TROPICUM Posted May 26 Posted May 26 (edited) Katy Perry began teasing her new album KP6 & lead single just a few days ago. Lady Gaga just teased and announced her comeback with LG7 and a snippet of its lead single. With the high possibility of both releasing around the same time, who will have more successful/impactful era? While obviously on a decline for several years, Katy's announcement was actually met with a very fair amount of hype around the GP. While Gaga has her new movie superhero (and Oscar darling) franchise Joker 2, or JFAD. Who do you think will be met with more success or acclaim? Will there be any surprises? Edited May 26 by TROPICUM 1
Popular Post blackoutbritney Posted May 26 Popular Post Posted May 26 Let's let both these ladies be successful in their own respective lanes! 28 10
truthteller Posted May 26 Posted May 26 Katy may prevail in the long run as she will deliver multiple visuals and a tour to keep the fans fed while Gaga will just jump from music project to acting project once she gets the album out
liam13 Posted May 26 Posted May 26 i just know they're trying to have another "applause vs roar" moment. my coin is on ga ga's side
Lamb4life Posted May 26 Posted May 26 Katy because her ATRL thread already accumulated over 100 pages while Gaga's is scrambling. 6 2
Sombre Posted May 26 Posted May 26 Who cares? Why are we beating a dead horse 11 years later? Pop music is pop music. I genuinely couldn't give less of a **** about chart performance in 2024. 2
Popular Post Biggie Posted May 26 Popular Post Posted May 26 15 minutes ago, Lamb4life said: Katy because her ATRL thread already accumulated over 100 pages while Gaga's is scrambling. Imagine saying this to a real life person 1 25
WhateverYouWant Posted May 26 Posted May 26 (edited) I think I'll put my money on Katy for now until something is released. Seems like she's trying to go back to what people want from her after trying things people didn't want from her. But with her last two releases I could see her totally dropping the ball again. where gaga gave the gays too much with ARTPOP then went the complete opposite way until Chromatica and it didn't really hit the same way. So now she's trying something new again and it could be good or bad. sales wise I'm sure gaga will do better either way. Edited May 26 by WhateverYouWant
Orsay Posted May 26 Posted May 26 Gaga will do a bigger first week of course. Beyond that i really don't know, there does seem to be a LOT of hype for Katy so hopefully she can get a cute hit! I'm rooting for both 1
Lasso Posted May 26 Posted May 26 i can't imagine either of them making much of a fuzz with their music rn, at least not until we actually know what it's gonna sound like. i feel like joker 2 will keep gaga on the news throughout the year, though, so i'm voting for her
Jotham Posted May 26 Posted May 26 Maybe we should stop pitting the two against each other and just root for their successes
WhateverYouWant Posted May 26 Posted May 26 (edited) 18 minutes ago, Lasso said: i can't imagine either of them making much of a fuzz with their music rn, at least not until we actually know what it's gonna sound like. i feel like joker 2 will keep gaga on the news throughout the year, though, so i'm voting for her I still think releasing a Joker movie as a musical is a big risk. It could be great for her or it could get panned. Musicals lately haven't been getting the most love. I couldn't even get my gay die hard mean girl fan friends to go see the new one in theatre lol. I'm honestly curious to see how this new joker movie does. Edited May 26 by WhateverYouWant
WhateverYouWant Posted May 26 Posted May 26 1 minute ago, Jotham said: Maybe we should stop pitting the two against each other and just root for their successes For the record, I want both to release good music. I'm not rooting for one over the other. 2013 seems so far away now since I enjoyed an album from either. I pray to god at least one of them deliveres this time.
rhaenyra Posted May 26 Posted May 26 I'm personally rooting for Gaga as I'm actually a fan of hers. Even tho Katy beat Gaga around their 2013-14 era, Gaga has beat Katy in everything else
Rino Posted May 26 Posted May 26 nice to see mature replies here. maybe liddos and kats won't be serving Xtina vs Brit stans level of embarassment in 2034 OT: I wish luck to both. actually, I wish commercial success to Katy and critical acclaim for Gaga. 1
Kayseri Mantisi Posted May 26 Posted May 26 didn't "Royals" ruin both of their "moments" in 2013? So the answer is L4 with Lorde 1 2
Mr. Stratus Posted May 26 Posted May 26 (edited) I like how I said Katy wouldn't release without Gaga and here we are! Prob Katy will win in the longrun if Gaga does dance 3 hours ago, Lamb4life said: Katy because her ATRL thread already accumulated over 100 pages while Gaga's is scrambling. Because there's like 10 pages in the Katy base vs. How active Gaga's is, none of them in Katy's music thread are proper fans - most are just the ones that are casuals and want to see her end Gaga/return so they can feel like they are 13 again Edited May 26 by Mr. Stratus 1
Recommended Posts