base talk Do you agree that 1989 > Teenage Dream?

[prettyinpink940]

Both are perfect pop albums, but 1989 takes the crown for me. 

[Wonderland]

No.

[perfect blue]

Stop spamming these stupid threads, @ATRL Moderation Team help

[HardBambi]

Not even MJ is not better than TD

[ThomasTea]

TD >

[Britney Spears]

Yes and it's not even close

[Timeless]

No Teenage Dream is way better. THE pop album of the 2010s decade.

[Scandalous]

no, as a swiftie. 1989 is bottom 2 taylor albums

[Asscatchem]

1989 + TV tracks > TD Complete Confection > 1989 > TD

Edited May 21 by Asscatchem

[Katamari]

Yes

 

 

prism is better than both tho 

[halcyonday]

Teenage Dream is the OG pop perfection.

[Gladiator]

Sorry but no, and its kind of refreshing to see people stop hyping up 1989. I am a Swiftie and 1989 is in the lower tier of her albums after the years have gone by, whereas Teenage Dream is still in the top tier of pop albums.

 

 

Edited May 21 by Gladiator

[Misty2412]

Yes. Teenage Dream is fun, but I much prefer 1989.

[flashfox]

Yes by far.

[AxelFox]

It's more polished and works better as a whole but has nowhere the personality nor is it as infectious as Teenage Dream. 
 

Though considering 1989 would most likely have not existed in the same form if it was not for Teenage Dream before it, I'm gonna go ahead and vote for the latter. 
 

Taylor perfected the formula, but could not recreate the magic and fun imo.

[oceans]

Shake It Off vs California Gurls

Blank Space vs Teenage Dream

Style vs Firework

Bad Blood vs E.T. (Remix)

Wildest Dreams vs. Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.)

Out of the Woods vs  The One That Got Away

New Romantics vs Not Like the Movies

****! vs Circle The Drain

Is It Over Now? vs E.T. (Original)

[liquiddiamonds]

Obviously lol

[shoganai]

No, let's be real.

[Cyber]

teenage dream is something nostalgia of 2010s and won't be forgotten.. along with Gaga's born this way

[jjmed59]

if we're gonna use the charts as a barometer for whats better (like swifties do), then the one with all those number ones is.

 

if not, it's still teenage dream dkskkgkskf there was a divine pop energy on that album that just has not been replicated since

 

((i still lovvveee 1989 and its top 3 tae albums for me))

Edited May 21 by jjmed59

[Aethereal]

both mid

[Mr. Duff]

I love me a lot of Taylor + Style and I Know Places >>>>> any song on Teenage Dream.

 

But overall I find Teenage Dream slightly the stronger album. The singles run was crazy (and all great pop songs). I also love all the album tracks, I mean Hummingbird Heartbeat and Who Am I Living For are bops. 1989 is a strong body of work too, but I prefer other Taylor's pop albums to it.

[CherryBay]

1989 was way too safe and focused on young audience 

TD at least was different in places and had something for everybody that's why TD was so successful era with 6 no.1 in the end

[G.U.Y_Del_Rey]

Yes, I agree

[Virgos Groove]

Duh. TD is beyond overrated.