poll Will Pitchfork pan TTPD?

[mercurialworld]

Title...

Edited April 22 by mercurialworld

[Trainwreck]

somewhere between 6 and 7.4

[Taylor fanboy]

Definitely lower than reputation's revisited score, 8.5.

[Gladiator]

I'm suspecting between 6 and 7.

[PrettyHurts]

Between 6.5 and 7.5 

[EnigmaticAndroid]

I don't think that they're allowed to give her a panning so no 

 

Music criticism is in shambles 

[shookspeare]

No, I think they'll give it a 7.0-7.5

[Blue Rose]

They gave Ed Sheeran at his peak a 2.7 for an album that's on par with TTPD quality wise. It would be iconic if they pull a similar stunt. Taylor doesn't deserve it but Ed didn't either. She's getting a 7.0

Offcial score is coming out in 5 hours too  

Edited April 21 by Blue Rose

[Draper.]

Between 4.0 and 6.9.

[GrandeVersace]

I don't think they're allowed to give a significantly low score. Nobody wants to mess with her or her stans.

[alejandreaux]

not that i personally think it's this bad but i feel like they will give it a 4.7

[Kimi]

no. 7-8, what was their midnights score 

[MissedTheTrain]

They're not going to pan it, but I can see a lower score than her past few albums.

[Chaos Angel]

7.0

[Sheep]

Nobody cares what the GQ music column has to say. 

[Rotunda]

Probably 7.0

[Reflektor_Creep]

4.5 

[Blue.]

Their takeaways article reads positively, and with Sputnik music giving it a 90 anything can happens tbh

 

https://pitchfork.com/thepitch/takeaways-from-taylor-swift-new-album-the-tortured-poets-department/

Edited April 22 by Blue.

[mercurialworld]

Personally, I'm getting strong 6.4.

[The Music Industry]

I'm sure OTHs are perched and refreshing the website for it

 

[mercurialworld]

2 minutes ago, The Music Industry said:

I'm sure OTHs are perched and refreshing the website for it

 

Is an OTH like a Taylor Swift opp?

 

[The Music Industry]

Just now, mercurialworld said:

Is an OTH like a Taylor Swift opp?

 

Obsessed Taylor Swift Haters 

 

[fromily]

Tbh the funniest/most interesting thing to do would be to just not review it at all. But since they're a Condé Nast column now that's not gonna happen. My prediction: boring middle of the road review that is critical enough to seem genuine but doesn't result in any bomb threats being sent to the basement 

[shimind]

Anything above 4 will be an atrocity. She needs a good downfall era to realize her mistakes and dump that producer she has been using since 2020

[NoName]

The album is split even between people that hate it and people who love it. A polarizing album indeed. Adele's least-liked album on there is the one that broke first week records so perhaps they will do the same to TTPD?

Edited April 22 by NoName