Jump to content

The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page


Recommended Posts

Posted
1 minute ago, Peroxide said:

Gorgeous still bring in… a war crime.

I suddenly wanna take back all the heart reacts I gave to you.

 

:clack:

  • Haha 1

  • Replies 10k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Brooklyn Baby

    1241

  • wastedpotential

    837

  • Dear Reader

    463

  • Klein

    375

Posted (edited)

Not 'thanK you aIMee' being lower than 'Robin' ..we won robin stans:suburban:

Edited by AshleyLovescats887
Posted (edited)

THANK YOU KIM IS OUT 

 

real-housewives-housewives.gif

Edited by wastedpotential
Posted

well bye kim

 

NewStanner

Posted

Oh that's - 

 

Before London Boy? Seriously?

  • Like 1
Posted

I swear I'm sabotating evermore next rate.

 

MIc7wn0.thumb.gif.09b51e3f687ed1c1a148db

  • Like 4
Posted
Just now, Forever Winter said:

31rXekD91oL._UF1000,1000_QL80_.jpg

 

242. thanK you aIMee

5.124

 

Comments

Bussea

7.5 - "I hate that oily pear shaped miss potato headed ass ho. KEEP WACKING HER TAYLOR!!! And Ku Klux Kanye."

MusicLoverDude

7 - "This is fine but it could have been better."

LoveInStereo

6.3 - "If the campfire song from SpongeBob was petty."

Edge of Glory

5.5 - "I swing between thinking she should be able to write about her traumas no matter how long ago they happened, and being like...girl this happened when OBAMA was still in office LIIIIIIIIIIIKE. anyway.......... great melodies, beautiful melodies."

wastedpotential

4.8 - ""What would happen if you just called Taylor up and ask what happened, how did this go so South?" Kris said. "This is what I don't understand. Because I really do like her and I like her team, and I like her mom. I don't understand what made her flip so quickly." /// "I'm Taylor's publicist and this is my UNEDITED original statement. Btw, when you take parts out, that's editing. "Kanye did not call for approval, but to ask Taylor to release his single "Famous" on her Twitter account. She declined and cautioned him about releasing a song with such a strong misogynistic message. Taylor was never made aware of the actual lyric, "I made that ***** famous." P.S. who did you guys piss off to leak that video?""

Achilles.

4 - "The novelty wore off fast."

KillingYourCareer

3 - "The melody is really nice, but the song is pure cringe, so I can't give it a higher mark. It's been many years, let it go."

blown away

2.7 - "No thank you."

Forever Winter

2 - "Why? Just why? I don't even mind her dragging Kim in 2024, but why make such a childish-sounding song out of it? We also didn't need her letters capitalised in the title to figure out who it was about. :skull:"

Life Savers

1 - "DELETE IT."

Miles.

1 - "We already have mad woman, we didn't need this cringefest."

sparrowblue

1 - "Yawning."

Nein

0 - "Another **** song."

My Tears Ricochet

0 - "This song is the nastiest sk*nk sh*t I've ever heard. Do not rate her. She is an ugly song."

Lazuli

0 - "Seriously... This song COULD'VE made me unstan her."

 

Results

  Hide contents

 

Starchild 7
AshleyLovescats887 10
AbeHicks 10
Diarrhoea 10
Taylor fanboy 10
SoSickOfThatSOL 10
heckinglovato 10
PaloSanto 9.5
Namigo 9
Enrique523 9
fridayteenage 9
Catch22 9
SleepingTigers 9
Kyle-x 9
TheArgonaut 8.8
Where are you now? 8.8
holyground13 8.7
PerfectSacrifice 8.6
PoisonedIvy 8.6
folkloreking 8.5
Ampersand13 8.5
idkwiam 8.4
Cruel Summer 8.4
Live To Tell 8
Venice B 8
makeawish 8
Strawberry Bubble 8
Byzantium 8
Heldenzeit 8
greeneyedsoul 8
K$Ellie 8
Bosque 8
Ms. Togekiss 7.9
MidnightsAtPeace 7.8
Bindi 7.8
Mr. Duff 7.7
tb6591 7.5
1989 7.5
LastKiss 7.5
gagacasanova 7.5
Yog 7.5
SLUTTVFTV 7.5
Sad Beautiful Tragic 7.5
Bussea 7.5
Quicksand 7.5
Sanguine 7.5
Peroxide 7.4
beagle 7.3
Iamanearthling 7.2
djcalpal 7.1
305 7
chosensparkles 7
reputation1989 7
Gorjesspazze9 7
Fitzswiftie 7
brokee 7
BOAZ 7
MusicLoverDude 7
Safe&Sound 7
enchanted0 7
Don 7
roso 6.8
pinkbowvintage 6.5
Soobin 6.5
Velvet Night 6.5
ChapelHooker 6.5
RihannaLoverrr 6.5
Top Dash 6.5
LoveInStereo 6.3
greento 6.2
Axolotl 6
vinicius 6
G.U.Y_Del_Rey 6
burninredhot 6
kyungsoowift 6
Flames2Embers 6
chiliam 6
Bartender 6
Blood Magic 6
NordicGuy 5.9
tjspy 5.5
americanlife 5.5
By the Water 5.5
Edge of Glory 5.5
Lorenzo22 5.5
SylMacPer 5.4
terrorblade 5
sanzo 5
llikeh 5
Arrows 5
Schami66 5
Mezik 5
Dear Reader 5
paulyyyozd 5
Klein 5
pavi 5
NewStanner 5
StØned 4.9
wastedpotential 4.8
Avrileon 4
itsjem 4
Vespertine 4
badidearight 4
halcyonday 4
Losing my ground 4
ONOPKA 4
Hooker Barbie 4
Swirl900 4
fab 4
AdrianNicki 4
TMRA 4
Achilles. 4
wehavetostan 4
creativity. 3.5
Clauss 3.5
DevilsRollTheDice 3
CamiloPg_ 3
KillingYourCareer 3
skizzo 3
Tusk 3
Riverbank 3
@freakum. 3
D-@-N 3
jacobhalkohit 3
Great Username 3
Tedwards 3
GuyNextDoor 3
Terylee 3
modern thing 3
twoheadlightshine 3
blown away 2.7
The Music Industry 2
Forever Winter 2
Ger.vaz 2
ellis-bell 2
yourfaveisaflop 2
Rev8 2
NextBish90 1.1
Solaria 1
NEX 1
Teen Spirit 1
4Real 1
a_d_22 1
Life Savers 1
frankvert 1
Feanor 1
Prismee 1
LVP 1
Miles. 1
Supernatural 1
Mocha 1
TaylenaStan 1
Holy Ground 1
LovaticSwiftie 1
FolkLover1989 1
Flower 1
jacklovesyou1 1
sparrowblue 1
StonedSoulPicnic 1
Theluckyone 0
Hurem 0
liam13 0
Nein 0
My Tears Ricochet 0
Lazuli 0
Michael196 0

