poll B'Day vs Confessions on a dance floor

[Aethereal]

Both highly successful albums, but which ones has the edge? 

 

Edited May 13 by Aethereal

[naval23]

Confessions for both. B'Day was bigger in the US though

 

Hung Up, Sorry, Get Together, Jump  - the 1-2-3-4 punch of excellence

[selena_lavigne]

I have never enjoyed B'Day. I have tried to enjoy it three times.

Get Together feels like meth.

Edited May 13 by selena_lavigne

[Alexz]

[itshyolee]

B'Day for both, but of course the gays are gonna choose Confessions On a Dance Floor

[Independence]

B'day like most of Beyonce's albums is complete filler. COAD wins with ease

[dopamina]

[XtiRih]

Filter after filter vs one of the best dance pop albums of the 2000s?

 

 

Queen of Pop of course

[Price of Fame]

Confessions sweetie

[Carla Rosón]

Pls this is like comparing Hard Candy vs Lemonade 

[UseYourIllusion2002]

Confessions was bigger and definitely better. B'day isn't a bad album, but it's not perfection like Confessions.

[UnusualBoy]

Girl pls...

[LatinFreak]

COADF has ZERO skips. I'll say that. 

[redsbae]

It's always Beyoncé vs. 

 

she truly is the standard 

[redsbae]

Madonnas international appeal cannot be compared. Confessions was a worldwide smash. Bday was revived with  irreplaceable and beautiful liar. Going with Madge on this 

[Gladiator]

I voted B'Day, which is one of my favorites. My initial listen of Confession was so overhyped. I got into Madonna's discography very late in life, and everyone was hyping up Confessions. For me, it didn't meet the expectations people were hyping it to be. I think I enjoyed 4 tracks. 

[Romova99]

Get Together and Forbidden Luv >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

[QuanticXplosion]

Bigger Star: Madonna 

Bigger era: Madonna's 

Better album: Madonna's 

[Karla Cabello]

bday was better, cod was bigger

[Mtjjproducer]

Bday was better

madonnas was bigger

 

i never could get the hype for confessions. I tolerated hung up when it came out and still kinda like it but hated the rest of the album. 

[king_queen]

1 hour ago, Mtjjproducer said:

Bday was better

madonnas was bigger

 

i never could get the hype for confessions. I tolerated hung up when it came out and still kinda like it but hated the rest of the album. 

This!!!

 

Confessions doesn't have a Freakum Dress so the better album HAS to be B'Day

Edited May 14 by king_queen

[spree]

3 hours ago, Carla Rosón said:

Pls this is like comparing Hard Candy vs Lemonade 

and Hard Candy would win! 

[Aethereal]

22 hours ago, LatinFreak said:

COADF has ZERO skips. I'll say that. 

I love New York has a cringe lyrics however the rest of album was a crafted masterpiece from head to toe. It would been even been bigger if US did not have an anti-Madonna bias..  

[Curaga]

I prefer B'day

[Triton]

Give it to Madonna.