poll act ii: Better singer/vocalist here?

[Devin]

Adele vs Kelly Clarkson

Ariana Grande vs Mariah Carey

Rihanna vs Britney Spears

 

 

act i thread below:

 

[suburbannature]

Be so fr

 

[50thStateofMind]

Kelly, Mariah, Rih easily

[Sheep]

Kelly, Mariah, Neither 

[Theshigo Washidu]

Adele

Mariah

Rihanna

[AWholeAssMess]

The unanimousness of the poll...

[Finite]

nnnn this thread is messy

[Finite]

To clarify modern day Ariana compared to my godmother Mariah is vocally better. If we’re talking about PEAK vocals, then Mariah wins. Just wanted to explain my choice because the SET UP

 

I’ll always be a lamb for life #L4L #KKLB 

[kimberly]

Kelly and Rihanna were obvious picks.

 

For Ari vs. Mariah, I went with Ariana because she can do a lot of styles well including Broadway and jazz. But they're pretty much equal for me and both would be my top picks out of the six names in this poll, if we're considering Mariah at her peak.

 

Ari trumps Mariah's 2020's vocals with ease, though.

Edited October 13, 2023 by kimberly

[modeblock]

the Britney set up 

 

OT: Mariah>>>>>>>>>>>>>

[Devin]

1 minute ago, modeblock said:

the Britney set up 

I paired her w/ Rih since they both have unique voices. I think some ppl sleepin on Britney tho she has her moments. 
 

4 minutes ago, Finite said:

nnnn this thread is messy

I’m tryna do fair pairings.

[suburbannature]

10 minutes ago, kimberly said:

Kelly and Rihanna were obvious picks.

 

For Ari vs. Mariah, I went with Ariana because she can do a lot of styles well including Broadway and jazz. But they're pretty much equal for me and both would be my top picks out of the six names in this poll, if we're considering Mariah at her peak.

 

Ari trumps Mariah's 2020's vocals with ease, though.

Mariah could do all that and more bffr

 

theyre not on the same planet unless we’re talking about 2020s Mariah.

[Khal]

42 minutes ago, Devin said:

Rihanna vs Britney Spears

JAIL!

Rihanna OBVIOUSLY

[kimberly]

18 minutes ago, suburbannature said:

Mariah could do all that and more bffr

 

theyre not on the same planet unless we’re talking about 2020s Mariah.

 

they aren't on the same planet when we're talking 2020's Mariah, either. 

[suburbannature]

Just now, kimberly said:

 

they aren't on the same planet when we're talking 2020's Mariah, either. 

Ariana's voice has lost weight and fluidity as well. And it will continue over time as that's a natural part of aging. 

 

Their peaks aren't comparable 

[Winged]

Kelly Mariah Rihanna

[JoeAg]

Kelly

Mariah

Rihanna

[kimberly]

1 hour ago, suburbannature said:

Ariana's voice has lost weight and fluidity as well. And it will continue over time as that's a natural part of aging. 

 

Their peaks aren't comparable 

again, 

 

I think their peaks are very much comparable and close, regardless of who you pick. I prefer Ariana's versatility just a little bit more. no need to go back and forth about it. 

[suburbannature]

4 minutes ago, kimberly said:

again, 

 

I think their peaks are very much comparable and close, regardless of who you pick. I prefer Ariana's versatility just a little bit more. no need to go back and forth about it. 

 

 

you may "prefer" it, but Mariah is objectively far more versatile.

Edited October 13, 2023 by suburbannature

[kimberly]

1 minute ago, suburbannature said:

 

 

you may "prefer" it, but Mariah is objectively far more versatile.

if it's objective let's close the poll then.

 

[suburbannature]

1 minute ago, kimberly said:

if it's objective let's close the poll then.

 

Might as well with those results 

 

[Katamari]

this thread exudes chaos energy 

 

 

 

kelly

mariah

britney 

[Katamari]

mariah could easily do imagine but ariana could never do without you or anytime you need a friend

[LikeATattoo]

1 hour ago, kimberly said:

 

they aren't on the same planet when we're talking 2020's Mariah, either. 

But why would we be talking about current Mariah and not prime Mariah? Like, what sense would it make to compare someone’s prime ability to another person’s post-prime ability?

 

 

[Popboi.]

Kelly, Mariah (currently Ariana), Rihanna