base talk why Selena has the most remembered Disney bops out of Miley and Demi?

[Arthoe]

Miley has been an international superstar for almost 20 years, none of Selena's early songs aren't even REMOTELY remembered unless you're a Disney adult. 

[tost1]

You just made that up

[Sad Serenade]

the OP is definitely trolling: Miley has some of the biggest hits of an ex-act during her disney days, Selena has some memorable hits too like LYLALS and Who Says (both pulling great daily streams without any gimmick or push), the demi's sneak is cute. 

7 Things needs to be mentioned here, it was a bop and a classic break up song specially for that Nick J. relationship. I'm pretty sure it was a Top 10 hit too.

Love You Like A Love Song and Who Says are still beloved the first one is about to hit 1B streams and goes often viral. Who Says and >Hit The Lights are both anthem they're really underrated.

[Blue Monday]

What is it with this site and trying to inflate Selana's importance/impact on popular music/pop culture 

 

The Climb alone is more remembered than anything Selena has dropped

Edited April 6 by Blue Monday

[Cain]

Because you're lying

[Gladiator]

You might have missed the reveal, but Hannah Montana is also Miley. 

[Erreur2 La Nature]

They certainly aren't more remembered than Miley's. PITUSA alone >>>>

[goverm3nth0ker]

im not trolling lol and how could this be a selena set up? selena and miley are on the same level they have been flopping for years, had a cute hit last year (flowers and calm down) and right now they are flopping again 

 

milena is not that iconic lol

[Freakshowvato]

First of all, those Demi songs listed are not from Disney. Heart Attack was the same era as Come & Get It and We Can't Stop.  Demi's Disney songs are This Is Me, Don't Forget, La La Land, Get Back, Here We Go Again, Remember December.

 

Demi was only on Disney for 2008-2010 so her time there was short lived and her biggest songs came post-Disney, starting with Skyscraper. Selena was still with The Scene when Demi released Skyscraper and Give Your Heart A Break.

 

However, I do think Miley has the biggest discography associated with Disney.

 

 

 

 

[brraap]

Quality over quantity girl. The day Selena or Demi can release a The Climb or Flowers, then I'll see 

[Freakshowvato]

Also out of Selena's entire discography (Disney and post-Disney), Love You Like A Love Song might be her only memorable song in my book.

[Jooj]

The receipts say otherwise and they point to Miley.

 

/endthread

[Jooj]

1 hour ago, goverm3nth0ker said:

im not trolling lol and how could this be a selena set up? selena and miley are on the same level they have been flopping for years, had a cute hit last year (flowers and calm down) and right now they are flopping again 

 

milena is not that iconic lol

The biggest song of 2023 was a "cute hit"? 

 

And they're not on the same level. Single Soon (marketed as Selena's comeback/lead single) and Used To Be Young were released at the same time and only one went top 10.

 

Hell, Single Soon almost missed the Top 20 lol!

Edited April 6 by Jooj

[Gladiator]

1 hour ago, goverm3nth0ker said:

im not trolling lol and how could this be a selena set up? selena and miley are on the same level they have been flopping for years, had a cute hit last year (flowers and calm down) and right now they are flopping again 

 

milena is not that iconic lol

lol miley is not flopping. ?

[goverm3nth0ker]

1 hour ago, Freakshowvato said:

First of all, those Demi songs listed are not from Disney. Heart Attack was the same era as Come & Get It and We Can't Stop.  Demi's Disney songs are This Is Me, Don't Forget, La La Land, Get Back, Here We Go Again, Remember December.

 

Demi was only on Disney for 2008-2010 so her time there was short lived and her biggest songs came post-Disney, starting with Skyscraper. Selena was still with The Scene when Demi released Skyscraper and Give Your Heart A Break.

 

However, I do think Miley has the biggest discography associated with Disney.

