xrosup Posted May 5 Posted May 5 On 5/4/2024 at 11:30 AM, Mitsuki said: Seungmin I'll believe it when I see the pics of them at the event. I don't trust Seungmin, he's a troll 1
Xalric Posted May 5 Posted May 5 3 minutes ago, geniecantstophypeboy said: Ranking some of the most popular, newer girl groups by the effectiveness and distinctiveness of their branding. (definition: branding = the activity of connecting a product with a particular name, symbol, etc. or with particular features or ideas, in order to make people recognize and want to buy it: Successful branding uses design to reinforce customers' visual memories) S-TIER - Everyone knows their sound, their image and their mascot Newjeans A-TIER - Unmistakable for another group Babymonster Dreamcatcher B-TIER - Several unique identifiable characteristics, but inconsistent from release to release Gidle StayC Aespa C-TIER - One trick-pony, one identifiable characteristic, that could be fleshed out a lot more Ive Lesserafim D-TIER - copycat, lost the plot or never had a plot to begin with Illit Itzy NMIXX I would bump GIDLE Aespa into ATier pull Babymonster to BTier, also bumped IVE & LESSERAFIM to B-Tier NMIXX to CTier and Itzy to BTier
Sad Beautiful Tragic Posted May 5 Posted May 5 I see why MHJ is mad. I'll Pray For Them needs to be disbanded already
Dialamba Posted May 5 Posted May 5 1 hour ago, hallucinate said: why are they posting a tik tok challenge for… eleven gaeul and leeseo posted one too, is it viral or something? edit: yujin and rei did as well They saw heya's numbers and they had to remind us they used to have hits 1
lgaga1fan Posted May 5 Posted May 5 I can't wait until some of you learn that "mixxpop" is not a real genre and genre mixing, switch ups, etc has been a ficture of pop and rap music for decades now 1
TheCal Posted May 5 Posted May 5 6 minutes ago, lgaga1fan said: Mine is a Slayyyter song y'all really just say random **** on this forum to talk and act like you know what you're talking about ijbol What are you talking about??? I think they meant Madison Beer's Make You Mine... which was very viral on tiktok yet wasn't able to get in hot100 2
lgaga1fan Posted May 5 Posted May 5 6 minutes ago, geniecantstophypeboy said: Ranking some of the most popular, newer girl groups by the effectiveness and distinctiveness of their branding. (definition: branding = the activity of connecting a product with a particular name, symbol, etc. or with particular features or ideas, in order to make people recognize and want to buy it: Successful branding uses design to reinforce customers' visual memories) S-TIER - Everyone knows their sound, their image and their mascot Newjeans A-TIER - Unmistakable for another group Babymonster Dreamcatcher B-TIER - Several unique identifiable characteristics, but inconsistent from release to release Gidle StayC Aespa C-TIER - One trick-pony, one identifiable characteristic, that could be fleshed out a lot more Ive Lesserafim D-TIER - copycat, lost the plot or never had a plot to begin with Illit Itzy NMIXX You got plenty of time to write these annoying ass rankings and arguments about branding huh. That one drag race challenge made you think you're serving label A&R today 2
xrosup Posted May 5 Posted May 5 On 5/4/2024 at 2:01 PM, Mitsuki said: Well, It's happening So it's basically confirmed yesss 1
illia Posted May 5 Posted May 5 (edited) 13 minutes ago, geniecantstophypeboy said: A-TIER - Unmistakable for another group Babymonster Sheesh is a bop but all their songs sounds like Blackpink rejects circa 2017-18. Unmistakable for another group you say? 13 minutes ago, geniecantstophypeboy said: B-TIER - Several unique identifiable characteristics, but inconsistent from release to release StayC Aespa Where have aespa been inconsistent? they should be S tier Stayc never got off track too, they're consistently serving pretty cutesy TWICE-adjacent sister music, they should be A tier 13 minutes ago, geniecantstophypeboy said: C-TIER - One trick-pony, one identifiable characteristic, that could be fleshed out a lot more Ive How could IVE concept be fleshed out more? It's elegant pretty girl music with bops. Do you need an IVE bunny mascot to put it in an S tier? 13 minutes ago, geniecantstophypeboy said: D-TIER - copycat, lost the plot or never had a plot to begin with Itzy Opinions on ITZY's music can be subjective, but they always kept the teen crush brand Edited May 5 by illia 1
