suburbannature Posted June 9 Posted June 9 Just now, XtiRih said: So you want to include more than just solo songs in the conversation? Christina's catalog since 2010 has sold (and outstreamed) better than anything Mariah has released since 1995 combined That's literally a lie Mariah's career post-1995 still surpasses in album sales by 20 million or 36% Mariah since 1995: Butterfly (1997) - 10 million #1s (1998) - 15 million Rainbow (1999) - 8 million Glitter (2001) - 2 million Greatest Hits (2002) - 5 million Charmbracelet (2002) - 3 million Emancipation (2005) - 10 million Einstein (2008) - 3 million Memoirs (2009) - 2 million Misc - 1.5 million = 59.5 million (and I removed some to err on the side of caution btw) Christina Career: Debut (1999) - 14 million Mi Reflejo (2000) - 2.5 million My Kind of Christmas (2000) - 1.5 million Stripped (2002) - 11 million Back to Basics (2006) - 4 million Keeps Getting Better (2008) - 1.5 million Burlesque (2010) - 1.5 million Bionic (2010) - 1 million Lotus (2012) - 600k Liberation (2018) - 250k The recent ones - 100kish = 38 million I actually inflated some to err on the side of caution) 5 1
XtiRih Posted June 9 Posted June 9 (edited) 18 minutes ago, suburbannature said: That's literally a lie Mariah's career post-1995 still surpasses in album sales by 20 million or 36% Mariah since 1995: Butterfly (1997) - 10 million #1s (1998) - 15 million Rainbow (1999) - 8 million Glitter (2001) - 2 million Greatest Hits (2002) - 5 million Charmbracelet (2002) - 3 million Emancipation (2005) - 10 million Einstein (2008) - 3 million Memoirs (2009) - 2 million Misc - 1.5 million = 59.5 million (and I removed some to err on the side of caution btw) Christina Career: Debut (1999) - 14 million Mi Reflejo (2000) - 2.5 million My Kind of Christmas (2000) - 1.5 million Stripped (2002) - 11 million Back to Basics (2006) - 4 million Keeps Getting Better (2008) - 1.5 million Burlesque (2010) - 1.5 million Bionic (2010) - 1 million Lotus (2012) - 600k Liberation (2018) - 250k The recent ones - 100kish = 38 million I actually inflated some to err on the side of caution) Since 2000* my bad lmao Glitter 2,100,000 Charmbracelet 3,100,000 Greatest Hits (2002) - 4,000,000 The Emancipation of Mimi 9,000,000 E=MC² 2,110,000 Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel 1,100,000 Merry Christmas II You 900,000 Me. I Am Mariah... The Elusive Chanteuse 305,000 Caution 200,000 Thank God I Found You 1,200,000 Loverboy 900,000 It's Like That 1200,000 We Belong Together 6,000,000 Shake It Off 2,000,000 Don't Forget About Us 1,500,000 Touch My Body 5,000,000 Bye Bye 1,500,000 Oh Santa! 500,000 I Want to Know What Love Is 1,000,000 #Beautiful 2,000,000 since 2010 Bionic 1,000,000 Burlesque 1,500,000 Lotus 650,000 Liberation 300,000 Not Myself Tonight 1,500,000 You Lost Me 800,000 Burlesque songs 3,000,000 Moves Like Jagger 22,000,000 Say Something 7,000,000 Feel This Moment 5,500,000 Your Body 1,500,000 Just a Fool 1,500,000 Hoy Tengo Ganas de Ti 1,000,000 Edited June 9 by XtiRih
suburbannature Posted June 9 Posted June 9 3 minutes ago, XtiRih said: Since 2000* my bad lmao Glitter 2,100,000 Charmbracelet 3,100,000 Greatest Hits (2002) - 4,000,000 The Emancipation of Mimi 9,000,000 E=MC² 2,110,000 Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel 1,100,000 Merry Christmas II You 900,000 Me. I Am Mariah... The Elusive Chanteuse 305,000 Caution 200,000 Thank God I Found You 1,200,000 Loverboy 900,000 It's Like That 1200,000 We Belong Together 6,000,000 Shake It Off 2,000,000 Don't Forget About Us 1,500,000 Touch My Body 5,000,000 Bye Bye 1,500,000 Oh Santa! 500,000 I Want to Know What Love Is 1,000,000 #Beautiful 2,000,000 since 2010 Bionic 1,000,000 Burlesque 1,500,000 Lotus 650,000 Liberation 300,000 Not Myself Tonight 1,500,000 You Lost Me 800,000 Burlesque songs 3,000,000 Moves Like Jagger 22,000,000 Say Something 7,000,000 Feel This Moment 5,500,000 Your Body 1,500,000 Just a Fool 1,500,000 Hoy Tengo Ganas de Ti 1,000,000 You're giving Trumpie denial of reality 1