 

the capitalization of KIM is one of the most cringe things she's ever done, embarassing
some songs should just stay in the vault
MIc7wn0.thumb.gif.09b51e3f687ed1c1a148db

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1
  • Haha 1
Posted

Worst song on The Anthology

Posted

I'm a Tortured Poets Asylum hater but there are worse songs than Thank You Kim.

Posted

Not this being the first one I don't agree with 

:suburban:
 

y'all hate it but she didn't lie 

:clack:

  • Thanks 1
Posted

Should've gave aiMee a 11 smh 

Posted

ATRL being a cesspool of misogyny.

 

Us Thank you Amen stans are FEMINISTS and a GIRL'S GIRL.

 

spacer.png

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
  • Haha 1
Posted

Me seeing Taylor write this song about Kim:

its-what-she-deserves-kim-kardashian.gif

 

 

Me seeing this song's placement in the rate:

its-what-she-deserves-kim-kardashian.gif

  • Haha 5
Posted

Oh, my first 10 out :weeps: 

 

I was a B.o.B STAN back in the day, I even bought Strange Clouds.  Still love it (and Both Of Us) to this day :flower: 

Posted
3 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

Bussea

7.5 - "I hate that oily pear shaped miss potato headed ass ho. KEEP WACKING HER TAYLOR!!! And Ku Klux Kanye."

 

@Bussea :bibliahh:

  • Haha 1
Posted
1 hour ago, Forever Winter said:

Ed-Sheeran-Taylor-Swift-Getty-H-2023.jpg

 

259. The Joker and The Queen (3.953)

 

Nein

8 - "This is so underrated."

wastedpotential

6.4 - "Ed tried booking Taylor for a hit, but no one told him Swifties don't give a **** about what she does on other people's albums. I guess he was trying to leverage her for the post-release revamp of whatever album this came from, but like... even Lord's singles with Ed underperformed pretty hard (I mean I don't know why he thought we'd go for this when EHC and End Fame haven't exactly set the strongest record), so clearly he should've known better. This is a funeral song, a real dirge of a song to get through, though the strings are decent. I will say this gives me flashbacks to an ATRL insider giving me tea about this, which I shared a screenshot of with ONE group chat of like five beloved oomfs, where one of them took it and spread it to all of her group chats, and then like three months later I got an understandably angry PM from that insider with a link to a highly liked instagram post with that screenshot... oh that was humiliating. It seems that user has deleted their ATRL profile (their username used to be ialmostdo, if anyone knows them off ATRL please let them know that I still feel horrible about it). For whatever it's worth I'm no longer speaking with that oomf ddd. Still, the song is pretty meh and my own personal guilts just bring it down further."

Forever Winter

2.5 - "Can she please stop working with this man. There better not be any f*cking Ed features in the rep vault."

Where are you now?

1.8 - "I aint reading all that i'm happy for u tho or sorry that happened."

blown away

1 - "Among the worst songs on the entire list, but I'm not wasting my 0 on this. I have enough faith that everyone else will drag this song through the mud."

Bosque

1 - "A trite sappy mess."

Achilles.

0 - "Forget about hopping on quick little remixes of hit songs, I would settle for her hopping on quick little remixes of songs that are at least worth listening to."