Raspy Posted May 5 Posted May 5 8 minutes ago, geniecantstophypeboy said: Ranking some of the most popular, newer girl groups by the effectiveness and distinctiveness of their branding. (definition: branding = the activity of connecting a product with a particular name, symbol, etc. or with particular features or ideas, in order to make people recognize and want to buy it: Successful branding uses design to reinforce customers' visual memories) S-TIER - Everyone knows their sound, their image and their mascot Newjeans A-TIER - Unmistakable for another group Babymonster Dreamcatcher B-TIER - Several unique identifiable characteristics, but inconsistent from release to release Gidle StayC Aespa C-TIER - One trick-pony, one identifiable characteristic, that could be fleshed out a lot more Ive Lesserafim D-TIER - copycat, lost the plot or never had a plot to begin with Illit Itzy NMIXX how the hell the dollar store blackpink get to be A tier make it make sense
lgaga1fan Posted May 5 Posted May 5 Just now, TheCal said: What are you talking about??? I think they meant Madison Beer's Make You Mine... which was very viral on tiktok yet wasn't able to get in hot100 They were talking about Charli so I assumed they thought this massively viral Slayyter song was a Charli song I don't follow Madison 1
Sheegs Posted May 5 Posted May 5 51 minutes ago, Winmill De Kwynn said: OMG this is a Japanese campiness at its fineness The girl sitting on a Lettuce leave slays The way they're fully embracing it their trollness as well 1
Rainy Devil Posted May 5 Posted May 5 I wonder if Salty & Sweet will have a sister in their upcoming album. This was my most played song from the MY WORLD mini. 1
Mattheo Posted May 5 Posted May 5 2 minutes ago, Rainy Devil said: I wonder if Salty & Sweet will have a sister in their upcoming album. This was my most played song from the MY WORLD mini. now if THIS is what winter meant by very aespa... we are so ready
TheCal Posted May 5 Posted May 5 2 minutes ago, lgaga1fan said: They were talking about Charli so I assumed they thought this massively viral Slayyter song was a Charli song I don't follow Madison you should give it a try, it's a cute bop 2
geniecantstophypeboy Posted May 5 Posted May 5 2 minutes ago, Xalric said: I would bump GIDLE Aespa into ATier pull Babymonster to BTier, also bumped IVE & LESSERAFIM to B-Tier NMIXX to CTier and Itzy to BTier That's fair. Gidle have that explosive Soyeonese magic. Reinventing yourself with new ideas all the time is both a strength and a weakness here, that makes your brand more volatile and less identifiable. Aespa have lost some of their identity when LSM left and they put Kwangya on the back burner, imo. Babymonster suffers from the comparison with Blackpink, that's fair. I don't know what to make of Itzy at the present. Others I think we agree with, you deleted the last tier.
TheCal Posted May 5 Posted May 5 (edited) now why the **** is Babymonster in A and Aespa in B tier Edited May 5 by TheCal 1
geniecantstophypeboy Posted May 5 Posted May 5 11 minutes ago, lgaga1fan said: You got plenty of time to write these annoying ass rankings and arguments about branding huh. That one drag race challenge made you think you're serving label A&R today What is a Kpop forum if not a place to discuss Kpop.
geniecantstophypeboy Posted May 5 Posted May 5 10 minutes ago, Raspy said: how the hell the dollar store blackpink get to be A tier make it make sense Blackpink is not active is why.
OrgVisual Posted May 5 Posted May 5 Itzy and Illit copycats but Baemon suddenly is not a carbon copy of Blackpink's music and image? 4
TheCal Posted May 5 Posted May 5 (edited) 22 minutes ago, geniecantstophypeboy said: S-TIER - Everyone knows their sound, their image and their mascot Newjeans Well can't argue with this. Noone does it better than them. Truly the best group Edited May 5 by TheCal 1
Recommended Posts