 

 

 

 

wasnt demo with hollywood records till confident or idk ? not my cup of tea anyway

[Movimento Perpétuo]

I like Selena's music but none of her The Scene 'hits' together are more remembered than Party in the USA alone bfr  

[Scars]

19 hours ago, Selegend said:

A song that does 30 can do 50, 60, 70k daily streams pretty easily. Miley is the moment now, she has been since Flowers and Grammy gave it a 2nd wind.  Selena is disliked atm and releasing questionable music and its easy to see that it can change anytime for her if u…. Just look at last year. 

Catalog songs can be heavily impacted by recent events, that's true, but thankfully we have overall streams available to show us the full picture beyond recent patterns. Selena is also behind Miley on that metric. 

 

The ifs and buts to justify Selena's current numbers are cute, but Miley has the most remembered hits out of the Disney bunch and that is backed by factual data. Period.

Edited April 6 by Scars

[The7thStranger]

As a data point from somebody who was far too old to care much about Disney acts by that age, the only Selena song listed above that I recognize here is Love You Like a Love Song.

 

From my point of view, Miley's music has far surpassed Selena's in terms of both popularity and longevity.

[AccioMiley]

Somebody needs to do a live on the streets video talking to people about who has more disney bops because this discourse needs to end lmao. 

 

Anyway. Miley clears with party in the usa alone. 

 

Nobody aint noddin their head like yeah

Movin their hips like yeah to....love you like a love song. Which is one of the most annoying selena and the scene songs. 

People just found her more "palatable" than miley back then because selena was tame af. Now she's just a ***** 

[Freakshowvato]

7 hours ago, goverm3nth0ker said:

wasnt demo with hollywood records till confident or idk ? not my cup of tea anyway

Yeah her first 4 albums were with Hollywood Records exclusively, then a joint deal between island and hollywood until 2021.  Either way, only Don't Forget and Here We Go Again are truly considered Disney eras. If we're talking about Hollywood Records songs, then we'd include Heart Attack, Skyscraper, Give Your Heart a Break, Really Don't Care, Neon Lights, etc.

[Miley Cyrus]

23 hours ago, unclefloprry said:

Love You Like a Love Song is bigger and better than Miley's discography btw 

Maybe for 12 year olds.

 

OT: 7 Things, See You Again, PITUSA, The Climb are bigger than the songs in the OP  

Even some Hannah songs are bigger than these  

[corotinho]

I don't think LYLALS is more remebered than PITUSA.

 

If you look at current stats, it's clear that:

 

1. Party In The USA

2. Love You Like A Love Song

 

Anyway, both are two and the only classics produced by the disney acts while they were on Disney. Both are huge with GP.

[corotinho]

On 4/5/2024 at 11:46 PM, Selegend said:

The top 4 basically never changes.

PITUSA, LYLALS, Who Says, The Climb. 
 

A song that does 30 can do 50, 60, 70k daily streams pretty easily. Miley is the moment now, she has been since Flowers and Grammy gave it a 2nd wind.  Selena is disliked atm and releasing questionable music and its easy to see that it can change anytime for her if u…. Just look at last year. 

For example

february last year: 

 

 

October last year:

 

look at Naturally, AYWR and stuff. 
 

anyway, enjoy ur fridayyy

Sis the way i love you so much, thanks for clearing

[corotinho]

On 4/6/2024 at 1:43 PM, Jooj said:

The biggest song of 2023 was a "cute hit"? 

 

And they're not on the same level. Single Soon (marketed as Selena's comeback/lead single) and Used To Be Young were released at the same time and only one went top 10.

 

Hell, Single Soon almost missed the Top 20 lol!

Spotify Stats:

 

Used To Be Young: 186M

Single Soon: 185M

 

A cute peak don't make it bigger lol

Edited April 9 by corotinho

[corotinho]

On 4/6/2024 at 1:44 PM, Gladiator said:

lol miley is not flopping. ?

she is... both songs post Flowers flopped, just like both songs released post Calm Down flopped too