base talk Bedtime Stories vs Joanne

[Josh]

 

Both albums exist to soften up their image for the gpee after their previous era was controversial

[BrandNewBrandon]

They both did what they had to do. Madonna was on the verge of creating her best work and Gaga was starting to be well-known as a vocalist and well-liked again. I haven't heard Bedtime Stories and I don't like Joanne. 

 

Come to think about it, I don't like Joanne so much that I'll probably even choose an album I haven't heard over it so Bedtime Stories is my answer.

 

Edited March 2 by BrandNewBrandon

[Eclass]

Take A Bow >>>>> Joanne.

 

 

 

 

[All Guns Blazing]

Bedtime Stories

[lillavend3r]

Both did what they were supposed to do. But Bedtimes Stories is amazing

[pxxxtrick]

Bedtime Stories. 

[ohwow]

at least bedtime tries to be interesting

[theweekend]

bedtime stories, sweetie...

[HardBambi]

25 minutes ago, Eclass said:

Take A Bow >>>>> Joanne.

 

 

 

 

Take a bow >>>> Gaga

[SinnerCity]

I guess Joanne was helped tone down Gaga’s perception at the time and help her land ASIB but overall it feels so out of place in her discography. 
 

Bedtime Stories is an outstanding project 

[pisuke]

Bedtime Stories and I consider this thread an insult. I mean, come on...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[worldwide angel]

must be getting deja vu . . . .

 

but

 

bedtime stories > 

[Legend E]

Even though I love Joanne and I think it's overly hated, BS>>

 

 

[supaspaz]

This is a very strange comparison. But Bedtime Stories is excellent and I don't like almost any tracks on Joanne, so easy vote.

[Karla Cabello]

girl..... 

[suburbannature]

excuse tf out of me

[JoeAg]

I love Diamond Heart, A-Yo, John Wayne, and Dancin' in Circles but Bedtime Stories clears, EASILY

 

I mean Human Nature, Bedtime Story, and Take a Bow alone demolish Joanne with ease 

[Bloody Willy]

Joanne is a stain on Gaga's discography and should never have been released. Bedtime Stories is excellent.

[Bethenny Frankel]

Love both but Human Nature washes Aunt alone

[AdrianNicki]

You guys really love to set up Gaga on this forum, don't you?

 

Godtime Stories>>>>>

[Janet]

Bedtime is in Madonna’s top 3 albums. Joanne is bottom 3 Gaga albums 

 

[Jooj]

Bedtime Stories is Madonna's best album. Joanne is Gaga's worst.

 

This comparison is a setup.

[MadOnHer]

Literally no contest on this one.

Bedtime Stories is a masterpiece.

The other is not.

[Tovitov]

I personally dont like Bedtime Stories that much. But the singles are great and Survivor is a slay. 

 

But I love Joanne as messy as it is. Maybe I'd feel differently had I been old enough when Bedtime Stories came out but I personally feel Joanne > Bedtime Stories

[Escape]

Now girl... Bedtime Stories.