XtiRih Posted June 9 Posted June 9 Just now, suburbannature said: You're giving Trumpie denial of reality You're the last person to say that. I'm not the one obsessed with global superstar Jlo 1
Sexyzinger Posted June 9 Author Posted June 9 Me (New York) creating a thread about Xtina clicking like on a post… as I sit back watching other fandoms of 40 year old baldies post pages scouring the internet for every single piece of "evidence" they can find of 20 year old fanfic 3
Sexyzinger Posted June 9 Author Posted June 9 Me (New York) creating a thread about Xtina clicking like on a post… as I sit back watching other fandoms of 40 year old baldies post pages scouring the internet for every single piece of "evidence" they can find of 20 year old fanfic
Sexyzinger Posted June 9 Author Posted June 9 Me (New York) creating a thread about Xtina clicking like on a post… as I sit back watching other fandoms of 40 year old baldies post pages scouring the internet for every single piece of "evidence" they can find of 20 year old fanfic
Sexyzinger Posted June 9 Author Posted June 9 Me (New York) creating a thread about Xtina clicking like on a post… as I sit back watching other fandoms of 40 year old baldies post pages scouring the internet for every single piece of "evidence" they can find of 20 year old fanfic
suburbannature Posted June 9 Posted June 9 1 minute ago, Sexyzinger said: Me (New York) creating a thread about Xtina clicking like on a post… as I sit back watching other fandoms of 40 year old baldies post pages scouring the internet for every single piece of "evidence" they can find of 20 year old fanfic 1 minute ago, Sexyzinger said: Me (New York) creating a thread about Xtina clicking like on a post… as I sit back watching other fandoms of 40 year old baldies post pages scouring the internet for every single piece of "evidence" they can find of 20 year old fanfic 1 minute ago, Sexyzinger said: Me (New York) creating a thread about Xtina clicking like on a post… as I sit back watching other fandoms of 40 year old baldies post pages scouring the internet for every single piece of "evidence" they can find of 20 year old fanfic 1 minute ago, Sexyzinger said: Me (New York) creating a thread about Xtina clicking like on a post… as I sit back watching other fandoms of 40 year old baldies post pages scouring the internet for every single piece of "evidence" they can find of 20 year old fanfic We get it. 1
Sexyzinger Posted June 9 Author Posted June 9 1 minute ago, suburbannature said: We get it. It's called a server glitch 😅 1
The Queen Posted June 9 Posted June 9 4 hours ago, ZacXCX said: What an entertaining thread that looks like it came straight out of 2002. I'm far from being a Little Xtinaster, but getting 4 pages out of a like is impressive. I want her to like a Britney post next. Get the geriatrics going. She doesn't follow her since the body shaming post. It's better that way, probably B would get mad for not getting a repost by X in her twirling/modeling videos.
Cry Posted June 9 Posted June 9 3 hours ago, suburbannature said: That's literally a lie Mariah's career post-1995 still surpasses in album sales by 20 million or 36% Mariah since 1995: Butterfly (1997) - 10 million #1s (1998) - 15 million Rainbow (1999) - 8 million Glitter (2001) - 2 million Greatest Hits (2002) - 5 million Charmbracelet (2002) - 3 million Emancipation (2005) - 10 million Einstein (2008) - 3 million Memoirs (2009) - 2 million Misc - 1.5 million = 59.5 million (and I removed some to err on the side of caution btw) Christina Career: Debut (1999) - 14 million Mi Reflejo (2000) - 2.5 million My Kind of Christmas (2000) - 1.5 million Stripped (2002) - 11 million Back to Basics (2006) - 4 million Keeps Getting Better (2008) - 1.5 million Burlesque (2010) - 1.5 million Bionic (2010) - 1 million Lotus (2012) - 600k Liberation (2018) - 250k The recent ones - 100kish = 38 million I actually inflated some to err on the side of caution) The sharp decline from Stripped to Back to Basics… and the fact that it also never recovered from there… poor girl.