 

Results

  Reveal hidden contents

 

MusicLoverDude 6
Starchild 3
AbeHicks 10
reputation1989 9.1
Mr. Duff 9
Kyle-x 9
MidnightsAtPeace 8.7
Hurem 8.5
TheArgonaut 8.2
Nein 8
brokee 7.8
Michael196 7.6
folkloreking 7.5
Blood Magic 7.5
tb6591 7.2
Avrileon 7.1
PerfectSacrifice 7.1
PaloSanto 7
Live To Tell 7
Iamanearthling 7
Fitzswiftie 7
Supernatural 7
Terylee 7
fridayteenage 7
makeawish 7
holyground13 7
BOAZ 7
SoSickOfThatSOL 7
beagle 6.9
305 6.5
@freakum. 6.5
Catch22 6.5
Heldenzeit 6.5
My Tears Ricochet 6.5
LoveInStereo 6.5
wastedpotential 6.4
itsjem 6.3
llikeh 6
LastKiss 6
Vespertine 6
Gorjesspazze9 6
Axolotl 6
Yog 6
Schami66 6
G.U.Y_Del_Rey 6
liam13 6
Don 6
Bindi 6
Lorenzo22 6
TaylenaStan 5.7
Cruel Summer 5.6
kyungsoowift 5.5
SleepingTigers 5.5
SLUTTVFTV 5.2
sanzo 5
Arrows 5
Tusk 5
chosensparkles 5
badidearight 5
Enrique523 5
ChapelHooker 5
Venice B 5
vinicius 5
djcalpal 5
Sad Beautiful Tragic 5
burninredhot 5
Strawberry Bubble 5
twoheadlightshine 5
Flower 5
greeneyedsoul 5
NewStanner 5
Edge of Glory 5
wehavetostan 5
Ms. Togekiss 5
SylMacPer 4.6
jacobhalkohit 4.5
Quicksand 4.5
Peroxide 4.2
pinkbowvintage 4
CamiloPg_ 4
D-@-N 4
halcyonday 4
Ger.vaz 4
Holy Ground 4
Klein 4
Bussea 4
Flames2Embers 4
Byzantium 4
yourfaveisaflop 4
Safe&Sound 3.8
idkwiam 3.7
Theluckyone 3.5
tjspy 3.2
NordicGuy 3
The Music Industry 3
Riverbank 3
Life Savers 3
Ampersand13 3
Tedwards 3
Mezik 3
RihannaLoverrr 3
Hooker Barbie 3
jacklovesyou1 3
chiliam 3
pavi 3
Rev8 3
heckinglovato 3
roso 2.8
Forever Winter 2.5
PoisonedIvy 2.5
1989 2.3
DevilsRollTheDice 2
a_d_22 2
skizzo 2
gagacasanova 2
Velvet Night 2
Losing my ground 2
ONOPKA 2
LovaticSwiftie 2
paulyyyozd 2
FolkLover1989 2
Clauss 2
enchanted0 2
Top Dash 2
Where are you now? 1.8
Namigo 1.5
Lazuli 1.5
terrorblade 1
Solaria 1
NEX 1
Teen Spirit 1
4Real 1
KillingYourCareer 1
Soobin 1
AshleyLovescats887 1
frankvert 1
Feanor 1
Prismee 1
StØned 1
Miles. 1
NextBish90 1
GuyNextDoor 1
americanlife 1
Mocha 1
modern thing 1
creativity. 1
ellis-bell 1
Swirl900 1
fab 1
Diarrhoea 1
sparrowblue 1
blown away 1
AdrianNicki 1
Taylor fanboy 1
Bartender 1
K$Ellie 1
Bosque 1
By the Water 1
StonedSoulPicnic 1
greento 0
Great Username 0
LVP 0
Dear Reader 0
Sanguine 0
TMRA 0
Achilles. 0

 

finallyyy, i never understood the hype for this song

Posted

HOW IS LONDON BOY STILL IN THE RATE

  • Like 1
  • ATRL Moderator
Posted

I'll admit that Aimee was a total dud for me upon first listen but I absolutely adore it now. Very sad to see it go :ducky:

Posted
Just now, Strawberry Bubble said:

finallyyy, i never understood the hype for this song

Which hype are you talking about? I only ever saw people dragging this song. :deadbanana4:

  • Haha 6
Posted
Quote

"That bizarre accent she does in this song should never be done again."

 

Posted

What's this London Boy hate? It's better than 50% on Lover.

Posted

I gave it a 1 but i didn't think it would be that low lmao

Posted
2 minutes ago, Achilles. said:

Me seeing Taylor write this song about Kim:

its-what-she-deserves-kim-kardashian.gif

 

 

Me seeing this song's placement in the rate:

its-what-she-deserves-kim-kardashian.gif

Exactly, these can both be true. I can hate the woman AND hate the song :suburban:

Posted

Thanks Kim is the worst TTPD song, good job everyone.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
  • Thumbs Down 3
Posted
1 minute ago, Klein said:

Which hype are you talking about? I only ever saw people dragging this song. :deadbanana4:

my friends loved this song lol. I'm going to show them this list and your comment 

  • Haha 1
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.