenage	8
makeawish	8
BOAZ	8
Klein	8
Heldenzeit	8
chiliam	8
Velvet Night	7.9
idkwiam	7.7
Cruel Summer	7.5
PoisonedIvy	7.3
The Music Industry	7.2
Michael196	7.1
Bindi	7.1
pinkbowvintage	7
MidnightsAtPeace	7
Avrileon	7
a_d_22	7
Hurem	7
vinicius	7
Miles.	7
Supernatural	7
paulyyyozd	7
FolkLover1989	7
Bussea	7
SleepingTigers	7
My Tears Ricochet	7
greeneyedsoul	7
LoveInStereo	6.7
Forever Winter	6.5
skizzo	6.5
wastedpotential	6.2
terrorblade	6
DevilsRollTheDice	6
Live To Tell	6
sanzo	6
Soobin	6
Riverbank	6
Life Savers	6
@freakum.	6
badidearight	6
Gorjesspazze9	6
Axolotl	6
Yog	6
G.U.Y_Del_Rey	6
liam13	6
Losing my ground	6
burninredhot	6
ellis-bell	6
Hooker Barbie	6
twoheadlightshine	6
sparrowblue	6
Don	6
SoSickOfThatSOL	6
Achilles.	6
Edge of Glory	6
heckinglovato	6
KillingYourCareer	5.5
By the Water	5.5
roso	5.3
tjspy	5.1
PaloSanto	5
NordicGuy	5
Namigo	5
Arrows	5
Theluckyone	5
gagacasanova	5
reputation1989	5
halcyonday	5
Iamanearthling	5
Venice B	5
Fitzswiftie	5
Mezik	5
Mocha	5
TaylenaStan	5
Nein	5
RihannaLoverrr	5
Dear Reader	5
brokee	5
Clauss	5
Flames2Embers	5
Byzantium	5
yourfaveisaflop	5
Blood Magic	5
Rev8	5
K$Ellie	5
StonedSoulPicnic	5
wehavetostan	5
Safe&Sound	4.8
tb6591	4.5
Sad Beautiful Tragic	4.5
americanlife	4.5
modern thing	4.5
Catch22	4.5
holyground13	4.5
itsjem	4.1
TheArgonaut	4.1
NEX	4
jacobhalkohit	4
Ampersand13	4
djcalpal	4
creativity.	4
kyungsoowift	4
Swirl900	4
fab	4
pavi	4
Bartender	4
Bosque	4
Where are you now?	3.8
Peroxide	3.6
LVP	3.5
TMRA	3.4
D-@-N	3
ChapelHooker	3
frankvert	3
Great Username	3
Strawberry Bubble	3
Quicksand	3
Flower	3
Lazuli	3
NewStanner	3
NextBish90	2.5
Terylee	2.5
AdrianNicki	2.5
Ms. Togekiss	2.5
blown away	2.1
Solaria	2
4Real	2
Vespertine	2
Feanor	2
ONOPKA	2
Lorenzo22	2
beagle	1.6
Teen Spirit	1
CamiloPg_	1
305	1
Prismee	1
Schami66	1
GuyNextDoor	1
LovaticSwiftie	1
Diarrhoea	1
Sanguine	1
Top Dash	0

 

[Dear Reader]

I'd like to give one of my 0s to this site's servers 

[AdrianNicki]

This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things out? Rate cancelled.

 

Edited September 2 by AdrianNicki