Xtina23 Posted June 9 Posted June 9 Not this thread being an all-out war between the lambs and fighters when all Xtina did was like Mariah's Instagram post 6
Bears01 Posted June 9 Posted June 9 The way this site holds on to decades old drama for dear life is really sad
La Reina Posted June 10 Posted June 10 11 hours ago, Death & Decay said: I love how Xtina liking one of Mariah's posts has sent ATRL into a tailspin. The chokehold Xtina has on this place… There was NO reason for this thread to be 5 pages long but they just couldn't help themselves by posting old stuff from 15+ years ago. And siding with awful people who bullied Xtina first (like P!nk, Kelly & Avril) just because you hate Xtina that much is pathetic. They always show who they really are. 3
La Reina Posted June 10 Posted June 10 11 hours ago, Rocket said: She does however have her hand tightly griped around that Ozempic pen. Ironic of you to say this when Mariah's ex-manager literally exposed the receipts of the endless surgeries Mariah got to lose weight and attempt to look better, whereas your Ozempic claims are unsubstantiated. Check who you stan first before coming for anyone, you tryhard. 1 3
Bubble Tea Posted June 10 Posted June 10 Squabbling about Mimi / Xtina sales in here like its 2003 ddd 2
unbothered Posted June 10 Posted June 10 I'm not surprised. She probably still stanned for her musically. I think this performance is a childhood memory for her too.
unbothered Posted June 10 Posted June 10 On 6/8/2024 at 6:50 PM, 305 said: Wait was there beef between them? Mariah never gave Xtina a chance. She was unnecessarily shady to her for no reason due to the media's comparisons to her like how she was to Ariana in the beginning. It was never Xtina, herself saying she was the "new Mariah" and all that. Regardless, Mariah took offense and I think Xtina retaliated back cause of Mariah treated her poorly for no reason, when in all actuality, Xtina came out always praising Mariah to the high heavens. 3 3
dirrtydiana Posted June 10 Posted June 10 12 minutes ago, unbothered said: Mariah never gave Xtina a chance. She was unnecessarily shady to her for no reason due to the media's comparisons to her like how she was to Ariana in the beginning. It was never Xtina, herself saying she was the "new Mariah" and all that. Regardless, Mariah took offense and I think Xtina retaliated back cause of Mariah treated her poorly for no reason, when in all actuality, Xtina came out always praising Mariah to the high heavens. Wheres this part in your post? https://forums.thefashionspot.com/threads/christina-aguilera-slams-mariah-carey.97501/
Sexyzinger Posted June 10 Author Posted June 10 17 minutes ago, dirrtydiana said: Wheres this part in your post? https://forums.thefashionspot.com/threads/christina-aguilera-slams-mariah-carey.97501/ Someone commented at that link: Quote Go Christina. I remember Christina saying in a mag that she was once at an awards/concert thing where they were both performing and Christina wanted to meet Mariah as she has looked up to her and Mariah went "NO, NO WAY". Some 16 year old singer wants to meet her idol and she couldn't even spare 5 mins to say hi. What a b*tch. It just goes to show how nervous Mariah is of younger talented singers. You didn't see Madonna, Janet or Whitney do this to Christina or Britney. is this true? Also, with all of these 20 and 30 something girlies stanning and citing Xtina. She has shown them nothing but love
BionicWooHoo Posted June 10 Posted June 10 Lmaoooooo all this over Xtina liking a post while she probably was taking a dump or something 4 1
dirrtydiana Posted June 11 Posted June 11 4 hours ago, Sexyzinger said: Someone commented at that link: is this true? Also, with all of these 20 and 30 something girlies stanning and citing Xtina. She has shown them nothing but love I'm a big fan of both but yes it's probably true. Mariah is notoriously defensive about newcomers who get called "the new Mariah" 2
Recommended Posts