PoisonedIvy Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Is anyone making a playlist of these songs from the bottom up? If not I can work on that tomorrow and post the link in here. I have both Spotify and Apple Music
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 2 Author Posted September 2 234. Girl at Home 5.352 Comments Bussea 10 - "I'm giving it a 10 because F*CK Y'ALL. This song has always been fun and it's been UNFAIRLY hated until that Elvis remix. F*CK Y'ALLLLLLLLL." My Tears Ricochet 10 - "Girl at home haters needs to see a doctor to clear their clogged ears first and then seek Jesus. Elvira remix just made an already solid bop to Pop perfection." Safe&Sound 8.2 - "STOP GIRL AT HOME SLANDER. This song is a form of feminism writing that I like from Taylor. She showed that she's defending the other woman in her own way, unlike that song in Lover which is very on the nose." gagacasanova 8 - "Taylor's Version clears with ease, OG version found dead in a ditch." LoveInStereo 7.9 - "The yassification of this song deserved more fanfare. The OG was cute but the production held it back. It was always meant to be a bop. "if I hadn't once been just like her" gives the song some substance & depth. It maintains a great balance between giving us both something to think about and something to dance to." SLUTTVFTV 7.3 - "The TV kinda goes awf ngl." Peroxide 7.2 - "The re-recording is a bit of a trip but the song itself is pretty decent." Yog 7 - "I have no idea why people hate this song." Miles. 7 - "The TV majorly upgraded this, the original was a 1." greento 7 - "The original was fine, I do prefer the new production though. Not quite sure why it got so much hate back in the day..." Where are you now? 6.2 - "Elvira at Home kinda slaps!" By the Water 6 - "We love you, Elvira!" wastedpotential 5.4 - "The way Vanessa Hudgens At Home turned into Gaga At Home during the New Testamentization of Redemption... Sometimes I feel confident that She loves us, and other times I feel confident that She absolutely despises us. The original was also bad (it's the one I scored and is the reason this didn't even leave the bottom 95% of my rankings here), but the Elvirafication of this song seems like an anti-gay hate crime, a mockery of the music we purportedly enjoy. Have we decided if this was originally written after the incident behind the scenes at Ellen that one time or if it was from some other part of the The Giver (blech) movie promo cycle? My memory fails me as I age into retirement and I fear I've lost the background details to time. I'm gonna need one of the girls stuck in the Red era (love y'all, but you know who you are) to come answer me." blown away 4.5 - "Bland and forgettable." Achilles. 4 - "UNYASSIFY HER." Nein 4 - "The Taylor's Version sucks too." Flames2Embers 2 - "Yaasssification GAH is the way to go." 1989 1 - "lol" The Music Industry 0 - "This song should've been kept OUT of Red. The fact that it made the cut while songs like Nothing New, Babe, Better Man and Forever Winter were booted out is incomprehensible. Girl At Home is just too lyrically simplistic, lacks emotional depth, has a very boring production (Elvira adding pots and pans did not help), and just the fact that it might be about Zac Efron is a no for me. OUT! :bam:" Results Spoiler MusicLoverDude 6 Starchild 4 AshleyLovescats887 10 AbeHicks 10 paulyyyozd 10 Bussea 10 My Tears Ricochet 10 Bartender 10 reputation1989 9.9 djcalpal 9 Supernatural 9 makeawish 9 Diarrhoea 9 AdrianNicki 9 LastKiss 8.8 idkwiam 8.5 Safe&Sound 8.2 PaloSanto 8 305 8 gagacasanova 8 Venice B 8 burninredhot 8 fridayteenage 8 Swirl900 8 Rev8 8 wehavetostan 8 LoveInStereo 7.9 Cruel Summer 7.8 brokee 7.7 beagle 7.6 NordicGuy 7.5 badidearight 7.5 halcyonday 7.5 Mocha 7.5 creativity. 7.5 PoisonedIvy 7.5 Sanguine 7.5 Top Dash 7.5 SLUTTVFTV 7.3 Michael196 7.3 Peroxide 7.2 Bindi 7.2 greento 7 Live To Tell 7 CamiloPg_ 7 folkloreking 7 Enrique523 7 ChapelHooker 7 Iamanearthling 7 jacobhalkohit 7 vinicius 7 Yog 7 Schami66 7 Miles. 7 Sad Beautiful Tragic 7 Quicksand 7 Kyle-x 7 enchanted0 7 greeneyedsoul 7 Blood Magic 7 MidnightsAtPeace 6.8 pinkbowvintage 6.5 Ampersand13 6.5 liam13 6.5 pavi 6.5 Edge of Glory 6.5 tb6591 6.2 TaylenaStan 6.2 Where are you now? 6.2 DevilsRollTheDice 6 4Real 6 KillingYourCareer 6 Soobin 6 Vespertine 6 Gorjesspazze9 6 Axolotl 6 tjspy 6 modern thing 6 Catch22 6 BOAZ 6 Flower 6 chiliam 6 K$Ellie 6 By the Water 6 StonedSoulPicnic 6 PerfectSacrifice 5.9 skizzo 5.5 wastedpotential 5.4 roso 5.1 sanzo 5 Arrows 5 Riverbank 5 Life Savers 5 @freakum. 