poll brat vs. E•MO•TION: Better Album?

[nostalgic]

EMOTION all the way & beyond

[bumpah]

i love brat but i love e mo tion more

[Digitalism]

E mo tion felt like it changed something 

Brat feels like another Charli album that just got lucky this time 

[Carla Rosón]

The poll 

 

even with brat being as overrated as it is I'm genuineily flabbergasted at how massively overhyped Emotion remains at its altar of basic white mediocrity

 

never change atrl 

[Baltie]

I love BRAT, but E•MO•TION is the better album, in my opinion. There's just something about it that makes it a pop bible, and it feels euphoric to listen to.

[skankle]

Quote

Every time a new flavour of the month homo pop album is released we get another bout of X vs Emotion threads. But guess which album is still the standard when the next flavour of the month comes around?

I think I first posted this when uhhh Sawayama was released and well, here we are! Almost 10 years on and Emotion is still the standard 

[Ger]

On 7/25/2024 at 10:30 AM, tjspy said:

I sometimes feel sorry for people that don't understand how Run Away With Me encapsulates everything that's perfect about pop music.

Yup, you are right and you should say it.

[Daddy]

I honestly can't choose. Brat is my E.MO.TION of 2024 sooooo... 

[UrMom]

Emotion! If there's one pop album that actually deserves 95 on MetaCritic, it's that

 

[Technicolor]

Emotion is still amazing so that one, Brat is really good tho

[prézli]

I Didn't Just Come Here to Dance clears.

[TaylorsSquad]

E•MO•TION is better by a landslide. 

[Kanes]

BRAT

[Mighty Oaks]

SHAT is one of the worst albums I've ever listened to, so Carly wins with ease. 

[Jay07]

I like Charli but I think brat is a little overrated. It's good but Charli had been putting good albums out for a while, Pop 2, how I'm feeling now are as good as brat so I'm not sure why this one hit so big. That said, I think Emotion is kind of a perfect and timeless pop album so that one.

[superben]

No pop album is better than Emotion since Emotion's release.