poll GUTS vs Breakaway - which is the better sophomore pop-rock album?

[supertiffany]

GUTS vs Breakaway

 

both are leaning pop-rock

both are sophomore albums too

 

which is better?

 

which is bigger? 

[naval23]

 

 

Breakaway sweetie I'm so sorry 

 

Breakaway, Since U Been Gone, Behind These Hazel Eyes and Because of You - quite possibly one of the best 1 2 3 4 single punches of a pop era ever 

[supertiffany]

 

 

 

 

[latingrl2005]

Really.....this is where we're at???

[zasderfght]

GUTS. Anyone voting for Breakaway probably prefers the early 2000s-pop sound, or they liked the singles off of Breakaway. This is an album comparison, and while Since U Been Gone is fire, GUTS-- as an entire body of work-- is vastly superior. 

[naval23]

3 minutes ago, zasderfght said:

GUTS. Anyone voting for Breakaway probably prefers the early 2000s-pop sound, or they liked the singles off of Breakaway. This is an album comparison, and while Since U Been Gone is fire, GUTS-- as an entire body of work-- is vastly superior. 

the poptimism era really has led us to this point 

[stevenisFADING]

Breakaway with ease.

[zasderfght]

6 minutes ago, naval23 said:

the poptimism era really has led us to this point 

Hey, Kelly Clarkson can probably out-sing Olivia, and Olivia has a long way to go to show the GP she has the longevity Kelly has, but we're also comparing just both artists' bodies of work. 

 

I would not be offended if someone chose Britney's best album over Bjork's worst album-- sometimes your fave just doesn't release their best material with album #2. And that's fine. 

[UnusualBoy]

Girl, I love Guts but Breakway clears with ease: Addicted, SUBG, Gone, Hear Me, You Found Me, BOY, Walk Away alone...

[znake]

GUTS and it is not even close 

[HEAVYONIT]

7 minutes ago, znake said:

Breakaway and it is not even close 

Fixed it for you 

[Mtjjproducer]

Bsffr it is breakaway for both 

[Robburro]

why are we disrespecting Kelly like this wtf

[Raphy23]

Under My Skin.

[pearlmercury]

lol breakaway anyways

[lelewlovebird]

I'm sure Guts comes across as more 'personal' but Breakaway>>>>>. BTHE, Addicted, Hear Me, BOY, Gone, SUBG, Walk Away, etc. are songs I vastly prefer to pretty much any of Olivia's, not to mention Kelly's vocal ability as well

[Kyoto]

38 minutes ago, zasderfght said:

Kelly Clarkson can probably out-sing Olivia

[Sheep]

I actively dislike Kelly and even I find this comparison insulting to Breakaway 

[Raptus]

Guts is full of s***, so the name is fitting. Concept album, I guess...

[loveisdead9582]

Breakaway and it’s not even close. 

[Geraldine]

Kelly sweetie

[GardenPanty]

GUTS. Only the singles on Breakaway are good

[FallenFroot]

Breakaway is a modern classic.

[xperience30]

Breakaway sweetie.....

[kellebrity98]

35 minutes ago, GardenPanty said:

GUTS. Only the singles on Breakaway are good

not when it has where is your heart, you found me and addicter