base talk Is Katy's halftime show superior to Gaga's?

[shyboi]

I love Gaga's as well but i always heard how Katy's was lackluster and is forgotten now 

 

But I disagree, I actually think is the best one after Shakira and Jlo.

 

She really wrapped everything up and gave us amazing moments, from sassy, to fantastic and straight up magical with that ending.

 

 

Which one is superior?

 

Edited February 23 by shyboi

[AxelFox]

Lady gaga is the better performer but I genuinely find Katy's show a lot more entertaining to watch. 
 

I feel like she understood the assignment better. 

[byzantium]

Katy’s was pretty good.  It was fun, full of hits and entertaining.  Personally I think it was the 3rd best MPG halftime after Shakira and Beyonce. 

[CovalentBondage]

The one who sang 100% live

[fa77ot]

yes gaga, yes superior

[shyboi]

1 minute ago, AxelFox said:

Lady gaga is the better performer but I genuinely find Katy's show a lot more entertaining to watch. 
 

I feel like she understood the assignment better. 

 

also I feel like the guests on Katy's HT show were on point 

 

 

[shyboi]

1 minute ago, CovalentBondage said:

The one who sang 100% live

 

both did

 

[DoubleRainbow!]

Yes, Katy has always played the visual card better than Gaga and the transitions were perfectly executed while Gaga’s feel all over the place

[Shimenawa]

Katy was all about the visuals and props, and she got overshadowed by Missy and the shark

 

Gaga was pure talent

 

Edited February 23 by Shimenawa

[Nicholai]

Gaga is superior.

[Bad News]

No.

[Beyonceist]

Production-wise, yes.

Performance-wise, no.

[dawnettakins]

I prefer the one who can perform and sing. Meaning Gaga.

 

Hope that helps! 

[frankvert]

No. Gaga sang live, was more energetic, had a better set list, and performed SOLO to boot 

[Pheromosa]

It’s funny how Gaga used to be the visuals girl 

[Dula Peep]

Not gonna lie, I expected much more from Gaga because she's Gaga.... outfit changes, interesting staging, bubble dress...something.

.. unfortunately for us she was in her Joanne "minimalistic" era. 

 

Overall performance wise she was better than Katy though

[Ron Ng]

Overall: Katy

Performance skills alone: Gaga

 

Gaga is a better performer, but her clothes, stage design and setlist are horrible. 

Edited February 23 by Ron Ng

[Jay07]

Gaga is the better performer but I feel she didn't have enough variety or wow moments other than the beginning and the end. It was too flat.

[Almighty Gaga]

If you're 9

[Brooklyn Baby]

They're both on par for me actually. Gaga is obviously the better performer and I loved the setlist. Katy ate with her production value, a visual feast 

[CallumDavies]

Katy’s is more remembered 

[manuelalex9810]

You could see Gaga’s performance in some TV talent show like XFactor, I actually I expected more. 
Katy exploded with creativity, she did outfit changes, different kind of sets, flew all over the stadium, visuals, hits, guests on point, etc. 

[Cameltoe Chariot]

2 minutes ago, manuelalex9810 said:

You could see Gaga’s performance in some TV talent show like XFactor, I actually I expected more. 
Katy exploded with creativity, she did outfit changes, different kind of sets, flew all over the stadium, visuals, hits, guests on point, etc. 

The delusions of Katycats are some of the most entertaining sh*t you'll find on ATRL my god 

[BionicWooHoo]

I think Gaga is the better artist overall (more talented, greater range, artistic growth, etc etc)

 

but Katy def understood the assignment better. It was campy and fun  and entertaining 

[UnusualBoy]

Gaga is the better performer for sure but Katy's SB was far more entertaining tbh.