base talk P4K: Tortured Poets 6.6/ Anthology 6.0

[danrich]

https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/taylor-swift-the-tortured-poets-department-the-anthology/

Edited April 22 by danrich

[suburbannature]

That's pretty accurate tbh

[Twizzy]

This can't be possible because ATRL told me one hour ago that they would rate it higher than Midnights 

Edited April 22 by Twizzy

[Slamless]

ooh the anthology at 6.0 in 2024 its bad for her  

[M.R.]

They split the score. The standard album is 6.6 and extended is 6.0.

Edited April 22 by M.R.

[JoeAg]

yeah, fair

i'm gonna read it now

[Brooklyn Baby]

I personally like the album and it's growing but I can understand why someone would not take to this album (even though it is better than MIDnights).

 

She needs to work with other producers for TS12.

 

They were wrong for that anthology score though 

[Aria0327]

Quite expected 

[50thStateofMind]

Gave the OG 6.6 and the Anthology a 6.0

[Slayn]

Anthology 6.0 too, they ate that

[Flower]

The Anthology being lower than the first half 

 

Aaron Denser stans in shambles 

 

 

[Miley Cyrus]

where are the lashings?? someone post them!

[Sadie Saxton]

 Not the anthology being lower

[TROPICUM]

the anthology being lower? what halsey said!

 

but that 6.6 was quite expected tbh...  not great not bad!

[ToraeGilt]

Not the anthology getting the same score as PF2 

[PrettyHurts]

 

[Blackout2006]

An accurate score  

[arctic-turner]

Too high

[Walk_Away21]

I thought Pitchwork went bankrupt and closed Is this another "Forbes says..." contributor type of article where fans publish for pennies?

[Bhabylon]

Quote

 Those that stand out mostly do so for the wrong reasons: There's the one that borrows its premise from Olivia Rodrigo, but executes it less skillfully; the one where Swift dwells on her resentment toward Kim Kardashian; the one with that weird lyric about racism in the 1830s. Th

Clock that tea!

[Villas]

It should deserved less, she is lost.

Edited April 22 by Villas

[mael]

She's on the same level as Nicki Minaj Petty, I can't believe it.

 

[Blackout2006]

9 minutes ago, Twizzy said:

This can't be possible because ATRL told me one hour ago that they would rate it higher than Midnights 

Thankfully not  At least I wasn't battling with my eyelids while I was listening to Midnights

[Starshine]

Nicki the standard-

 

 

[CandleGuy]

Pretty much what I expected. Main album deserved more but P4K are too indie/hipster to give her a higher rating.