5 Fitzswiftie 5 G.U.Y_Del_Rey 5 Losing my ground 5 GuyNextDoor 5 americanlife 5 RihannaLoverrr 5 holyground13 5 Strawberry Bubble 5 Clauss 5 twoheadlightshine 5 fab 5 yourfaveisaflop 5 TheArgonaut 4.5 blown away 4.5 Lorenzo22 4.5 terrorblade 4 SylMacPer 4 llikeh 4 Tusk 4 chosensparkles 4 Prismee 4 Terylee 4 Nein 4 ONOPKA 4 FolkLover1989 4 Heldenzeit 4 NewStanner 4 Achilles. 4 heckinglovato 4 Hurem 3.5 Dear Reader 3.5 Solaria 3 itsjem 3 D-@-N 3 frankvert 3 Tedwards 3 LVP 3 Ger.vaz 3 Klein 3 Hooker Barbie 3 kyungsoowift 3 SleepingTigers 3 jacklovesyou1 3 Don 3 TMRA 3 SoSickOfThatSOL 3 StØned 2.9 Mr. Duff 2.2 Forever Winter 2 NEX 2 Theluckyone 2 Velvet Night 2 Feanor 2 Great Username 2 NextBish90 2 Flames2Embers 2 Byzantium 2 Lazuli 2 Bosque 2 1989 1 Teen Spirit 1 a_d_22 1 Namigo 1 Mezik 1 LovaticSwiftie 1 ellis-bell 1 sparrowblue 1 Taylor fanboy 1 Ms. Togekiss 1 The Music Industry 0 Avrileon 0 Holy Ground 0 1
holyground13 Posted September 2 Posted September 2 5 minutes ago, Catch22 said: Superstar is fairly rated but it's NOT worse than That's When, be real That's When is so cute! Keith Urban sounds hot on it too and I love the production 4
Dear Reader Posted September 2 Posted September 2 well Gaga at Home should've been out for a long time
Taylor fanboy Posted September 2 Posted September 2 I fear the rule of no 1s and/or 2s for an album benefited LOSER by a LOT. What is YNTCD, The Man, London Boy, The Archer, Daylight, still doing here? 1
AdrianNicki Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Oh no! Not one of my faves. I love that song (Taylor's version that it, the OG is dogshit).
Tusk Posted September 2 Posted September 2 3 minutes ago, PoisonedIvy said: Ok I'm starting to believe that @AshleyLovescats887 really is Taylor's ATRL burner, because some of these scores and defenses for the absolute bottom of the barrel of her catalogue.. It's very telling to what songs she has left comments on...and the way she commented. I believe. 1
PoisonedIvy Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Red is so polarizing fr, it has some of her absolute best and some of her absolute worst 1 2
Klein Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Just now, Cruel Summer said: the is NOT what I expected and now I'm mad Not what I expected either but I'm even happier Bye bye Vanessa Hudgens 1
wastedpotential Posted September 2 Posted September 2 3 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Have we decided if this was originally written after the incident behind the scenes at Ellen that one time or if it was from some other part of the The Giver (blech) movie promo cycle? My memory fails me as I age into retirement and I fear I've lost the background details to time. I'm gonna need one of the girls stuck in the Red era (love y'all, but you know who you are) to come answer me." Looking for an answer
AshleyLovescats887 Posted September 2 Posted September 2 3 minutes ago, PoisonedIvy said: Ok I'm starting to believe that @AshleyLovescats887 really is Taylor's ATRL burner, because some of these scores and defenses for the absolute bottom of the barrel of her catalogue..
gagacasanova Posted September 2 Posted September 2 (edited) Taylor's Version ... BANGER lemme go give Her a listen Edited September 2 by gagacasanova
Cruel Summer Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Goddess At Home could have been so good if it was finished as a country pop song.
Tusk Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Who Taylor still give Zac Efron a second glance with his new face? Discuss. 1
Starchild Posted September 2 Posted September 2 3 minutes ago, NewStanner said: I don't like this one at all, no matter which version it is But it's not offensive, so I guess a 4 from me was a fair score Nnn same thoughts, I gave it a 4 too 1
Miles. Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Obsessed with the new conspiracy theory that @AshleyLovescats887 is Taylor's burner account. Either way, LOVE that she is giving 10s to basically every song in the rate 2
By the Water Posted September 2 Posted September 2 Lilly Jay at Home (Elvira's Version) is a bop. Y'all need to get serious 1 1
Cruel Summer Posted September 2 Posted September 2 So I started listening to Fearless TV to mourn its first loss and kinda realized just this second that The Other Side of the Door is kinda just Mine but before Mine, like you know?
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 2 Author Posted September 2 The moment many of you have been waiting for. Quote "This unapologetic female rage is everything."
Recommended Posts