poll Who is the better songwriter: Mariah or Taylor?

[Santhosh]

Mariah sweetie

[GreatestLoveofAll]

Mariah wrote the entire Butterfly album- a masterclass of pop music songwriting. That alone takes it. Though Taylor's work on folklore is very very well done.

[KatyPrismSpirit]

Mariah's debut and Daydream have some of the most legendary songwriting ever 

[Devin]

its mariah like cmon now. 

[Sad Beautiful Tragic]

27 minutes ago, byzantium said:

It's a bit ironic for a person with a username like that to make a thread about songwriting. 

 

/close thread 

[Eternal220]

Taylor

[Princess Aurora]

10 minutes ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

Mariah's debut and Daydream have some of the most legendary songwriting ever 

OMG 

[dirrtydiana]

Still Mariah. Did you see this thread pop up when typing the title and decide to make yours anyway?

 

 

[Queenyoncee]

8 minutes ago, Ethereal said:

 

/close thread 

[AllyGayTor]

Mariah. Expecting the predictable wave of polls after this tho 

[ontherocks]

Taylor, easily 

[dirrtydiana]

45 minutes ago, AllyGayTor said:

Mariah. Expecting the predictable wave of polls after this tho 

Surprisingly it was a Mariah mega landslide in both polls before the threads got merged 

 

[stevyy]

Butterfly (song) is a poem... like Goethe level of poem. 

[HarajukuPrincess]

Love both, but Mariah takes this one 😊

[Finkypop]

Taylor by far 

[BionicWooHoo]

6 hours ago, byzantium said:

It's a bit ironic for a person with a username like that to make a thread about songwriting. 

Whatchu mean? All the boys wanna taste my woohoo is so feminist and fun. Do you not like camp? Do you not like fun? 
 

 

[Sheep]

Who does ATRL consider better at writing music? Discuss. 

[PoisonPill]

Love Tay but We Belong Together alone clears her 

[LittleStarmen]

Mariah does MUSIC

taylor does songs

 

If you take away the tabloid context of each Taylor song you are left with nothing...

Edited April 22 by LittleStarmen

[Kingdom]

Don't ever insult mariah like this again. MARIAH writes songs that actually feel REAL. Taylor does sum else

[Strawberry Bubble]

katy perry and rihanna >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

[PoisonedIvy]

You're asking a website that is currently stroking their massive, throbbing, veiny, uncut hate boners for the biggest artist on the planet to make an unbiased judgment? Good luck with that! I will not be participating as I do not feel the need to compare two of the most talented songwriters of all time as if there is only room to enjoy one. But the rest of you can have fun fighting about arbitrary & subjective things. 

Edited April 22 by PoisonedIvy

[Sheep]

3 minutes ago, PoisonedIvy said:

You're asking a website that is currently stroking their massive, throbbing, veiny, uncut hate boners for the biggest artist on the planet to make an unbiased judgment? Good luck with that! I will not be participating as I do not feel the need to compare two of the most talented songwriters of all time as if there is only room to enjoy one. But the rest of you can have fun fighting about arbitrary & subjective things. 

sis you really coulda just said Mariah, you didnt really need to write the whole essay about how the answer being mariah is unfair to your favorite billionaire 

[bielneira]

I have to pick Taylor since she writes stories, which she is the best at

[suburbannature]

Just now, bielneira said:

I have to pick Taylor since she writes stories, which she is the best at

And Mariah obliterates in this area too.  

 

OT: Mariah, sweetie.