suburbannature Posted February 16 Posted February 16 17 minutes ago, Alongoria13 said: If you add every Mariah album from 2008 onwards you can’t even outsell Hard Candy. Why since 2008 when Einstein was released the same year and automatically makes this false? 21 minutes ago, She-Rah said: Someone correct me but didn’t Madonna outsold every Mariah release the last 2 decades? I’m not even going to mention their touring gross differences I’m referring to ”reduced to Xmas” when her 90s/00s catalog is outstreaming Madonna, Janet, Celine, Whitney’s with EASE outside of Xmas. 1
suburbannature Posted February 16 Posted February 16 1 minute ago, ZeroPoint said: I can’t believe the Caution slander going on in this thread Giving Me Life and Portrait are career highlights It’s because that album being acclaimed doesn’t fit their narrative so they are conveniently forgetting it. and conveniently ignoring Mariah’s recurrent streams outside of Xmas trampling the other girls. The transparency 3
toxicgenie Posted February 16 Posted February 16 I feel like either Mariah sabotaged it cuz she didn't care for it. Or Ariana sabotaged her. IDK it just doesnt make sense.
Cloudy Posted February 16 Posted February 16 Caution was perfect but that was so long ago, and she hasn't done anything interesting or note worthy since then except maybe that embarrassing NYE performance and being reduce to xmas meme lady 1 1 1
HardBambi Posted February 16 Posted February 16 43 minutes ago, Alongoria13 said: If you add every Mariah album from 2008 onwards you can’t even outsell Hard Candy. Thank you! That’s all. 1
kindararenext Posted February 16 Posted February 16 madonna hasn’t released a good album since confessions and that was almost 2 decades ago so i think you’ve lost the plot a little bit 3 1 1
Aria0327 Posted February 16 Posted February 16 Caution served tho. she would serve again if she give up belting out of her comfort zone and get rid of the excessive filter for her vocals 1 1
Stankonia Posted February 16 Posted February 16 Caution STOMPS on every Madonna album released after the Bush administration so this whole thread is definitely a lie 2 1 1
MattieB Posted February 16 Posted February 16 48 minutes ago, simplywohoo said: Girl youre not a black woman 1 3
ithinkheknowsoutsold Posted February 16 Posted February 16 1 hour ago, Alongoria13 said: If you add every Mariah album from 2008 onwards you can’t even outsell Hard Candy. If you add every Madonna album from 2008 onwards you can't even outsell Hard Candy Are you trying to imply Madonna is also incapable of serving anymore? 1 1
panochita Posted February 16 Posted February 16 1 hour ago, Solaria said: It’s clear that she’s losing the hag war against Madonna. Madonna is selling out tours and bagging a streaming hit 40 years into her career while Mariah only has one Xmas song that got dethroned in the US by Brenda Lee’s last year as well. Her new remix with Ariana has been widely negatively received by stans as well. Why is Mariah having so much trouble? Has Madonna released a good album ever since hard candy? We all know the answer is no, plus she embarrass herself with shitty collabs like the maluma feature or the Anitta one 1
panochita Posted February 16 Posted February 16 That one xtina Stan trying to get into the convo, you don't belong here try to fight the other 00s fads instead 1
Maroonx Posted February 16 Posted February 16 While I am not a Mariah fan, you can't discredit her accomplish and success... some of yoll in this thread are delusional. Also why bring Madonna into every comparison thread... a mess Anyway I haven't heard Ariana's remix, and after reading the rave reviews, I won't even bother... Time for a new management MC x 2 1
GreatestLoveofAll Posted February 16 Posted February 16 calling her a hag- we comparing looks now? chile... Mariah is a certified legend with literally nothing to prove. She had the album sales, the cultural and musical dominance in her heyday, has the talent and skill and influence. i dont get why you guys seek to find any fault in her when she is really just minding her business and enjoying the fruits of her labor. 1
fememeist Posted February 16 Posted February 16 Even the older gen poc legends like Mimi still get discriminated by her white peers’ stans. Like clockwork! 1 1
She-Rah Posted February 16 Posted February 16 1 hour ago, kindararenext said: madonna hasn’t released a good album since confessions and that was almost 2 decades ago so i think you’ve lost the plot a little bit Hard candy is amazing 1
Green Posted February 16 Posted February 16 She will serve with her new album if she pulls another Caution (when it comes to quality at least)
Vrx. Posted February 16 Posted February 16 Objectively we can say Mariah is one of the most talented artists in a booth. There’s really no doubts about it. Her runs and melodies are some of the best recorded to this day. It’s kind of a shame both her and Madonna aren’t focusing on just delivering music regardless of success since they’re at the point of their careers that they can do whatever and afford to take any risks they want but choose not to. 1
spiritboy Posted February 16 Posted February 16 As a longtime Madonna stan, i love and respect Mariah a lot. She is a legend that deserves better. People should see beyond her Christmas songs and discover what a fantastic discography she has. I will always root for her as there will never be another Big 5 like Madonna, Mariah, Whitney, Celine and Janet. Those women were and are something. Enough with stan wars and let’s enjoy them while they are alive and still giving us music. 1
Zefierce Posted February 16 Posted February 16 5 hours ago, playwithme said: Mariah hasn't been relevant since the mid-00s. This is incorrect i would say at least late-00s. 2
Recommended Posts