base talk Delete one Taylor Swift album: reputation, Lover, Midnights, TTPD

[skizzo]

I would delete "Lover", but keep "DBATC", "False God", "Cornelia Street", "Cruel Summer" and "Afterglow"

[Strawberry Bubble]

Deleting lover means deleting cruel summer 

[CécredSpaces]

21 hours ago, Cruel Summer said:

I have to go for Lover. It has some great songs and Cruel Summer's resurgence as part of the Eras Tour narrative was amazing to witness, but it feels less essential to the canon of her artistic growth, development, and identity than any of the others. I couldn't bring myself to get rid of Reputation, Midnights feels too essential to her current career arc, and TTPD is now my favorite album in her discography. Lover's role could essentially have been served by a completely different pop album.

She needed a mediocre album for Folklore and Evermore to work. Lover served its purpose.

[gagacasanova]

Tortured poets department

[chosensparkles]

the one I barely use: Lover

[Lorenzo22]

well it's (l)over 

[Gladiator]

Easily Lover.

[Aethereal]

Never listened to any of them in full. 

[Ewan Chaos]

Can't decide between Reputation and Midnights. I dislike Rep the most of her albums, but don't love where we're at with Taylor these days which is clearly a direct result of Midnights doing so well (which I would have been fine with if the album wasn't so bad...).

 

Went with Midnights 

[NoOneDiesFromLove]

Don't set up Loser like that

[Nico Robin]

Lover and I would also choose the same songs as you +- 2 more

[eli's_rhythm]

I can't believe Midnights has the least votes when it's the most forgettable project here with the least career highs!

[queenoftheclouds]

Lover

[Tistotal]

This really put me in perspective that folklore and her ugly sister evermore weren't the rule but the exception.

 

OT: TTPD and midnights.

[WillieMonroe]

oops deleted them all

[RobynYoBank]

I want it to be Lover, but after Eras Tour I don't know if I can sacrifice Cruel Summer. 

[aesthetic bih]

OVER

[Baltie]

TTPD. I love Taylor but I just don't see myself going back to this particular album. It's too long and some of the lyrics feel like word salad masquerading as "poetry".

 

The other albums I'd probably voluntarily listen to again in the future. If I were to rank them, it'd be reputation > Lover > Midnights.

[Rence]

Midnights if I can keep 3AM. Otherwise I'll go with rep.

 

Lover and TTPD despite having some lows still have many career highlights.