Shinning Posted June 4 Posted June 4 41 minutes ago, Matthew said: Even Lemonade had more impact And both are more iconic and impactful than any Gaga album so why are you even talking? 4 2
AxelFox Posted June 4 Posted June 4 They're doing a bit much with this, especially when you consider the other images on the list. But as somebody pointed out already, this is definitely an iconic image for 21st century music and pop culture. It's simple yet very symbolic and easily recognizable. Definitely her best album artwork too and one that I feel will have the most staying power alongside the DIL one. I know people raved about the Cowboy Carter one but I don't think it's as effective nor does it evoke the same feeling of importance. 2
Pinkbutterflies Posted June 4 Posted June 4 4 minutes ago, Shinning said: And both are more iconic and impactful than any Gaga album so why are you even talking? What kind of impact did any of Beys albums have except for a gauge to reveal delusional people?
Album Leak Posted June 4 Posted June 4 (edited) 12 minutes ago, AxelFox said: They're doing a bit much with this, especially when you consider the other images on the list. But as somebody pointed out already, this is definitely an iconic image for 21st century music and pop culture. It's simple yet very symbolic and easily recognizable. Definitely her best album artwork too and one that I feel will have the most staying power alongside the DIL one. I know people raved about the Cowboy Carter one but I don't think it's as effective nor does it evoke the same feeling of importance. In the sense that they were trying to find something even relatively iconic from the past 5 years of pop culture and celebrity zeitgeist, I think it's an okay pick, and it overall mashes decently well with a lot of the themes of the images that were chosen. But I think a more fitting image overall would've been a paparazzi photo of Brtiney Spear's meltdown, as it does showcase the absolute harrowing side to the celebrity culture and it's effects on people, perhaps moreso women. And let's be real, those images are burned in the head of most people who saw them at the time. Janet Jackson's nipslip would've also been a good choice, though admittedly that's more of a moment rather than a singular picture. They also debated on Marilyn Monroe or the Kardashians, which admittedly would also be decent picks for different reasons. Edited June 4 by Album Leak
Mordecai Posted June 4 Posted June 4 beyonce is an incredibly gifted and talented artist, that doesn't mean we need to worship the ground she walks on with publications like this 1
AxelFox Posted June 4 Posted June 4 2 minutes ago, Album Leak said: In the sense that they were trying to find something even relatively iconic from the past 5 years of pop culture and celebrity zeitgeist, I think it's an okay pick, and it overall mashes decently well with a lot of the themes of the images that were chosen. But I think a more fitting image overall would've been a paparazzi photo of Brtiney Spear's meltdown, as it does showcase the absolute harrowing side to the celebrity culture and it's effects on people, perhaps moreso women. Janet Jackson's nipslip would've also been a good choice, though admittedly that's more of a moment rather than a singular picture. They also debated on Marilyn Monroe or the Kardashians, which admittedly would also be decent picks for different reasons. I agree, these would've been great picks as well and representative of what they were trying to showcase there. But as they pointed out as well, there's a deeper cultural meaning to what she tried to achieve with this album compared to a pic of Britney spears with the umbrella - highlighting Black queer contributions to music in the culture because, very frequently, those same contributions are erased or attributed to someone else. Especially in pop culture. And that's probably what made them go with it in the end. 1
Arrows Posted June 4 Posted June 4 It's not even among the 25 most important female album covers. Even Beyoncé herself has several more era-defining images than this.
LoveInStereo Posted June 4 Posted June 4 Should've been Kim K's break the internet pic that was completely unavoidable. This cover was a big deal to gay ppl & pop stans but it didn't have widespread reach, sorry! 3
byzantium Posted June 4 Posted June 4 (edited) I feel like this is a narrative certain "culture critics" in high castles are pushing rather than it being organically true. Edited June 4 by byzantium
on the line Posted June 4 Posted June 4 And Beyonce claiming songwriting credits for the photo in 3, 2, ....too late.
DorothyVallens Posted June 4 Posted June 4 Americans are so self-centered, it's crazy. Most of those pictures are America-defining, not world-defining. About 10 gays know about the Beyonce cover in my country, let alone the whole planet. 1
BGKC Posted June 4 Posted June 4 (edited) Omg I would say one of, if not the most iconic album covers of the 2020s so far… but what is thiiiisss, honey? A photo that defines the modern age? Edited June 4 by BGKC
Lose My Breath Posted June 4 Posted June 4 47 minutes ago, LoveInStereo said: Should've been Kim K's break the internet pic that was completely unavoidable. This cover was a big deal to gay ppl & pop stans but it didn't have widespread reach, sorry! No. She literally has no talent, and is famous for being famous. Lets not celebrate that. I like Kim, but no thanks
ScorpiosGroove Posted June 4 Posted June 4 1 hour ago, Pinkbutterflies said: What kind of impact did any of Beys albums have except for a gauge to reveal delusional people? ask the two broads in your avi, they'll gladly tell you how beyoncé influenced them OT : the fumes in here ijbol miserable as usual 1 1
byzantium Posted June 4 Posted June 4 35 minutes ago, DorothyVallens said: Americans are so self-centered, it's crazy. Most of those pictures are America-defining, not world-defining. About 10 gays know about the Beyonce cover in my country, let alone the whole planet. It's literally an American newspaper. Why would you expect it to be talking about your country?
QueenBeyoncé Posted June 4 Posted June 4 Another hit to the gut that your faves will never be impactful or influential as Beyonce, sucks huh
Recommended Posts