goverm3nth0ker Posted April 6 Posted April 6 (edited) Demi has Skyscraper, GYHAB, and her magnum opus Heart Attack. Meanwhile, Miley has 7 things, The Climb and even one of her best sellings Party in the USA. But why Selena's seems like the memorable ones? LIke the songs have the best streams and YT views and Disney definitely spammed her more than her peers. Even my local friends acknowledge them more and some people say that The Scene era was her peak era. Let's revisit: TO SPECIFY, i meant GLOBALLY idc if PITUSA is 13xplatinum or peaked 2. question: is Selena a MPG or a nostalgia act? Edited April 6 by goverm3nth0ker 2 5 3 6 16
Gorjesspazze9 Posted April 6 Posted April 6 Miley is definitely most remembered. The Climb and Party in the us is still played on radio across the country today. Nobody is playing who says or naturally 11
Eat The Acid Posted April 6 Posted April 6 Lmao what? Miley was Avril while Selena and Demi were Vanessa and Michelle. Non comparable in terms of memorability. Next! 1
karron0624 Posted April 6 Posted April 6 Naturally and lylals as peak. Who says and a year without rain though are t as remembered i say If i ranked them as most remembered, i would say: 1. Party in the usa 2. Love you like a love song 3 Naturally 4. The climb 5. A year without rain 6. seven rings 7. Heart Attack 8. Who says 9. Gyhab 10. Skyscraper, which i havent heard played in the wild for over a decade. 1 5
Scars Posted April 6 Posted April 6 Party in the USA (one song) - 1,5B streams Selena Gomez & The Scene (three albums) - 1,9B streams Why are you setting up poor Selena like that? 2 3
unclefloprry Posted April 6 Posted April 6 9 minutes ago, goverm3nth0ker said: question: is Selena a MPG or a nostalgia act? both Miley and Selena are nostalgia acts. 1
dopamina Posted April 6 Posted April 6 When I Look At You Party In The U.S.A. The Climb See You Again 7 Things Butterfly Fly Away Can't Be Tamed Who Owns My Heart
unclefloprry Posted April 6 Posted April 6 Love You Like a Love Song is bigger and better than Miley's discography btw 2 2 1 11
JO1s Posted April 6 Posted April 6 Party in the USA is more remembered than any sg during and post Disney… this set up. 1
Tm4074 Posted April 6 Posted April 6 The Climb and PITUSA are far more remembered than any of those Selena songs. PITUSA is 13x Platinum so that alone invalidates this argument.
goverm3nth0ker Posted April 6 Author Posted April 6 miley has ONE popular disney song that is PITUSA. but come on now, LYLALS globally is still more remembered and played. I'm not saying Selena is bigger than MIley bc shes not, thats why i didnt use that word, Hannah Montana was THE thing. I just said that, people talk more about Naturally, AYWR (or the spanish version), Who says and LYLALS more than 7 things, See you again, Fly on the wall, Can't be tamed, like nobody remembers that 1 5
Selegend Posted April 6 Posted April 6 (edited) Some of u will try to gaslight members into believe Selena has closer to Demi numbers when The Climb does 300k daily, Who Says 250k daily and Skyscraper does like 20k. And u guys can check on Kworb. And Who Says had days where it did 400k btw. PITUSA is the bigger classic tho! Of course. but even so, LYLALS does +600k daily and had its days when it did 900k (PITUSA numbers today, for example). Edited April 6 by Selegend 2
goverm3nth0ker Posted April 6 Author Posted April 6 1 minute ago, Tm4074 said: The Climb and PITUSA are far more remembered than any of those Selena songs. PITUSA is 13x Platinum so that alone invalidates this argument. in the US maybe thats why its called Party in the USA but I lived in Europe and Latam and ppl adore(and stream) LYLALS! 1
Selegend Posted April 6 Posted April 6 1 minute ago, goverm3nth0ker said: in the US maybe thats why its called Party in the USA but I lived in Europe and Latam and ppl adore(and stream) LYLALS! They do. LYLALS is pretty remembered.
WEEKND Posted April 6 Posted April 6 I don't like Selena at all but in her career she has done 2 great things A Year Without Rain Baila Conmigo two indéniable quality songs
Scars Posted April 6 Posted April 6 (edited) 10 minutes ago, goverm3nth0ker said: I just said that, people talk more about Naturally, AYWR (or the spanish version), Who says and LYLALS more than 7 things, See you again, Fly on the wall, Can't be tamed, like nobody remembers that Spotify: The Climb - 618,773,339 (303,581 daily streams) Naturally - 134,835,435 (55,782 daily streams) A Year Without Rain - 106,940,511 (39,436 daily streams) If people are talking more about Naturally, why aren't they even bothering to stream it? stop setting up this woman. Edited April 6 by Scars 1 1
Abracadabra Posted April 6 Posted April 6 13 minutes ago, unclefloprry said: both Miley and Selena are nostalgia acts. Didn't Miley just have the biggest song of 2023?
dopamina Posted April 6 Posted April 6 2 minutes ago, unclefloprry said: Love You Like a Love Song is bigger and better than Miley's discography btw Hot 100 PITU #2 LYLALS #22 Spotify PITU 1.5B LYLALS 813M Youtube PITU 979M LYLALS 743M RIAA PITU 13x Platinum LYLALS 5x Platinum
goverm3nth0ker Posted April 6 Author Posted April 6 1 minute ago, Scars said: Spotify: The Climb - 618,773,339 (303,581 daily streams) Naturally - 134,835,435 (55,782 daily streams) A Year Without Rain - 106,940,511 (39,436 daily streams) If people are talking more about Naturally, why aren't they even bothering to stream it? stop setting up this woman. Okay miss Scars, if you checked i named 4 selena songs, can you name other tan the climb or PITUSA? Quantify babe. like gosh, i just said what i saw from the GP, im not even a selena stan and if it weren't for flowers I would've said that Selena is bigger than MIley overall when she was just lucky and both are flops
Recommended Posts